South Africa must embrace their physicality

By The Crowd / Roar Guru

There isn’t anything fancy about South African rugby. There is no nous, no side stepping, no deft little touches nor anything that suggests they are going to outwit their opponent.

You can’t sugarcoat a grapefruit and sell it off as an orange, it still remains bitter. The longer the taste lingers on your tongue, the worse it becomes.

That is what South African rugby is all about, big hard men running at you in relentless waves at pace. It is direct, it is predictable and when done at intensity it is akin to a juggernaut steam rolling a minivan.

In such a case it is an awesome spectacle to watch, and most teams find it hard to stop.

It is however reliant on 15 men all switched on and physically able to sustain that long enough until the opposition relents. There is one back up to this plan – Willie le Roux. However even his skills can only be utilised if he gets the ball with some inclination of space.

If you are up to it, you can outplay the Boks. It does require extra special skills and talent though, something not many teams possess, and it is a requirement to execute those skills at the highest level because the Springboks do possess the ability to counter attack with pace.

Then there is the outsmart option, if you decide to play a game of chess against a team really only capable of Chinese checkers, and again you execute your moves well, it is possible to beat them.

Finally there is the negative option, which is a dread to watch, and it does require some leeway by the referee, but slow the game down, niggle, nag, pull, tug and simply get their minds off the game and frustrate them into a frenzy.

You see the South African mentality is one of an eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth. When they retaliate it isn’t subtle, and with the number of cameras available on match day, not hard to prove.

There are of course certain laws that protect the prey of these neanderthals, when South Africa kick an up-and-under, you only need to jump in the air, no real need to actually secure the ball, as the law protects the receiver and not the chaser, and due to the direct running style of the Springboks there is always the potential they will make contact with the airborne players, concede the obligatory penalty and the subsequent yellow card.

Stand up to their runners, as South African forwards aren’t well known for their timing, and even when they innocently (if there is such a thing) raise the arm to fend off the tackler, chances are you will get an elbow to the face and again benefit from the subsequent penalty and yellow card.

We have all heard about the fact that white men can’t jump, well big Afrikaners can’t bend, so sending vertically challenged runners onto our forwards should gain the required penalty.

You may think I am being facetious, but I am being as honest and direct as any Afrikaner can be.

There is no hiding from the truth, South African rugby is never going to embrace intelligent and skilful rugby. Rugby for them is warfare, it is a battle of physical dominance and there is no place for subtlety or finesse.

The first step to redemption is to admit one’s weaknesses. On the evidence we have seen over 100 years of Springbok rugby it is time to accept the fact that we have a unique way of playing rugby, and it is time we accept that we are not going to change.

Over the past few years Heyeneke Meyer has been telling the South African public that nothing has changed, however many of us chose to believe that South Africa have entered a new era of creative play – myself included.

No more, I suggest the whole of South Africa embrace the fact that we play rugby for different reasons and therefor with a unique philosophy and no amount of criticism by pundits, journalists or fans from opposing nations should deviate us from our cause.

The question is then, what must Meyer change to truly embrace this philosophy?

Fortunately not much, the truth is preparation for Tests will require less aspects to focus on, the set phase will of course be important, the breakdown will be vital and fitness will be key.

Other than that Meyer simply needs to select the biggest, strongest, fastest, meanest buggers on the South African landscape.

If you accept that you are going to run direct angles, not vary the point of attack much, and play the opposition into submission, then selection issues become simple and focused.

Meyer must work on getting these 15 behemoths to work as a collective unit to produce a continuous wave of physical brutality. Therefor fitness and intensity is the only two real requirements.

It is not going to work all the time, but when you look at the last few years when South Africa were mentally switched on, had their most physical players available, and lifted their intensity, nobody except the All Blacks were able to stay with them. Their failures came when they lacked the intensity and mindset to dominate their opponents or were in two minds about which game plan to employ.

I’d rather see a focused group of players, knowing the single purposed goal is to pulverise their opponent into submission, than a hesitant team, incapable of making decisions.

Leave the trickery, creativity and skillsets to other teams. Let them bring their nous and guile and we’ll just tackle and run them into the ground.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-04T12:46:06+00:00

Charl

Guest


Understood Nick, not a problem.

2014-12-03T13:05:28+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


Fair enough then Charl. I might have misinterpreted that for 'superiority' but when the genetical stuff is followed by hurt or even kill I felt those were the words of someone who does have a complex of superiority and may think his boys are way more lethal than they really are (and I did reread the initial post a few times before posting btw and couldn't not react). You are completely right that most countries have 'a past' and it includes mine, and believe me, I would have jumped the same way at any French poster talking about our 'genetical advantage' or the fact others 'fear us' etc and compared it to the not so glorious French past ( wouldn't have struggled to find examples as we have many) the same way I did it here. I have nothing against SA the nation, on the contrary I should say, and have a lot of sympathy for Afrikaners especially considering what they have been enduring in the last few years. Imo the initial post was actually a disservice to SA hence my reaction.

2014-12-03T11:01:22+00:00


Just about mate.

2014-12-03T10:54:57+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


BB. If they embraced their physicality any more, it would be a reddit hug.

2014-12-03T10:34:34+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


As a musing, perhaps the Springboks need to look to play rugby in the most generic way possible (that is to say, focus a bit less on pummelling the opposition into the dirt), and from there let their natural strengths shine through that, this is to say making the size and power of the Springboks forwards an added benefit to a well rounded side rather than a focal point. Could apply the same things to the Wallabies and their excessive focus on "running rugby"...

2014-12-03T10:17:37+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


One one hand, yes other teams have big players. On the other hand I'd suggest the Springboks have an average of about 5% in size on most sides in the forwards.

2014-12-02T23:45:00+00:00

JimmyB

Guest


England have beaten SA in SA.

2014-12-02T23:31:39+00:00

nickoldschool

Guest


My point being what you say is incorrect. The Dutch aren't a race nor genetically bigger. And no the world isnt scared of the saffas nor intimidated by them. No more so then when they face 15 samoans , allblacks or mean nutters in general. When i meet a saffa i dont think wow what a threat. Most of you are actually fairly friendly and interestibg chaps. No need to use the 'we are the scariest' stuff, makes you sound insecure and arrogant to big you up.

2014-12-02T21:51:09+00:00


Power does not work all the time, we have seen the evidence of that this year, a ball carrier with single focus point at the defensive line is easier to bring down as it is mostly one pass off the ruck. so the point of attack never shifts. imagine using that play as a setup for an offload to shift the point of contact with another runner or runners.

2014-12-02T21:40:50+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


He is ready to return

2014-12-02T20:40:39+00:00

Normal and rational SA supporter

Guest


I hear you BB, but as John Robbie would say...what would the opposition like the least when they have to play you..to me its wave after wave of Alberts ,Flo, Vermeulen ,Etzebeth, Flip Vdm and Bismark running at you trying to run over you and once the defence creaks then big backs power through..thats surely what they would like the least? other teams get smart and ambush us on the odd occasion ( at home in UK only when we are slightly overconfident ! ) because they cannot compete with the power game so need to improvise to compete ? Wales and Ireland have never won a game in SA in history ( not convinced England or Scotland have either ) , does that make our power game drastically wrong ?

2014-12-02T20:40:34+00:00


Looking forward to it

2014-12-02T20:34:47+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Here is the Springbok cricket team: Willem Alberts, Victor Matfield, Damian de Allende, Tiaan Liebenberg, Cornal Hendricks, Willie le Roux, Francois Hougaard, Bismarck du Plessis, Duane Vermeulen, Butch James, Handré Pollard, Jan Serfontein, Louis Koen.

2014-12-02T20:18:59+00:00

Normal and rational SA supporter

Guest


Hi Charl, thank you for that. I meant big / large and intimidating and definitely not "superior" ..Thanks

2014-12-02T20:10:07+00:00

Normal and rational SA supporter

Guest


Sorry that was meant for Nick at the Old School..your point being ?

2014-12-02T20:08:35+00:00

Normal and rational SA supporter

Guest


Your point being ?

2014-12-02T17:34:06+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Surprised Wales outmuscled the boks, lost a bit on that. I really expected that the boks would be too physical but it was the other way around

2014-12-02T17:02:04+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


agree, NOS it's not the issue everyone has big players now Japan even

2014-12-02T16:41:58+00:00

Armand van Zyl

Roar Guru


I have been on a psychological hiatus Sensei Jones. I'll explain in my next article.

2014-12-02T15:09:48+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Welcome back Laeveld. Back from grindstone? Im looking forward to seeing the form of SA SR15 teams. - HM is going to need them to lift their game in key departments - But I think he needs to be clear with them - And it needs to be something realistic - Something SR teams can buy-into

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar