Cameron Smith's 300th a reminder of State of Origin's great divide

By Jason Hosken / Roar Guru

The celebrations accompanying Cameron Smith’s 300th NRL appearance last Friday night not only honoured a remarkable achievement and resilient football club, but highlighted the massive imbalance fuelling Queensland’s State of Origin dominance.

Smith’s rare one club triple century is even more impressive given almost every day of his Melbourne journey has been shared with fellow one-club players and Queensland mainstays Billy Slater and Cooper Cronk – both rapidly approaching the 300-club themselves.

Earlier this season, Corey Parker reached the landmark and shows no sign of declaring short of former Brisbane teammate Darren Lockyer’s NRL record.

Like Smith, Parker heads a list of current loyal teammates in Sam Thaiday and Justin Hodges to have played at the same club over the last decade.

Further north, and the Cowboys foundation for an inaugural title was bedded down over 10 years ago with the signatures of Johnathan Thurston and Matt Scott.

Even Queensland’s more transient Origin regulars are cut from the same cloth.

Darius Boyd’s eight years for the Maroons are born through loyalty towards Broncos coach Wayne Bennett. Melbourne provided the launching pad for Souths’ wrecking ball Greg Inglis.

These ten Lang Park legends have a combined total of 253 Origin appearances – that’s an average of nine series per man.

Equally impressive, eight have represented Queensland on 23 or more occasions whereas only four of New South Wales’ finest have reached the same milestone since the concept began in 1980.

Amazingly, Nate Myles is Queensland’s only regular with an alternate selection background having initially been chosen from Sydney.

So what’s the point?

Striking at 9 from 10, Queensland hardly needs another peck on the cheek from The Roar.

In simple terms, Australian rugby league’s showcase has inadvertently been hijacked by three NRL clubs.

It’s no secret Queensland’s success shares close links to the Storm’s strong affiliation north of the Tweed and the Cowboys and the Broncos’ sole access to Brisbane.

While the Maroons are chosen from a smaller pool of NRL talent, it’s important to recognise the pre-Origin selection process concentrating Queensland’s best juniors among fewer clubs in their formative years.

It goes without saying Queensland’s best up-and-comers will mostly gravitate towards clubs close to home, but some head south to the proven tutelage of Craig Bellamy.

The advantage this provides over their far-flung New South Wales counterparts is a congregation of elite juniors across fewer teams.

Unintentionally, the current structure of the NRL facilitates Queensland’s ability to forge key combinations across a few elite clubs providing an almost seamless transition to the next level.

In some ways it clarifies why the forced selection of Daly Cherry-Evans from the outside mimicked a fish out of water.

It’s a theory of minor relevance to those bleeding Maroon, just another excuse to raise a glass of Caxton Street’s finest – this time in recognition of the proven model nurturing generation next.

For the Blues nothing has changed. Their annual build up remains a heated selection debate of inconsistent club combinations versus form individuals pooled from the length and breadth of the NRL.

Queensland has rubbed the benefits of club combinations in the Blues’ faces for years. New South Wales know it but are hamstrung by a ‘spoilt for choice’ spread of talent.

Newcastle’s one-club trio of Andrew Johns, Danny Buderus and Matt Gidley spearheaded the Blues last period of consecutive series victories. Since then the search for similar combinations has complicated their quest.

This has led to the type of frustration recently vented by Phil Gould in the Sydney Morning Herald where he wrote, “selfishness has been the biggest factor standing in the way of New South Wales matching Queensland for the past 10 years”.

Unfortunately for the Blues, more than an attitude adjustment is needed before the Maroons are matched on a regular basis.

Dilution of Queensland’s breeding grounds through NRL expansion north of the border and even by reduction to the south will notably level the playing field.

And while Origin is unlikely to influence NRL expansion, it’s worth considering the commercial impact of long-term Maroons domination.

More importantly, additional NRL clubs in Queensland will not only spread the Maroons’ talent but offer additional opportunities for players who miss the initial cut in their home city.

But until then, not even the waiting game is a guarantee of Blues success. Under the current NRL format the next generation of Queensland’s top guns are waiting in unified groups to extend the Blues misery.

The Crowd Says:

2015-07-26T10:27:35+00:00

Brett

Guest


False. The 2011 season not just 3 weeks. But good to know using drugs to cheat is okay only if you do it sometimes.

2015-07-26T01:17:14+00:00

Squidward

Roar Rookie


3wks in a 15year career. Go home Brett you're drunk.

2015-07-25T19:28:34+00:00

Ra

Guest


Where do I book in for my Darwin season tickets Wayne? I'm a starter !

2015-07-25T19:25:48+00:00

Ra

Guest


Samoa, Fiji and Tonga would want to contest with PNG Brett.

2015-07-25T11:10:21+00:00

Brett

Guest


Renegade and Squidward, which part of Gallen taking illegal peptides, pleading guilty and consequently being charged by ASADA do you not understand? Play the ball, not the man.

2015-07-25T08:07:20+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Top wrap, Ra. You've covered plenty there. I'm looking forward to the Kiwi tour to the UK at the end if the year - good on them from taking it on. I'm disappointed the Aussies snubbed it.

2015-07-25T08:00:22+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


He learnt his trade under scott at the Cowboys.

2015-07-25T07:02:17+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


Logo? Crocs

2015-07-25T05:39:22+00:00

Wayne Lovell

Roar Guru


I would love to see a Darwin team

2015-07-25T04:59:13+00:00

Squidward

Roar Rookie


He's a fool. Especially considering Gallen should've been on about 300 but not because of injury

2015-07-25T04:34:54+00:00

Renegade

Roar Guru


Right so, Darius Boyd destroys his Achilles earlier this year and returns 2 months early.... Based on your interpretation- must be peptides. Yeah sure, simple - good logic Brett... Smh

AUTHOR

2015-07-25T03:34:44+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Something along those lines appears inevitable and your timeline probably close too. NRL in PNG would be mayhem of the highest order. Big job to make it sustainable but I hope to see it one day. I'm not so sure about Central Coast, will rely on reduction in Sydney I'd say.

2015-07-25T01:35:41+00:00

Brett

Guest


The NRL eventually needs to expand. The contenders are: - Brisbane - Central QLD Coast - Central NSW Coast - Perth - New Zealand - PNG I honestly believe 8 Sydney teams is too many and the NRL will have to relocate or disband 2 Sydney teams. This will leave us with 20 teams, where they play each other once, then we hold the final series for the top 8. Maybe this will be the scenario in 2030, who knows.

AUTHOR

2015-07-25T00:44:01+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


No MB. The point is listing a few observations that have helped Qld become a force. I reckon it highlights the need for another Qld NRL team, Brisbane my preference. The very nature of this may break up the current supply of combinations. Gee, it'll probably assist strengthening Qld rugby league.

2015-07-25T00:28:17+00:00

Ra

Guest


And yet some would suggest the injection of Lilly in the last SOO was the game changer of that match which flies in the face of the club combinations theory for the obvious reasons...

2015-07-25T00:19:53+00:00

Ra

Guest


I think you're talking building a culture of understand and relations, genuine off-field friendship, willingness to meld and into that familiarity combination thing there Jason.

2015-07-25T00:11:20+00:00

Ra

Guest


That's an old worn out line of dribble there Robbo. I don't know of any guy who reluctantly pulls on a green and gold jersey and goes out and plays deliberately below par for his chosen country of representation.. How un Australian of you to suggest that. If on the other hand you have names and compelling evidence to support your claims then please roar them out loud so we can all know,

2015-07-24T23:53:52+00:00

Maroon Blood

Guest


Soooo, correct me if I am wrong, the point of this article is how to make NSW more competitive?? Easy, start by getting rid of Bob Fulton and work downwards from there. Another hint: Look at what Qld did to their organisation after the 2000 whitewash........

2015-07-24T23:40:28+00:00

Ra

Guest


No argument Jason, we've spent years getting beaten up by that Queensland combination in Green and Gold colours. But that gave our backroom boys a good chance to build our player base and strategy. I had to sit and admire the confidence that oozed from Steven Kearny in the television interview the day before the delayed Test match at Sun Corp. He already knew what they needed to do to win that match. Laurie Daley will spend half his summer at the beach and the other half analysing the Kiwis last three wins. And especially how the Kiwis were able to shut down that fantastic close in spine of Smith, and his two lieutenants in the halves. The Kiwis have known how to do it for years now, but there is a big gap between knowing it and executing it Whether Daley can do that next season remains to be seen, but I agree with you to some extent about club combinations, Half of the Kiwis pack play for the Storm and therefore have that intimate and innate knowledge of Smith's and Cronk's play. I don't want to get into that dribble about Queensland v Kiwis. It's just time wasting dribble. But I would like to congratulate Big Slammin' Sam and evergreen Corey Parker who were in my eye Aussie standout players of the 4Nations series and Anzac Test and they took that form into the SOO and back it up week in week out for their club. Tough on the paddock, humble off it. Well done boys, a couple of true legends !! Finally congratulations Cameron, a fantastic player, a great captain and according to most a top bloke too.

2015-07-24T08:11:46+00:00

Brett

Guest


If a Minichiello or a Slater were able to use certain peptides to improve recovery from their injuries, they would have more games to their name. Pretty simple.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar