The notion of ‘Side by Side’ lost on some Magpies supporters

By Jamie Radford / Roar Pro

Following an interview with Melbourne radio station 3AW after last weekend’s embarrassing capitulation to the Tigers, Collingwood captain Scott Pendlebury was subjected to some venomous and vitriolic attacks on social media.

This tasteless vitriol was also repeated ad nauseam in the comments sections of various media websites who published either match reports or articles on the fallout of the interview itself.

Although one expects this kind of inane commentary from supporters of other clubs, amazingly (or perhaps not) the majority came from people who supposedly support the Magpies.

Calls were made for Pendlebury to be sacked, not just as captain, but from the side altogether. Others questioned his commitment, and some quite special individuals questioned his ability to even play the game.

Of course many of these requests and statements of never a truer fact, were filled with all manner of descriptive language unfit for general publication, emphasising the importance of the writer’s message.

So what did the Collingwood skipper do to deserve such a reaction?

He admitted to a radio station that he had never played in a game before with such little meaning, as the Magpies were no longer any chance of making finals.

What? How dare he! Collingwood had just been smashed by the Tigers, of all teams. As captain, Pendlebury needs to be setting the right example. Why, he should be so upset by such a loss he should be punching holes through dressing room walls while weeping uncontrollably.

I mean who does he think he is? Just because he is a five-time All Australian who happens to have won three club best and fairest awards, three runners up and a third, as well as being a Norm Smith Medallist in a premiership year and having played over 200 games. That does not give him the right to be truthful.

Yes, that’s it, sack him, or if not then at least strip him of the captaincy. I would suggest whoever the new coach is going to be – because Nathan Buckley certainly won’t be there next year – can select a new skipper.

Yes, that’s right folks, Bucks is gonskies. At least according to those in the know. Bloke can’t coach, and will never be involved in a premiership. Fact is, these intellectual giants state, is that Nathan Buckley has pretty much single-handedly decimated the Collingwood Football Club.

All those premiership stars gone, and look what Collingwood have got to show for it. Taylor Adams, Jack Crisp, Brodie Grundy, Tom Langdon and Marley Williams. What a bunch of no hopers.

Makes no difference they were all selected in the 2015 AFL Players Association’s 22under22 squad, or that the Magpies have the second most representatives in the side behind Greater Western Sydney. They’re still hopeless.

That also goes for Alex Fasolo, Jarryd Blair, Jamie Elliott and a host of others.

Although luckily for the four top 10 draft picks selected over the last two years in Darcy Moore, Jordan De Goey, Matt Scharenberg and Nathan Freeman, they haven’t played enough senior games yet to gauge whether they should be sacked or not. Although there have been quiet rumblings about one or two of them.

It goes on and on, and does so every time the Magpies have a big loss, or heaven forbid a few honourable ones or a form slump. It’s no wonder Collingwood supporters are so reviled by those of other clubs. Fact is we deserve it.

Yes, that is correct. I am one myself, I’m sometimes sorry to say, and have been for a very long time. Not sorry that I support the Magpies, but sorry that such a vocal and ignorant minority tarnish the rest of us with their tainted brush.

Sorry that I have to cringe looking at my ‘fellow supporters’ almost falling over the fence from the weight of the froth flying out of their toothless mouths while they wildly gesticulate and excessively abuse any Tigers player within ranting range.

Sorry that Dustin Martin has to pay a $2000 fine, when instead he and his teammates should be commended for showing such restraint. Sorry that when someone asks me who I support I feel a caveat of, ‘but don’t hold that against me’, is in order.

Sorry that our coach and our captain have to put up with this sort of rubbish from our own so called supporters – and particularly sorry that I even feel the need to write this article.

I realise that there are supporters like these at all clubs, however it seems that Collingwood has quite a few more than any other.

Even James Hird, who was coach of a club involved in one of the biggest controversies in living memory, seemingly had more support from Bomber fans than Nathan Buckley has had from sections of the Magpie Army. And I dare say, Collingwood are in a far healthier position than that of the Bombers.

I do not expect every Magpie supporter to agree with every decision or move the club makes. I also have no problem with it being questioned on social media or through other channels. Nor do I think they should not be able to boo opposition players – as long as it is done with even a minimum of decorum.

Collingwood’s motto is ‘Side by Side’. However it is unfortunate that the notion appears to have been lost on many of their supporters.

But given the lack of rational thought that went into some comments on social media over the weekend it is hardly surprising that the concept goes over these people’s heads.

The Crowd Says:

2015-08-28T05:47:03+00:00

Pauly

Guest


Didn't win though. The following year we were exposed as anything in a more forgettable GF.

2015-08-28T05:46:10+00:00

Pauly

Guest


To all the people calling for the sacking of Bucks, can I ask you, who will take his place? If you hadn't noticed, the coaching ranks of the AFL are pretty thin at the moment and I can't think of anyone who would do a better job that isn't already employed by another club and likely to remain so. Give Bucks some time.

2015-08-28T04:09:05+00:00

Rich_daddy

Roar Guru


"subjected to some venomous and vitriolic attacks" From Collingwood supporters? Who would have thought? :)

2015-08-28T02:52:07+00:00

Tricky

Guest


Incorrect Plainsman, in 99 we were bottom then in 02 we were in the GF.

2015-08-28T01:32:51+00:00

bart

Guest


I read the other day that perhaps there should be another decent trophy during the AFL season, if you look at some other sports they have multiple trophys on offer, the only focus is on winning the AFl premiership and you have a one in 18 chance of winning it, in a 12 team comp you have a better chance of winning it. Look at soccer, they have the Asian cup, the FFA cup and a league, perhaps the AFL need to look at .....and wait for it ..... a 10 a side knockout mid week cup across all AF clubs in the land, easy to play, easy to organise, easy to travel, easier to televise etc, of course the cream would rise to the top and all the AFL clubs would end up making their way through, but perhpas winning that may make up for a bad AFL season. A left field idea perhaps, but i think we should increase the amount of silverware on offer, more for fans to keep an eye on.

2015-08-28T01:25:47+00:00

Plainsman

Guest


I agree with the article. As a Pies supporter of many years I have seen them lose umpteen grand finals and seen them carry the wooden spoon but I have rejoiced in the 1990 and 2010 flags. Supporters might recall the slump we were in when Tony Shaw was the coach. IMHO the issue is not so much the sentiment but the fact that people now have an array of platforms to express what ever thought bubble is in their heads. IN days of yore you might very well be angry but you had to express this through letter writing or emailing. This actually takes time and thought so cooler heads would prevail and a more moderate view would be expressed. (I am generalizing but you get the point). Perhaps if we just ignore the twitterati and do some more moderate analysis then we might get a better picture. sacking Buckley - I don't think so - it took Mick Malthouse several years to get the Pies up to scratch.

2015-08-28T01:23:02+00:00

footyfact

Guest


While some of what is written here is true, the same can be said of every other club. I remember tigers supporters throwing memberships and even spitting on Danny Frawley a few years ago. The general population has a small percentage of imbeciles, and that will be reflected in club supporters. By logic, the clubs with the biggest following, will have the most imbeciles. They'll probably have the most brain surgeons too, but these people don't feel the need to vent there frustration in public or on (un) social media.

2015-08-27T23:01:41+00:00

WhereIsGene

Guest


Membership numbers suggest Collingwood fans are really falling off the bandwagon. Hard to blame them with the way Buckley has taken the team backwards since Mick's departure.

Read more at The Roar