What we learnt after a sublime month of rugby

By Will Macpherson / Expert

So the next stop’s a triple shot of Bledisloe action alongside a Rugby Championship, eh? Cool. Then a mouth-watering November in northern climes? Alright, if we must.

And a World Cup just around the corner? Based on the last month, rugby, you’re well and truly spoiling us.

The action either side of the ditch was mighty fine over the last three weekends (besides that miserable evening in Melbourne), but what exactly did we learn?

1) The alphabety Smiths – Aaron, Ben and Conrad – are in classes of their own
Unfortunately they couldn’t do it in tidy A,B,C fashion but these three grabbed a Test each by the scruff of their scruff of its little English neck and with it ripped Red Rose hopes apart, petal by petal.

Smith is the most common surname in England but the sight of folk from the Old Dart filing out of Kiwi stadiums – and there were a fair few in each, especially Dunedin – bemoaning the brilliance of a man with that name became a weekly occurrence this month.

First it was Conrad’s go in Auckland. There was a sense of inevitability about the All Blacks winning that cagey, scrappy game and it was appropriate that Conrad Smith, the Kiwis’ man for all seasons, situations, climes and conditions, popped up to score it. The legs may be slowing but the mid sure ain’t. Malakai Fekitoa was brilliant in Hamilton but based on the way he spoke in the build-up to the game, he knows he was just keeping Smith’s seat warm.

After all, Conrad’s lost just seven of 77 Tests. That’s no coincidence.

In Dunedin it was Ben who was wowing us, in his first shot at fullback for the All Blacks. After he served up a repeat dose in Hamilton, it’ll be a long way back for ol’ Izzy Dagg, but the Smith who really caught the eye in the Third Test was little Aaron. As English fans searched for positives amid the dire first half display that cost them the game, many pointed to Ben Youngs’ performance.

But I just didn’t get it. Sure, there was the neat snag on Kieran Read and the break for Marland Yarde’s try, but I simply couldn’t understand how a man who’d been so utterly out-played by his opposite number could be singled out for praise.

Watching the game back, Smith was infinitely better than Youngs – but that was purely down to the brilliance of the latter not the inadequacy of the former. Smith’s service from the base was perfect, his snipes well-timed and his defence excellent. Ultimately, he had enough of the zip and fizz of champagne to make Youngs look like a stodgy tankard of mead.

2) The French are dross
The Wallabies have achieved plenty and come a long way in the last three weeks. Combinations are clearer, the leadership pool and tight five stocks look deeper than we realised and the back line has a bit about it.

But ahead of Bledisloe season, there can be no assumption that they’ve received anything like ample preparation. Put simply, the French weren’t up to it this year. While Messrs Guirado, Parra and Chouly impressed intermittently, no Frenchmen showed anything like the consistency required to succeed.

Phillipe Saint-Andre – surely not far from the guillotine – can blame whatever the Top 14s imports all he likes (lest we forget he perpetuated the problem while Toulon’s coach with the signings of Matt Giteau and the like) but 40 months into the job he has no idea what his best team is.

Far sterner Tests – where we will learn even more – lie ahead for the Wallabies.

3) Mid-week matches are a wonderful thing
England went a little off-piste in the final week of their tour with a trip to Christchurch to play the Crusaders. For many – players, locals, media and opposition – this was one of the tour’s real highlights. England were supposed to play many of their 2011 World Cup games in the city but for obvious reasons decamped to Dunedin and Queenstown, where their infamous dwarf-tossing revelry took place. Their management had been keen to return to Christchurch since.

It was a productive few days. A mixture of newbies and experienced internationals played impressively against a fired-up Crusaders side containing six All Blacks and with all the fun of the fare that comes with the Canterbury experience in front of a packed out AMI Stadium.

The pre-match entertainment – blonde maidens, noble steeds and actual Crusaders – was brilliant and the crowd had a ball. In the post-match presser, Todd Blackadder called for more mid-week matches. I know we live in an ultra-professional age, but there should be, and in this case was, much, much more to these tours than just the Test matches on Saturday.

