The Leftorium World XI

By Daniel Gray / Roar Guru

I love lefties. Batsmen and bowlers, that is. There’s just something about a cover drive played by a left-handed batsman.

Or the way a left arm quick curves the ball in to trap a batsman LBW, as demonstrated by Mitchell Starc at Manuka Oval on Wednesday night.

Following my article last week outlining an Australian left handed XI from the last 30 years, I decided to give them some competition, in the form of a World Leftorium XI.

I must give a quick shout out to my Kiwi friend Rhys, who helped shape the squad through robust debate and a small amount of sledging.

As per my Australian team, this side is made up of players who played at Test level in the last 30 years, hence the absence of Gary Sobers in the all-rounder position, along with many other left-handed cricketing greats of the past.

The competition for my side was fierce, and this group certainly have the goods to challenge my Australian side, especially in the batting department.

Alastair Cook 8423 runs @ 46
Captain Cook is relegated to vice captain here, mostly due to the presence of his opening partner. With the memories of his seemingly neverending innings on Australian shores a few years back still fresh in the minds of most local fans, Cook has continued the recent phenomenon of English sides performing well away from home.

This is demonstrated by his average jumping from 42 at home to the mid-fifties abroad.

A big scorer once he gets settled, my Australian Leftorium bowlers will want to strike early to avoid disappointment.

Graeme Smith (c) 9265 runs @ 48
Despite taking on the South African captaincy at a ridiculously young age, Smith still managed to be an extremely consistent performer at Test level, as demonstrated by his average over 100 plus Tests.

While his attempts at taunting Australia’s bowlers through the media proved a source of comedy gold, Smith’s ability to rack up big scores and bat all day were no laughing matter. If these two get settled, you may want to change the channel.

Kumar Sangakkara 11988 runs @ 58
One of two men in my team capable of donning the gloves, Sanga is an underrated beast of a batsman. With the best average in my side, the smiling assassin is still racking up the runs in his late 30s.

Brian Lara 11953 runs @ 52
World record holder. Princely. Fan of young English blondes. Brian Lara was called many things throughout his career, some of which are unlikely to be published in The Roar.

One description sums up Lara – bloody good batsman. When he was on song, which was more often than not, Lara was more or less indestructible – except by his own hand. If my Aussie Leftorium bowlers have managed to dismiss Cook or Smith early, they’ll want to knock over Lara in a hurry as well to avoid humiliation.

Shivnarine Chanderpaul 11684 runs @ 53
Another dominant lefty proving that age shall not weary him, Chanderpaul continues to anchor the West Indian Test line-up while pushing in to his forties. I’m quietly hoping he leaves the anti-glare face strips at home for this series.

Graham Thorpe 6744 runs @ 44
This place was a tough call, with my choice being between Thorpe and David Gower, who both averaged 44 throughout strong Test careers. Thorpe got the nod based on his average against the strongest side of his era. Gower’s average dropped to 32 against fearsome West Indian attack of the 1980s. Meanwhile, Thorpe’s increased slightly from 44 to 45 against Australia, earning him the number six spot.

Andy Flower 4794 runs @ 51
While more recently renowned for tormenting KP, Flower made a career humiliating international bowlers in the strongest side Zimbabwe managed to field before Mugabe made himself chairman of selectors.

The second gloveman in my World Leftorium team, Andy Flower could really bat anywhere from 1 to 7. A ferocious batsman at a time of strong bowling line-ups, Flower assumes the Gilchrist-role in my team, piling on the pain after his teammates have put a big score on the board.

Daniel Vettori 360 wickets @ 34, 4516 runs @ 30
The all-rounder and sole spinner in my XI, Vettori ties up an end with the ball, while also providing valuable lower order runs at number eight.

Wasim Akram 414 wickets @ 23
The leader of my looping lefty attack, Akram was a consistent wicket taker and constant threat to batsmen throughout his career. Perhaps a little more wiley than the brute force of Johnson in my Australian attack, Wasim was no less menacing in his own, quiet way.

One of my favourite bowlers, I have mixed feelings about wanting him to succeed against my fictional Aussie side, as I did whenever he played our real team here or abroad.

Zaheer Khan 311 wickets @ 32
The second in my trifecta of subcontinental left arm quicks, Zaheer will take the new ball with Akram and most likely continue his habit of obtaining early breakthroughs, as demonstrated throughout his career.

Chaminda Vaas 355 wickets @ 29
The final bowler and member of my side, Vaas is another attacking quick who may find himself making way for his countryman Rangana Herath in spin friendly conditions.

So there it is, Roarers. My World Leftorium XI. In a five Test series against my Aussie side, they would put up a good fight, before going down 3-1.

The Crowd Says:

2014-11-21T09:45:49+00:00

Bluebag

Guest


Bevan's career was crucified by selectors who undermined his tenure. He needed security but they panicked when he had one poor series

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T08:30:31+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Fair call, Spruce.

2014-11-21T07:40:04+00:00

Arvind

Guest


A specialist captain to get in Australia's face.. I see your Fleming and raise you Saurav Ganguly. Hundreds of reasons as to why he should be left out.. but the man could really get people going.. both team mates and opposition..

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T03:36:03+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Hi BBA, I picked the team on a player's greatest strength, so while Hadlee was handy with the bat, he fails on basis of being a right arm bowler. That's a fair point on Gower, and you certainly highlight some of the difficulties in comparing players between eras. You're spot on with Fleming. Career Test average of 40.06. This drops to 33.87 at home, but jumps to 45.92 away. I guess we can put that down to a combination of the wickets, pressure of playing in front of a home audience, and perhaps being distracted thinking about his acting performance in the recent ads he'd shot with Ricky Ponting!

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T03:30:59+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Hi Jammel, fair enough. Don't get me wrong, I love Bevo as a player, and wish he'd been able to cement a Test spot. There were so many good Aussie lefties through the late 80s in to the early 2000s. I was a big fan of Kat and Lehmann as well, and I think they were both underrated spin bowlers.

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T03:18:30+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Hi Spruce, thanks for the comment and kind words. Glad you're enjoying the articles :) Fleming is an interesting one. Certainly a great captain. Sanga is pretty ridiculous. Was looking through his stats while writing the article and just smiling to myself.

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T02:58:49+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Great call, Jammel. I thought he had retired before my cutoff, but his last Test was on Dec 30 1984-Jan 2 1985, so he just makes it. Ok, let's put him in for Thorpe. No arguments from me. He takes over from Smith as captain as well.

2014-11-21T02:58:48+00:00

BBA

Guest


Is it too sneaky to boost the bowling attack and the tail to include R Hadlee (he does bat left handed) for say Zaheer Khan. Would also prefer Gower over Thorpe, although you marked Gower down for his record against teh Windies I do think that the lack of protective gear against teh windies bowling at that time is a major factor. Hell, I like the idea of Fleming over Thorpe too, I think Fleming;s average is affected by batting on NZ wickets, had a better record overseas than in NZ from memory.But overall would think Fleming would add a lot more to the team than Thorpe, also gives you a really good first slipper.

2014-11-21T02:58:36+00:00

pat malone

Guest


the big cat!

2014-11-21T02:56:52+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Hey? Thorpe was twice the batsman Fleming was.

2014-11-21T02:47:44+00:00

jammel

Guest


Thorpe is the guy that looks out of place in this XI. Possibly just out of the era criteria, but what about Lloyd instead?

2014-11-21T02:46:13+00:00

jammel

Guest


Daniel - I see Bevan as a much better spinner than Lehmann. Bevan was a genuine wicket taker in ODIs and Tests alike. Worth having in a team to combine with Brad Hogg! I think Bevan, over time if given opportunities, would / should/ could deliver an average much higher than what he achieved in his limited opportunities. So I wouldn't say I'm ok with his Test average; rather, I view him as being much better than that. Moreover, I don't see it as Lehmann or Bevan, I see it as Katich or Bevan really competing for that final spot.

2014-11-21T02:41:27+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


I'd bring Fleming in instead of Thorpe. Not anything against Thorpe, but you want someone who will support Shiv in case of a top order collapse. Fleming was rock solid, and is arguably the best captain the southern hemisphere has ever produced. Definitely Flower to be the keeper. Sangkkara averages 70 without the gloves. Unbelievably good. Great teams though, and great articles.

2014-11-21T02:39:07+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


I guess its a horses for courses call there. If the match was being played in Australia you would want the outsider like Boult who would adapt (and be willing to adapt) to the pitch conditions. Zaheer rarely shows any interest in playing outside India.

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T02:22:14+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


You're ok with Bevan's batting average of 29 in Tests? Lehmann's Test batting average was 45, and bowling average of 27, so only marginally higher than Bevan.

2014-11-21T02:11:53+00:00

jammel

Guest


Craig Watson - that Australian Test left-handed XI looks okay. I'd be having Starc or more probably Bollinger over Bracken, or Whitney. Lehmann deserves a mention as does Warner. I'd have both Bevan and Hoggy as my spinners. Bevan plays over Katich/Warner/Lehmann for his spinning strike ability. I'd play: MTaylorV Hayden Langer BorderC MHussey Bevan Gilchrist+ Johnson BHogg Bollinger Reid

2014-11-21T02:04:18+00:00

Gooner

Guest


Bruce Reid

2014-11-21T01:15:40+00:00

Craig Watson

Guest


Exactly..probably will be but is not now. Reason I did not have him on list. Bracken and Doherty .. good limited overs bowlers..would not be in my test side. Still need a couple more quicks. C'mon Roarers?

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T01:01:11+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Quality, JGK. Well played.

AUTHOR

2014-11-21T01:00:50+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Haha, good old Ranatunga. I couldn't bring myself to make him captain! I think in good batting conditions, it would be a high scoring draw. In my favourable bowling conditions, I think the Aussies have the upper hand, just slightly.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar