Michael Clarke: a man who divided and conquered

By Glenn Mitchell / Expert

Michael Clarke was not everyone’s cup of tea but there is no arguing that he leaves Australian cricket having made an indelible impression.

The Oval Test – his 115th – will mark the end of his Test career.

Just days after bristling at suggestions that his career was about to end he completed a 180-degree turn after a humiliating innings defeat at Trent Bridge that saw England regain the Ashes.

The end of Clarke’s career is diametrically opposed to the way it started.

I was lucky enough to be behind the microphone at Bangalore in 2004 when he literally danced his way to 151 on debut.

With footwork reminiscent of Kim Hughes at his best he dominated both Anil Kumble and Harbhajan Singh.

Remarkably he topped not only the batting averages on his maiden tour but the bowling as well courtesy of an incredible 6-9 off 6.2 overs in the fourth Test at Mumbai.

On his return to Australia he joined an elite group by scoring a century in both his first overseas and home Tests by making 141 against New Zealand at the Gabba.

After that initial home series he had a six-Test average of 60.9 with two centuries and another innings of 91 against India.

Australian cricket had found a new wunderkind – he was even nicknamed ‘Pup’ as the young kid on the block.

As is often the case with newcomers reality soon hit home and without a century in the following 12 months he was dropped in late 2005.

He was reinstated for the Bangladesh tour in April 2006 and it was not long before he was again back among the runs.

At number five in the order he became a lynchpin of the Australian batting line-up.

At the SCG in January 2008 he helped Australia record a mighty victory in what was a spiteful Test.

Thrown the ball by Ricky Ponting in the shadow of stumps on the final day he claimed 3-5 in 1.5 overs to snatch victory with just eight minutes remaining in the match.

Following the retirement of Adam Gilchrist in April 2008 Clarke was elevated to the vice-captaincy.

From early in his career Clarke was earmarked as a future leader which was something that did not sit well with many rusted on Australian cricket fans. When he was anointed as Ponting’s successor, however, the die was set.

Here was a man who was very much Gen-Y. From the diamond ear stud and sleeve tattoo to the model girlfriend he was not the sort of man that ‘old-timers’ could imagine as their national captain.

After Australia’s defence of its World Cup title ended at the quarter-final stage at Ahmedabad in early 2011 Ponting stood down from the captaincy of both the Test and one-day teams.

Clarke was now the man and many had reservations about his appointment, especially as Test skipper. There was no doubting his tactical nous but there were lingering concerns over his interpersonal skills and A-list life off the field.

Stories had circulated of a physical dressing room altercation with Simon Katich following the SCG Test in January 2009, an incident that rankled many.

Some had also questioned his decision to leave the 2010 tour to New Zealand for ‘personal reasons’ which ended in a split from fiancé Lara Bingle.

While some questioned his suitability for the leadership one thing was certain – it brought the best out in him as a batsman.

In Clarke’s first 15 Tests as permanent skipper he scored seven centuries including a record four doubles in the 2012 calendar year – 329no and 210 against India and 259no and 230 against South Africa.

He was soon anointed as the number one ranked Test batsman in the world.

The runs, in the main, kept flowing with centuries in consecutive Tests against England in 2012-13, a series in which he led Australia to a resounding 5-0 victory.

But following that series things began to slip both with his form and fitness.

An exception was an unbeaten 161 against South Africa at Cape Town in March 2014, an innings he completed despite suffering a fractured shoulder as a result of Morne Morkel bouncer.

While playing against Pakistan in the UAE in October 2014 Clarke was forced home with a hamstring injury. He faced a race against time for the first home Test of the summer against India.

As he was battling to regain fitness, Australian cricket was struck by an unimaginable tragedy when Phil Hughes was struck a fatal blow while at the crease in a Shield match at the SCG.

The pugnacious Hughes was virtually a little brother to Clarke and his death floored the Aussie captain.

In the days following Hughes’ passing Clarke, despite his own grief, was a tower of strength for all and sundry as a nation struggled to come to terms with the tragedy.

Even Clarke’s strongest detractors dipped their lids at his stoic performance.

With the scheduled first Test at the Gabba postponed the series started a fortnight later at Adelaide.

Clarke was declared fit and led from the front with an emotional century however when it was Australia’s turn in the field he tore his hamstring and missed the remainder of the series.

The goodwill earned in the wake of Hughes’ death was short-lived with many questioning why he played and risked serious injury.

Clarke spent the remainder of the series in the Channel Nine commentary box which drew further ire from the fans who questioned whether the captain should be passing judgment on his own charges.

Again, all was forgiven at the end of the summer when he held the World Cup trophy aloft at the MCG – the last match of his 245-game, 7981-run career.

The focus now turned towards the Ashes in England. Clarke arrived in the Old Dart badly in need of runs, but try as he may he could not recover form.

Come the fourth Test at Trent Bridge he had averaged a mere 28 in the preceding eight Tests.

Clarke added 10 in Australia’s first innings of 60, falling to a woefully executed drive well outside off stump that left his team teetering at 6-29. In the second innings he went for 13.

By match end, with the Ashes gone, he announced that the fifth Test would be his last.

The thought of captaining a side while at rock bottom form wise was no longer an option.

He will enter his final Test with 8628 runs (4th all-time for Australia) at 49.3 with 28 centuries.
Cricket fans will form their own opinions of his career.

At his best he was one of the finest batsmen of his generation and an artful and attacking leader.

He was also a divisive figure with fans as witnessed by his off-field run-ins with the likes of Katich and Michael Hussey, two of the sport’s most respected players.

As a selector he was party to the infamous ‘Homework-gate’ and after he relinquished that position he directed thinly-veiled criticisms of the men who were charged with that responsibility.

Perhaps, in essence, the closest comparison to Clarke’s career is that of his great friend and mentor, Shane Warne, the man who personally presented his number 23 ODI shirt to Clarke upon his retirement.

It was Warne who was granted the interview following the Trent Bridge Test where Clarke announced his retirement. The pair will likely soon share a commentary box.

Michael Clarke is shortly to ride into cricket’s sunset.

He will leave as a man who often thrilled the fans but perhaps never gained full acceptance from them.

The Crowd Says:

2015-08-15T00:21:12+00:00

Tricky Ricky

Guest


Michael Clarke would have to be the most self absorbed and aloof sportsman I have ever encountered when my son and I met him at a children's Milo Cricket event. Adam Gilchrist was also present that day. Gilly you are a wonderful man and a great ambassador for cricket. Bye bye Michael like me and many members of the cricketing public you will not be missed.

2015-08-11T02:39:03+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


And those who look at scores.

2015-08-11T02:10:30+00:00

ChrisB

Guest


Hayden was the ultimate flat track bully who enjoyed some glorious years in the early Noughties after Ambrose & Walsh, with Donald in decline, Wasim & Waqar going etc, and before the improved English attack of 05 (Jones especially) and then Steyn and co made him look plodding Unfortunately his go hard and go early approach has become endemic. Whereas his team was awesome and had the fear factor to intimidate (of which he was a key part to be fair), later teams have tried the same with lesser stocks in reserve. But think how atrocious he looked at times in 05 and after. It was actually quite similar to a lot of dismissals in the current series

2015-08-10T14:56:17+00:00

Aransan

Guest


That sums it up pretty well Jimmy.

2015-08-10T12:20:39+00:00

Jimmy

Guest


Clarke will be remembered for the 8000 runs he scored and being ranked the best batsman in the world through a competitive period.

2015-08-10T12:08:35+00:00

Andy

Guest


Come on Glen, the English press is the base line for doing the right thing? If your defence for anything is 'the English media did it first' your moral, ethical and spiritual compass is as useful as a toaster. It was pretty bad timing for Englands win but wonderful for everyone connected with Australia especially cricket Australia as it completely overshadowed the spanking we took.

2015-08-10T12:05:50+00:00

Andy

Guest


I think it was a little unclassy to do it right after the game, especially with almost 2 weeks between games but from an Australian team and management perspective it was brilliant, we are all mostly talking about Clarke and how good or bad he was and who the next captain will be. Lots of pressure off the boys. So little unclassy but very patriotic too :-)

2015-08-10T12:03:46+00:00

Andy

Guest


Zing

2015-08-10T12:01:12+00:00

Andy

Guest


I am actually very surprised that his average is only 38, in my head he was very very good against spin. He has usually played with a very good side around him too. Did he get out lots early on or late in his career?

2015-08-10T07:57:45+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


Yeah, you could always go and read an English article. About the English victory. On an English website. And let us enjoy reminiscing about our retiring captain ahead of his last ever Test.

2015-08-10T07:56:11+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


On a side note, I can think of a bowler who was carrying on, clapping in the batsman's face and sledging him to hell and everything, and yet the whole world seem to agree this was nothing more or less than absolutely fantastic, spirited, passionate cricket. Out of interest, why is it great when Wahab Riaz sledges but ugly when an Aussie does?

2015-08-10T07:50:43+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


Disagree - having an all-rounder would have been very handy. If we'd had a proper bowling attack, we'd have at least had a good chance of containing England to a lower score, giving ourselves less to chase down in the second innings. We may have at least avoided an innings defeat, and who knows? We may have even got a bit of a lead, and then you never know what might happen. I know it's all optimistic 'if's and 'may have's, but to be honest, once Starc had sprayed them, Hazlewood had sprayed them, Johnson had failed to make any impact, and Lyon was doing about as well as you can expect a spinner to do on a green-top, I'd have been pretty damn happy to have Watto to throw the ball to. They wouldn't have spent the whole day scoring at 4.5 runs an over, at the very least.

2015-08-10T07:40:33+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


So Swanny pissed off home mid-series, as soon as he decided the team no longer required his services, and that's more gracious? Contrast Swann's actions to those of Haddin and Watson. They only played one Test before being dropped, and have stayed for the rest of the series to give every support they can to their team-mates and their replacements in the XI.

2015-08-10T07:35:33+00:00

chivasdude

Guest


bigmick1, I am afraid your comment says more about you than it does of Clarke. Churlish and unnecessary.

2015-08-10T07:34:23+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


I think Clarke's timing was excellent, intentional or not. Yes, everyone's talking about him, and yes, he probably knew that would happen - and the thing is, now all of the headlines are about Clarke's retirement and not about our pathetic performance, and the team has got a chance to recover while the media lays off them and attacks or praises Clarke instead, depending on their opinions. It takes the heat off them. Similarly, it gives us grieving fans something to distract us from the tale of woe that was our Ashes tour - the ones that like Clarke go and re-watch the highlights of his triple hundred and reminisce about all the good times, the ones that don't hit the internet forums to complain about how divisive, narcissistic or average they reckon he was. But either way we get a break from the haunting reality that we just lost the Ashes. Announcing that the Oval will be his last Test also gives the team something extra to play for - they'll be doubly as determined to win this last one and give their captain a high note to go out on - and something for us to cheer for as well. So come on, Aussies! Win it for Clarkie!

2015-08-10T07:32:19+00:00

Andy

Guest


You'd be the perfect person to ask... Is it Hingerland or Ingarlarnd? Is it Saffica or Siffrica? Fffank you.

2015-08-10T07:22:01+00:00

Zim Zam

Roar Rookie


It'll be very, very sad if Clarke is only ever remembered as a Captain for the controversies and the less successful period he presided over. Clarke had a difficult era of Aussie cricket to lead in - right as all the legends retired, and we had to rebuild. He was carrying the team half the time, and had to deal with a lot of crap, all the Mickey Arthur drama, the thrashing in India, losing in England ... Through all of that he was able to keep the team more or less together, especially once Darren Lehman came in. We were losing in England last time as well, and yet we were improving across the series and it was much closer than ... well, than this last one. Then he was at the head of one of the most remarkable turnarounds in history. I'm just so glad he got that 5-0 Ashes series, he bloody well deserved it. His captaincy that series was just terrific. That'll be my enduring memory of Clarkie, anyway.

2015-08-10T05:51:15+00:00

Another Pom in Oz

Guest


I thought he retired ages ago. Certainly played like it...

2015-08-10T05:31:43+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Has England won another series? When was that? Oh...on the weekend. We already knew that. Did you know Clarkey is retiring?

2015-08-10T05:30:12+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Probably the people like you and me who bother to post about it.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar