Makybe Diva Stakes preview

By Adam Page / Roar Guru

Spring is here and when it comes to Melbourne that means one thing… Group l racing at Flemington. And that begins this Saturday with the Makybe Diva Stakes day.

The feature race on the card is the $400,000 Group l Makybe Diva Stakes (1600m), named in honour of the best staying mare we will ever see. She is the only horse to have won three Melbourne Cups and the only horse in history to win at four Melbourne Cup carnivals.

The race itself has been a great platform leading into the better races, and as such, the race is saved for good horses. Northerly, Weekend Hussler and Shocking are most notable recent winners.

The top pick in betting is Dissident thanks to his dominant win in the Memsie Stakes (1400m) on August 30, winning by over two lengths and running smart time. Five of his ten rivals that run here finished behind him in that race, but as we know Flemington and Caulfield are two completely different beasts. I think he could be a risk at the price, given that it is his first time at ‘Headquarters’ and he won’t get the perfect run he got first up.

Boban caught the eye of everyone with his slashing fourth in the Missile Stakes (1200m) on August 9, then ran in the Memsie and had no luck, getting stuck three wide with no cover. When he doesn’t have something in front of him he tends to pull his head off and have nothing left for the straight.

Despite that, he loomed and sprinted for about 100 metres, but the tough run told just late and he ground way away for fifth to Dissident. He won the Emirates over the identical path last year and will appreciate the bigger surroundings. If he gets cover and a drag into the race, it’ll take a pretty good effort from his rivals to hold off his turn of foot.

Many, including those on The Roar, were quick to pot Puissance De Lune after his first up failure in the P.B. Lawrence, but you have to remember he was three wide with no cover and was first up from the Cox Plate and coming back from a tendon. He then bounced back to his best form with a closing third in the Memsie after getting the suck run behind the three on speed runners. He saves his best for Flemington and will take some beating, even more so if there is any give in the ground.

Messene was very good in the Missile behind Sweet Idea, then he went to the Memsie and looked all at sea around Caulfield and was a beaten horse on the turn. Can the loss be put down to the fact he was another victim of a Sydney horse failing at their Caulfield? We will learn more after this weekend. Ability wise, he is very good, but that last effort has turned me off a touch.

Spillway looked very sharp in recent jumpouts at Flemington and brought that on race day with a narrow second in the P.B Lawrence Stakes (1400m) to Star Rolling on August 16. He had the gun run behind the speed and looked the winner 100 metres, but Star Rolling packed one too many punches. Big test here against some quality animals, but he himself is good quality also, so he can’t be left out.

One roughie to look out for is Sertorious. He was excellent in the Memsie, really surging the last 100 metres, and ran through the line as well as I’ve seen for a while. I think whatever he runs in over 2000 metres and beyond he’ll be ultra competitive in, but he is another who races quite well at Flemington and will relish the rise to 1600 metres. You know he’ll be very strong at the end.

Selections
Boban (3) on top, to beat Puissance De Lune (6) and chuck in Sertorious (5).

Other key races on the program start off with the $200,000 Group ll Let’s Elope Stakes (1400m) for the mares. The race looks down to four genuine winning chances, headed by Gregers, who has done nothing wrong in two runs this time in, both resulting in wins.

She looked in trouble last time out at Caulfield, but surged late and proved too good in the last little bit. Big query on her at 1400 metres, and I think she’ll be better with some cover this time in order to run the journey. If she runs the distance out, she’ll go close.

Commanding Jewel got the big pass mark when she savaged the line late near the fence when third to Gregers at Caulfield. She was given a gun ride to win this race last year, and in what looked to be a strong edition. Goes up two kilograms from that win, but looks much stronger and imposing now, along with the fact she has a stack of upside.

Based on the way she trialled, I thought this could be the best prep Dear Demi produces, and she certainly didn’t deter that with her outstanding fifth to Gregers at Caulfield. She had no right to finish off the way she did given the race was set up for those on the speed, but she really let down hard and was beautiful through the line. Looking for further, but her class will carry her a long way.

The other winning chance is Solicit, who has her first run as a four-year-old mare, and she looks on target this Spring thanks to a recent jumpout placing where she hit the line with purpose. She has good tactical speed and can sit close to the speed, and will be strong at the end of 1400 metres.

Selections
Gregers (3) the one to beat, ahead of Commanding Jewel (1) and Dear Demi (2).

The Danehill Stakes (1400m) has been a great kick off point for three-year-olds in recent years, and is usually won by one of the more dominant gallopers – Black Caviar in 2009, Sepoy in 2011 and Snitzerland in 2012.

Brazen Beau was one of the better youngsters during the latter part of the Autumn and into the Winter. He finished off his campaign with a fighting second to Almalad in the JJ Atkins after seemingly having the race won 300 metres out. The eventual winner packed plenty under pressure and just outgunned him late, by I think Brazen Beau is a sprinter, hence why he is resuming here to get a look at the track and distance in readiness for the Coolmore Stud. Trials have been sharp and Pumper has made the trip from Sydney to steer.

Get The Nod was ultra impressive when he resumed with a thumping win in the Vain Stakes, made even more dominant by the fact he sat wide all the way with no cover. Barrier one down the Flemington straight is the concern because it can be a major disadvantage, but he is a very, very good horse who has proven he can overcome adversity and still beat his rivals.

Big, big watch on the star filly from Adelaide, Go Indy Go. She was outstanding in the Autumn and proved she was one of the best youngsters going with an outstanding triumph in the Champagne Stakes during the Championships at Randwick. Hasn’t trialled publicly in preparation for this, but the class and the fact she’ll be strong at the end of 1200 metres brings her right into the mix.

Selections
Brazen Beau (2) in a ripping race, to beat Get The Nod (3) and Go Indy Go (7).

The final key race to look at is the Bobbie Lewis Quality (1200m). This has also been a good horses race, with the likes of Bon Hoffa, Doubtful Jack and We’re Gonna Rock saluting. 2013 winner Speediness is attempting back-to-back and has looked quite good in recent Caulfield jumpouts, so a fresh forward showing wouldn’t surprise.

El Roca has had a few hiccups this Spring, with little niggles here and there, but he looks over them based on how sharp he looked in a recent jumpout here, winning and winning with plenty in reserve. He comfortably beat Dissident first up last time in and both of these horses have gone on to bigger and better things, so that form reads pretty well here, along with the fact he is drawn around early speed, so he should get the beaut sit.

The old warrior Temple Of Boom has to go in as a serious threat here. At the start of the Autumn he was just okay without being anything great, but a change of riding tactics saw sharp improvement. He caused a boil-over in the Victory before running three ripping races at Group l level. Another who hasn’t trialled publicly, but he loves the straight six and Tegan Harrison makes the trek from Brisbane to ride.

Flamberge was given a gun ride by Vlad Duric to win first up at Caulfield in Theshark.com.au Stakes, beating home a pretty good field. His form from the Autumn was excellent, with a couple of fifths to Lankan Rupee at Group l level. Considering that, he looks very well placed here, especially with the run under his belt.

Selections
There are a host of other chances, but I’ll stick with El Roca (5), ahead of Temple Of Boom (2) and Flamberge (3).

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2014-09-12T03:48:16+00:00

Adam Page

Roar Guru


I agree with Messene. He should be at least double his price after the way he went in the Memsie, but being trained at Flemington, bigger surroundings...I doubt he can win, but I wouldn't be totally surprised. In the Let's Elope, Commanding Jewel is starting to get to rock bottom odds of $2.50. Yes, she was the run of the race in the Cockram, but second up, the chance she could run flat, up against Gregers who has the extra run under the belt and maps so well on the speed map. The Danehill is a fair dinkum lottery. Haven't seen Looks Like The Cat trial, but based on what I saw in the Winter, he was the one out of the J J Atkins with the most upside, so he is the interesting runner for mine. I was very impressed with Brazen Beau and his recent trials, and I agree with Nordic Empire. He is overs and should get a nice smother behind the pace. Also keen to see how Rhythm To Spare goes in the last. His latest jumpout at Flemington was first class and looks ready to rock and roll first up from the good gate with Oliver.

AUTHOR

2014-09-12T03:41:12+00:00

Adam Page

Roar Guru


On face value, Dissident was impressive, but he was given an absolute plum ride by Melham behind a good speed. At the price, I think he is serious unders. Sure, he could win impressively again, but he is too short for mine. This is the race PDL has been set for since coming back from injury, so I am thinking he'll go very close if he reproduces his Memsie effort, along with natural improvement. If there was any rain about, he'd be on top.

2014-09-12T02:29:06+00:00

andrew

Guest


im sertorisus' biggest fan, but this is not his race. he has qualified for the caul cup and high enough up in order entry to be certain of a run. they are just churning him over in readiness. a few nice 5th's or so in WFA lead ups, and then tighten him up for his grand final. I think he is the perfect type of horse for a caul cup, he is decent odds at $31 too. but not sat, over 1600m in a G1 WFA race, with plenty of good milers in the field. fawkner is the value in the main race. super record at flem, and he is not just a 'dour stayer' resuming, rather a horse with a genuine turn of foot and quality to him. had some super wins this track in spring 2013 in fast times. has an 8kg swing on dissident for beating him in last year George main (for what its worth). as for the others, its time for divan to take centre stage, and am confident if he can just get a truly run race, we will see a star in the making. at $7, this is a good time to invest. you could be taking short quotes him in coming weeks. jacquinot bay is good value in the 2nd, where I don't overly rate the two faves off wet track winter formlines, and a race otherwise full of dour stayers with poor form, jacquinot ran well 1st up and was alongside st jean last time. a few specials in Adelaide. strobes in the 1st, burgundy blast in the 2nd and classy jack in the last.

2014-09-12T02:23:58+00:00

ray ford

Guest


Most wfa gr 1 races are won by the runners up front in the cock-pit. think of the great Wfa horses that have done that. The king, sunline, might n power. Dissident ridden well, will eyeball the leader or lead himself. Boban & co will be back & have to be ready to go when Dissident lets down. Catch him if you can.

2014-09-12T01:31:04+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


All great points Bondy, and I think you're right about PDL especially.

2014-09-12T00:03:19+00:00

Bondy

Guest


Cam I think PDL has to go back to a handicap to win a feature , I backed Messene last start and won't again, if he wins I'll be booing . Comm Jewel seems now to short for mine Greggers gets an easy sit or lead. I backed Nordic Empire last start I felt like I'd been captured by Isis . D Oliver's got a solid book of rides. A great card at Flemington ..

2014-09-11T22:51:09+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Great preview Adam, and I love that line about Makybe Diva being the only horse to win at four Melbourne Cup carnivals. I'm not sure I'd come across that before. I'm happy to call Dissident the horse to beat, with Boban third up at a Flemington mile as his main danger, but I feel both are just a touch skinny. I can't see how PDL could beat all of Dissident, Boban and Spillway, and think the market has him incorrectly installed as third favourite. How Messene is at anything but healthy double figure odds is beyond me. Biggest unders of the day at $7.50. Spillway is a huge danger, he beat PDL by about the same margin Dissident did, yet is three times the odds. Fawkner is also capable of running a huge race at a track and distance he loves, and is the fourth winning chance. I'm going to do some Cox Plate doubles with him today. The Let's Elope looks a cracker with a strong top end. Commanding Jewel the one to beat off her first-up run that no-one missed, but she'll be jumping at rock bottom odds because of it. Very interested to see how Solicit goes and where she ends up this campaign. Seriously, where do you start with the Danehill. Looks Like The Cat shouldn't be forgotten, with that Brazen Beau/Almalad form (you never know which of the three year olds has made the most progression). And don't forget Nordic Empire at $18 too. Underrated colt who was only just bloused by Chivalry, supposedly the best colt in Victoria, in the McNeil (admittedly he was a bit weak in the Vain, but wasn't comfortable in the lead and is a much better horse with a sit). What a race. I'm with you on the Bobbie Lewis quinella, and I don't hate Charlie Boy either, but anything could pop up here. What a card it is, and there are going to be a heap of horses to follow out of it.

2014-09-11T22:17:49+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


I reckon the Sydney horses might be to strong in my eyes. Stellar preview Adam I reckon the Boban vs PDL match up is going to be a great one!

2014-09-11T21:23:44+00:00

Bondy

Guest


Dissident won like an odds on pop last start and now he's 9/4 $3.30 seems good odds , PDL needs to go to the Toorak Hcp to win Boban must be very close to a lay. The big question from Flemington is can the Melbourne horses hold out the Sydney raiders, I suggest not...

Read more at The Roar