Six talking points from Super League Round 1

By Andy Sharpe / Roar Guru

Super League is back, having kicked off over the weekend. So what were the talking points out of the first week back?

1. Warrington Wolves could challenge for honours again in 2016
After a lacklustre 2015, a superb performance to win 12-6 over Leeds Rhinos bodes well.

I always thought Chris Sandow would have a big impact on Super League, and although he struggled at the end of last season after his early move from Parramatta, he looked in top form against the Rhinos, with a superb solo try to open the scoring.

Ben Currie was also outstanding for the Wolves, while prop Jordan Cox showed why Hull KR should not have released him, with an outstanding debut from the bench.

2. Are Leeds spent?
Meanwhile, the Wolves’ opponents, Leeds, are fielding predictable calls that they won’t be the force that they were last season, when they took out the Challenge Cup, League Leaders Shield and grand final.

It would have been a struggle to be that same force without losing the quality and experience of the players that they have.

I have said before that the replacement players they have brought in are anywhere near the standard needed to fill the huge holes left, and on Thursday night they looked slow and unimaginative. They weren’t helped by losing new captain Danny Maguire to injury in the first half – he will be out for around eight weeks – and his halfback partner Liam Sutcliffe was struggling as well.

Jordan Lilley, who played as back-up hooker to Rob Burrow, was outstanding.

3. Hull FC reignite hope (again)
Hull FC started the season as expected, easily defeating Salford Red Devils 42-20 in an attacking display that has all my Hull FC friends expecting the Super League trophy to be handed over to take up residence at the KC Stadium.

It would be fantastic for the sport if a new team away from the only four clubs that have won it since 1998 – Wigan, Bradford, St Helens and Leeds – could win the grand final. While I expect Hull FC to have a much improved season (he says through gritted teeth) I’m not sure they will be good enough to take out the grand final.

Their squad is strong, and if they fail to make the top six they need to look at their coaching set up.

This week’s game, away at Catalans Dragons, will be a good marker for their season to come.

4. Dave Taylor looks good
Talking of the Dragons, I was really impressed with Dave Taylor on debut against the Warriors on Friday night. He is a huge man with a big reputation who never really fulfilled his potential in the NRL, despite playing eight games for Queensland in State of Origin and a solitary Test for Australia in 2012.

He lost his way a little bit over the last couple of years, and there was even talk of him heading to Japanese rugby union before the Dragons offered him a lifeline. The ‘Coal Train’ is only 27, and may have the best years of his career ahead of him if he can keep away from the fine cuisine in the South of France.

I was also impressed that the Dragons stuck to their task against the Warriors. In previous years, they would have fallen away and conceded a hatful of points. The Dragons could end up in the top six this year if they can get three or four wins away from home, but the loss of hooker Paul Aiton for the next few weeks with a pectoral injury will be a blow.

5. Castleford already in trouble
It is never good news when a player is ruled out for possibly the entire season so early in the year, so it’s sad that Castleford captain Michael Shenton may miss the rest of the year after suffering an ACL injury in the 16-16 draw at Hull KR on Sunday.

Call me a biased Hull KR fan, but there is a bit of a witch hunt going on from Castleford towards French hooker John Boudebza, who was involved in the tackle that Shenton was injured in. The comments emanating from Castleford coach Daryl Powell and Shenton himself are totally out of order.

I was at the match on Sunday, and saw nothing wrong in Boudebza’s tackle – and I have watched it back since. Boudebza did not throw himself at the back of Shenton’s knee’s at all, and there was no malicious intent. Nor has there been any comment made about a more dangerous cannonball tackle carried out by Tigers forward Lee Jewitt in the first half.

Rugby league is a tough sport and injuries happen – sometimes players need to be cited and banned for the challenges they make, this isn’t one of them. I will be desperately disappointed if Boudebza receives a ban.

The match itself was played in poor conditions and was a tough outing. Italy international Josh Mantellato was the hero for Rovers, scoring two acrobatic tries and kicking a last-second conversion to level the scores. Former Hull KR star Jake Webster replaced Shenton and was outstanding, scoring two tries.

6. Where are the Giants’ replacements?
Both Danny Brough and Eorl Crabtree said the Giants needed to bring new players in, especially in the wake of the unexpected loss of Brett Ferres to Leeds Rhinos.

The Giants suffered more blows to their squad on Friday night at St Helens, with first-choice fullback Scott Grix dislocating his shoulder, which will give him a lengthy spell on the sidelines, while captain Brough suffered a dead leg and is unlikely to be fit for Round 2, and Joe Wardle is out for a month after damaging a quad muscle.

Add injuries to Craig Huby and Kyle Wood in pre-season and the last thing they needed was one of their most experienced players, Luke Robinson, to announce his enforced and immediate retirement from the game.

Robinson has a hip injury and has been told that his continuation in the sport will severely handicap his future well-being. He will be a big loss to the Giants, but it is only right that he is thinking of his future away from rugby league and ensuring that he can be the husband and father he wants to be for many years to come.

The Giants are giving a trial to former St Helens, Hull FC and Bradford Bulls winger Jamie Foster, and are close to signing Hull FC utility back Curtis Naughton on loan for two months as cover for Grix.

They need to strengthen much more if they are to challenge for top four again this year.

The Crowd Says:

2016-02-11T22:28:14+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


Sorry, I didn't mean the dragon itself, but rather the chop-suey font used.

AUTHOR

2016-02-11T08:39:56+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


This site is so educational!!!! :)

AUTHOR

2016-02-11T08:39:21+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


Thanks Russ - the club went to the RFL to appeal the decision on Wednesday night and the original verdict was upheld - absolutely farcical - I really do believe that the comments from Daryl Powell have had a major impact on this decision and Powell should be warned about his future conduct in situations like this - fat chance of that happening though.

2016-02-11T06:39:01+00:00

Russ

Guest


Or you could have said because they felt like having a dragon - Cathar! ;-)

2016-02-11T01:40:18+00:00

Cathar Treize

Roar Guru


Sleiman, Dragons have a long history in European mythology. Here is a quote regarding the Catalan & Dragon mythology (not to mention St George & the dragon slaying, Welsh symbol & dragons) etc: "Dragons are well known in Catalan myths and legends, in no small part because St. George (Catalan Sant Jordi) is the patron saint of Catalonia. Like most dragons, the Catalan dragon (Catalan drac) is an enormous serpent with two or, rarely, four legs and sometimes a pair of wings. As in many other parts of the world, the dragon's face may be like that of some other animal, such as a lion or bull. As is common elsewhere, Catalan dragons are fire-breathers, and the dragon-fire is all-consuming. Catalan dragons also can emit a fetid odor, which can rot away anything it touches. The Catalans also distinguish a víbria or vibra (cognate with English viper and wyvern), a female dragon with two prominent breasts, two claws and an eagle's beak. Dracs, Víbries and other mythological figures used to participate in correfocs during popular celebrations." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_dragon

2016-02-10T20:16:40+00:00

Russ

Guest


I agree with you here Andy I looked at the video about 15 times and even asked for clarification because I thought I must be missing something. Then again this wouldn't be the first time a club and the injury have swayed a verdict in SL!

2016-02-10T12:04:56+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


Catalan are my number two Super League team. Though I don't really understand why the club went with a Chinese themed logo to represent rugby league in France...

AUTHOR

2016-02-10T11:17:02+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


TH, I completely agree with you - it is an absolute joke. The club are appealing the decision and hopefully they will get a result, although I don't see them wiping the ban out completely - it will just make the RFL look bigger idiots than they do already. Also agree about the Dragons. They would have fallen away badly in previous years at Wigan and the FC game on Saturday is already a big one even though it's only round 2 - the Dragons expect to win at home so it will be a real test for FC and will go some way towards telling us if we should believe the hype for once.

2016-02-10T10:28:46+00:00

Tripehound

Guest


Andy, having watched the Shenton/Boudebza incident several times I'm at a complete loss as to how the judiciary have come to the conclusion that any foul play was involved and especially that they have used their 'discretion' to increase the length of the ban. Some of their previous decisions have, in my opinion, been totally arbitrary and without any consistency and for me the judiciary panel isn't fit for purpose. Catalans can take real heart from the Wigan match, I think Saturdays game against the Airlie Birds could be a season defining fixture for both sides.

AUTHOR

2016-02-10T09:32:06+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


Hi Riley, I think the Giants are going to struggle to make the top 4 this year - Ferres is a huge loss, Robinson likewise, Wardle is out for at least 4 weeks, Grix even longer and they have a skinny squad anyway. I think Wigan for the title this year but I would love to see a new team win it - 4 champions in 18 years is ridiculous - it would do wonders for the game in France if the Dragons could do it but there away form is key - I think the Wolves look most likely again to break into the club. Leeds will struggle against the Cowboys (I'm going to that match) - losing so many quality players is not easy and I don't think they've recruited particularly well (Gallaway, Mullalley, Falloon), apart from Ferres. I can see the Cowboys taking the WCC home.

AUTHOR

2016-02-10T09:26:55+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


Alex, I agree. I've been struggling to understand why so many pundits cannot see the Dragons improving this year with the acquisitions they have made. They are always strong at home and they must improve their away form if they are to move up the table - but with the squad they have I would expect them to sit inside the top 6 comfortably.

AUTHOR

2016-02-10T09:24:44+00:00

Andy Sharpe

Roar Guru


Edward, it's a disgraceful and outrageous decision. The normal length of the ban for Grade B charge is 1-2 matches and they have extended that to 4 because of the seriousness of the injury to Shenton - I don't like seeing players hurt but the fact is he did nothing wrong in the tackle. His shoulder contact is around Shenton's hip area and the problem occurs when he slides down trying to bring him to the ground - it is a rugby tackle that happens hundreds of times every weekend. I can't help but think that Shenton and his coach Daryl Powell have forced the RFL's hands because, basically, they TOLD them it was an illegal challenge and they don't want to be seen as soft. I don't know if you have seen the tackle - it's available on You Tube - but I would be interested in everyone's thoughts. Yes, I am a Hull KR fan - and it hurts even more now that we have no recognised hooker for the next 4 games (Shaun Lunt is currently injured) but I can honestly say that if Boudebza had been guilty of an illegal challenge I would have quite happily accepted the ban.

2016-02-10T06:02:28+00:00

Alex Green

Roar Guru


Thanks for the article Andy. Half of Catalans squad could still be playing in the NRL, surely they will be in with a chance this year?!

2016-02-10T04:40:13+00:00

Riley Pettigrew

Roar Guru


It's going to be a long year for my Giants. I'm hoping for a play-offs finish at best. I'm going to put an early prediction and say that St. Helens or Catalan will win in 2016. I'm worried for Leeds, fingers crossed though they win the WCC for the sake of English rugby league.

2016-02-10T02:55:04+00:00

Up the Wahs

Roar Guru


sorry andy http://www.skysports.com/rugby-league/news/12217/10161649/hull-kr-hooker-john-boubedza-banned-for-four-games

2016-02-10T02:24:16+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


My Giants are in trouble...

Read more at The Roar