The best and worst NRL defensive halfbacks this year

By Matt King / Roar Rookie

‘Defence is the best form of attack’ and ‘every team is as strong as its weakest link’ are both motivational sayings drummed into kids around rugby league circles.

These quotes are used before games to stimulate aggression and at half time to instil hope.

If your rugby league team is leaking a mountain of points in defence, they will need to score double the points in attack.

‘Run at the little man’ is another great tactic used by beginner coaches and the little man on the field is usually the hooker or the halfback.

Therefore, to be a sensational hooker or halfback they will need to learn to tackle from an early age.

Which had me thinking, who is the best and worst defensive halfback in the NRL?

Before I looked at the statistics and crunched the numbers, I predicted who I thought would be the best and worst defensive No. 7s.

In the horrible defence corner I predicted Eels halfback Chris Sandow. He is constantly being pushed off tackles with ease and his small stature does not help. On the other end of the scale I predicted the Warriors’ Shaun Johnson would be brilliant in defence.

The end results are not all that surprising but there are some interesting figures that were found. The findings were taken from the missed tackles statistics by the main fifteen playmakers.

Let’s start with the worst defensive player maker in the NRL this year to date. Luke Brooks from the Wests Tigers has participated in 11 games in 2014 and has missed a staggering 54 tackles. This gives Brooks an average of 4.9 tackles missed per game, which makes it hard to believe how the Wests Tigers could be sitting sixth on the premiership ladder.

However, Luke’s statistics are not off the charts – he has a contender hot on his heels. Chris Sandow is the next worst defender in the NRL this year so far. Sandow has played fewer games than Brooks due to personal issues he had at the start of the season. He has missed a total of 33 tackles at an average of 4.7 per game.

The next halfback is a little surprising considering his team was in the top three for the first quarter of the season. Albert Kelly has been palmed off a total of 42 tackles in the nine games he has played, giving him an average of 4.66 disastrous attempts to tackle per game.

The next halfback that your team does not want in their defensive line is Tyrone Roberts from the Newcastle Knights. He has successfully slipped off 39 tackles at an average of 3.54 missed tackles per game.

The next six No. 7s are fairly close and barely passed their defensive training as a junior. Ben Hunt from the Brisbane Broncos has missed 36 tackles from 12 games at an average of three, Mitchell Pearce from the Sydney Roosters scrapes in as the sixth-worst defending halfback in the game with the same average as Hunt, but has missed just 30 tackles.

Peter Wallace from the Penrith Panthers is next with 25 misdemeanours and an average of 2.77. Robert Lui from the North Queensland Cowboys, missing 21 crucial game-losing tackles, gives him an average of 2.33. My prediction of best defending halfback falls dramatically short, as Shaun Johnson is next on the list. He has fallen off a tackle a total of 22 times at an average of 2.2 per game.

The Blues, bra-wearing halfback Trent Hodkinson comes in next at an average of 1.99 defensive errors per match. Terry Campese requires a special mention as the fifth-best defensive No. 7 in the NRL this year, although he should be brilliant at defending – he’s has been around for long enough. He has missed only 17 tackles in the 10 games he has played this season at an average of 1.77 tackles per game.

The virtually unknown Jeff Robson features as the fourth-best defensive playmaker, dropping only 12 from the seven games he has played. The top three defensive halfbacks of the NRL in 2014 are not all that astonishing. Number three, Cooper Cronk, has played only nine matches for the Melbourne Storm this year, falling off 14 try line challengers at an average of 1.55. It is true that Queensland are extremely lucky on the halfback front at the moment. Number two, Daly Cherry-Evans, has also played nine games this season, bouncing off only 13 times at an average of 1.44.

This brings us to the best defensive halfback in the NRL for the 2014 season. Adam Reynolds from the South Sydney Rabbitohs has successfully trumped all other No. 7s this season by producing the best defensive performance. He has participated in all 11 games and slipped up on only 14 occasions, which gives him the incredible average of 1.2 tackles missed per game.

One of my defensive predictions was fairly accurate, however there is no way I would have thought Adam Reynolds to be the best defensive playmaker in the game today. Combined with his incredible kicking game, lighting speed and calm composure, perhaps A. Reynolds will be the next household name.

Maybe he could solve NSW’s problems and help them to a series win one day. Or maybe he could be the next incumbent when Cronk and Cherry-Evans retire from the international team. One thing is for sure, coaches will continue to tell their players to ‘run at the little guy’.

The Crowd Says:

2014-06-01T22:37:11+00:00

mushi

Guest


Three things on the use of the missed tackle counts 1. The correlation between pure missed tackles per match and points allowed isn’t as great as you would think. Because not all missed tackles are created equal, some are desperation efforts that slow down a player who gets tackled in the next couple of steps. Given most half back are defending close to some forwards this is typically the case. 2. Shouldn’t we look at error rates as a % of tackles? Otherwise players that just simply get asked to do more or have played more minutes appear “worse” 3. The most important single event in a set of six with regards to defence is positional kicking. A half back that kicks 10 metres further and into more space than his better tackling counterpart is going to have a more positive effect on his team’s defence.

2014-06-01T11:17:02+00:00

Barry Barker

Guest


Kudos to you for including other relevant tackling stats to back up your statement.

2014-06-01T09:34:44+00:00

Josh Allerton

Roar Guru


Campo has been playing halfback all year apart from the last 2 weeks.

2014-06-01T05:59:35+00:00

Peter Rabbit

Guest


Thanks Bob for reminding me of an old saying ---Queenslanders are so slow, their thongs don't slap when they walk.

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T05:37:42+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


A bit of a back flip on your previous comment?

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T05:36:16+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


There you go didn't know that about Johnson. I based my prediction purely on size and current form. I used foxsportsstats.com and went through every single game of the year to come up with this article.

2014-06-01T04:47:07+00:00

that az guy

Guest


good read, given the bigger guys run at them it is not a big surprise that they miss some tackles, how does the missed per game stat hold up against forwards? also interested to see the fullbacks defence stats

2014-06-01T04:45:52+00:00

Matthew Buxton

Roar Pro


Geez these comments are a bit harsh. Maybe I'm chuffed as a Souths fan. When Adam Reynolds was coming up through the ranks, before he played first grade, his coaches all said he was one of the best defensive halves they've seen, and this just backs that up. He does well for a little bloke!

2014-06-01T04:37:42+00:00

Barry Barker

Guest


Good analysis of missed tackles. Wouldn't swap worst offender Brooks with any of the other halves Soward was a turnstile who helped Dragons win a comp. Souths Reynolds so far failed to get Souths to a GF, Could not bring home the bacon.

2014-06-01T02:40:20+00:00

DMC

Guest


Interesting article Matt, thanks. Is it just me or is it really hard to get full and comparative (ie halfbacks from all teams) statistics. NRL.com stats section has been reduced for public viewing during the past few years, and no other site is particularly good. Or am I missing something/ another site? On Johnson, your expectation that he would be a top defensive halfback is not well founded. He was a touch footy player and relatively new to league. For his first season and a half in the NRL he was an abysmal tackler, lacklustre jersey grabber and for a bloke that is not small, it wasn't good enough. Credit to him, he has worked hard on this aspect of his game and improving defensive stats reflect that. I would suggest (without adequate stats available to be sure) he is the most improved defensive halfback of the past few years.

2014-06-01T02:37:43+00:00

The spectator

Guest


campese threw me, my bad!

2014-06-01T02:27:39+00:00

krayola

Guest


I was a bit harsh, so apologies Matt. You are doing this out of your own time. I read this on the League Live app and assumed the content on there was sourced and at least partially paid for. I think my frustration arose from the fact that there is a lack of deeper analysis among NRL stats and just a general lack of progressive thinking in the media that cover the game. Leading to articles like this one, which while they are an interesting topic, could be developed so much further.

2014-06-01T01:58:05+00:00

Bob Horke

Guest


Whats wrong Matt, Blues got your tongue? Sounds like someones been paid off by the NSW to omit legends like the king!!!

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T01:37:40+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


If you see below, Reynolds has made the most tackles in total out of all halfbacks and has better averages no matter how you look at the stats.

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T01:35:12+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


See below tackles per game v missed tackles

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T01:33:27+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


Oh Bob

2014-06-01T01:21:18+00:00

Schuey

Guest


Krayola, he doesn't get paid to write articles so forgive him for being 'lazy'. I think ur criticism is very harsh. Waiting for your effort so we can tear it to shreds. I enjoyed the article and learned from it.

2014-06-01T01:12:40+00:00

Bob Horke

Guest


What about Wally Lewis?

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T01:11:35+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


Yes, if you read the headline it says "The best and worst NRL defensive halfbacks this year". This year meaning 2014, you are right I should have added that in the article. I have put up more stats in the comments as well, have a look.

AUTHOR

2014-06-01T01:07:51+00:00

Matt King

Roar Rookie


Alright as requested. I got the total amount of tackles and divided against missed tackles and found out how many tackles each player made before missing a tackle. In order from worst to best again. Name Total Tackles Total Missed Avg. Brooks 123 54 2.27 Sandow 123 33 3.72 Roberts 156 39 4.00 A. Kelly 172 42 4.09 Hunt 196 36 5.44 Lui 133 21 6.33 Pearce 202 30 6.73 Johnson 150 22 6.81 Wallace 176 25 7.04 Hodkinson 136 19 7.15 Robson 117 12 9.75 Campese 184 17 10.82 Cronk 154 14 11.00 DCE 172 13 13.23 Reynolds 212 14 15.4 Therefore Reynolds wins out again, completing the most tackles also. The others didn't really move around too much and Brooks is still the worst defensively.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar