Not now, not ever: Why I won't boo Adam Goodes

By Sean Lee / Expert

I won’t boo Adam Goodes. Not now, not ever.

I won’t lie. As a footballer he has annoyed me, but I am not so blinded by my prejudice that I can’t also recognise the brilliance of his play.

As a man though, Goodes sets as fine an example as anyone playing the game. With the AFL’s image in tatters we actually need more players like Adam Goodes to look up to.

Let’s face it, some AFL footballers have a penchant for getting into trouble. Goodes is not one of them.

He has not been photographed snorting cocaine. He has not had an affair with a teammate’s wife. He has not physically abused anyone. He has not sexually abused anyone. There are no photos of him naked on social media. He doesn’t send obscene text messages. He has not been picked up for drink driving. He has not been arrested for being drunk and disorderly.

He has not been arrested for being a public nuisance. He has not urinated on a shop front. He has not flashed his privates in public. He has not broken a teammate’s jaw in a fight. He has not been thrown out of a nightclub. He has not spent the night in a hotel room with an under-aged girl. He has not jumped all over someone else’s car while on a footy trip.

He hasn’t really done anything wrong at all.

Further to that, he has actually shown all the qualities that embody what many of us believe Australia is all about – the courage to stick up for yourself and your mates.

That’s exactly what he was doing two years ago when he singled out a member of the crowd who had uttered a racist remark. Not many of us know what it feels like to be constantly vilified, whether deliberately or through ignorance, but it can not be pleasant. It matters not if the perpetrator is male or female, 13 years old or 130 years old.

It simply should not happen.

Nicky Winmar and Michael Long were sick of fighting the battle with their fists and took a stand against on-field vilification years ago. Their actions changed the way AFL footballers approached the game. That the spotlight has turned now to the crowd is a natural progression of what they started, and Goodes was within his rights to make the stand that he did.

It was something that we all should have looked at and thought, “OK, there is obviously an issue here, how can we prevent it happening again?” But for many it was easier to label Goodes a sook and ignore the bigger issue.

The criticism he copped for highlighting the plight of Indigenous Australia while serving as Australian of the Year was also difficult to fathom. The position offers a perfect platform from which to raise awareness of issues. 2015 winner Rosie Batty used it to highlight the devastating effects of family violence. 2012 winner Geoffrey Rush highlighted the state of the Australian film industry. 2010 winner Professor Patrick McGorry highlighted the debilitating toll that mental illness takes on our society, in particular our young people. The list goes on.

Surely this is what we want in our Australians of the Year – people willing to speak out for what they believe in. If they don’t, then we are left with a meaningless figurehead.

The furore surrounding Goodes’ war dance bordered on the hysterical. It may not have been the wisest thing to do, but was anyone really, really threatened by it? Was anyone really offended by it? And if so, are they able to even explain why? Surely a middle finger raised by a cowardly fan in the relative anonymity of the crowd carries far more malicious intent than a dance done in front of a national audience.

The middle finger brigade are at every game. Just watch when the cameras zoom in on a player getting a free kick on the boundary line. You’ll see them every time. And yet, that is acceptable I suppose, because it is directed at a player, not the other way around. Strange world we live in.

The incessant booing that has followed Goodes this year is little more than bullying. The definition of bullying that is applied in my workplace makes mention of a repeated behaviour that is directed towards a person in a way that victimises, humiliates, undermines or threatens that person.

Yep.

I’m no saint. When an opposition player knocks one of ‘my boys’ arse up with a crude tackle or a head high bump, I’ll boo and hiss with the best of them. Same if the umpire makes a howler of a decision in the goal square gifting the opposition a goal.

But that is where it ends. It doesn’t snowball into something else entirely.

I’ve asked a few people why they boo Goodes and the answer is almost always the same. It is because he is a tool, or a dickhead or a sook. But ask them to elaborate further and they struggle to articulate their reasons.

Well, I’d need something stronger to go on than that.

So no, I won’t boo Adam Goodes. Not now, not ever.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2015-08-01T05:37:41+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


I'd actually forgotten about the Nick Reiwoldt pics.

AUTHOR

2015-08-01T05:36:38+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


I think you have nailed the difference between barracking and bullying.

AUTHOR

2015-08-01T05:27:21+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


I've read that book twice. Took me about six months each time. Still don't know if I liked it or not! Raised some interesting points though.

2015-07-31T16:33:51+00:00

AussieBokkie

Guest


Very well said mate. Loved the article. Block your ears to the Neanderthal's rolling out their uneducated, ignorant and hateful tripe. JJ seems like a prime example. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2015-07-31T10:47:46+00:00

holty

Guest


Nice Penster.

2015-07-31T07:11:06+00:00

Olivia Watts

Roar Guru


What he said! Sean, thank you for your unbiased, calm, erudite and compelling article. It says everything I would have said but in such a concise and educative way that I clearly see the difference between Guro's and Experts when it comes to writing on here. Bravo Sean and Bravo Adam Goodes who, as shown by Sean, has done nothing in his life or his football to warrant such offensive behaviour. I am sometimes put down by other writers here who feel that I have Goodes on too high a pedestal, I disagree. Both as a man and as a footballer I do not find any pedestal too high for him. He has earned every accolade ad deserved all the glory and honouration which has come his way. No matter what I write though, some will continue to boo. Shame of you. To the decent and reasonable members and attendees of sporting clubs, don't sit silently. Speak out, tell your fellow'supporters' to can it and,mid they add racist commentary to their booing, name and shame them though speaking out and having them ejected or arrested. Take a stand,must as Adam has done and Nicky and Michael in years past. It is said that all it takes for evil to triumph is for good men to sit silent and do nothing. Be string all of you and let the silent minority be loud and clear in their message - racists and rabble rousers go home; our club does not support you and does not need you. As a community of sporting supporters we can do this!

2015-07-31T06:52:27+00:00

johno

Guest


Agree that NR was a victim in those picture leaks, but what about Josh Bootsma and his social media nude pics? Got him sacked from Carlton. His image was distributed by himself ..... or maybe its in referral to NRL players peeing in their own mouths, or doing bizarre acts with dogs ....

2015-07-31T06:28:02+00:00

Mark

Guest


By JJ's logic we should all be up in arms over Rosie Battie being AOTY last year then? Until someone gives me a decent reason as to why Goodes is boo'd it doesn't matter that Australia is split. Quite frankly seeing the comments on here, facebook, ect on why he is boo'd I would say it matters even less,

2015-07-31T05:34:47+00:00

Penster

Guest


Wrong and wrong. Congratulations. I'm saying that given so many people have expressed outrage at racism against 1 celebrity footballer, it's surprising that more didn't turn out to support the cause of those Aborigines who don't have money, prestige, accolades, and are amongst the worst treated in this country. It's cheap and easy to log on, and tell all your facebook friends how disgusted you are, but where's the outrage for those who really need it? Clicktivism.

2015-07-31T04:10:24+00:00

Mad Max

Guest


Hey Mark ... you grow up. Half this nation is split on this issue ... including myself. Just cause you think you're right don't mean JJ hasn't got a point (and you are basically in the same boat as those booing and rightly/wrongly labelled as racists). This whole thing has been made worse via the media, this has warped into a unnecessary beast and a true blight on our country.

2015-07-31T03:40:43+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Sean, I agree with a lot of this article, but this particular bit irritated me.. "There are no photos of him naked on social media." Nick Riewoldt and others had these images distributed without their consent, no differently to that celebrity hacking scandal a while back they are the victims, if it happened to Ellyse Perry half of the roar would be writing about how it was a sex crime.

2015-07-31T03:35:59+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Indeed.

2015-07-31T03:34:42+00:00

Mark

Guest


Grow up JJ. By that logic the last 5 years + of AOTY are a farce and should be thrown in the bin.

2015-07-31T03:18:32+00:00

JJ

Guest


And he would have come remotely close to a nomination had he not called out 13 year old girl? Highly doubt it champ. How man people have set up charities foundations etc and never given a chance in hell of becoming Australian of the year. It was blatant reverse descriminatation. .. sadly this is the period in time which we exist.

2015-07-31T02:11:18+00:00

ben

Guest


Ok pat so we shouldnt take being called coconuts as insulting when its a derogatory term for pacific islanders?

2015-07-31T02:07:06+00:00

Ian

Guest


so your line of thinking is - it's bad to be 'anti ra*ist'? and these people who don't like ra*ism didn't attend these rallies therefore the abuse of Goodes isn't ra*ism?

2015-07-31T02:03:56+00:00

Ian

Guest


Good call. Maybe Mitch Johnson received terrible abuse directed at his moustache and he stood there and took it like a real man. Because moustache abuse is just not on.

2015-07-31T01:53:41+00:00

Rob McHugh

Roar Guru


Someone at my football club was trying to prove white players had been booed, and led with "Stephen Milne got booed every week". Really? Stephen Milne?

2015-07-31T01:43:19+00:00

chivasdude

Guest


Well written and well said.

2015-07-31T01:42:51+00:00

Mitcher

Guest


Setting up a foundation to support the underprvileged is a 'ridiculous act'? Love to hear that explained.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar