BBL week ahead: Regular programming to resume

By Brett McKay / Expert

Never mind controversial notions about playing Big Bash League games on Christmas Day in the future, there is a much bigger and much more immediate BBL issue at hand right now.

No. Game. Tonight.

I can’t understate how big a crisis this is. Have you seen the TV guide for tonight? I mean, really looked at what we’re going to watch in this sudden cricket-free vacuum? Miss Fisher, Destination Flavour Christmas, the movie Frozen for goodness’ sakes, Shrek the Halls, and bloody Mrs Doubtfire shape as your non-BBL options. The time to panic is here.

Despite this bombshell, here’s a few things to talk about over the second week of the tournament.

Twenty20 D-oesn’t R-equire S-toppages, thanks
There’s been a bit of talk in the first week of the BBL about a few dud umpiring decisions, and there’s no doubting that there has been several given out that shouldn’t have been. Have they been so bad that we need to bring DRS in, though?

Personally, I don’t think it’s a major problem. If batsmen can benefit from thick edges carrying the rope, and even the ropes being shorter than they should be, then they can probably put up with copping the odd rough LBW against them.

The whole point of Twenty20 cricket is brevity, and getting a full competitive game completed in a short timeframe. One twenty over innings is supposed to be done in 90 minutes, plus or minus, and even if only one DRS usage were permitted, it would put that timeframe in doubt. The game needs to move quickly, and if that means umpires under increased pressure are going to get the odd one wrong, so be it. Players get the odd shot or the odd delivery wrong, too, after all.

One point though, the Travis Head caught behind the other night should definitely have been sent upstairs, unless – by the letter of the BBL playing conditions – both umpires thought the ball had clearly carried.

And if that is correct, then they shouldn’t umpire again this season!

Cameron White’s cricketing crossroads
He’s the former Victorian captain who should’ve played more international cricket than he did, but who by the end of last season found himself out of the Victorian team he seemingly captained since primary school. He who became the scapegoat for the Melbourne Stars losing a fourth consecutive BBL semi-final.

Snapped up by cross-town rivals, the Melbourne Renegades, White immediately repaid the faith shown in him, knocking up 55 in their season-opening win over Brisbane last weekend. He didn’t quite get away last night against the Sydney Sixers in Melbourne, but it’s clear he’s an important piece in the Renegades’ top order puzzle.

Still only 32 and with a first class average just over 40 and a career Twenty20 strike rate around 130 runs per 100 balls faced, this season’s BBL quite possibly – surprisingly – represents White’s last chance to show he still has plenty to offer the game in Australia.

Victoria seem to have made up their mind, but a strong BBL might convince another state of White’s worth. By the same token, a strong BBL might convince White that the T20 circuit is where his future lies, where he could play for another ten years and make a fortune.

It’s a big week ahead for the Perth Scorchers

We’ll find out just how good the Scorchers are going to be in the next seven days. After showing some promise but then losing their way against Adelaide on Monday, Perth now hosts Brisbane in the Boxing Day match, and then head to Melbourne to face the Renegades next week.

They’ll have to do this without their star Test bats though, and now also without key bowler, Nathan Coulter-Nile, who is facing a lengthy spell on the sidelines after dislocating his shoulder.

The Scorchers have played in four consecutive BBL Finals, but if they were to drop these two games this week and go to 0 and 3, even just making the semis will become quite the task.

There’s some promising young kids in the west who will now get their chance in the sun (see what I’ve done there), but they can’t just gain experience, they have to fire from the outset on Saturday.

Who is this week’s premiership favourite™?
Hobart very nearly proved in their capitulation at the hands of Nathan Lyon and the Sydney Sixers last Sunday that this will indeed be the kiss of death this season, but their demolition job of Brisbane on Tuesday night confirmed that they will indeed be one of the teams to beat.

But I also mentioned the Adelaide Strikers as another genuine smokey last week, and their unbeaten start to BBL05 means they deserve elevation into this exalted WTWPF company. In beating the highly fancied, but I feel overrated Melbourne Stars, and then knocking off the Perth Scorchers in the west, the Strikers will have made people take notice.

Jason Gillespie seems to have struck a nice balance within his quality side, Brad Hodge is leading them very well, and though this might change in a fortnight, they remain unaffected by national selection. Deserving competition leaders

Tip of the week: Sydney Thunder to beat Adelaide Strikers in Sydney, Monday night.
That all said about Adelaide, the Thunder are the only other unbeaten side after the opening week, and their cellar-to-penthouse turnaround is fast becoming the story of BBL05.

And I reckon they can continue their run, too, and bring the Strikers’ run to an end. Even though they’ll likely be without Usman Khawaja, having Mike Hussey at 5, Andre Russell at 6, and Ben Rohrer – who is not my stunt double, thank you, Ryan O’Connell – at 7 last week against the Stars on Sunday night was a bit of a luxury. Even if they all slide up one spot, the Thunder will still have a strong line-up. They’re beginning to turn Spotless Stadium into a bit of a fortress, too.

The Crowd Says:

2015-12-25T11:38:52+00:00

ak

Roar Guru


Tomorrow is Rohan Kanhai's 80th birthday. Expecting an article on the great West Indian.

2015-12-24T10:41:04+00:00

Burgs

Guest


I'd be happy to do away with DRS completely; I enjoyed that aspect of the India series, when the umpire rose his finger it was out, makes it more exciting. Umpires are generally very good, and we get bad calls with the DRS anyway.

2015-12-24T05:02:14+00:00

Atawhai Drive

Roar Guru


Cheers, Brett, have a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.

2015-12-24T05:01:29+00:00

AlanKC

Guest


Keep DRS out of T20 for mine, as you point out Brett, part of the attraction is the pace of the game. Who wants to see the game held up for up for minutes with no guarantee of getting the right outcome anyway?

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T04:44:06+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


And what's our thoughts on Cameron White? Does he have a future in Australia beyond the BBL? Is 32 too young to join the international franchise circus? I'll leave that one with you all - have a great Christmas everyone, enjoy your time off, and please stay safe if you're travelling anywhere around..

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T04:42:24+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Certainly agree with this, AD, I've quite enjoyed the umpires have to back their judgement..

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T04:41:44+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Bill, I've long been saying it should be taken out of the players hands, so I certainly agree with this point. However, if not for LBW, then what's the point really?

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T04:40:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Cheers Onside, all the best for you and yours, too...

2015-12-24T04:06:44+00:00

Spruiker

Guest


Merry xmas and happy new year to all roarers

2015-12-24T03:54:20+00:00

Atawhai Drive

Roar Guru


I haven't missed DRS at all in the BBL matches I've watched this season (all except the one last night _ only caught the end of that). This type of cricket really needs to be kept moving, and not having endless DRS replays certainly helps to keep things ticking over. I'm not sure that human error adds to T20's drama, but the umpiring errors so far have not been of the grotesque variety. Ball-tracking is a particularly dodgy technology in any case.

2015-12-24T03:52:03+00:00

Bill

Guest


Make it available to the umpires. Not the teams to challenge. And not for lbw either.

2015-12-24T03:48:55+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


I'm a bit torn to be honest. On one hand, wickets are super crucial to T20, so when there's a howler it feels as though it unjustly affects the game. But on the other, I completely subscribe to your argument that T20 is supposed to be the rapid fire form of the game, and it could add unnecessary delays. I reckon if it could be made much quicker, and possibly taken out of the players hands - ie there is a third umpire that reviews every "out" decision to check its veracity - then that could be an option. But then what would you do for howlers that are given not out? Its a difficult one; and quite often that means status quo wins out.

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T03:43:27+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


What's everyone's general thoughts on DRS in T20? Would you rather the opportunity to correct the odd howler, or like me, do you think human error adds to the drama of the short form of the game?

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T03:42:17+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


God, I hope not....

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T03:41:43+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Our minds are literally ahead of their time..

2015-12-24T03:21:29+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


You could say you need to watch Carols by Candlelight.

2015-12-24T03:20:23+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Is it the Karaoke version?

AUTHOR

2015-12-24T03:10:15+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Well, as if the prospect of Frozen the movie tonight wasn't enough, the first of the Frozen Christmas gifts has just been unwrapped in the McSport house. :shock: Look what you've reduced me to, BBL!!

2015-12-24T02:54:03+00:00

onside

Guest


I will start to watch Big Bash when the finals start. The knockout stages add focus. Win = continue. Lose = out. I had an enlightening experience through the week at a dinner party attended by a variety of young blokes (our sons). There were six of them , all aged about 23, all recently graduated including medicine and architecture.They absolutely loved the Big Bash, knew all the teams and the players.Right across it. Dissapointed at Brisbane's efforts, ( but we do live on the Sunshine Coast ). During dinner one of them had his I phone strategically positioned behind a serviette and kept every -body at the table up to speed on the encounter. The point is: it was the first time I had ever been in a group of people that loved BBL My age group (old farts inc) go out less, and gravitate towards more established sports. For the first time, (away from the manic TV promotion), the penny dropped, and I understood and shared the groundswell of support. Fantastic. Am I a fan, well not until the finals , but I am happy for those that are and understand the games magnetism. In closing Brett, I hope you enjoy Christmas with family and friends, and 2016 brings excellent health, lots of laughter and a little prosperity.

2015-12-24T02:40:44+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


And a quick Wikipedia check confirms that there wasn't one in the pre franchise days, either. It says something when we think there was one and there wasn't; our minds creating memories because it just makes logical sense! A Christmas Eve-Christmas Day addition to the fixture, and a slightly earlier start/later finish to the regular season would mean the League could be extended by one round with minimal fuss. Who doesn't do that? I'm sure the broadcaster would be stoked to have another four nights of 1,000,000+ eyeballs to sell.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar