Five questions from Round 2 of the NRL

By Ryan O'Connell / Expert

We’ve now completed two rounds of the 2015 NRL season, and already some themes, trends and narratives are starting to emerge.

Round 2 action saw the Bulldogs and Sea Eagles bounce back from disappointing Round 1 losses, highlighting that reports of their demise had been greatly exaggerated.

Meanwhile, the Panthers continue to show they’ll be a force to be reckoned with in 2015, belting the hapless Titans. Sadly the Sharks appear to be toothless in attack, thus allowing the Broncos to win their first game of the second Wayne Bennett era.

Lastly, in the battle to avoid the wooden spoon (tongue firmly in-cheek), the Tigers drew some Dragon blood, and the Raiders lost to the Warriors.

However, with so much to digest and dissect, we’ll focus our attention elsewhere, in the form of five questions that need answering after round 2 of the 2015 NRL season.

1. A grand final in March?
Steady on there, Ryano. It’s a bit early in the season to be labelling a game a ‘grand final preview’.

Having said that, Sunday afternoon’s blockbuster between the Rabbitohs and the Roosters was nothing short of sensational.

As I tweeted during the game, so often we see heavily anticipated and much-hyped games fail to deliver the goods. The Bunnies and Chooks encounter most certainly wasn’t an example of that, as the two premiership heavyweights threw everything they had at each other.

In the end, Souths won 34-26, but that score doesn’t reflect the closeness of the combatants, and how impressive both teams were.

It’s a cliché, but neither side deserved to lose, and it certainly whets the appetite for a finals match-up between the two fierce rivals later down the line.

A grand final preview? Even as a Doggies fan, I’d have to admit to being excited by the prospect of these the two teams facing each other at the business end of the season, should they continue this level of play all year long.

2. And yet… where the hell was the crowd?
The winners of the last two NRL competitions. Two teams that seriously dislike each other, based on geography and history. Two premiership favourites this season. Each team coming off an impressive Round 1 victory. Sunday afternoon footy.

Every single ingredient was in play for a bumper ground.

Yet the Bunnies and the Chooks could only draw approximately 27,000 fans to the game.

Disappointing. Measly. Poor. Discouraging.

Select whatever adjective you like, but the fact remains that this was a bad look for the NRL. If this game couldn’t produce a massive crowd, what can?

I have two excuses for my own lack of attendance: I’m not a fan of either team, and it was my mother’s birthday. (Happy birthday, mum.)

What excuses do fans of these two teams have for not turning up?

Certainly the players from both clubs held up their side of the bargain, and produced one of the best games in recent memory, and matched the hype I talked about in my first question.

It’s just a damn shame such a relatively small crowd were there to witness it.

3. Where to now for Manly?
Daly Cherry-Evans is off to the Gold Coast for 2016, and it’s now confirmed that fellow half Kieran Foran will depart for Parramatta as well.

So where to now for the Sea Eagles?

Recruitment for the 2016 season now becomes vital, and should become the Manly hierarchy’s top priority.

They’ve lost two of the best young players in the game, who also happen to play in the most important and influential positions on the park. Replacing them will be no mean feat, but if the Sea Eagles want to remain competitive in the years to come, they quickly need to develop a solid plan to replace their halves.

Never mind that the forward pack remains an issue as well.

Oh, and that backline stalwarts Steve Matai, Jamie Lyon and Brett Stewart are all on the wrong side of 30 years of age.

Seriously, Manly have more issues than Norman Bates.

Perhaps a more pertinent question is: just what the hell happened on the peninsula?

4. Is it panic stations yet in Townsville?
Full disclosure: I only watched the first 15 minutes of the Cowboys vs Knights game on Saturday, so I can’t talk in detail about the game, or the performance of North Queensland.

However, the ladder tells you all you need to know: the Cowboys have started the season a disappointing 0-2.

Though it would be silly to panic so early in the year, three of the Cowboys’ upcoming four games are against the Storm, Panthers and Rabbitohs, which means North Queensland need to find their mojo soon, or risk playing catch-up for the rest of the season; a position no team wants to be in.

You can understand if a few fans up north are starting to sweat a little bit. And it has nothing to do with the humidity.

5. Do we have to talk about the referees?
Regular readers will know I’m loath to write about the referees. Far too much attention is given to officials and their decisions, and I make a point of not even attempting to know who the referees are, their names, their style, etc.

Furthermore, Round 2 is far too early to talk about conspiracy theories, the standard of refereeing for 2015, or an officialdom crisis that needs to be addressed by the NRL.

By the same token, the refereeing in the Manly versus Melbourne game was appalling, with the Storm in particular on the wrong end of some game-changing decisions.

I mentioned on Saturday night that it’s customary to buy someone a drink before you do what the referees were doing to Melbourne.

I can’t believe we’re having a whinge about the refs so early in the season, and I especially can’t believe I’m the one leading the charge, but it would be remiss to talk about Round 2 without discussing Saturday night’s poor refereeing.

Let’s hope this is the first and last mention of referees in 2015.

The Crowd Says:

2015-03-18T00:59:29+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


The 100,000 at the protest march was more about anti-corporatisation than pro-South Sydney. Business at the time were more interested in telling customers what they wanted than... Oh.

2015-03-18T00:53:32+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


People go on about pride and honour and such things in sport but they mean nothing if you don't exist. Souths entered the modern world after dodging a few bullets. It's stupid to try and dodge bullets and Souths should be justifiably looked down upon for it for attempting to do so for so many decades. But they survived and that's all in the past. Well done to them for getting their house right.

2015-03-18T00:44:12+00:00

Ken

Guest


Manly's fall in playing stock has been fast (and will probably continue over the next couple of seasons, Lyon, Matai etc can't have many years left) but, in fairness, they have managed to hold a successful team together for much longer than most other teams manage. If you accept that teams going bust after success is simply a reality of this era then the best you can do is to keep the boom going for as long as possible - I'm not a Manly fan but you can't deny they've done this.

2015-03-17T23:27:13+00:00

Jonathan

Guest


PHac signed the 10 year deal because it suited his private business inrerests, my guess when the deal is up we will be Moore Parks no1 tennant.

2015-03-17T23:21:27+00:00

Muzz

Guest


Rick, I know plenty of people who no longer go to games as they've had enough of the sub standard/bias refereeing.They still love their club and the game but refuse to waste their free time and money.

2015-03-17T23:08:10+00:00

Rick Karaitiana

Guest


I agree Muzz, I for one now watch the Rugby, the Manly v Storm game just confirms, my opinion Referees make mistakes I accept that, but the Manly/Storm game was blatant refereeing, I feel sorry for the players and the coach, 2 games like that drops the team out of the top 4, to the last 8, another 2 games like that ends all hope for the season, these players and the coaching staff spend all pre season getting the players fit, and working on team plays, only to have it destroyed by 2 men. some questions need some answers.

2015-03-17T09:56:08+00:00

Muzz

Guest


And don't bother asking any mates that support Manly to help you as they don't travel : )

2015-03-17T09:51:34+00:00

Roarfan

Guest


Is 2015 going to be the same as the previous years. Referees are back to their howlers again. Tony Archer saying yes they got it wrong. What about the punches thrown in round 1 10 minutes in the sin bin. I thought if a punch was thrown you were sent off. The player concerned played in round 2. What a joke. Betting should not be allowed on NRL until the referees improve and that includes the video ref

2015-03-17T09:44:36+00:00

Muzz

Guest


SpongeBob, Depends if the grounds/green keeper mower the grass perfectly parallel to the 20/30 metre line. If so, then your correct.He's onside. Climb the fence at night with a mate and a measuring tape and check it. Let us know how you go.

2015-03-17T08:52:42+00:00

Chui

Guest


Luxury

2015-03-17T08:08:46+00:00

3 Hats

Guest


In 2014 the crowd for the Minor Premiership game at SFS was 32,481. In 2013 the crowd for the Minor Premiership game at ANZ was 59,708. 27,227 more fans attended ANZ Stadium. So in reality more fans go to ANZ than the SFS!

2015-03-17T08:08:21+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Good luck to you Jethro. Sounds good. It can be a slog getting anywhere in Sydney. I reckon canberra's a great stadium to watch footy from. Not a bad seat in the house.

2015-03-17T07:59:47+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Back in my day we used to walk six miles in the snow to get to a game. Barefoot. We couldn't afford shoes. Just to make it special we'd share a stale ryvita at half time and have a sip of water. Sometimes we'd get lucky and there'd be chewing gum stuck to the bottom of a chair.

2015-03-17T07:46:26+00:00

Jim

Guest


Well I guess you get credit for admitting it. Doesn't make it any better though

2015-03-17T07:46:16+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Guest


I can't believe how easy I have it here in Canberra TB. I live about 1000 metres from the bottom of O'Connor Ridge where I park the car and walk up the bike path to Bruce Stadium. I booked a family ticket for the Warriors game on the Tuesday and got seats two rows from the fence in front of the Mal Meninga Stand. Watched the game in comfort - walked down the path to the car - and took 2 minutes to get home. Feel sorry for you poor buggers in Sydney having to slog your way through the traffic. Hopefully the Raiders will show a bit of form and get the crowds back to a respectable size.

2015-03-17T07:43:13+00:00

Statler and Waldorf

Roar Guru


A "typical" Souths fan has a huge smile on his face and only sees the positives At the moment

2015-03-17T07:40:16+00:00

Jim

Guest


I don't agree. We have a family season pass. We go to all the games at Homebush . Parking is zero as we park about a 10 minute max walk away. We take our own food or eat before we go. Maybe an ice cream or something at half time. I don't drink beer at the footy cause its rubbish I wouldn't buy at half the price same with the food, I wouldn't let my kids eat that poison. It's no effort but it's a great family day out. I guess people who can't drag themselves or their family to the footy just aren't that into league

2015-03-17T07:38:45+00:00

Statler and Waldorf

Roar Guru


I think it came down to anz, relocate to gosford as Singo wanted a team up there or stay at redfern and get closer to going broke. It was a good financial choice to make Epiquin is right. All the backing eventually came in later

AUTHOR

2015-03-17T07:37:32+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


Love your passion, Terry. It seems it might be a long year for the Dragons, at this rate.

AUTHOR

2015-03-17T07:36:43+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


I did not!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar