NRL contenders and pretenders: Part 4

By Tom Rock / Expert

Three sleeps to go, and thank Christ. The saturating coverage of unrealistic preseason promise and unbridled optimism is making me a little nauseous. I even ran into a few Wests Tigers fans who were looking forward to the upcoming season! Utterly outrageous.

With a dearth of preseason fixtures across the weekend to over analyse, the NRL instead trotted out a parade of club captains for the 2016 season launch.

Alarmingly, league bosses have stumbled across the realisation that using the most marketable player in the game as the focus of their marketing campaign is a more sensible option than trotting out decaying US rock acts.

What’s next, reasonable ticket prices? Surely not.

NRL contenders and pretenders:
» Part 1
» Part 2
» Part 3

This is the final instalment in our four-part pre-season review series, looking at the prospects of the cream of the crop from 2015: the Melbourne Storm, Brisbane Broncos, North Queensland Cowboys and Sydney Roosters.

Starting next Monday, Taking it One Week at a Time will be publishing a weekly column. Keep an eye out for it on The Roar, or be notified of new articles by liking our Facebook page or registering your email address on the blog.

4. Melbourne Storm

It has become fashionable to write off the Storm as premiership contenders. After a decade of success, and the odd bit of cheating, the inherent tall poppy cutter within each of us relishes in predicting the demise of the Melbournians.

With Cooper Cronk, Billy Slater and Cameron Smith all on the wrong side of 30, surely the infamous Big 3 cannot deliver Melbourne another finals berth? But why not? Cameron Smith remains the best hooker in the game. Billy Slater is arguably still the top fullback. Cooper Cronk continues to fend off contenders Ben Hunt and Daly Cherry-Evans for selection as the Queensland and Australian halfback.

Toss in the odd Kiwi International, another token Queenslander or two, and a precocious youngster like Cameron Munster, and the Storm boast another strong squad in 2016.

Any coach presiding over a team which is lucky enough to contain an immortal or two can win a premiership. Michael Hagan made that abundantly clear when he ‘guided’ Newcastle to victory in the 2001 season.

It’s the way Craig Bellamy does more with less which sets him apart from the Hagans of this world. The fact that, 18 months after his retirement, people not only still remember the name Bryan Norrie, but that the man has his own Wikipedia page, is a true testament to Bellamy’s talent at turning career journeymen into quality first-graders.

This year’s list of lost souls and wayward boys includes ex-Titan’s big unit Matthew White, former Raider Mark Nicholls, and Manly misfit Cheyse Blair. The blueprint for Craig Bellamy and the Melbourne Storm never changes. Trot out the Big 3, surround them with whatever players you can afford with the remaining funds, make the finals and repeat. It is hard to imagine 2016 being any different.

Predicted finish: Third

3. North Queensland Cowboys

Johnathan Thurston and the Cowboys finally delivered a long-awaited maiden premiership to Townsville in 2015. JT cemented his place in rugby league history by producing an improbable piece of individual brilliance, snatching glory from the hands of certain defeat.

Or was that Michael Morgan? Not important.

What’s important is, where to now for the Cowboys? As the euphoria of grand final success slowly left their systems, the Cowboys embarked on a state-wide coronation tour of back slapping, hand-shaking and complimentary schooner accepting. While other teams ran up sand hills, the Cowboys were running up bar tabs. And good for them. After a long, arduous season, the boys needed to wash the dust out of the back of their throats.

So apart from plunging North Queensland into a XXXX famine, what have the Cowboys been up to this off-season? Not much really.

Glenn Hall retired, but no one seemed to notice or care. Cameron King left the club for Parramatta, but he was rubbish anyway. And Robert Lui set sail for Super League, leaving Australian women feeling a tad safer.

With little in the way of new signings to compensate for these departures, the Cowboys are essentially going for the old rinse and repeat approach. But will it be enough?

Will Thurston still have the same hunger and drive after removing the Provon and Summons sized monkey from his back? Will the Cowboys have the same luck with injury?

Can Michael Morgan and Lachlan Coote replicate their outstanding form? Paul Green must have been losing sleep over these or similar questions, deciding to knock back the Queensland Origin gig to focus on taking North Queensland back to the finals in 2016.

Based on their roster, it is difficult to imagine the Cowboys not being a major factor come September.

Predicted finish: Fourth

2. Brisbane Broncos

The return of super coach Wayne Bennett to the club he led to six premierships was always going to pay dividends for the Brisbane Broncos, but few would have predicted they would go within a Herschelle Gibbs of grand final glory in his first season back at the helm.

The impact Bennett had on his team was obvious and immediate. Adam Blair played his best football since his days under Craig Bellamy, Ben Hunt took his game to the next level, and even Darius Boyd stopped being such a petulant douchebag.

Bennett’s biggest success came in the maturation and subsequent on-field performance of Anthony Milford. Despite sporting a criminal moustache, Milford was electric in 2015, crowning his breakthrough season with a breathtaking grand final exhibition of running rugby league.

The halves partnership of Milford and Hunt will make Brisbane a finals fixture for the foreseeable future.

Outside of their poaching of centre James Roberts from the hapless Titans, the Broncos were quiet on the player market. They will instead rely on developing their own young talent and maintaining the play of their ageing veterans.

Speaking of veteran players, league fans are still waiting for Father Time to finally catch up with the ageless Corey Parker, perhaps in scenes reminiscent of the Nazi villain in Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade withering away in front of our eyes.

With the honour of club captaincy and another tilt at Queensland Origin and Telstra Premiership glory on offer in 2016, betting against another vintage season from the salt and pepper warrior would be to ‘choose poorly’.

On the flip side of the coin, fans of the iconic Jonah Lomu Rugby, arguably the greatest sports game to grace our consoles, will recognise the familiar surname of young forward Joe Ofahengaue.

Nephew of Wallaby great Willie Ofahengaue, Joe played a handful of games in 2015, and looks set for a much bigger role this season. The reality is that the Broncos are returning with almost the same side in 2016, and there is no reason to suggest they won’t enjoy the same success.

Predicted finish: Second

1 Sydney Roosters

Since the arrival of coach Trent Robinson in late 2012, the Roosters have enjoyed one of the most successful periods in club history.

Buoyed by a roster which constantly seems to defy all salary cap logic, and funded by third-party payment mastermind Nick Politis, Robinson has steered the Bondi club to three consecutive minor premierships and a premiership in his three years in charge.

During this period of sustained success, it has often been speculated how the Roosters can field a team bulging with representative superstars while teams like Canberra and Parramatta struggle to attract players with more than an under-13s best and fairest award to their name. When a salary cap official was approached at his Coogee beach-side mansion for comment, he quickly sped away in his new Audi R8.

Yet even the bottomless pockets of Politis have been unable to prevent the inevitable player drain. Footy Show regular and cashed-up bogan James Maloney moved down the coast to Cronulla, Michael Jennings was deemed surplus to requirements and signed with Parramatta, but the most shocking departure was that of Roger Tuivasa-Sheck, who sensationally snubbed the Roosters and committed his future across the ditch to the Warriors.

And just to rub their beaks in it, Roger set about having a Dally M calibre season and cemented himself as the new face of rugby league. Just when Roosters fans thought their off-season could not get any worse, Mitchell Pearce happened.

In the aftermath of the now infamous Australia Day Dog Act, Pearce fled for the forgiving shores of a Thai rehab facility, at the Roosters’ expense, leaving his club and the NRL to decide just what to do with him. Todd Carney will no doubt be looking on with keen interest.

Despite significant player departures, several painful bites from the injury bug and the clouded future of Pearce, the Roosters still maintain a talented roster. Cordner and Waerea-Hargreaves will return by mid-season, and to the horror of women and golden retrievers throughout the Eastern suburbs, Pearce will likely be back around the same time.

If Trent Robinson can steady the ship and keep them afloat until then, the Roosters look primed for another assault on the Premiership.

Predicted finish: Fifth

Keep an eye out for our weekly column throughout the 2016 NRL season on The Roar, or by liking our Facebook page or registering your email address on our blog.

The Crowd Says:

2016-02-29T20:00:32+00:00

maximillian

Guest


That's kind of my point. The NRL is 1 of the most even competitions you'll find in world sport so any preseason predictions should always be taken with a grain of salt. On this website alone you will have differing opinions from passionate fans. I actually respect guys like Walter & the author of this article for putting their reputations on the line & showing their predictions. In a difficult competition to predict they leave themselves open to massive scrutiny & potential egg on their face. For the record I actually think Souths will make the 8, but wouldn't be surprised if I was proved wrong & they finished 9-12.

2016-02-29T07:16:54+00:00

American Dave

Guest


Only three sleeps to go! After the rubbish that was dished out by the Hurricanes and US Eagles in the rugby hopefully the Cowboys can lift my spirits with a resounding win over the weekend!

AUTHOR

2016-02-29T05:17:05+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


Fair point. Happy to be proven wrong and watch DCE have an utter dog of a year. Especially during the Origin period.

2016-02-29T05:10:29+00:00

3 Hats

Guest


You actually mentioned 3 out of 7? Where did the other 4 predict Souths to finish mate?

2016-02-29T05:08:52+00:00

3 Hats

Guest


Those from nrl.com are nothing more than staff writers, Roosters and Manly fans. I have read it they base their prediction on what happened in the LAST 4 weeks of the COMP. Have a look at Big League and RLW. EXPERTS mate. And there are 10 others I have mentioned here who say Souths will make the 8 and a few who say Souths will make the TOP 4. Gerald Condon from readingtheplay.com 3rd Graeme Hughes 5th Matty Johns from Tripple M Top 4 Mathew Elliott Big League Magazine! Top 4 RWL Magazine ALL TOP 8 Martin Lenahan Editor in chief Tony Adams News Editor Steve Mascord Senior Writer Joel Gould Senior Writer Rocco Luca Editor Tom Smith Staff Writer So for every so-called expert, you can find to belittle the Rabbitohs I can find just as many who believe Souths WILL make the Semis! Including Myself

AUTHOR

2016-02-29T03:58:46+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


Exactly

2016-02-29T03:13:52+00:00

Frunze

Guest


So the Broncos "quietly" add a struggling teams best player to their already star-studded roster so we should direct all our attention on the Roosters due to who they "might" (but probably won't) sign...

2016-02-29T02:58:26+00:00

Jarrod Free

Roar Rookie


Hardly. The storm have Cronk and Smith, and in recent years have also had a very solid 5/8 such as Gareth Widdop or Blake Green. You could hardly call Cooper Cronk the sole playmaker.

AUTHOR

2016-02-29T02:56:44+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


The same could be said for the Storm, yet Cooper Cronk seems to get by just fine.

2016-02-29T02:55:29+00:00

maximillian

Guest


Theres an article similar to this on the NRL website today with 'experts' doing some predictions & 3 of the 7 experts picked the Rabbit's to finish 9th, 12th & 13th respectively. Walter isn't the only 1 that thinks the Rabbits will miss the 8.

2016-02-29T02:52:12+00:00

Jarrod Free

Roar Rookie


Very brave to say Manly will do so well with an unproven coach at the helm. I agree that DCE is a class player, but I do not think it will be enough to get them through the season without a hitch. There is also the fact that, given he will be their sole playmaker (as you say), it is certain that teams will line him up for a gluttony of punishment, running forwards at him even more than they run at Luke Brooks and Mitch Moses. There is a very significant chance that he will get injured at some point, and then it may well be curtains on Manly's 2016 season.

AUTHOR

2016-02-29T02:49:41+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


No argument here. Broncos have been doing it for years. I reckon if you tried to track down all the local endorsement deals Lockyer signed throughout his career, it would read like a credits reel of a TV show. Unlikely he could even name them all. The Roosters just seem to do it in more of a flamboyant, obvious way, almost challenging people to question them. I await the upcoming signatures of Hayne and SBW with keen interest.

2016-02-29T02:32:58+00:00

Frunze

Guest


Yeah, Roosters are rorting the salary cap, which is for sure a good guess, but Broncos aren't? Roosters NSW rep Malony, NSW and Australian rep Jennings, NZ rep RTS and the Broncos lose an aged former Origin and test player to retirement and then add the Titans best player to an already star-studded team.... Obviously the author is is trying to dazzle us with storied about the Roosters so as to hopefully keep our attention away from the Broncos.

2016-02-29T02:29:58+00:00

Brian

Guest


Lyon and Matai aren't getting any younger either. They've taken a page out of the mighty Broncos playbook and assembled a mobile pack though. I have them at five.

2016-02-29T00:26:13+00:00

Dean - Surry Hills

Guest


Well replied TIOWAAT- I had them just sneaking into the 8, but cannot see them winning more games than the Broncs, Cows, or Bunnies. Only time will tell.

AUTHOR

2016-02-28T23:52:29+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


While I understand Rugby League is a game steeped in history and tradition, I don't think Manly's recent lack of minor premierships will have any bearing on their ability to win one in 2016. The loss of Foran is huge, and Dylan Walker won't go close to filling that void. But I don't think he'll have to. DCE will take the next step with the added pressure and responsibility of being the sole play maker, and to play off my favourite all-time NRL cliche', the forwards will lay the platform. I agree the competition will be fierce this year as many sides have improved. However the veteran leadership Manly has at its disposal will be the difference between them and sides like Canberra or Parramatta.

2016-02-28T23:46:32+00:00

Dean - Surry Hills

Guest


Manly have not been minor premiers since 1997, though you have them to finish first past the post! They've lost Foran, and picked up an average defender in Walker as his replacement. Without doubt they've strengthened their pack, however they've gained a rookie coach. I can't see them finishing higher than 5th, and if a few key injuries take place, then they will struggle to make the 8. There's just too much competition this year with multitudes of skillful Kiwi and PI players firmly entrenching themselves in the NRL.

2016-02-28T23:24:05+00:00

fiddlesticks

Guest


slater and smith are on the decline. i will relish the storm not making the 8

2016-02-28T23:23:37+00:00

fiddlesticks

Guest


a deep and complicated argument there curaeus

2016-02-28T23:11:26+00:00

up in the north

Roar Rookie


Good efforts tiowaat, look forward to more of your input. Three sleeps indeed. Sooo looking forward to another season. This one will be even better than last with the way many clubs have improved so it'll be a tally ho paper between the top eight.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar