SPIRO: Where is the ARU plan to win Sevens Olympic gold in Rio?

By Spiro Zavos / Expert

There was a time when the Australian Sevens team was routinely booed, because with players like David Campese, Mark Ella and all the other Ellas, Australian sides were just too good for their opposition in most of the tournaments.

Call it the Richie McCaw factor. Booing was a compliment to that line of Australian Sevens sides that played so splendidly, so often, at Hong Kong.

» Olympic rugby sevens – men’s schedule
» Olympic rugby sevens – women’s schedule

But now, several decades after those great days, there is no booing for the Australians, only a sort of boredom at their general hard-working standard of play

We are going into a year where Sevens Rugby offers an Olympic gold medal for the national side, but there is no indication that the ARU board and chief executive have any plan to achieve this result.

There was a time, but not now unfortunately, when the Sevens squads – even after the era of the Ellas and Campo – turned up wonderfully gifted youngsters destined to have great careers later on as Wallabies.

I remember predicting that an unknown halfback from Canberra who astonished us all at a Hong Kong Sevens tournament would go on to have a terrific career for the Wallabies.

That halfback was George Gregan.

Some years later, another youngster played with such freakish brilliance at another Hong Kong Sevens tournament that the predictions of a fabulous Wallaby career were obvious and inevitable.

That player was James O’Connor.

Since then about the only outstanding Wallaby who has come through the Sevens ranks, essentially, has been Bernard Foley.

Why isn’t Australian rugby producing the young players who start off making their name as Sevens players and then translate the experiences and lessons, learnt on and off the field, in the shorter form of the game to the 15-man game?

On Friday, the ARU named the national Sevens side to play the opening round of the 2015-16 World Rugby Sevens Series this weekend at Dubai.

The three new players in the squad are Wallaby winger Henry Speight, Sydney flier Tom Kingston, and the ‘rugged’ South African Stephan van der Walt (you only need Australian citizenship to be eligible for Olympic selection).

Most rugby followers are familiar with Speight and Kingston. Both are wingers and occasional centres who are quick and, especially in the case of Speight, tough enough to play as a forward in the Sevens game.

Scott Bowen, the Australian men’s Sevens interim (!) coach, told The Australian that Speight might be moved into the forwards later on, saying, “He’ll play some time on the wing, but I would imagine he would also spend some time at centre, looking forward to Rio, it’s probably not out of the question that he could end up playing that hybrid forward role, a quicker back who packs down as a prop.”

The problem here is that Speight is only going to play four of the 10 world series tournaments before Rio. The majority of his playing time will be for the Brumbies.

This suggests that Bowen should throw Speight into the forwards at Dubai and continue with this experiment at the other three world series tournaments so that at Rio the winger/prop will have had some extended game time in his new Sevens position.

There is also an element of a bet each way with the Speight deal. He really should be playing at least seven world series tournaments before Rio, as the All Blacks coming across – Sonny Bill Williams, Liam Messam and Augustine Palu – are going to do.

Van der Walt seems to be a similar case to Speight. He joined the Brumbies as a biggish winger (192 centimetres, 98kilograms) for the 2013 season. His impact there has been minimal. Now he has a chance to establish his Sevens credentials.

The rest of the squad for the Dubai tournament are experienced players, with the captain Ed Jenkins and star centre Cameron Clark (the son of Greg Clark, the excellent rugby caller) as the outstanding performers in the side.

Cameron Clark, with his ever-smiling face, speed and athleticism, reminds me of an Australian Bobby Skinstad, a throwback to the days when players had fun on a rugby field and transmitted that fun to the spectators with their spectacular play.

The Australian squad goes to Dubai having won the Oceania Regional Olympic Qualifier in Auckland two weeks ago without conceding a try in any of their wins.

Last year the Australians were the Dubai tournament runners-up to a rampant South African side. They subsequently finished fifth in the world series, 14 points behind England, and had to qualify for the Rio Olympics.

On the face of it, the squad that had a lacklustre season in 2014 is not strengthened significantly for this Olympic year.

This raises the issue of Quade Cooper, alas.

Cooper’s French club has agreed, following some pressure from the player and the ARU, to release him to play for Australia at Rio.

The previous interim coach to Bowen, Tim Walsh, told The Australian at the time of the Toulon concession that Cooper should not be an automatic selection for Rio, saying, “You can’t just be a good kicker or passer. You have to be able to tackle, to ruck, to counter-ruck, make good decisions, pass at pace left and right.

“Everyone has to be able to do it. Quade no doubt can do all that. It’s just can he prove he can do it in that amount of time, and can whoever the coach is give him the confidence he is the man for the job?”

The tone of the comments suggest that Walsh is not at all confident that Cooper is the answer to the Australian problem of lacking a gifted playmaker.

At the time of these comments, too, the thought was that Toulon would be reluctant to allow their star recruit too much time away. But the disastrous (for Cooper and Toulon) match against Wasps, where Cooper missed numerous tackles, made no breaks and missed passes like a talentless novice, could encourage Toulon to get him off their books and into the Australian Sevens side as soon as possible.

There was a time when Cooper could have been a Sevens player at the same level as Mark Ella. That time is well gone. His tackling has become deplorable, he has lost his speed, and now his passing game seems to be breaking down.

The ARU should make it public that even though Cooper might want to play for the Sevens side at Rio, he is not wanted.

Eric Rush, arguably one of the greats of Sevens Rugby, told me once that Sevens is essentially a tackling game. Cooper’s tackling, even at its least worst, has never been a strong suit in his game.

The ARU should forget about Cooper; if they are successful in snaring him for Rio, the Quade Project will end in tears.

Instead, the ARU need to get a full-time, long-term coach. They can’t hope to go to Rio with a series of interim coaches. If Bowen is deemed to be the man and he wants the job, then give it to him. Or else come to a quick decision about who should be the full-time coach.

And I would offer an lucrative short-term contract up to Rio for someone like Mark Ella or David Campese, both gurus in Sevens Rugby, to be the strategic brain and selector for the Australian side going into the Olympic tournament.

Once again, the lack of gumption by the ARU in appointing a full-time coach points to a fatal lack of real rugby nous with its CEO, Bill Pulver.

Sevens Rugby is not as chopped down version of the 15-man game. It is a specific sport in its own right, within the rugby genre. The Australian Sevens side needs a full-time, permanent (at least until Rio) coach right now.

One of the truths of Sevens rugby is that it is much easier for good players to switch successfully to the 15-man game than from the 15-man game.

Of the 620 player in the initial squads for the 2015 Rugby World Cup, 135 had a Sevens background. Interestingly, this number is down from the 160 former Sevens players at the 2011 tournament.

The greatest of all the Sevens coaches, Sir Gordon Tietjens, has insisted that any of the 15-a-side players have to play, as a minimum, four tournaments. Messam and SBW are going to be full-time Sevens players this year.

DJ Forbes, the long-time New Zealand Sevens captain, has stood down from the captaincy to concentrate on actually making the side for Rio. Scott Curry, a faster version of Ed Jenkins, will captain the New Zealand side in the prop/winger position.

Typically, too, Tietjens is stealing a march on other teams by taking a 14-man squad to Dubai, rather than the 12-man squad that Australia is taking. Tietjens wants to have the maximum amount of time with players who could make the Rio squad. They will be exposed to his relentless, demanding fitness regimes.

The 14 players, too, will enable him to play to train with two complete Sevens team which will create, he insists, “more competition” within the squad.

About Pulu, a newcomer to Sevens Rugby but an All Black last year, Tietjens says, “He’s come on in leaps and bounds in the time he has been with us… He’s got very good vision. He’s quick off the mark… He’s going to keep teams honest and he’s very strong and physical.”

Notice the difference between this sort of specific assessment and the lack of a similar sort of assessment about Henry Speight in the ARU’s media release about its team at Dubai: “The team is looking sharp and the players are fit and raring to go…. We have three debutants keen to make their mark…”

Two other Tietjens initiatives are in play at Dubai as well. Sonny Bill Williams will be with the team “as a learning experience”.

And last Wednesday in a media release the New Zealand Rugby Union stated, “Sevens maestro Tomasi Cama takes on a pivotal new off-field role… The star playmaker will deliver performance analysis services to the All Blacks Sevens and New Zealand Women’s seven coaches and players.”

Cama will also be part of the New Zealand coaching contingent for the women’s and men’s squads at Dubai.

Bill Pulver should be ashamed of his lack of support for the Australian sevens squads, women and men.

As the legendary Chinese warrior Sun Tzu is supposed to have said, “The battle is won before it is fought.”

Battles are won as much by the planning that goes in before as on the actual field of conflict.

We are seeing the sort of planning from the NZRU that helped win back-to-back Rugby World Cup tournaments being invested in the chase for Rio gold.

But where is the planning for Rio gold from the ARU?

The Crowd Says:

2015-12-04T18:35:47+00:00

Redsback

Guest


Massive delay in responding, because I didn't think anyone would read down this far. 1. I assume that the ARU would have looked into this, so there must be a way to make it happen. 2. There are special provisions which allow potential Olympians or Pakistani cricketers to become citizens on a fast-tracked basis. That said, surely if Quade could have become a citizen beforehand, he would have done it (assuming that my understanding is correct that he hasn't)

2015-12-03T01:27:29+00:00

Warwick Todd

Guest


Ella was not exactly Trevor Gilmister either. There is more romance surrounding Ella's career than any player of any era from any country. He cut through defences in the days when rugby was more touch than tackle, retired after only 25 tests and has criticised the way the wallabies play since.

2015-12-02T23:23:02+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Ok Michael. Even though the government published website makes no mention of it, I'll take your word on this immigration matter. You've seemed across it so far...

2015-12-02T22:29:02+00:00

Michael

Guest


That's where you are incorrect. Kiwis can apply for residency when they relocate to Aus but it is only granted in a very limited number of cases so almost all enter Aus on SPVs and are ineligible to apply for residency or citizenship while in the country. It's an interesting anomaly.

2015-12-02T22:28:00+00:00

Michael

Guest


That's where you are incorrect. Kiwis can apply for residency when they relocate to Aus but it is only granted in a very limited number of cases so almost all enter Aus on SPVs and are ineligible to apply for residency or citizenship while in the country.

2015-12-02T22:18:41+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


How so. I said exactly what the requirement was. Because no people bother to do it, doesn't mean it's not possible. Your post is misleading, because you state they cannot get citizenship, they can. Just not automatically.

2015-12-02T22:14:48+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Now thats jibba jabba if I ever saw it... :-)

2015-12-02T21:49:23+00:00

Michael

Guest


Your post is factually accurate but misleading. In practice virtually no post Feb 2001 NZers moving to Oz are granted residency (there are very tight requirements around age, qualification, health, occupation etc) and almost all enter Oz on an SPV which allows them to live and work here indefinitely (provided they remain of 'good character'). However SPV holders are not eligible for social security or other Commonwealth social assistance apart from health and do not qualify for citizenship on the basis of residency. Moreover they cannot apply for residency while in Oz on an SPV but must return to NZ and initiate the process. This also applies to Kiwis who were brought to Aus as children. Thus the status of NZers is different to other migrants in that they have virtually unfettered ('scuse the pun) entry to Aus but are constrained (as guest workers) in their ability to become permanent residents or citizens. You may debate the desire ability of this but the point of the discussion is Quade Cooper's eligibility to represent Australia at the Olympics, as that would require him to be an Australian citizen. Maybe he arrived before the 2/2001 deadline? I don't know but it is more complicated than most people realise.

2015-12-02T21:41:34+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Cooper is a much more accurate passer than NMS or Nonu, don't be silly.

2015-12-02T20:54:01+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


It's amazing what you can find out when you look for it... https://www.border.gov.au/Trav/Citi/Appl/New-Zealand-citizens-living-in-Australia "On 26 February 2001, the Australian Government announced that New Zealand citizens arriving after 26 February 2001 are required to apply for and be granted a permanent visa if they wish to access certain social security payments, obtain Australian citizenship or sponsor their family members for permanent residence." The change meant that New Zealanders in order to become citizens had to go through a process similar to what people from every other nation need to. Not removing any eligibility.

2015-12-02T20:50:45+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


You cannot, "not be eligible for citizenship" on the basis or origin, or time of arrival. The requirements may have changed, but you cannot not be eligible.

2015-12-02T08:33:48+00:00

Fount8

Guest


Maybe but Kiwis who arrived in Oz from 2001 on aren't eligible for citizenship. This is a significant issue between the two countries and might make some kind of 'special arrangement' politically awkward.

2015-12-02T00:09:28+00:00

RubberLegs

Guest


How did Spiro get onto the "From the experts " side of this page?

2015-12-01T20:55:11+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


American Dave your last line is exactly what I have disagreed with. No player "chooses" to go down this path in Australia. Player's who cannot crack a Super Rugby team do. Hence why there is so much turnover. There are no 7's specialists who could make it in 15s but choose not to. Look at the squad. Speight has Super Rugby experience of course. Ed Jenkins the captain was in the Waratahs Academy for 4 years. Does not have a single cap. Boyd Killingworth was a starter for the Rays in the NRC, but would be very little chance of a Waratahs contract, let alone game time. Tom Kingston is a good player, but in 2 years at the Rebels he got 12 caps. In 5 seasons of Super Rugby he has gained 41 caps. That's 50% of the regular season games played in that period. Pat McCutcheon has been at the Waratahs since 2010. He has also gained 35 caps in those 6 seasons. That's about 30% of games possible. I wouldn't be surprised if he's made the decision knowing he's behind Hooper, Dempsey, Dennis, Lousi, Mumm and possibly Holloway in the back row pecking order. James Stannard also has Super Rugby experience dating back to 2008, but in 5 seasons from 2008 he only managed 31 caps before making the decision to go to the Japanese Top League. Stephen Van Der Walt was a Brumbies squad member. I don't believe he was capped once. It's a path that players who don't see themselves making a career as a regular super rugby starter choose to go down. No disrespect meant by that. It's just the reality. If these players were able to make careers like experienced Wallabies have, they wouldn't be in the 7s squad based on the names that have featured there over the years.

2015-12-01T12:27:27+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Sports like Athletics, Tennis, Swimming, Football, Volleyball, Basketball, Martial Arts, Rowing, Handball.... I've no idea what this cut nonsense is about.

2015-12-01T10:36:55+00:00

Jerry

Guest


More than just the first 20 TWAS, come on.

2015-12-01T10:27:25+00:00

Phantom

Roar Rookie


I always thought it was compulsory to boo Australian teams.

2015-12-01T10:17:15+00:00

Phantom

Roar Rookie


lets see how many tickets are sold to the Olympic 7s games

2015-12-01T10:00:37+00:00

American Dave

Guest


I would hardly say the Crusaders choked in that game. They spent an entire season on the road after their homes were destroyed by a massive earthquake. Even then the Reds managed to edge them out in the final. Fine to be proud of the win, but keep it in perspective champ.

2015-12-01T09:43:46+00:00

American Dave

Guest


So much angst, but broadly I have to agree with Spiro. The ARU clearly does not have a reasonable plan to compete in the Rio Olympics. I watched the Eagles go through the motions with an interim coach and it normally never ends well. I am left feeling Australia will get knocked out early and maybe embarrassed. I might be wrong (actually I often am) but I think the ARU not paying enough respect to the only recent rugby inclusion in the largest sporting event in the World is a bit short sighted. While I am not interested in turning this into a "Cooper is great" V "Cooper is rubbish" comment (apparently a lot of people have skin in this) I think he would be a rubbish player to include in a modern 7's team. To weak in 1 on 1 tackles and simply not fast enough. I cannot see him taking down Danny Barrett, catching up to Baker or out witting Test. Not meant to be a slight on him, just clarifying that assuming he will be successful in 7's because he had a couple of good years in super Rugby does a massive dis-service to the guys who have decided to go down this path.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar