Team of the Round: Round 3

By Katfish / Roar Guru

Another weekend of great footy has come and gone, so who makes our Team of the Round?

Back Pocket: Jack Hombsch (Port Adelaide)
Kept Jarrad Waite goalless after he kicked seven the week before. Only collected seven touches but his defensive efforts cannot go unmentioned. Yet to play 50 games, he could become one of the competitions premier defenders in a few years.

Full-Back: Michael Hurley (Essendon)
Along with Tom McDonald, has been the standout defender of the season with another strong performance against the Blues. Was strong defensively, helping out teammates with 10 one-percenters, but also found plenty of the ball. Finished with 23 touches and 11 marks in an all-round display.

Back Pocket: Neville Jetta (Melbourne)
Jetta has conceded just one goal to Betts in their last two meetings, with the small defender blanketing his opponent. Betts was restricted to just five score involvements, his worst output of the year thanks the Jetta’s effort on the weekend.

Half-Back Flank: Bachar Houli (Essendon)
The best half-back of the round, Houli found plenty of the ball with 32 touches and used it well too. consistently rebounded from defence.

Centre-Half Back: Rory Thompson (Gold Coast)
Played on Clark for most of the game, restricting him to just one goal. Was also there late in the game with pivotal spoils deep in defence that prevented certain goals and kept the Suns in the game.

Half-Back Flank: Luke McDonald (North Melbourne)
His late defensive efforts against Port Adelaide kept the Roos in the game as he stopped two certain goals in the last quarter. He offered plenty of rebound as well, setting up numerous Roos attacks with his run and long kicking. His defensive efforts put him ahead of Grant Birchall, who also could have been selected.

Wing: Jordan Lewis (Hawthorn)
Another big game for Lewis with 41 touches and 10 inside 50s. Was overshadowed by the performances of Luke Hodge and Jarryd Roughead.

Centre: Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
The Hawks skipper pulled off the performance of the round. Forty-four touches, nine clearances, two goals and three goal assists.

Wing: Stephen Hill (Fremantle)
Has been the standout winger of the season with his run and carry, as well as his ability to hit the scoreboard. Kicked three goals again and sliced through the middle of the ground with his blistering pace. His disposal was as good as ever against the Eagles with 30 disposals at a disposal efficiency of 87 per cent.

Half-Forward Flank: Trent Cotchin (Richmond)
Cotchin was back to his best on Saturday collecting 37 disposals (18 contested). Was influential across the ground with a combined 11 inside and rebound 50s. Also kicked a goal after intercepting a kick inside 50 and looks set to collect the three votes.

Centre-Half Forward: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
While Daniel Hannebery was given the best on ground by the umpires, Franklin proved the difference between the two sides. He kicked 5.5 against a legitimate opponent in Joel Patful where the Giants were without such dominance in their forward line.

Half-Forward Flank: Dayne Beams (Brisbane)
Was a shining light for Brisbane after getting thumped by the Tigers. Finally performed to his potential in Lions colours after a sub-par start to the year. Played a lone hand in the middle with more clearances and contested possessions than any other on the field.

Forward Pocket: Mark LeCras (West Coast)
The two dominant small forwards for Round 3 were Lindsay Thomas (four goals) and LeCras (five goals). Thomas scored three clutch goals in the last quarter that put the Roos in front. His impact late in the game was far greater than LeCras’ but LeCras was the better of the two, kicking five goals despite the Eagles having just 39 inside 50s for the game.

Full-Forward: Jarryd Roughead (Hawthorn)
Rebounded from a poor performance last week by dominating his cousin Jordan Roughead in Launceston. Seven goals, 28 disposals and an incredible 21 score involvements.

Forward Pocket: Tom Lynch (Gold Coast)
Erratic (and low) goal kicking stopped him from kicking five or six goals. His presence forward throughout the game gave the Suns a shot at winning, especially when Jesse Lonergan went down. Had he kicked straight, the Suns would have won their first game of the season.

Gets the nod ahead of Travis Cloke because of his impact throughout the game with Cloke kicking three of his five goals in the last quarter when the game was over. Will battle with Jesse Hogan to claim the title of the next great centre-half forward.

Ruck: Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne)
Almost willed North over the line with impressive ruck-work in the last quarter where his silver service guided his on-ballers to a dominance in clearances in the last quarter. Dominated Paddy Ryder in the ruck all night to be the best ruckman of the round.

Ruck Rover: Lachie Neale (Fremantle)
Outshone fellow midfielders in his best on ground performance in the Derby. It was a phenomenal effort for a player yet to reach 50 games. Forty of his 42 disposals were effective. He also chipped in with three goals in the best performance of his career.

Rover: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
While Hodge was the best player of the round, Selwood was the most influential. Proved unstoppable against the Suns who simply could not match him in the contest. Found the ball at will with 23 contested possessions and eight centre clearances. Was the only reason that Geelong didn’t lose the match.

Interchange: Rory Sloane (Adelaide)
If ‘toughness’ was the difference between the Crows and Dees, then look no further that Sloane and Thompson. Sloane is the toughest bloke in South Australia and he shone in the wet. Eighteen contested possessions, eight clearances and ten tackles saw him collect honours of best on ground.

Interchange: Jobe Watson (Essendon)
Another captain to step up and dominate for their club. Jobe has moved on from his time as a contested ‘accumulator’ and is now spending more time outside the contest with 27 uncontested possessions. His nine inside 50s and round high four goal assists proves that he is just as damaging in space as he is in the contest.

Interchange: Scott Thompson (Adelaide)
Just as prolific and tough as Sloane, his work in the clearances was as good as anyone, with 11 clearances and 11 tackles. The toughness and class of the Adelaide duo in the wet showed the difference between the two sides. Thirty-two-years-old, but obviously not slowing down.

Interchange: Dan Hannebery (Sydney)
Awarded the Brett Kirk medal for the best on ground in the ‘Battle of the Bridge’, Hannebery was prolific in the contest as well as in space with an even spread of contested and uncontested possessions. Finished with 35 touches, seven clearances and three shots on goal in a polished display.

B: J Hombsch, M Hurley, N Jetta
HB: B Houli, R Thompson, L McDonald
C: Lewis, Hodge, S Hill
HF: Cotchin, Franklin, D Beams
F: LeCras, Roughead, Lynch
FOLL: Goldstein, Neale, J Selwood (c)
INT: Sloane, J Watson, S Thompson, D Hannebery

The Crowd Says:

2015-04-22T08:59:05+00:00

Natalie Swansfan

Guest


Heeny is stiff, RIsing Star nominee, 4 goals. Just so I can understand the logic, Lynch should have kicked straight which might have got him 5 or 6 in a losing side.....but didn't. Heeney, kicked 4 and assisted Buddy to two of his, plus his 17 and with Buddy basically won the game. Tough omission

2015-04-22T05:44:38+00:00

Mark

Guest


Solid player but not great. Definitely overrated.

2015-04-21T14:48:24+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Last year's demise was totally injury...nothing else. McPharlin, Johnson out, Ibbo out before half time. Taberner injured before half time and Danyle Pearce and Michael Barlow both broke bones before half time. Port were monstered by Freo until half time and took until the last 5 minutes to catch them...because...and only because of the injuries. The Freo midfield dominated until the injuries. Freo's midfield beat Sydney's midfield the week before.

2015-04-21T14:32:54+00:00

Michael huston

Guest


Agree to a certain extent, but you can't deny how important the midfield is to a premiership. Teams with a weak back line or forward line have won flags, but no team without an A-grade midfield has won a flag. If I was to apply this to your team, Don, last year your midfields were beaten in consecutive weeks by Sydney and Port Adelaide in the finals. It wasn't completely responsible for your finals exit, but it did contribute to Freo's demise. When Freo's midfield is able to beat the best throughout the finals to win a flag, they could easily be the best. If i was to pay your boys the highest compliment, I'd say that your midfield is looking eerily like the Brisbane team of 2001-2003. Very strong, very tough, and very dominant when on fire. You've got a way to go, but your boys resemble that Brisbane team more so than Sydney or Hawthorns.

2015-04-21T13:49:11+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


The former Aussie wicketkeeper, Timmy Zoehrer, took one of the all time great hangers playing for East Freo in the WAFL...but it wasn't paid. Stood, with straight legs on the pack, grabbed it Garry Moorcroft style, one grab, and it only jarred out as he landed on the ground after re-entry. Poor Timmy...was wonderful at all sports and will be remembered as 'almost' in all of them.

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T13:14:19+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


If it's paid it counts. Yarran ran out of bounds in his 2012 goal of the year but it was paid a goal by the umpire so a goal it stays

2015-04-21T12:57:57+00:00

Old fashioned views

Guest


To call Elliots a "mark" is to say that West Coast was impressive

2015-04-21T12:38:28+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


A flag has no impact on quality. A midfield can be stunning but if a whole defence is absent with injury, the resultant elimination from a Premiership doesn't render the midfield less able. Premierships have nothing to do with it.

2015-04-21T11:10:14+00:00

Michael huston

Guest


But you may be looking too much at stats. If a midfield is more outside-oriented or more inside-oriented, it doesn't make a difference. It's how the midfield works over all. Therefore, I'd argue Freo has the most to prove out of the three: Hawthorns midfield has taken them to three flags and four grand finals, and Sydneys midfield has taken them to a flag and two grand finals. If Freo's midfield takes them to a flag this year, then they'll be more than worthy of discussion. But they're definitely the best out of three at the moment.

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T10:52:32+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


There have only been 4 players not in the team that have been suggested in the comments. It would be interesting to see who the other 7 that I missed are. Another comment would be handy (as indicated by the 'fire away' comment)

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T10:45:32+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


Hodge is still a beast in the contest

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T10:43:23+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


Honestly, I rate Fremantle's the best of the three because it has the best balance of inside and outside players. Fyfe, Barlow, Neale and Mundy are exceptional at stoppages while Pearce and Hill are two of the best wingers in the competition and offer the run and carry to compliment this inside grunt. Sydney's midfield is probably a little too inside dominant while the Hawks is too outside dominant with Hodge and Lewis combining for just 17 contested possessions and Mitchell probably a bit small to dominate the stoppages. Their run and carry through the middle is better than any other though. Great call on Mick & the Blues

2015-04-21T08:20:18+00:00

Full Purple Jacket

Guest


If you're talking about D. Pearce he was actually the very first free agent to move clubs, Port to Freo. Pretty sure Kennedy came from the Hawks too. But yea, cry me a river Mick. Short memories over at the Blues I reckon, maybe its because they didn't get where they wanted to be when the snared Judd.

2015-04-21T07:47:45+00:00

Michael huston

Guest


Hawthorn keeps playing Hodge in the middle, he wins the Brownlow easy. It's pretty easy to forget how dominant this guy is in the midfield as opposed to commanding the half-back line. I'd also argue Hawthorn have arguably the best midfield in the competition. Lots of talk has rightfully centered around the midfields of Sydney and Fremantle, but the when all guns blazing, the Hawks can be unstoppable in the center. Hodge, Lewis, Mitchell, Smith, Hill, Duryea and Langford. Kennedy, Jack, Hannebery, Parker, McVeigh, Jetta and Bird. Fyfe, Mundy, Barlow, Neale, Pearce and Hill. Dear Malthouse: instead of blaming free agency for your clubs inability to improve and be a winning team, take a look at how Clarkson, Horse and Ross Lyon have assembled winning midfields through developing the players and actually coaching them to be good players. Not one of those star mids mentioned above came from another team yet all have propelled their teams to great success.

2015-04-21T07:01:16+00:00

13th Man

Guest


Lachie Neale also should get goal of the round. That was a monster kick from at least 60 out snapped it around the body. and it sailed another 20 metres further into the crowd. If you haven't seen it watch it here http://www.fremantlefc.com.au/video/2015-04-19/freos-firstquarter-blitz

2015-04-21T06:57:25+00:00

13th Man

Guest


Geez its a good problem to have if Fyfe is getting numbers like that and being outshone by other midfielders.

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T04:57:19+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


fire away

2015-04-21T04:46:32+00:00

Kaks

Roar Guru


Well...i would have to agree with about 50% of the names in this team

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T01:29:24+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


poor Lumumba - had a hanger taken on him and was crunched by Tex in the same marking contest

AUTHOR

2015-04-21T01:28:02+00:00

Katfish

Roar Guru


Hannebery played a balanced game and was outstanding. 44 touches and 2 goals from Hodge is impossible to go past. Maybe Watson could've been replaced for Fyfe given the Bombers were thumped in clearances and contested possessions and Watson had no impact there even though his team needed him to. I've been questioning Lewis' disposals lately too. 41 touches at 61% even though he only had 7 contested. Is he really as good as everyone has been saying?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar