Brad news for Australia as Haddin pushes for recall

By Daniel Gray / Roar Guru

Well, this is awkward. Just days after Australia completed a humiliating 405-run bludgeoning of the old enemy, reports from the UK suggest wicketkeeper Brad Haddin is expected to play in the squad’s next tour match in the hope of a recall for the third Test.

The circumstances of his leave of absence from the side deserve the utmost sympathy and patience. However, the selectors cannot ignore the immediate and positive impact on the side that came from the addition of Peter Nevill and young tyro Mitchell Marsh.

Both players were instrumental in the Aussies’ crushing win, with Nevill taking a record-equalling seven catches to accompany a solid 45-run first innings knock in his debut Test. After serving a long apprenticeship behind Haddin in NSW, it appears the apprentice is ready to become the master.

While the sentimental fan in me doesn’t begrudge Haddin a farewell on his own terms, professional sport is not a Disney movie. Some athletes drive off into the sunset after winning a championship or a big series, others are cut down by injury.

Haddin was presented with a golden opportunity to retire in a blaze of glory, beer and sledging following Australia’s World Cup victory earlier this year. This would have provided the selectors with an ideal opportunity to blood Nevill in the West Indies, along the lines of Matthew Wade’s introduction to Test cricket a few years back.

Fortunately for all parties, Nevill has now confirmed he is the perfect replacement for Haddin, and should retain his place for the foreseeable future.

Sometimes the selectors are forced to tap a player on the shoulder and suggest in a kind but firm way that retirement is their best choice. For the sake of Australian cricket and current series momentum, we can only hope Rod Marsh will be having a conversation along these lines with Haddin in coming days.

Putting aside all the ‘lifeblood of the team’ rhetoric that is constantly brought up whenever Haddin’s place in the side is questioned, it is difficult to ignore the strong performance of Nevill in his debut match.

Going back to Haddin now would arguably give England a chink in our armour to target. His mixed form over the past 18 months was followed by a poor showing with the bat in the first Test of the series, along with an embarrassing dropped chance from Joe Root that cost Australia dearly.

Rod Marsh and his panel have already made a wise choice in dropping Shane Watson for the in-form Mitchell III, aka Mitchell Marsh.

Big second innings hitting and incisive strikes at key moments more than justified that selection choice. Nevill’s contribution with gloves and bat was equally valuable, and his quiet, precise manner behind the stumps will be missed if he is relegated to the bench for the rest of the series.

At the end of the day, time waits for no man. Sport can be cruel, but Haddin has had his fair share of highlights and victories throughout a solid career.

He will recognise more than most that at the end of the day, cricket is just a game. This series will roll on with growing momentum, and Australia must maintain consistency in performance and selection, with Peter Nevill behind the stumps.

The Crowd Says:

2015-07-22T16:26:17+00:00

Antim bhusal

Guest


Although nevil seems to be the perfect replacement for haddin, haddin should be given another opportunity to give him the farewell he deserves...haddin should decide his retirement at the earliest...

AUTHOR

2015-07-22T06:06:47+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Absolutely, Donna. Hard to change a winning side.

2015-07-22T04:00:52+00:00

Donna

Guest


Well said, Daniel, although Haddin may feel badly done by. Still, the team comes first, doesn't it?

2015-07-22T03:05:42+00:00

Existentialist

Guest


I think Haddin should be the better man and say "I'll be Peter's back-up!" This won't happen given his ego but it would be nice to see. He may just garner a skerik of respect back from those who question his sportsmanship. Then if the Aussies do go 3-1 or at least 2-1 up going into the last test then like I espoused on another post let Haddin and Watto have their swan song. This is a team game ... stand aside Pride & Prejudice

AUTHOR

2015-07-22T01:20:38+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Absolutely. I think keeping Haddin in the party as a mentor/back up to Nevill makes the most sense with three Tests remaining. Perhaps get Sam Whiteman a short stint with a county side so he is in close proximity and getting experience in English conditions as well?

2015-07-22T00:56:23+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


It would be pure insanity to restore Haddin. There are issues here, if Hadin retires, they need to fly someone over as a back-up, but at the same time Haddin should have been dropped months/years ago. If we restore Haddin and lose, we'll look particularily foolish.

AUTHOR

2015-07-21T23:10:56+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


I guess that's possible, TCL, but I hope not.

AUTHOR

2015-07-21T23:10:30+00:00

Daniel Gray

Roar Guru


Agreed, Nordburg.

2015-07-21T22:52:37+00:00

Nordburg

Guest


Healy was a far better keeper than Haddin and he didn't get the farewell he wanted -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2015-07-21T21:21:50+00:00

horse

Guest


An excellent article, Daniel. We feel sorry for Haddin, but the team comes first.

2015-07-21T16:05:16+00:00

TheCunningLinguistic

Guest


"While the sentimental fan in me doesn’t begrudge Haddin a farewell on his own terms, professional sport is not a Disney movie." I agree 100%, Daniel. I love an athlete being able to farewell their chosen sport at the time of their choosing. Unfortunately, I think Haddin may have missed that opportunity. Neville adds a balance to the team, a security that comes with knowing there is a steady bat behind you, a guy who prizes their wicket quite dearly. Haddin doesn't, and while his keeping has been reasonably good (Root howler aside), his frailty with the willow does leave a definable chink in the armour, as you say. I think they will slot him back in. I do not agree with this, however it will probably happen. Maybe he could announce one 'last hurrah' Test, followed by his retirement, with Neville to come in for the Fourth and Fifth Tests? Wishful thinking...

Read more at The Roar