The Wrap: Full moon fever engulfs Super Rugby

By Geoff Parkes / Expert

It’s usually easy enough to tell when there’s a full moon. My cat Tiggy, the one who runs like Mitchell Johnson, turns from a placid homebody into a rebellious teenager, staying out on all night benders.

She eventually signals her arrival home, and the end of the full moon, by triumphantly dragging trophies through the cat-flap, in the form of unfortunate local rats, mice and baby possums.

So imagine how confused I was this weekend with the cat snug and sleepy inside, yet some of the action so bizarrely left-field that the only possible explanation was that a full moon had descended on Super Rugby.

First cab off the rank was Ma’a Nonu, enjoying his best super rugby season for many years, but who somehow conspired to gift a try to Crusaders’ powerhouse Nemani Nadolo, to seal the Hurricanes’ fate in Nelson.

Nonu seemed to have plenty of time to cover a Dan Carter cross-kick, even sensing that Nadolo was charging towards him in chase. However, instead of making a positive play at the ball, he made a late decision to provide a block, to allow Nehe Milner-Skudder to provide the clean up instead.

Trouble was, he didn’t tell Milner-Skudder, and even if he had, this was not a block in the form of subtle obstruction we see every week, but a full blown, attempted shoulder into Nadolo.

It is hard to comprehend what Nonu was thinking. Even if he had succeeded, he was odds on for conceding a penalty try, with a yellow card to boot.

Nadolo meanwhile was having none of the nonsense, and breezed by an embarrassed Nonu to claim the try. Junior rugby coaches everywhere should use this footage as a prime example for young players to show the benefit of always playing the ball and not the man.

A few hours later, sitting through a long night of oscillating between enjoying the audacious strokeplay of the New Zealand batsmen in the second Test against England, and then cursing their rash stupidity, I stumbled into the Rebels v Sharks game from Durban.

This was an eminently winnable match for the Rebels, with the Sharks outpointing the Auckland Blues as rank underachievers this season and, once again in this match, failing to convince as a side capable of sustained, cohesive attack.

But in the 29th minute, the game was effectively decided when Jannie Du Plessis decided to give his opposite, Rebels’ prop Laurie Weeks, a cuff across the head, as the pigs trundled downfield after a kick.

That Weeks was upset at receiving such a whack in open play was understandable enough. But his reaction wasn’t – as though he had been overcome with full moon fever he slipped a solid right cross into Du Plessis and then, encouraged by this success, threw in a couple more scoring punches to the head for good measure.

Referee Jaco van Heerden kept an impressive clear head throughout the TMO proceedings, and calmly made the correct call – a yellow card for Du Plessis as instigator, and a red card for Weeks for continuous punching.

Weeks seemed genuinely astonished at his fate. Perhaps he had been watching a tape of Buck Shelford in the 1987 Rugby World Cup semi-final, thinking that it was still ok for players to deliver on-field justice?

But really, he was more like Ivan Milat being shocked at being found guilty of the backpacker murders. You can act as innocent as you like, but sometimes the facts simply speak for themselves.

The true folly of his brain snap was revealed a few minutes later at the next scrum, with Sean McMahon making way on the field for a required front rower. McMahon was just the type of player to take the game up to the Sharks, and he and coach Tony McGahan would have been seething that he effectively became the player sent off, wasting his next 50 minutes riding the pine.

On the positive side, captain Scott Higginbotham manfully did his best to make up for the man short, scoring two powerhouse tries, and busting out wide to set up a thrilling late try for Bryce Hegarty. He still gave away too many penalties for comfort, but in this sort of consistent form, is a must for Michael Cheika’s 2015 Wallabies.

Was there a full moon too in Perth, where the Force succumbed to a Queensland Reds side who, according to skipper James “Scoop” Slipper, “came here wanting to get a victory?”

That would imply that the Force only play so ineptly once a month. So no, this was merely a side with consistently poor attack this week dropping the level of their defence down to match it.

Finally, as if to show full moon fever isn’t the exclusive domain of Super Rugby players, Newcastle Knight Tariq Sims stepped up to the plate with a bizarre cameo, immediately following their 20-24 loss to the New Zealand Warriors in Auckland.

With Warriors captain Simon Mannering conducting an on-field interview, Sims wandered into shot behind Mannering’s shoulder and then, realizing he was on camera, decided to milk his 15 seconds of fame in a manner more usually associated with immature young kids.

Perhaps Sims is a funny guy in person, although Brisbane’s Justin Hodges would likely beg to differ, following a Sims shoulder charge to his head last year which earned Sims a five match suspension and a premature end to his North Queensland Cowboys career.

Knights fans would surely expect their players to be showing more hurt immediately following a loss, and this is the point. What Sims might see as funny on an end of season footy trip, or after a victory, merely marks him as a tool in this context.

Interestingly, Sims’ 2015 suspension was punctuated by a Twitter attack on the NRL by his partner Ashleigh Sudholz who, in the best Tania Hird tradition, accused the NRL of corruption. On the evidence, it wouldn’t shock me to find that every week is a full moon in this household.

The Crowd Says:

2015-06-02T07:28:19+00:00

Akari

Roar Rookie


What is of concern is that I haven't seen or heard of the Rebels coach condemning Weeks for his stupidity. He seems to have brushed it under the carpet and Weeks lives on to play another game and display more stupidity then. He should have been fined $20k for stupidity alone and another $1 for pretending he is a tough nut and a heavy boxer that he is not.

2015-06-02T02:41:36+00:00

Sean Turner

Roar Guru


Im afraid I have to agree with you there, although I wish it wasn't so. Throw the TV producers who control the big screen replays in with the TMOs and you have at the makings of at least one unjust exit for a team.

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T23:13:57+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Yes Rob, Coles is definitely an honourable mention. He (and Steve Hansen) won't be wanting any more nights like that.

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T23:12:54+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Ray, I don't think reefing concerns are just about northern hemisphere refs any more. Let's face it Australia can hardly complain if they don't produce any refs of their own who are good enough to make the panel. Sure they wouldn't play under them but the point is that it would be a bit rich to point the finger at anyone else. My concern is actually around the TMO, and the lack of consistency over how referees and TMO's interact. I'm nervous about a major refereeing controversy over a TMO decision at this RWC - whether it be against the Wallabies or in any match. As for the Tah's, don't you think that the person who needs to adjust - and quickly - is the coach? He seems still to be in denial about the judiciary decisions instead of accepting where the line is drawn and insisting his players adjust.

2015-06-01T16:16:59+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks Allanthus. I think Coles LO throwing was thwarted by the fullmoon. Two fubars led to two Crusader tries. Nonu had a nothing kick, under no pressure. This too lead to another try.

2015-06-01T14:50:56+00:00

RaymondReddington

Roar Rookie


Fair Call .... Also this white line fever actually started with the last two Waratah's games where 4 players have put the renaissance in jeopardy .... I fear for the fate of the Wallabies at the RWC with regard to NH refereeing ...any thoughts ?

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T12:57:44+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Agreed Sean, that was totally illogical. I thought it was a try anyway, he had enough downward pressure for mine and the fact that the ball squirted out on a slippery surface, well so what? I really worry that the world cup is going to be decided by a TMO going off on a tangent trying to prove something that doesn't need to be proved.

2015-06-01T08:57:27+00:00

Sean Turner

Roar Guru


Thanks for the piece mate! A worthy read. A very strange weekend of rugby indeed. Although I think the Damien Mckenzie no try call takes the cake. Conceding his hands never even touched the ball is one thing, then calling it a knock on is another entirely. Hamilton residents should be on the look out for werewolves after that one.

2015-06-01T05:35:27+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Sims does it constantly, was more the point I was making.

2015-06-01T03:53:47+00:00

Chas

Guest


Brett from now on you will need to clarify which brother you are talking about, Francois 'Tabbie' du Plessis (younger brother) is currently playing for Associates (Soaks) in Perth :-)

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T03:18:55+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Max I think you're on the right track. If we see a spate of players deliberately using open hands to strike, just to avoid red cards, I'm sure this will be cracked down upon.

2015-06-01T03:17:40+00:00

grapeseed

Guest


I quite liked this article. More please. That is all.

2015-06-01T02:10:05+00:00

Old Bugger

Guest


Brett The amendment provides clarification and removes all confusion. Cheers again to you and Roar.

2015-06-01T01:12:22+00:00

Max

Roar Rookie


I have no problem with Weeks being sent off but just because his offence was worse than Du Plessis' doesn't mean that you can't give them both a red. The degree of punishment can then be differentiated by the tribunal. If Du Plessis had used a closed fist rather than an open one he would have met the threshold for a red, despite the acts being equally dirty and dangerous. Brett seems to have eluded to the fact that in knowing precisely where that line is (rightly or wrongly) drawn and adjusting accordingly, that the strike had a premeditated air about it and this is something that should be taken into account when punishing such indiscretions.

2015-06-01T00:36:29+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


OB, since I've just spotted you, you'll be pleased to know the guys updated their wording around the Super Rugby table yesterday. Thanks again for picking it up..

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T00:12:34+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


It was a lame effort indeed OB, but the Highlanders deserve plenty of credit too. I wouldn't be overly worried though, I still expect the Chiefs to play a major role in the playoffs.

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T00:10:29+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Yes Digger that's my point. Sims has a lot of physical attributes but perhaps not the humility and maturity to become the player he could be.

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T00:08:52+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Did you see it Alex? Agree, bombing isn't anything new or noteworthy in itself, but gee…. there was something particularly unhinged about Sims in this one.

AUTHOR

2015-06-01T00:02:29+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


That's a good point Brett, they've identified where the line is and are pushing right up to it. Cheap shot merchants usually get their comeuppance in one way or another, but let's hope that doesn't become the norm.

AUTHOR

2015-05-31T23:57:57+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Agree Sheriff, although I expect he was not in the RWC squad anyway, even before Saturday. It looks like Phipps, Genia with Giteau in reserve for the RWC. It's frustrating, he's very capable but can't seem to focus on his role as part of the team game, taking too much on himself, including being second referee. His missed touch from the last minute penalty was unforgivable. Again, I saw that as ego getting in the way - instead of taking his time and making sure the ball went out near the 22, he went for the 5 metre line. The Brumbies didn't need another try, they just needed to secure their own line out, from wherever it was, for the win.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar