Rights, lefts and reds go flying in French rugby game

By Ben Gibbon / Roar Guru

For as long as there have been cards to punish misdemeanours in sport there have been referee blunders.

On the whole refs and match officials are for the most part fair in their judicial decision-making. However, there are times when their influence is felt unfairly.

Take the time, for instance, when English referee Graham Poll mistakenly issued Croat Josip Simunic three yellow cards before sending him off during a group runners-up match during the 2006 World Cup.

By any means three is a lot of cards – particularly for one person!

To put this into perspective, according to ESPN’s Rugby Stats website the most amount of yellow cards awarded in one game is five against Fiji. That is potentially 50 minutes of 14 men as one the best possible outcomes. However, it could be much worse if some of those players were sent off at the same time.

Five cards! Frivolous, ridiculous, abhorrent, over the top and erroneous in the modern game I hear you cry.

Well, how about six cards… six red cards?

If five yellows made your purest blood boil just thinking about such a travesty then surely six reds will see your entire body explode in a similar manner to what would occur if you were abruptly and unexpectedly dropped into a vacuum.

I can almost feel the self-created atmospheric imbalance pulling my eyeballs out of their sockets right now.

But alas (and ignoring hyperbole), six red cards was exactly what occurred in a semi-professional French club match between Le Boulou and Salanque Côte Radieuse following a all-in team fight that lasted several minutes.

Most impressively, four of the six came within the first three minutes of the match after a fight broke out following a failed scrum that ironically lacked any venom.

The pursuing brawl is arguably one of the biggest seen for a while at the professional level and saw a number of players consequently suspended.

Oh sacrebleu!

The Crowd Says:

2014-11-26T15:42:02+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Brilliant French fights are superb

2014-11-26T10:07:53+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


2 red cards in the Biarritz vs Agen match (Pro D2) on the w-e, same stuff (scrum> brawl). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H8K7NrKckxk

2014-11-26T07:52:39+00:00

Hello

Guest


That fight is very funny. The punches being through by the lock in white cracked me up

2014-11-26T03:10:51+00:00

PhillNZ

Guest


Get rid of Red and Yellow card system an introduce the old 10 finger for sin bin and pointed finger for ordering off with ref miked up and explanation to stadium. Use the american system of personal fouls and change player , coaches won't like it because it will screw their "spark plug" changes at 60 min if individual gets fouled off in 35th min. But back to the game , yep it happens they will get a holiday for a few weeks , the PC brigade will go on how their little Johnnies won't play etc.etc......

2014-11-26T02:25:17+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


"a fight broke out following a failed scrum that ironically lacked any venom." Ben, the reason the scrum 'lacked venom" is that both sides knew beforehand that they were going to brawl hence they were ready for it and didn't care about pushing.

2014-11-26T02:12:09+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


The ease of use of the yellow cards are destroying the game and give the refs too much power to determine the game. If someone farts the ref will issue a yellow card.

Read more at The Roar