4) England versus All Blacks at Twickenham is the most mouth-watering of the upcoming clashes
Sorry to pee on the parade of the ‘Bledisloe Festival’ (give me strength) that was launched yesterday, but I believe, even after a blackwash, the most exciting clash on the rugby horizon is England versus New Zealand at Twickenham on November 8.

Twice in New Zealand England showed they had the minerals and resources to take on the All Blacks but twice they fell short. Once the wounds have healed and the heads have been cleared on a Caribbean beach, they’ll be mighty hungry for revenge.

Twickenham, of course, was the last place the All Blacks lost, 18 games ago. Less than a year from a World Cup final on that very ground and England, with their pride tainted after some big talk in New Zealand, must dispel that nagging feeling that they’ve still won nothing of worth and lay a marker down ahead of a World Cup that they’ll believe to be theirs.

They’ve claimed the All Black “aura” is fading, but accept they remain the team to beat. What’s more, from Brodie-gate through a tough series, New Zealand – public, players, maybe even press – has developed a level of respect and admiration for this England side and their modus operandi. There’s a fair bit of appetising action to get through first, but this is set to be a hum-dinger.

5) Big Bill Skelton is ready, but give ‘Cliff Palu some credit
He’s the man of the moment so I best give him his due. Will Skelton only played 58 minutes this June but by god he looked good. It wasn’t the sheer scale of his frame, it wasn’t that try with Frenchmen falling off, it wasn’t even that outrageous cleanout.

It was that stunning short-ball to Izzy Folau just after the break that. How the hell can a thing looking so cumbersome produce a moment of such subtlety? Skelton looks like his hands should crush a ball like Lenny crushed those bunnies in Of Mice and Men. Instead he’s got the manual dexterity of a surgeon.

But amid Big Bill’s excellence, let’s not forget the performance of Wycliff Palu. I’ve never been his biggest fan and have used these pages to advocate the selection of his rivals at no.8.

But on Saturday he was brilliant and showed exactly why he’s racked up a half-ton of caps. His combination with Scott Fardy and Michael Hooper is balanced and he was dominant at the breakdown and bustling with ball in hand. Chapeau, sir.

Rugby, just keep doing what you’re doing.

The Crowd Says:

2014-06-26T14:44:04+00:00

JimmyB

Guest


Just out of curiosity Will, who was bigging up Ben Youngs?

2014-06-26T07:34:33+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


The IRB don't recognise Cyprus' results as being official test matches.

2014-06-26T07:19:56+00:00

warrenexpatinnz

Roar Guru


Sorry somer, Keith wins as he is a New Zealander, he is an iconic rugby commentator and he was pricking the AB hyped media ballon. If anything we should say "All Blacks close in on Tier 1 rugby record" so we differentiate between a part record or a complete record. Yes I'm having fun with this.

2014-06-26T06:56:31+00:00

Jackster

Guest


Oh yes! It feels gggoooooooodd to be ab supporter right now. This team likes to win, therefore set records, therefore break records so why not the next one! 18 in a rows coming up...and deservedly so for this outstanding team. Great series England! BUT our boys aint too old to kick your butts again come 2015...damn! 15 months is too f@#$÷% long to wait!!

2014-06-26T05:47:54+00:00

DanFan

Guest


Aaron Cruden is the new generation of AB leaders and he is on the field. Also, Sam Whitelock is already standing out in that area. I see many leaders of the future in that team already.

2014-06-26T04:48:47+00:00

somer

Guest


Well Keith is being a pedant, it's obviously the Tier 1 record which everyone is referring to and the only one that carries any real gravitas. Cyprus also aren't a full member of the IRB so none of their matches count towards world rankings.

2014-06-26T04:14:58+00:00

Riccardo

Guest


"...England may beat NZ at Twickenham, but they’re no chance against the Wallabies". Like last year I guess. How did that turn out again? I'm expecting a repeat on 29 November. But by all means, keep the hyperbole coming...

2014-06-26T02:34:53+00:00

warrenexpatinnz

Roar Guru


It is the rugby record as stated by Quin that counts regardless of whether it is tier 1, SANZAR only or Six nations. Keith is far more of a rugby expert than I will ever propose to be and his view is correct. IF the ABs beat the Wallabies and achieve 18 wins then congratulations to them for extending their impressive winning streak but it will not be a world record, it will not be a rugby record until they reach 23 to equal then 24 to pass. Trivial I know but factually correct.

2014-06-26T00:04:15+00:00

ChrisT

Guest


I love it when you boys comment so knowledgably on a tournament you clearly don't even watch. England finished on equal points with the overall winners Ireland (who England beat) and won the Triple Crown. To remind you, you win that by also beating a Welsh team that is very capable of being a part of knocking Australia out of the RWC group stages this time around. A much better French team than the one that only finished 6 points off the Wallabies (who were playing at home) were the only team to beat England, by 2 points, in Paris, in a game that could and should have been England's for the taking. But yeah, actually mediocre because England are setting higher standards now.

2014-06-25T18:54:59+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks for the article. My top five: 1. Australia has developed depth 2. ABs needs new generation of onfield leaders 3. The real Boks hasn't appeared yet 4. All the teams played to their rank (ie NZ SA AU England FR Wales) 5. Player weight matters more than ever, but cannot sacrifice speed (backs) or set piece (forwards)

2014-06-25T16:05:42+00:00

pieter sauerman

Guest


And the one thing we've learned is that Wayne Barnes must have serious blackmail material! After his "magnificent" management of the lifeless 6-0 win in the Australian series, he gets awarded the NZ-Bok game at Ellispark. Refereeing bodies obviously are afraid they get undone by the players again! Ridiculous appointment, how he referees anything but 7 year old girls since 2007 I don't know!

2014-06-25T15:02:05+00:00

StrYdeRZA

Guest


Weren't ABs gifted a run to the final in 2007... and how exactly did that Wallaby v Springbok qtr final in 2011 come about? ... just saying...

2014-06-25T12:34:56+00:00

niwdEyaJ

Roar Guru


looking at the draw, I don't think it's as simple as that... Aus & SA are on the horror side of the draw.. AB's are practically gifted a run to the final whereas Aus & SA will have to play each other and England just to make it to the Final...

2014-06-25T12:06:38+00:00

Blinky Bill of Bellingen NSW

Guest


Now THAT would have been an interesting contest. :)

2014-06-25T11:03:25+00:00

Harry Jones

Guest


Yes, the only true benchmark is the RC. The team that wins is the WC favourite.

2014-06-25T10:54:18+00:00

Zero Gain

Guest


Exactly, and they were beaten by France too. Don't let actual results get in the way of a good dream. Talk about talking it up.

2014-06-25T10:53:49+00:00

Fair go

Guest


My forecast: by Xmas and with speight Higgers and bam-bam and carter Sio and OConnor and hopefully a few others showing up through the rugby championship that the wallabies will be the talk of the town. They are progressing well with each game and will benefit enormously for some time in the furnace with the ABs and boks.

2014-06-25T10:51:47+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Good piece but agree with Chuck, we here in the South have just kicked off the International season so plenty of rugby ahead before even considering the Spring Tour. Not to mention Super Rugby resumes and the pointy end of the season awaits. The RC is the big one everyone is waiting for down here.

2014-06-25T10:23:21+00:00

Ralf

Guest


Good article.. kiwis still look good, like an old doctor who uses a few tired but effective techniques. But the real game in RWC will be who gets out of POOL A. Wales did pretty well against the Boks, England coming along well, Aus starting to gel. Next years winner of the RWC is more likely to be who wins Pool A... NZ have an easy run to the foals but will be old and takeable.

2014-06-25T10:02:38+00:00

Dru

Guest


Nice article. Thanks.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar