Why it sucks that 'Bomber' Thompson is on the radio

By Josh / Expert

Like a lot of footy fans, I wondered now and then over the off season exactly what was going to happen to Mark Thompson.

Personally, I rank Thompson as being among the modern era’s greatest coaches. Kevin Sheedy, Leigh Matthews, Mick Malthouse, Alastair Clarkson, Paul Roos, John Worsfold – he’s in good company.

I was excited to see what role he might turn his coaching talents to next.

So, you can imagine my disappointment yesterday afternoon when the news broke over Twitter that Thompson’s next big thing was a radio commentary position at 3AW.

I don’t like to spread rumour but sometimes it’s not possible to avoid, especially on a topic like this one.

When Essendon fell to a last-gasp Drew Petrie dazzler in the first week of September, rumours were flying left right and centre.

Had Thompson just coached his last game? Would he even be at Essendon in 2015? Or would Essendon shove golden boy James Hird aside and install Thompson as their long-term leader?

It was a reasonable enough proposition to make. Thompson had just coached Essendon to their highest finishing position since 2002 and gotten them as close to winning a final as they’ve been in the last decade.

We can only drool over the match-up that might have been – a semi-final stoush that would’ve pitted both Thompson and Paul Chapman against Geelong, a club that once hailed them both as legends, and still might.

There was a time there, too, when it really seemed like Thompson might be set to continue wearing the pants in the Dons coaching box. News of meetings behind closed doors abounded and media agencies everywhere had ‘James Hird sacked’ pieces in the barrel and ready to fire.

Nothing came of it. Who knows why or how, but nothing did.

Things took a left turn, a sharp one. Thompson gave an emphatic speech at the best and fairest about his reignited passion, and when a slew of post-season senior coach sackings began he was linked to club after club.

For about a day and a half the notion that Thompson was going to coach Gold Coast in 2015 was held at a similar level of certainty to death and taxes.

But again, nothing came of it. Then in November it broke that Essendon had decided there would be no room for Thompson inside their walls in 2015.

As time went on it became less and less likely that he was going to take on duties elsewhere, and yesterday’s 3AW announcement finally brought those hopes to an end.

I’m sure that Essendon have their reasons, but from a pure footy perspective it doesn’t make a lick of sense to me.

Thompson made Essendon a more exciting, more dangerous outfit than they have been in years. To push him out the door is an immense waste of talent no matter which way you slice it.

To make matters even stranger, Essendon followed this up by welcoming back ‘old boys’ Mark Harvey and Matthew Lloyd into coaching positions at the club.

It would seem Thompson’s just about the only club great who’s not welcome this year.

I said before I don’t like spreading rumours, and I meant it, but it seems like that’s what the entirety of Essendon’s ASADA saga has become. The truth of it all has long been burnt, buried, or spirited away. It’s become a game of politics, public image, and more than anything else, pride.

That’s a game that Bomber Thompson – an old-school footy coach who eats sandwiches in the coaching box and doesn’t care what anyone thinks of it – was simply never meant to play.

It’s hard to know what goes on behind closed doors, but in the end it seems that whoever makes the decisions at Essendon decided Thompson had outlived his usefulness, and that was that.

I’ll miss his press conferences most of all. In age of highly choreographed media events and cookie-cutter coaches who never stray from the party line, Thompson’s casual media moments were a balm. Now the best we’ve got left is Mick’s war on Stevo and Ross Lyon’s shifty eyes.

We can still hold out hope of course. Many great coaches have left the game, only to return down the track. Matthews. Roos. Malthouse. Rodney Eade’s about to have a crack at it this year.

We may see Thompson back in the box yet.

If this is it, though, then in this modern, media-driven age, where genuine characters of any kind are few and far between, I think we owe Bomber Thompson our gratitude for his contributions to the game.

Well done, Bomber – if I ever see you down the street, the sandwiches are on me.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2015-02-04T14:32:50+00:00

Josh

Expert


No, the fine was paid in full - http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-11-26/thompsons-30000-fine-finally-paid

2015-01-28T01:49:13+00:00

Aransan

Guest


Andy, you are off the rails again. Bomber did pay his fine. Essendon didn't sack him as he was appointed coach for the 2014 season only.

2015-01-28T00:47:57+00:00

andyl12

Guest


Of course, for Bomber to coach again he'd have to pay his $30,000 fine, or hope the AFL rescind it. Am I right that this non-payment was part of the reason Essendon sacked him?

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T07:55:18+00:00

Josh

Expert


Yes, I think there's still a solid chance we will see him coach again, even if it's not as the no. 1 guy. And I hope we do, he has too much experience and wisdom to be left chattering on the radio. Would love to see him employed with my boys North Melbourne even if it was only a development/mentoring part time role.

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T07:52:29+00:00

Josh

Expert


Puzzling is definitely the word for it. So much going on behind the scenes that we will probably never hear the truth of.

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T07:51:26+00:00

Josh

Expert


I'm a fan of Harvey, think he got a rough dismissal from the Dockers. That said, the team has since shown potential that he just wasn't getting out of it. He'll certainly be a good fall-back option if things go south with Hird. No doubt Bomber had the benefit of an excellently talented group of players, but it's one thing to have them, another to get them working in cohesion. The transformation they took from down and out in 2006 to dominant in 2007 will be remembered as an awesome achievement, some of his best work.

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T07:47:54+00:00

Josh

Expert


Ditto, he's great to watch on FoxFooty, and I suppose I'll listen in on 3AW now too.

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T07:46:26+00:00

Josh

Expert


I'm a "screw loose" kinda guy.

2015-01-27T04:34:24+00:00

Fred

Guest


You want boring and someone who actually says nothing - then its Rocket. Appears to be this timid person who toes the party line. Has never coached a GF winning side and never will. I expect Gold Coast to go backwards this year

2015-01-25T02:46:06+00:00

joe

Guest


judy and big al could not agree with you more,the guys a good coach but a nut case.

2015-01-24T06:59:10+00:00

BigAl

Guest


My thoughts exactly Judy. One could argue whether he was a good coachr, but he has got results there. However when he gets a microphone in his hand, he is an embarrassment to himself and all around him.

2015-01-24T05:09:26+00:00

Judy Atu

Guest


A breath of fresh air in the after match interviews?? He acted like he had a screw loose, I for one am glad he's not coaching at the GC I swear He has lost his marbles. Thank God we got Rocket instead

2015-01-24T02:36:02+00:00

William R

Guest


Josh. What you say is quite right but I also believe Mark wanted to coach Essendon but his problem was he went about it the wrong way, he wash a breeze of fresh air in the coaches box but remember he only had a one year appointment so he could do whatever he wanted,because he knew they wouldn't despacth him during the 2014 season. I am hoping that he will be on the fox footy program with the same people as last year if not it is our loss he made good televising last year

2015-01-24T01:03:14+00:00

MarkG

Guest


Whenever I question why is Bomber on the outer at EFC, I get told he has a dark side. Absolutely no idea what this means. But this is a major contributing factor to him not coaching in 2015. If there was a dark side, this disappeared in 2014. Been to a couple of Essendon training sessions. Harvey is doing a large % of the coaching. I've got a lot of respect for him as a coach as well. He built the Fremantle foundations for Lyon to take over. Harvey expects a very high work ethic from the players .... this will remove their inconsistency and fadeouts. Re Bomber, Geelong assembled one of the most talented group of young players that I have seen. He is a great coach, but he also had an exceptional team.

2015-01-23T22:57:28+00:00

Aransan

Guest


Assuming Hird continued as coach I would like to have seen Thompson continue at Essendon as match day coach. My belief is that Essendon couldn't find a significant role beyond that for him and Thompson wanted more power than Essendon were prepared to give him. It was puzzling that Thompson didn't pay his fine in a timely way. There was a possibility that Hird would have been sacked but he couldn't have been sacked just because he exercised the legal options open to him. If the ASADA action against the current and former Essendon players fails then Hird's future will depend on future results. I don't believe he is a good match day coach but if he is given the right support and takes advice that shouldn't be a problem.

2015-01-23T22:26:11+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


Don't write off him coaching the Bombers within the next year or so. If things go pear shaped at Essendon on field, off field or with the ASADA then his media contract is probably written so that he has an "out" should a top flight coaching role be offered to him. Sounds like he is "parking" himself where he will still be visible (audible anyway) until something comes up ala Paul Roos the guy who had no interest in coacheing ever again.

Read more at The Roar