Clarke, Haddin and Rogers' careers in limbo

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

The careers of Michael Clarke, Brad Haddin and Chris Rogers are in limbo after an otherwise successful opening day of the first Test against India at Adelaide.

Clarke’s future remains unclear after again injuring his back and being forced to retire hurt, Brad Haddin’s duck leaves him with 71 runs at an average of eight from his past six Tests, and Rogers endured another failure.

Clarke has famously missed only one Test through injury during his storied career, despite carrying a serious back injury for many years.

>>FOLLOW THE LIVE BLOG OF DAY TWO

But he has never looked as physically fragile as he has this year. Prior to making a fluent 60 on Tuesday, his Test form had been dire for a solid 12 months.

His past eight Tests had seen him score just 357 runs at an average of 27, with almost half of those runs coming during a remarkable 161 not out at Cape Town to set up a wonderful 2-1 series win over South Africa.

His other scores during that period, in order, read: 24, 23, 10, 6no, 10, 6, 23, 17no, 19, 1, 0, 2, 3, 47, 5. Clarke simply has not looked the same player that ran roughshod over opponents in 2011, 2012 and 2013.

The most noticeable symptom of his decline has been degenerating feet movement. Nimbleness had been a hallmark of his batsmanship, whether demonstrated by skipping down the track to flay the spinners or swivelling swiftly to pummel short balls from the quicks.

There were signs on Tuesday that, perhaps, he had returned to his free-moving best. On 33, facing Mohammed Shami, he fetched a short of a length ball from well outside off, pivoted, and deposited it with a thunderous pull shot through mid wicket.

It was reminiscent of the imperious cross bat strokes he unfurled while flaying India and South Africa during consecutive seasons of extraordinary dominance in 2011-12 and 2012-13.

Yet, less than an hour later, his body betrayed him once again, amid the most innocuous of actions. Clarke swayed gently under an innacurate bouncer from Ishant. That simple movement was enough to leave him first wincing, then crouching, then laying, then departing.

The severity of his condition is not yet clear. Given the manner in which he was rushed back into the side without any match practice, following confusion and quarrelling over his fitness, he may well sit out the rest of the match.

The death of Phil Hughes has left this series heavily compacted, with four Tests in as many weeks. With an impending World Cup and the all-important Ashes on the horizon, Clarke may need a lengthy rest to ensure that he doesn’t miss matches more important than those in this series.

If he sits out the remainder of this Test it will be Haddin who takes over the captaincy, one would assume. The wicketkeeper is fortunate to have retained his position after abysmal returns during first the Test series against South Africa and then the debacle in the UAE against Pakistan.

In South Africa, he was exposed by pace. In the UAE, he floundered against spin. Against India, his presumed lack of confidence saw him rather curiously request a nightwatchman despite Australia dominating at 4-345 against a deflated Indian attack on the flattest of surfaces.

Nathan Lyon was exposed to the new ball, was promptly bowled, and then Haddin belatedly strode to the crease and lasted less time than his tail-ender teammate. Haddin effectively dealt his side a double blow and opened the door for the Indians who, up to that point, had looked a broken bunch.

The veteran gloveman is 37 years old in a side which has seven players in the twilight of their careers. Australia will soon have to begin significant generational change – they have missed a trick by not starting it already – and Haddin is the most vulnerable player, alongside 37-year-old Chris Rogers.

The Victorian opener’s lean run continued as he was caught behind for nine off the bowling of Ishant Sharma. Like Haddin, his returns have dwindled since Australia’s 5-0 flogging of England last summer.

Like Haddin, it seems the Australian selectors are keen for him to stretch his career to next year’s tour of England. Rogers has formed a solid opening partnership with Warner and his vast experience and success in England makes him an attractive Ashes tourist.

He and Haddin both must find touch quickly, however, or they could find their careers won’t last the summer.

Clarke’s finicky chassis could soon condemn him to a similar fate. His mind will be motivated by the twin goals of captaining Australia to World Cup glory on home soil and finally winning a Test series in England, after being part of three successive defeats.

But his body will dictate terms. We may be witnessing the final days of Clarke, Haddin and Rogers.

Fortunately for Australia, they have several young players who continue to blossom and look set to lead Australia into their next generation.

David Warner extended his astounding form surge yesterday, notching his seventh ton in his past 11 Tests. The exhilarating opener’s innings followed a path which is becoming familiar. He took on the new ball, scattered the field and then shifted down a gear and calmly exploited the many generous gaps in the field.

As a younger man he was so determined not to lose the rollicking momentum of his knocks that he would try to manufacture boundaries from deliveries which demanded respect. Now he is prepared to cash in on the easy runs which present themselves once his early belligerence has intimidated the opposition bowlers and skipper.

Warner is now arguably the most valuable Test batsman on the planet. His young teammate, Steve Smith, looks set to compete for that lofty title in the years to come.

Over the past 12 months, the versatile middle order strokemaker has made 782 Test runs at 60. At 78 not out at the close of play, he is within reach of making his fourth ton in that period.

Many of Smith’s highest scores at Test level have come amid rearguard actions necessitated by top order collapses. On Tuesday he had the luxury of striding to the crease with the score at 2-206, following Clarke’s retirement.

Similar to Warner, he looked in complete control of his game and the attack from the start of his innings. The maturation of both Smith and Warner has been a sight to behold this past year.

Their raw teammate Mitch Marsh also gave further cause for optimism with another assured innings. He did not capitalise on his start after moving smoothly to 41, but Marsh’s batting continues to bely his very modest first-class average of 29.

The tall 23-year-old used his feet confidently against India’s spinners and played fluently off both front and back foot to their quicks. While he is yet to play a big, breakthrough innings, returning 205 runs at 41 across your first five Test innings is an extremely encouraging effort.

The future of Australia’s Test team appears to be in good hands. The changing of the guard has begun.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-11T04:34:56+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Strangely, I was reading that exact information yesterday on a church website. But, yes, concentrate. After Nathan Lyon's bowling today, he is in the side for the rest of the summer. Lyon's penetration, Marsh's probing economy and two missed catches off Johnno will all just look like unremarkable numbers in a scorebook. In reality, they are all worthy of extended comment.

2014-12-11T04:20:20+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Did you know that the song Twelve Days of Christmas, was actually written by Catholics in England because Catholics for several centuries were not allowed to teach their beliefs. So they created the 12 days of Christmas for their children as a means of remembering the essentials of their belief The meaning was hidden in each verse. So 'True Love' was Christ, the partridge was a bird prepared to sacrifice itself for its young, two turtle doves was the Old and New Testament, three French hens was Faith, Hope and Love, four calling birds were the four gospels etc. Their children learned their beliefs through remembering the song. Oh that's right. We're talking about sport arent we.

2014-12-11T02:24:32+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Does that include statisticians? On that list...I forgot to add a partridge in a pear tree.

2014-12-11T01:47:31+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Now that's an idea.

2014-12-11T01:46:02+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Still think you're fibbing Don. I've noticed that as people move up the ranks in professions they fib more and more. It becomes an art form.

2014-12-11T01:12:55+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


What about posting on The Roar?

2014-12-11T01:06:22+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Be careful Bear. I was moderated yesterday for saying, "That's you." to SS when he was describing how social media types just get on a trend in a thread and criticize. ("No need to get personal", they said). Imagine what they'd do if you say I'm fibbing. You're joking...I was telling the truth...while they let SS and SFL abuse whoever they want. I guess SS just has thin skin. It's worse than you think. I'm actually teaching the teachers how to teach. Good luck, next generations. They'll all be wearing purple in the winter and changing their names to Marsh in the summer.

2014-12-11T00:36:46+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Food for the gods Don. The true modern day gladiator sport.

2014-12-11T00:31:35+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Now Don. Methinks you're fibbing. And a school teacher as well. What an example for the littlies. Tsk tsk.

2014-12-11T00:26:30+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Shaun Marsh has hit a purple patch and no doubt this will have him as next in line for the tests such is the favouritism shown by selectors. He's averaging 71 this Shield season and is in fine form. But Shaun has done this before. Shown us classy performances and even a top test score and then plummeted. Its not as if he was 25 and still learning the game...that would make him at least a much better proposition. But he's 31 1/2 years. If Australia was going for experience, your Voges would be a far better option. He's averaging 90 so far this season and has an over 42 first class average. He's 35 but a far better proposition for a year or two than S. Marsh in my opinion. Far more reliable and consistent. Personally though I'd go for youth and Burns

2014-12-10T21:25:01+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


3 Chappells (although one of them hasn't played as many tests as SOK), 2Waughs, Ponting, Taylor (2 of them), 4 Marshes, 2 Hoggs, Hughes (Kim and Merv), Hayden, Langer, Jones, Matthews (Greg and Chris) and 388 more that I know of. I understand that SOK, himself, has conceded he is not good enough (which makes 2 O'Keefes). Apparently, Matthew Wade wants him in because he's " not as tricky to keep to".

2014-12-10T21:05:30+00:00

Armchair Expert

Guest


Name all of those ex-test players, besides Warnie, who don't think O'Keefe can succeed in tests Chris.

2014-12-10T20:10:43+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Some ambidextrous qualities. I've watched a game or two of the game of the gods, yes. Like Rugby Union also and increasingly soccer. Write with some difficulty with both hands. I can also pick my nose with both pointer fingers, though I'm not that effective with the skill of thumb picking yet.

2014-12-10T18:38:26+00:00

Armchair Expert

Guest


I wouldn't select Sean Marsh to bat in tests at no3 unless he was batting there (and making runs) for WA.

AUTHOR

2014-12-10T15:28:17+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Just been a wonderfully consistent player for QLD for many years now. If he had an extra 6-7kmh of pace he'd have had a look in at Tests at some stage I reckon.

2014-12-10T15:17:37+00:00

ES

Guest


Haha, yep. He's been excellent this year.

2014-12-10T14:55:24+00:00

jack thomas

Guest


Larney, i see you defending watto. No need. You see, the best in the world gets attacked the most the moment they see a chance. I remember when he was performing great in shorter formats & in tests during 2009-11, he was heavily criticised/hated. So, defending him will have no use. I'll tell all the roarers why watson has so many fans(none in Oz, but countless cross the world). Many prefer quality over quantity. The smiths, clarkes, & many modern day batsmen move/jump in the crease a lot before the bowler releases the ball. Thats not right. Watson's batting is text-book cricket & also has the dominance factor which i love it. Thats quality. A bowler/batsman can (take any number of wickets/score runs) which really doesn't matter if its done in a wrong way. There must be rules for batsmen as there are for bowlers. Regarding his bowling. Injury is around the corner for him since he's still bowling. He has the physique of a gladiator which just can't take the demands of bowling. & Its been proved over the years that he gets injured while bowling again & again. I guess, he will not be dropped since his talents are visible for all. Only a injury will end his career. Hence many(haters) stress that he must bowl to be in the team.

AUTHOR

2014-12-10T14:42:25+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Hopes gives away too many runs. He bowls a boundary ball nearly once a match.

AUTHOR

2014-12-10T14:39:43+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


No chance I'd be dropping Mitch Marsh. He was great in Pakistan as the batting lineup crumbled and looked very composed again yesterday. He has been extremely encouraging and now deserves a good run at it.

AUTHOR

2014-12-10T14:27:10+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I'd imagine he's very rusty after his long layoff. Australia really need him to fire soon because he if he hits form he could win them the World Cup and would also be an asset in the Ashes with his vast experience against England and good record in Ashes Tests.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar