Underboks: Projected to lose in Salta, South Africa to win at a canter

By Harry Jones / Expert

The scrum is toast. The lineout is in shambles. Ruan Pienaar scored the only try thus far in the tournament, but nobody in his home country believes in him.

Yep, South Africa are the underdogs this week.

The young saviour Handré Pollard is discredited or demoralised. Cornal Hendricks’ first weakness exposed for all to see: he is shaky under the ‘Garryowen’.

Willem Alberts is injured, and thus, we cannot make the gain line. The maul is hackneyed. South Africa is descending into a new Dark Age.

Sprinkle a few drops of holy water on these Bok babies and they melt. A baptism of shame awaits in Latin America, a papal excommunication from clear second in the world, to a team beaten by the twelfth rugby apostle.

The numbers, history, the mood, and realism support this bleak view.

Perdition on the Pampas: it is over, the seven-Test winning streak, the bright view of the future, the four-try average, the defence will even crack, and all we once loved about the formidable Bok loose trio will come undone.

In their first year as a Rugby Championship invitee, the Argentineans drew with the highly favoured Springboks, and South Africa was lucky to get that result. Only a Frans Steyn chargedown try saved Heyneke Meyer the ignominy of being the first Bok coach to lose an official Test to Argentina.

Last year, in the same stadium in vineyard-rich Mendoza, after a 73-13 hiding in Pretoria, the Pumas clawed and scratched (and maybe even bit) their way to a tense finale, with Morne Steyn saving Meyer again.

You would think that the Argentine power brokers would pick cold Mendoza again – third time’s a charm. But the drenched and embarrassed Boks will now see a new site: the city of Salta.

Salta is a colonial city in the far and dusty northwest corner of Argentina. The weather is projected to be 33 degrees in the afternoon, and balmy at night.

The size of the stadium will remind many of the Boks of high school derbies: 20,000 fans only. The predicted mood: enraged fury.

The field is Bloemfontein hard; it might suit Willie le Roux’s chip-and-chase game. He was one of the few Boks to emerge from the deluge of Pretoria with his already world-class reputation enhanced.

He has worked to become a high ball specialist; the two best exhibits of this proposition are last week’s Test in hail and driving rain with very fired-up Pumas chasing with great desire; and the first June Test against Wales in which le Roux was magisterial in the air. Textbook timing of the leap, the sideways cradle, the intent to attack when landing.

But why would the Boks be better in Salta than Pretoria? Can Francois Louw play better than last week? Two pilfers, sixteen vital tackles, Argentine ball slowed to a standstill, a couple of lineout takes, and full bore engine for 80 minutes against an inspired Argentine pack? Won’t he be sore and mortal?

I wrote recently about what it’s like to be Duane Vermeuelen. We all know that Thor is part human; only partly a god. Last week he had to hammer down behind a back-pedalling scrum. Will a 22-hour flight restore his power?

Last week, Pienaar created and finished a beautiful try in the first stanza of the Test. Won’t it be years – or never – before we see this anachronistic anomaly again?

With Meyer obviously outmatched by Daniel Hourcade, the all-Shark front row toothless, the gangly Lood de Jäger entrusted with masterminding the lineout, Eben Etzebeth still regaining match fitness, the hole left by Alberts, their breakdown woes, the painstakingly predictable service of Pienaar, the probable return of Steyn in the deep, deep pocket, from whence no probing attack ever was launched, the mismatched and pass-adverse midfield of Jean de Villiers and Damian de Allende, the lonely forgotten Bryan Habana, and a bench that brings no zip; the Boks are the underdogs.

But they’ll win in a canter, after a brutal first 20 minutes of bare knuckle brawling. Boks by 15 or so; with a nice array of highlights.

Why?

1. Weather matters in rugby
Maybe more than in any other sport, except golf. I agree with the criticism of the poor adaptation skills by the halfbacks and the captain and vice-captain last week, and Meyer is ultimately to blame.

But the Argentines won’t be able to rely on hail and locusts and frogs and darkness this week: it’ll feel exactly like the weather on the du Plessis farm. There will be space and there will be mismatches at 2, 4, 6, 8, 11, 12, 14, and 15.

Rain obscures; but a good hard field exposes speed and power differentials.

2. Embarrassment
External and internal motivators both tap into the power of embarrassed, proud men, who have dedicated their lives to being the best.

Look for five forwards to play inspired mongrel rugby: Beast Mtawarira (a warrior who never got anything easy), Bismarck (who has been cursing softly for 100 hours), Eben Etzebeth (who is not happy and won’t be happy until scores are settled), Louw (who has never been the happy-go-lucky guy he seems), and Vermeulen (no commentary required).

This is a core. They feel bad. They want to make things right.

3. Meyer has earned their respect and love
Watch how Meyer takes responsibility for failures, but is very critical of minor technical points when his team wins easily. Love him, hate him, or ‘meh’ him, Meyer has this team playing for each other, for him, and they don’t relent.

I expect a highly focused and razor-sharp Bok team to take the field in Salta. They would despise giving Meyer the distinction of ‘first to lose to the Pumas’. They’ll play for Meyer.

If I’m wrong, I’ll write an ode to the glory of Wyatt Crockett’s soaring boring backside.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2014-08-24T12:41:08+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


The plot was lost The game was won But only by the skin Of our underpants Our front row back peddled Then ran backward Then got in fetal position And surrendered Meanwhile, many Boks didn't tackle hard or well I was ashamed Also, I'm very sad that Malherbe is out We have no tighthead But I must point out a few saving graces: 1. Louw & Vermeulen stood up and fought 2. Habana & Hendricks finished brilliantly 3. We were the fitter team at the end 4. Our bench made a huge impact 5. 33-31 and 8 points on the log No excuses; never excuses Argentina played very well--better than we did, for 60 minutes; but we know how to win in 20 minutes That's it Humility

2014-08-24T11:26:15+00:00

fanie

Guest


So who lost the plot.Come on Harry be a man tell us who lost the plot.Was it your written word the Springboks the captain or the coach.You don t have to answer i will take it as all of the above mentioned.If there are excuses for this pathetic rugby display please don t put it in The Roar.

2014-08-24T11:03:05+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


Still want to talk after the game, Harry? :-)

2014-08-24T11:02:30+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


Beast is a gimmick. Always has been. Super Rugby is basically irrelevant. The Tahs always had strong when Al Baxter was their 3.

AUTHOR

2014-08-23T13:17:35+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Always nervous on test days. But looking forward to it, too. Juan Smith takes the field--what a player! Eben Etzebeth back in gear. Handre Pollard the kid--can he bounce back? What will Willie pull out of his bag of tricks? How dastardly will the Argentines be? Who will lose the plot? Who will seize the stage? SA by 15-20.

2014-08-23T01:14:55+00:00

Owen McCaffrey

Roar Guru


The only thing people are going to remember is the score. There is an international referee and TMO so if either team breaks rules they risk penalties or infringements. I sense a little nervousness. Everyone knows Argentina has a 6 point advantage at home on the Boks so in theory they should win today.

2014-08-22T23:19:02+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Nah. That's not at all my proposition. You might discover from my 2500+ comments, especially about WBs and OZ SR teams - are focused scrums, ruck and the pack playing tight. But for the Boks, I sense that HM is trying to get his team to play wider that was has been their traditional gameplay.

2014-08-22T19:09:08+00:00


Yep, I have noticed that attitude amongst my fellow Aussie posters. Tough way to live, but I suppose it is a case of different priorities for different Unions, eh?

2014-08-22T18:44:33+00:00

Daws

Guest


Welcome to Australian rugby BB, where spinning it wide is expected regardless of what foot you're on.

AUTHOR

2014-08-22T17:03:52+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


There are very few saints in the top teams' packs. Argentina is probably less angelic than anyone else currently.

AUTHOR

2014-08-22T15:35:51+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Haha! Ben S, are you really ragging on Beast when he has a bulging disc and was a consensus SR prop? I think you are being satirical

2014-08-22T15:34:32+00:00


I actually don't have many issues with the manner in which Walsh officiates, I don't think I would like him much as a person if I had to meet him, but his refereeing is sound in my opinion.

2014-08-22T15:32:40+00:00


Well, these past few years, even when we haven't done well we generally still win ;)

2014-08-22T15:30:42+00:00


To be honest I think we have a few players that overstep the line of intimidation, Bakkies was one of them, Dean Greyling another. Etzebeth was taught a valuable lesson by Nathan Sharpe in 2012, if you going to headbutt someone that taunts you you will be banned, the alternative is if you are going to get a ban, use it to the full extent of the law, really headbutt the gut (OK that was a joke) Our domestic club rugby can be a bit thuggish, it was like that when I still played, but that is 20 years ago. Even then, it was more a case between certain clubs due to feuds or long standing issues. For the most part, our players aren't deliberately dirty, but some have very short fuses and do react when it is clear they will get in trouble for it.

2014-08-22T15:04:06+00:00

Chivas

Guest


And for the record Fitzy was known to be a bit of a dirty player, so the fact he got confused as a pork sandwich by the bloke he was holding down is no great surprise. I am just not sure it is a response which can really be legitimised :-)

2014-08-22T13:29:46+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


Done well like last week? "Beeeeeasssstttttt!"

2014-08-22T13:23:03+00:00

IvanN

Guest


Id imagine that its worse for England and Wales to keep losing to such a 1 dimensional teeam, than to lose to a well oiled unit like NZ ? I guess it only takes 1 dimension done well...

2014-08-22T12:48:43+00:00

Ben.S

Roar Guru


Oh mannnnn...

2014-08-22T12:11:30+00:00

fanie

Guest


Ja well it can also be Salta oh Salta what have we done to deserve such negative rugby and a ref like Walsh enough i said i will await the last whistle of the match before i put pen to paper and in BB words at present everything said is conjecture.

AUTHOR

2014-08-22T12:04:47+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Pienaar is an incredibly gifted footballer Played 4 positions for Boks? Old school skillset Not a nicer guy around Very easy to cheer on Hope he scores 4 tries 4 different ways

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar