My Wallabies squad to face France in the first Test

By Combesy / Roar Guru

With just under three weeks until the Wallabies first Test of the year against France, I will attempt to deduce what Ewen McKenzie’s squad will look like.

With 32 spots up for grabs and a World Cup just over a year away, players will be hoping to get in early and impress Link in the hope of maintaining their spot on the plane to Heathrow.

The squad will include some of the usual suspects we have become accustomed to in gold. McKenzie will add some fresh new faces in the hope of securing some partnerships and combinations before the Rugby Championship in the coming months.

Front Row
We will see much of same from last year in terms of front row stock. James Slipper, Ben Alexander, Scott Sio and Sekope Kepu will all be in the mix, but the final prop position is left open.

There are two schools of thought here: pick a proven player, or pick a fresh new face.

In the first category we have older heads in Benn Robinson, Greg Holmes and a newer Wallaby in Paddy Ryan. In the later category we have fresh-faced new kids on the (international) block Toby Smith, Keiran Longbottom and a smokey in Paul Alo Emile.

McKenzie will be looking to forge a new front row in hope of cementing some form and reliability for the upcoming Rugby Championship while having one eye on developing towards the 2015 Rugby World Cup. He will also have to decide whether to maintain playing James Slipper at loosehead or shift him back to tighthead in partnership with Scott Sio, who has been in good form throughout Super Rugby this year.

My picks: James Slipper, Scott Sio, Ben Alexander and Toby Smith will get the nod. Smith has enjoyed two Super Rugby titles with the Chiefs and been tested longer at the top level than the other newcomers.

Hookers
The starting Moore is a shoo-in and has probably already had his jersey and Wallabies gear tailored, pressed and sitting in the cupboard.

That being said there is plenty of discussion around who should join him in the match 23, and indeed in the squad. The usual names are being thrown around added with a new face in a tough, hard-working toiler based in the west.

Up for selection are Moore, Tatafu Polota-Nau, Saia Fainga’a, James Hansen and newcomer Nathan Charles. Being that Moore has the No. 2 already sewn up, the discussion is around who will get the No. 16 and who will be added to the squad.

Polota-Nau has been around the Wallabies set-up for some time, though form of late has seen him slide down the pecking order. One thing that may put the selectors at ease is they know what they can expect from him – hard running and even harder hitting!

James Hansen and Saia Fainga’a have been shuffled around more than the cards at a blackjack tabl, making it hard to make a case for either of them. Fainga’a brings hard hitting, strong running and good aggression at the breakdown but can be a penalty magnet. Hansen has a good overall balance to his game but lacks game time.

This brings me to Nathan Charles, the bolter. Charles has enjoyed a great season at the Force off the back of hard work and dedication to make it to the top. For this reason, he gets my nod.

My picks: Moore, Charles, and Tatafu Polota-Nau, the latter purely on experience.

Locks
Now to one of the most contested positions in the squad. With wallaby stalwarts Rob Simmons and James Horwill in the middle of a rubbish season for the Reds, these positions have become hotly contested by plenty of new comers.

The other players putting their hands up are Luke Jones, Cadeyn Neville, Sam Carter, Kane Douglas, Hugh Pyle, Sam Wykes, Will Skelton, Adam Coleman and Mr Fix-it, Scott Fardy.

McKenzie will look for a combination of experience and youth. Horwill and Simmons will both be in the squad, and with Kane Douglas and Hugh Pyle going offshore this season it sees three positions wide open.

My picks: Horwill, Simmons, Jones, Skelton, Coleman.

Back Row
This hotly contested position seems to have been shored up with injuries to Wallabies fetchers David Pocock and Liam Gill. Michael Hooper has two hands on the No. 7 jersey this year, with the experienced Matt Hodgson keeping him honest from a not so distant position.

No. 8 seems to cause a little bit of conversation between rugby followers. Cliff Palu is damaging at 8 and brings a mountain of go-forward to any team he is part of, but will he stay fit enough for the Wallabies to rely on his power. Other candidates for this position include Scott Higginbotham and Ben McCalman from the west.

Blindside flanker should go to Scott Fardy, a man who seems to share Richie McCaw’s ability at the breakdown but without the subtlety. Discussion will come down to tactics employed by McKenzie, and who possibly who Link plays at 5 and 8. Angus Cottrell, Colby Fainga’a and young gun bolter Sean McMahon are also putting their hands up.

My picks: Michael Hooper, Cliff Palu, Scott Fardy starting, with Hodgson, McCalman and Cottrell in the squad.

That’s the forwards done and 19 of the 32 picked, on to the backs and halves.

Scrum-half
Usual suspects Will Genia and Nic White are both putting their hand up and fighting for a starting berth. The form of former Wallabies Luke Burgess and Nick Phipps gives the selectors some discussion on the last halfback spot.

Burgess injuring himself in Saturday night’s game against the Reds at Suncorp has probably made the decision a lot easier for the selectors.

My picks: Will Genia, Nic White and Nick Phipps

Fly-half
A hot topic between rugby followers and couch dwellers over the past few days, with incumbent fly-half and Wallabies vice-captain Quade Cooper suffering a sidelining shoulder injury.

This makes room for the Waratahs’ Bernard Foley and Brumbies Matt Toomua to slog it out for the No. 10 jersey. Add to this selection group former Wallabies fly-half and Waratahs second-five Kurtley Beale, and McKenzie has a larger headache to overcome in the coming days.

I prefer Toomua at 12, and enjoyed watching him grow in that position on the Northern Hemisphere tour last year.

My picks: Bernard Foley and Kurtley Beale.

Centres
I’m not going to even begin to pick the combination that will hit the field in the Wallabies first XV on June 7. Pat McCabe makes my utility selection group and Adam Ashley-Cooper will be picked on the wing being that he played a large part of the international calender there last year.

My picks: Tevita Kuridrani, Matt Toomua, Kyle Godwin.

Wingers
This position has been up and down all year, with no certainties other than the Honey Badger, Nick Cummins. Players putting their hand up include Jesse Mogg, Rod Davies, Adam Ashley-Cooper, Rob Horne and Tom English.

My picks: Nick Cummins and Adam-Ashley Cooper, with Rob Horne, Jesse Mogg and Tom English missing out.

Fullback
Short and sweet – Israel ‘gifted’ Folau. The man has talent by the bucket load and is one of the best pure athletes I have seen in some time.

Utilities
Pat McCabe and Christian Lealiifano are victims of their own flexibility.

Both can cover several positions and will add some depth and comfort to Ewen Mckenzie’s squad for the June Test against France.

The Crowd Says:

2014-05-21T12:25:19+00:00

PiratesRugby

Guest


Imagine the outcry if the WBs don't win! The outrage on this blog alone will force Link to quit.

2014-05-21T12:03:33+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Totally agree Tane, Longbottom is underrated. Game one should be a bit of a blooding, sink or swim, give new people the opportunity

2014-05-21T11:54:57+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


I agree Skelton will be as effective as Folau. He is a sensation and a must. Now is the time, it is our only hope with Palu to have a forward pack with presence. This and developing new props now will determine if the wallabies can be a force. The status quo wont cut the mustard for the RWC. I am very optimistic of the wallaby chances now. The ABs would develop him properly, he would counter the boks locks. Jiggles has to get his red beer googles off, but as I recall he said the same about Folau. Our backs will take care of themselves.

2014-05-21T11:19:13+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Id like to see Longbottom, Jones and Skelton get a run in game 1.

2014-05-21T11:13:56+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Theres no way he shouldnt be in the squad. Last I looked they had Fardy at 6 who plays lock. If they start, the lock gets injured, Fardy moves to lock, McCalman or Higgers comes onto the flank. Personally I would start him. Have him play 45-55 and then bring on Horwill or Jones. He is an amazing assett imo and I hope he refuses selection and moves back to NZ and trys to wear black.

2014-05-21T11:07:53+00:00

Tane Mahuta

Guest


Theres another Quade?

2014-05-21T10:46:39+00:00

PiratesRugby

Guest


If I'm not mistaken, your starting 23 omits every Australian S15 captain.

2014-05-21T09:51:45+00:00

Adsa

Guest


4 this year

2014-05-21T09:22:57+00:00

Rotuma Island.

Guest


Skelton has jumped lineouts before.

2014-05-21T08:26:36+00:00

Chan Wee

Guest


1-Scott Sio. 2-Stephen Moore. 3-James Slipper. 4-James Horwill 5-Rob Simmons 6-Scott Fardy. 7-Michael Hooper. 8-Wyclef Palu. 9-Nick White. 10-Matt Toomua. 11-Nic Cummins 12-Pat Mccabe. 13-Tevita Kuridrani. 14-Adam Ashley-Cooper. 15-Israel Folau. 16-Nathan Charles. 17-longbottom (?). 18-Ben Alexander. 19-Luke Jones / Will Skelton 20-Matt Hodgson. / Scot H'botham 21-Will Genia. 22-Bernard Foley. 23-Kurtley Beale / Jason Woodward ( :P )

2014-05-21T08:06:57+00:00

44bottles

Guest


That's odd, I don't take any team with Higginbotham seriously.

2014-05-21T08:00:44+00:00

Dru

Guest


Tomua or Fardy as Captain options is "left of field" and very interesting. Bold. I like it a lot. Sort of looking forward that perhaps the WBs could use. Not going to happen, but 10/10 for the thought.

2014-05-21T07:59:38+00:00

44bottles

Guest


I think it's just down to practice. They would all know the calls, but match experience helps you know when to call what.

2014-05-21T07:51:22+00:00

44bottles

Guest


Problem is I only see two jumpers in that starting forward pack. If Skelton is picked starting, I don't think we can select Palu as (as far as I'm aware) neither can jump .

2014-05-21T07:50:53+00:00

Dru

Guest


Like it though.

2014-05-21T06:23:53+00:00

Phil

Guest


I like him too,but I don't think the world will end if he doesn't make the team.His form has not been as good as the start of last season when he was virtually a must pick.Link should know him well from his Reds days.

AUTHOR

2014-05-21T05:09:59+00:00

Combesy

Roar Guru


I too want to see the Sio-Moore-Slipper front row. Slipper has played a couple of games at THP this year so that could temp McKenzie into picking him there. Will be interesting to see if he comes back on the 30th as a THP or goes back to playing LHP

2014-05-21T04:59:53+00:00

maxxlord

Roar Rookie


I don't take any team without Scott Higginbotham seriously

2014-05-21T04:50:59+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I don't get the insistence on him playing 80 minutes. He's a sub. On the rare occasion a starting lock gets injured in the first 10, then he'll have to play 70 mins. The stats might say "tackles", but how often does he monster the other guy? No one else does, except Cliffy occasionally. Those two destroyed the Lions physically last weekend.

2014-05-21T04:48:20+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


That's very close to the team I would go for for the first French test. Slipper tried at TH. Skelton on the bench. Simmons beating out Horwill because he's better in the lineout, but he better lose the brain explosions. Oh - and probably Moore as (c), though Hooper is the only other option right now for mine. Guys like Fardy and Toomua are future possibilities the way they're going. Same backline as what worked well on the EOYT, with Foley in for Cooper. I'd contemplate Lilo at 10. Foley's the one I'm least confident in. I think Toomua/Beale and Foley/Toomua are the best 10/12 options, but both have big question marks. Do you keep Toomua at 12? I also think I'd go Kepu on the bench ahead of Alexander. Kepu is a more consistent scrummager, though seems a little out of favour at the Tahs. And I wouldn't mind Smith ahead of Benn robbo as LH replacement, though Robbo can still be good when he's up for it. Higgers misses out with McCalman on the bench. Higgers has been inconsistent for mine. That one's a toss up depending on what you're looking for, but you couldn't argue with going for McCalman given his form.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar