The trade deadline is one of my favourite times of the NBA season for no other reason than I look forward to seeing what sort of crazy deals teams manage to pull together.
So when Cricket Australia announced that they were introducing trade periods for the Big Bash League, I was intrigued by the possibilities that it could bring. However it’s taken two years for us to see the first actual trade occur.
The Perth Scorchers have sent left-arm orthodox Michael Beer to the Melbourne Stars in exchange for leg-spinner James Muirhead.
I have no idea why.
It is a trade that appears to make little or no immediate sense for either side.
James Muirhead will go from being the likely first choice spinner in the Melbourne Stars squad to presumably being, at best, the second choice behind Brad Hogg in the Scorchers line-up.
I suspect he will be ahead of Ashton Agar in the Scorchers’ spin-bowing pecking order, a result that is also potentially terrible for Agar’s progress.
If we assume that this season will be Hoggy’s last hurrah, then James Muirhead would find himself in prime position to inherit Hogg’s spot as the Scorcher’s main spin option in 12 months’ time.
For the Perth Scorchers this is very much a forward looking trade, they have swapped their 30-year-old for a 21-year-old as the back up for their 43-year-old.
From the Melbourne Stars perspective, they’ve lost a guy who was possibly their breakout success last year, with James Muirhead unseating Clive Rose as their primary spin option after just a couple of matches.
The big positive for Michael Beer is that he’s now out from under Brad Hogg’s shadow, and while he’s not a bad bowler – a career T20 economy rate of just 6.27 is pretty good – his overall career trajectory is heading in the opposite direction to Muirhead’s.
I also struggle to see how Michael Beer, or Clive Rose for that matter, makes it into a full strength Melbourne Stars side that seems likely to be based around a couple of specialist quicks and an assortment of all rounders – including the part-time spin options of David Hussey and Glenn Maxwell.
The Stars now look set to be in the market for a long-term specialist spin option for the 2015-16 edition of the Big Bash League – unless, of course, Michael Beer proves me wrong and has a blinder of a season.
Overall, the Scorchers have clearly got won this trade by picking themselves up a steal in a young developing talent like James Muirhead, and a genuine successor to Hogg, at the same time offloading a guy they’ve only occasionally used last season.
Perhaps had the swap been between Ashton Agar and James Muirhead it could have made slightly more sense.
At this point I’m undecided, maybe trades don’t really work in cricket, maybe there is a reason its taken two years for the first one to take place.
Daniel
Guest
I heard that beer wanted to move to a different club as he thought that he could get more opportunities away from Hogg and agar. Muirhead also said that he would love to work with Hogg to work on his variations. If more info wanted, head to perthscorchers website and view the article they published.
Broken-hearted Toy
Guest
Beer is a good short format bowler. I hope he does very well in Victoria.
Don Freo
Guest
Agar is coming into his own. He has bowled beautifully this year. Hoggy is the one who will fall by the wayside.
Don Freo
Guest
Victoria's Shield side is comprised of probably the worst 11 cricketers playing Shield cricket...apart from SOK...and to not give James Muirhead a game in preference to two 30 yo, Ahmed and Holland, indicates that mates and relatives run Victorian cricket. If I was Muirhead, I'd get out too. He is better than Boyce and Zampa, showing it for Australia in T 20 last time he played, and Vic just refuse to acknowledge him. A punishment for trying to go to SA. Well, VCA, Muirhead will punish you unless you wake up.
Dean Robinson
Roar Pro
Considering he can't get a game for Victoria in either format a full move to the West probably wouldn't the craziest idea. Maybe wouldn't be so great for Agar though.
Dalgety Carrington
Roar Guru
Given the bounce of the WACA can be something that really enhances leg-spin bowling, I reckon Muirhead will find it a place that will really benefit his development as a bowler. It's a pity it is only for the T20's, but perhaps he could look at a shift over to have the WACA as a home base across all formats if it works out well. I've always hoped WA could get some leg-spinners in, especially given Warney's good record at the WACA, but I guess maybe the grade wickets don't benefit spinners all that much, or maybe the captains don't know how to use them. Perhaps the WACA might also shell out for Warney or Magilla to come over and coach both Muirhead and Voges on how to get the most out of leg-spin bowling.