Brisbane Roar insults fans by upping sticks to the Gold Coast for the Asian Champions League

By Simon Smale / Roar Guru

Brisbane Roar announced yesterday on Twitter that due to a long standing Foo Fighters concert at Suncorp Stadium, and an obscure AFC competition rule, Brisbane will be playing their home Asian Champions League games on the Gold Coast.

Rule 19.3, if you’re interested, states that every home game in the competition has to be played at the same venue.

A couple of months ago, I wrote an article saying that taking home games away from home was a terrible idea, for various reasons.

I also wrote about the pitch at Wembley being not suitable for an England European Championship qualifier against Slovenia, due entirely to the multipurpose nature of the stadium and the fact that an NFL match was played six days before the vital game.

This ties in with the perceived lack of quality of the Suncorp Stadium pitch that blighted games hosted by Brisbane in the Asian Cup.

These two issues have come together in a nightmare scenario for Roar fans, which will result in Brisbane not playing a single Champions League game in front of their own fans this year.

The Roar confirmed yesterday that due to the fact that Suncorp Stadium is being used for a concert the day before an AFC Champions League game date, they are moving all three of their games down to the Gold Coast at Robina Stadium.

Before I start, I don’t know how much effort behind the scenes the Roar made to get special dispensation for the unfortunate set of circumstances they found themselves in, and I know that the Roar don’t own Suncorp and have little to no say in the scheduling.

However, as we know, the AFC can be flexible when it comes to stadiums. Western Sydney Wanderers were allowed to play the home leg of their Champions League final at Parramatta Stadium, despite reports to the contrary in the build up. So had the Roar been desperate to play at Suncorp, I’d guess that they could have been able to.

Instead Brisbane are sugarcoating the decision, with managing director Sean Dobson saying that this decision is part of “a broader commitment by the Roar to work with local communities and expand its footprint and fan-base across South East Queensland”.

Despite Dobson’s assertion, I see this as an astonishing affront to the loyal supporters of the Brisbane Roar, who have likely been looking forward to some continental light to help recharge a somewhat disappointingly dreary domestic season for some time now.

The fans are being told that to see their team play in this increasingly prestigious competition, they will have to travel more than an hour south of their homes, on a weeknight.

The club have said that free buses and trains will be offered to ticket holders, but this is simply a token statement in that it is no different to any other game. The Roar play at Suncorp, which already includes free transport to and from the ground with your match ticket.

Instead of mingling in the usual bars and restaurants around Caxton Street and Paddington, fans will endure a painfully dull bus or train trip of more than an hour – and that’s if the notorious Pacific Motorway car park is flowing well – to a stadium that rarely pulls a crowd at the best of times.

And that’s if they even bother making the journey at all.

We’ve all heard the arguments for the multi-use of stadiums, and how that’s how the money is brought in. And look, I’m sure the Foo Fighters gig is going to be excellent – and at $160 for general admission, you’d sure hope it would be. And if there were complaints about the pitch when it was specifically being prepared for football during the Asian Cup, after a gig the surface will undoubtably be horrendous, so if we ignore the obviously appalling scheduling, moving the game is the only alternative.

This should have been a wonderful opportunity to build upon the success that the Asian Cup generated in the country among football fans from around the continent.

And since Western Sydney’s incredible victory in this tournament last year, the Roar should have been trying to make inroads themselves, and build upon Australian football’s recent dominance across the continent.

But why would you choose to play your home games 100 kilometres away in an area that struggled to garner support when it hosted its own club, for a competition that has struggled to gain much support in Brisbane in the past?

Why not play at Ballymore? It’s local, and certainly big enough for the attendances that are likely on a Tuesday or Wednesday night. The Roar train there and are familiar with the ground, (and they will be doing their bit for charity by giving the Queensland Rugby Union some bonus revenue).

Even the Queensland Sports and Athletic Centre at Nathan would be a better bet, and much closer for fans than the Gold Coast.

I’m worried that the Roar risk a huge backlash from their fans over this, and even by offering tickets for next to nothing – $10 for adults and $5 for children I’ve seen reported – they risk playing in an unfamiliar venue in front of a couple of stewards and vast swathes of empty, sky-blue seats.

Winning the league and qualifying for the ACL should be a reward for both the club and the fans, not a huge inconvenience. Western Sydney’s accomplishment put the club and the entire A-League on the map, in what was one of football’s greatest feel-good stories of recent years. The Roar’s attitude to the competition, and their fans by comparison, unfortunately does not compare.

Or perhaps I’m being unfair. Perhaps this is the best way to deal with an unfortunate situation and gives fans on the Gold Coast a chance to see some AFC, international football. Let me know what you think.

The Crowd Says:

2015-02-11T22:53:21+00:00

britesparke

Roar Rookie


Multi use venues are a real problem- as you have mentioned there is quite literally no control over anything including scheduling! Suncorp provided a debacle for the Asian Cup in terms of pitch quality and you cannot blame Roar management for shifting their Asian Champions League matches (the only ones they can shift) to another, more reliable venue! I don't see the shift as an inconvenience for the fans. On the contrary, why not offer fans a venue with a better pitch that has not had a rock concert the night before and watch players having to come to grips with a bumpy pitch (hence a poor quality match!)

2015-02-11T13:05:25+00:00

Boban

Guest


Yeah but that stadium is purpose built for AFL and cricket, not football.

2015-02-11T02:43:50+00:00

Wainscoting

Guest


Very well said. I don't mind taking a day off work for a road trip, but I can't help but struggle with an overwhelming sense of betrayal. I engage football with my heart above and beyond my head and I strongly perceive his decision as a subversion of the exchange of identity between the club and myself. I still recall vividly travelling to that soulless club's stadium in that soulless city. Holding a rare opportunity to present ourselves internationally there now seems hardly less of an affront now than it would have been a few years ago. Who are we? Brisbane?

AUTHOR

2015-02-10T21:39:42+00:00

Simon Smale

Roar Guru


Can't help but agree with you there olmeister. Transparency and at least pretending to care about the loyal supporters would be nice.

2015-02-10T20:31:32+00:00

JohnL

Guest


Thanks for your reply Simon. Agree, some transparency is definitely needed!

2015-02-10T16:18:14+00:00

olmeister

Guest


Thank you all for an interesting discussion. But I still want to know what the ACL's officials said when the Brisbane Roar leadership pointed out that the FooFighters gig was out of their control and games 2 and 3 can be held at Lang Park. Unless they never pointed it out, in which case they should not be in charge of my favourite team.

2015-02-10T16:10:37+00:00

olmeister

Guest


Perry Park has Bowen Hills railway station just across the road and I think every train in Brisbane stops there. There is enough room for a 20-30,000 capacity. I think it would be perfect. Doesn't solve our current problem, though.

2015-02-10T12:55:06+00:00

Paul

Guest


Try driving to Park Road, at least try to go to one of the games. I once travelled from Rockhampton to Melbourne to watch Victory play in an ACL fixture. I will agree it's a dumb decision by management but there's nothing you can do about it and you might as well take advantage of an opportunity that is unlikely to present itself next season.

AUTHOR

2015-02-10T09:25:52+00:00

Simon Smale

Roar Guru


I get your point Craig, but I think the point is that the club is called Brisbane Roar, not South East Queensland Roar. It might seem fairly minor, but a football club is meant to be a symbol of the community it represents. By playing "home" matches in a totally different city it is a significant betrayal of the trust that goes with putting your faith in what is effectively a group of 11 strangers every week to represent you and your community. I get your point about having to travel to Sydney to see any big event live sport of merit, but if Wollongong had its own A-League team, and they decided to play home games in Sydney, that would be an affront to the supporters in Wollongong right? It would be like having a team based in Gosford and playing home games in North Sydney (oh wait, that sounds somewhat familiar). This is an issue I feel quite strongly about, (the number of articles I've writen about this type of situation is probably a clue there) and is symptomatic for me of the gradual erosion of what sport is meant to be.

AUTHOR

2015-02-10T09:15:51+00:00

Simon Smale

Roar Guru


Hi jb, thanks a lot for your comment - and for that information. I certainly wasn't aware of the backstory of the Nathan Stadium - only that the Broncos played out there for a few years and my neighbour (a staunch Broncos member for many years) did not particularly enjoy travelling out there to watch games! I didn't know the Roar had moved to Perry Park to train, I remember watching a pre-season game at Ballymore (against Redlands United) and assumed they used the stadium as a training base for that reason. As for your first comment, as far as I am aware the draw for the ACL only happened fairly recently, and as such the clash has only just been realised (although I agree, the possibility should have been raised that this could happen). I am guessing (and this is a guess) that The Roar were not entirely sure about rule 19.3... In fact, I have been told by members of the media that their information (from the AFC no less) was that the first game was "venue TBC" and the other two were to be held at Suncorp. Read into that what you will...

2015-02-10T09:13:57+00:00

Ian

Guest


The change of venue is terrible and not good for travelling families (and not only families). It is a bit of a hike as we went there for Gold Coast's last ever game (against Roar) in 2012). I certainly can't go with the distance involved. After reading some comments the only alternative is that the foo fighters concert does not count as an exceptional event. I find this harder to believe as the ground will be terrible and not fit to play on the next night. Perhaps they could have moved the game to the night before the FF concert but there are probably rules about when the games can be played. I hope for Roar's sake it was a situation that could not be avoided but without confirming the FF concert was 'out of their control' the moving of all 3 games is not the right decision. One game is acceptable, not all 3. "Growing the statewide supporter base' is up there with 'philosophy'. If the FF concert was not deemed 'out of their control' the Roar have not communicated properly again.

AUTHOR

2015-02-10T09:05:48+00:00

Simon Smale

Roar Guru


Hi John, thanks for the comment. I totally get what you are saying, but I agree (perhaps unsurprisingly) with Waz. If the club had asked other venues in Brisbane to use their grounds for these matches they should have said so, and been apologetic about having to take the game into a different region of the country. As it happens, they didn't, and trotted out an insulting, sugar-coated response that this is all part of a "regional expansion" and will be a unique "away day experience for fans". I would love, and I'm sure I'm not alone here, to get some transparency from clubs when decisions like this are made. It should not require fans or (amateur) journalists to go hunting for answers.

2015-02-10T09:01:28+00:00

Ian

Guest


Hey TK - I've thought that myself - Fussball is having some R&R and Uncle Junior is his new name for whatever reason. He should take it as a compliment his writing style is recognisable to some. Let's not tell anyone else.

2015-02-10T08:05:33+00:00

Cpaaa

Guest


I think this is like Sydney FC wanting to expand their fan base by playing games at Parramatta stadium. Robina Stadium is simply a ridiculous location. AFL wins on the Gold Coast with their stadium as it is centralised, high traffic area and next to the Casino. I think this also rules out a second Brisbane team It also suggests Brisbane needs a 2nd stadium. (2million people and Suncorp has the monopoly) Brisbane Roar are now in the leading position, for the dumbest decision of the year.

2015-02-10T07:41:03+00:00

TK

Guest


I guess this will be another lesson for A league clubs to look at scheduling more strategically in future particularly at multi purpose grounds.

2015-02-10T07:27:47+00:00

Cpaaa

Guest


Nordster wrote that the great, J Warren said, "maybe focus on winning the thing rather than hosting" J Warren didnt say that at all, he said, "Australia should focus on winning the World Cup, and not just QUALIFYING for the World Cup"

2015-02-10T07:26:50+00:00

j binnie

Guest


Towser- Don't know whether your remark was a joke or not,-------the land was originally a cemetery jb

2015-02-10T07:05:46+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


Is that you, Suncorp? Would you care to comment on the state of the pitch for the Asian Cup while you are here?

2015-02-10T07:02:10+00:00

Lionheart

Guest


or Townsville. Let's write to a few pollies in this coming year, and get this issue some attention. Anna Bligh looked after the Gold Coast, but our Brisbane reps don't care.

2015-02-10T06:51:33+00:00

pjm

Roar Rookie


2012- Guys don't book anything in case we in this competition in 2 years.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar