Six Nations preview: Eddie's England to pip Welsh in classic

By Matthew Hughes / Roar Rookie

I thought I would be brave this week and predict the outcome before the match.

In recent seasons Wales have adopted the mantle of England’s bogey team. In 2012, Scott Williams ripped a ball and scored the winning try at Twickenham. The next year, Grand Slam hopefuls England were torn to shreds by an inspired Wales.

And in last year’s World Cup, England were mugged by a moment of brilliance and humiliated by a moment of stupidity that ushered in the end of the Lancaster era.

This leads us to the new era. Eddie Jones has listed his priorities as putting some arrogance and aggression back into the England shirt, while trying to balance a back-line that has boundless potential.

This stands in contrast to the Warren Gatland era that remains as steady as a rock; a rock made up of outstanding defence, massive ball carriers and opportunistic but limited attack.

Both men have strong opinions so you would have been within your rights to expect some firecrackers in the build up to this game. Eddie Jones has instead taken his media hat off, avoided the pre-game hype-machine and has, so far, refrained from saying anything too inflammatory.

This has resulted in Warren Gatland lamenting the silence and celebrating his antipodean rival as “great” and “refreshing”, while instead questioning George Ford’s defence. The idea being that to attack Jones would reduce the pressure on the England players, but by attacking Ford’s defence it will play on the young man’s confidence and pit him directly against England’s current number 12.

With the return of Manu Tuilagi to the Test squad and Henry Slade soon to return from a broken leg, the candidates for the 12 shirt are swelling. Ford will be painfully aware that the in-form Premiership stand-off and bruising defensive player, Owen Farrell, is now directly auditioning for his shirt.

And I’m sure Gatland hopes that the internal pressure for his position and external pressure on his defensive technique may adversely affect Ford’s decision making skills; in turn forcing the young fly-half to over compensate for his perceived weaknesses.

This will manifest itself in the ball that is needlessly run from deep or a cut-out pass too far. Decisions of this nature will play directly into the hands of the Shawn Edwards defensive machine that gobbles up mistakes and spits out tries week in, week out.

But this is all a sideshow; the real battle will take place in five key areas: at prop, second row, the open-side, the backs (en-masse) and the subs.

Samson Lee versus Joe Marler
I’m not going to pretend that I understand all the intricacies of front-row play. In my playing days I was a flanker and occasional second rower, because of this my ears still retain their natural shape and I’m pretty happy about that.

But even to me it is clear that Marler, set against a technically accomplished tight-head, has a tendency to engage on the angle and give away penalties.

Added to that, his sometime-suspicious technique has been noted by the international refereeing community and if there are any problems in the scrum the referee will often look at his side first.

It may not always be Marler’s fault but, due to the difficulty of refereeing a scrum, the officials have been known to jump to conclusions based on reputation before.

Ultimately, as is the trend in modern rugby, this battle will come down to whoever gets on the good side of Craig Joubert and until the substitutes are introduced, I see the impressive Samson Lee edging it.

Alun Wyn Jones versus George Kruis
This will be the best competition on the park.

George Kruis, to some, is the surprise of the tournament. If Jones was looking for a ‘test animal’ I think he may have found one in this combative second row.

On the opposing side, Alun Wyn Jones is a proven Test animal with years of experience playing in big pressure games; he steals line outs, tackles relentlessly and consistently disrupts the opposition ruck, which would suggest he should edge this contest.

And that would be true if this was a fair fight, but it isn’t. It’s gang warfare and Kruis has the stronger support with (potentially) an even better second row, in Maro Itoje, packing down beside him.

Therefore, I see England becoming more dominant in this area as the game wears on.

Sam Warburton versus James Haskell
This is the area in which Wales have a clear advantage. Warburton is a leader, a poacher, a man-breaking tackler. He consistently makes the right decisions at the right time.

In contrast, Haskell gets yellow carded – a lot.

The Welshman will take this contest but despite popular opinion, winning the battle of the 7s doesn’t necessarily mean you will win the game.

So to the most significant contest on this list.

Welsh backs versus English backs
Rob Howley claimed midweek that Wales won’t be playing ‘champagne’ rugby was like me declaring I have no intention of dating Natalie Portman; it was never a possibility anyway.

And unfortunately for the Welsh fan of champagne rugby, Wales only have five attacking options at the moment and they’re all of the heavy stout variety.

In contrast, the England backline now looks fairly balanced; strength and ferocity with Farrell and Mike Brown is complimented by the guile and speed of Jack Nowell, Anthony Watson and Jonathan Joseph.

Added to this is a bench that contains the sheer power of Manu Tuilagi (although for a heterosexual man I spend far too much time worrying about his groin). There’s also the speed, running lines and siege canon boot of Elliot Daly; both ready to be used or not used depending on the game-situation.

The only aspect in Wales favour is, again, experience. This English back-line has not crackled into life quite how some supporters might have hoped before the tournament but there is a feeling of inevitability that one day they will.

This heavily contrasts a very experienced Welsh back-line, who rarely crackle but possess a tried and tested game-plan that they consistently carry out with devout commitment and ceaseless power.

And finally, the game decider.

Wales’s bench versus England’s bench
The modern game is 23 against 23 and traditionally in this fixture it is the team who can finish strongest that will win the contest; a factor that Eddie Jones will have taken note of.

The Welsh bench, barring Rhys Webb, is stocked with good players who just aren’t quite as good as the man they are replacing.

In contrast, each player on England’s bench offers something different to the man they replace. It is this part of the game where Jones will look to use the variety of his bench to finish Wales off; whether it’s through Mako Vunipola’s off-loading game, Jack Clifford’s pace, Manu Tuilagi’s bulk or Elliot Daly’s boot.

Ultimately, Wales are physically the toughest team in the tournament and Saturday the 12th will be Eddie Jones’s hardest day as the England coach so far.

Added to this, the collective patience of the English supporter was exhausted by the Lancaster regime so Jones will not have as much wiggle room should England lose another important game against Wales.

Therefore, his media silence becomes telling, suggesting he recognises how much is at stake for this young side so early in his tenure and to not give this contest the respect it deserves would damage the positive atmosphere he has so far created.

A prediction based on history would suggest if England are leading by more than a converted try with ten minutes to go then it’s theirs. If not, then look out for the English mistake and the Welsh celebrations.

However, I believe Eddie’s England will be able to take that step Lancaster’s England never managed.

Tip: England 24 Wales 13

The Crowd Says:

2016-03-11T12:24:00+00:00

Tycoch

Guest


Bookies have England as 5 point favorites

2016-03-11T12:23:26+00:00

Tycoch

Guest


Halfpenny still out, and will be for a while. Gethin Jenkins out. Scott Williams (3rd choice centre). Otherwise at full strength

2016-03-11T05:36:41+00:00

timbo

Guest


Wales are probably just favourites, but the game is a coin toss. This Welsh side have been together, effectively, for four years or more. They're at their peak, and virtually injury-free. Logic suggests that should give them an edge, but it will be close.

2016-03-11T03:20:47+00:00

SP

Guest


Are Wales injury free? If so, I reckon they'll win.

2016-03-11T03:00:39+00:00

mtiger

Roar Rookie


"13 needs to be the quickest in order to get around the rush and exploit the space left by the drifting defenders" I think Slade is one of the few who could do that AND be a playmaker. So, with a 10 in Farrell like a Morne Steyn, ENG will have 2 playmakers. If ENG can have that, they will be up there with AUS and NZ at the next world cup. That has made ENG interesting to me.

2016-03-11T02:25:50+00:00

Euan

Guest


Wow! "The heavy stout variety"! That made me laugh out loud, getting inquisitive stares from the rest of the office! What nectar!

2016-03-10T22:10:00+00:00

Jake

Guest


5th v 6th. Can't imagine the skill level will be too high, but it's the event that matters......innit? The rugby is secondary, apparently. Go Wales!

2016-03-10T21:35:07+00:00

#fishesofwales

Guest


2nd row will not be so easily won pal. Tulip or whatever he likes to be called now isn't a match for Billy. place kicking biggar and farrell are evens Agreed wales have their bosh strategy sorted in roberts/north/cuthbert but none of them can dance past Robertson esk like Joseph, watson and billy-bob

2016-03-10T17:50:14+00:00

Chaz

Guest


Excellent piece, Matthew- really looking forward to the game and this only helped build the anticipation. For all the Australia England rivalry and the once a decade win against the ABs, not to mention the history against Scotland, Ireland and France, the England Wales game is the one that I love the most. Probably driven by the combination of its evenness over 130 odd years, the humiliation meted out to England in the 70s (not easy for an adolescent to take) and the experiences of the past 4-5 years. For what it's worth, I think England will win an exciting game by a relatively close points margin but nonetheless quite comfortably. This is based on the last three games, where England have clearly had the better of Wales, other than the last 10 minutes of the RWC game. 21-16 to England, outscoring Wales 2-1 in tries.

AUTHOR

2016-03-10T15:42:12+00:00

Matthew Hughes

Roar Rookie


I get the feeling Jones would prefer a straight swap, Tuilagi for Farrell during the game. But I see the future of England, unless Ford rediscovers his form, being Farrell Tuilagi at 10/12. You're right though, it would be interesting. I hope it's a dry day and we get a good game, these teams are pretty even I think, Welsh experience should make them favourites but we just don't know how good (or bad) England are yet, hence my prediction.

2016-03-10T15:18:46+00:00

Tycoch

Guest


If Wales have success running at Ford, I expect Farrell - who is an excellent tackler - will move to 10, and Tuilagi will come on at 12. Which will make it interesting

AUTHOR

2016-03-10T15:10:36+00:00

Matthew Hughes

Roar Rookie


With aggressive defences nowadays that usually rush up in the 10, 12 and 13 channel and have the winger and fullback drift to cover broken tackles in the midfield and then use the touchline as another defender, ideally your 13 needs to be the quickest in order to get around the rush and exploit the space left by the drifting defenders. Your 10 and 12 need to be distributers in order to get the ball away quickly but ideally you also want them to be strong so that they can go up the middle and test the shoulders of the opposite 10 and 12 and keep them honest. Basically you want to keep the defence trying to do two jobs, drifting to stop the pace and rushing to stop the charge and at some point a mismatch will occur. Catt/Tindall is a perfect example, Wales were rushing that day because Tindall wasn't great at holding the man but he was a bull. Catt came on and suddenly the Welsh defenders needed to be conscious of defending more than one option. But in the end that game was settled by the magic of Robinson.

2016-03-10T15:09:34+00:00

Tycoch

Guest


As a Welshman let me say not a bad review but at few points: No mention of respective half backs. I think clear edge to Wales at 10. Scrum half (9) fairly even. No mention of place kicking - very important given England's poor discipline - edge Wales with Biggar Wales backs: three are very large (North, Roberts and Cuthbert). If either North or Cuthbert get into space they are lethal. Yes they are big, but skillful and fast. Roberts is "heavy and stout" and will be running at Ford - who Wales think is a defensive weak-link. The other two backs - Davies and Williams can be very creative, especially Liam Williams I agree front rows pretty even, but will depend on how Marlar is treated by referee because he rarely pushes straight. Wales definitely have edge in second and back row flankers, #8 is pretty even Bench - Wales replacement front row is almost on a par with starting trio. Half backs - Webb and Priestland have different strengths/weaknesses than Gareth Davies and Biggar. Replacement lock - Charteris - is normally a starter, but has come back from injury. Tipuric (flanker cover) completely different style to starting 6 and 7, Bear in mind England and Wales have been playing each other since 1881, interestingly they almost have identical win totals - Wales 57, England 58. Having said all this I expect a close, dour game - either team could win. Winning margin likely to be 3-5 points.

2016-03-10T14:55:34+00:00

riddler

Guest


people tend to forget that game and catt's massive positive effect.. very under appreciated for that world cup is catt, unfortunately people seem only to remember as being a rather small and ineffectual speed bump vs jonah..

AUTHOR

2016-03-10T14:48:13+00:00

Matthew Hughes

Roar Rookie


Ah, I wouldn't usually write an article like this but I had to do it for practical reasons- I can't imagine that after the game I will be in any fit state to write a postcard nevermind a post-game analysis. There's a good chance Wales will upset England, they're certainly good enough but I think they may have peaked with this style and will need to change something to start beating the SH teams more often.

2016-03-10T13:58:31+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


Personally I'd hope there were play-makers throughout the team. But pushed to two, probably at 12, as when Catt came on against the Welsh in the 2003 RWC quarter and did much to influence a game that was slipping away.

2016-03-10T13:55:26+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


let's be honest. An England Wales review will only attract the usual click baiters if the Welsh end up putting one over the English - then they'll all be falling over themselves spewing bile. Even Spiro might venture back to the 6N after completely screwing up his fearless predictions for round one. Hold your powder Matthew

2016-03-10T04:20:46+00:00

mtiger

Roar Rookie


Where would you prefer the second playmaker? and why not at 13?

2016-03-10T04:12:13+00:00

Not Bothered

Guest


I dont like the idea of having your 2nd playmaker at 13.

2016-03-10T01:55:45+00:00

mtiger

Roar Rookie


WIth Slade back, and going to 13, Jones can put a beast at 12.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar