Daley's Bird to Lewis and Ennis a thumbs up for Kevin Walters

By Jason Hosken / Roar Guru

When the New South Wales State of Origin team was announced last week I expected to see a combination selected mostly from the NRL’s form teams, not a hodgepodge mix with an unhealthy bottom-eight flavour.

Laurie Daley’s Blues will run onto ANZ Stadium this week representing 11 clubs with eight of the squad chosen from the lower half of the competition and only four coming from sides inside the top-four.

It’s staggering, not even Kevin Walters can contain his delight. Brimming with confidence the rookie coach seamlessly staged the Maroons annual pre-game injury heist. Now he’s probably learning to laugh Goofy-style from his Golden Boot five-eighth knowing only a miracle can prevent his squad, with 12 stars from the premiership’s top-four sides, from being threatened in Game 1.

Queensland’s decade of domination stems from a generation of freakish talent gelled mostly across the Broncos, Storm and Cowboys while NSW’s feeble resistance has relied on dubious combinations selected from a broader network.

But there’s no reason for a repeat in 2016.

If you think NSW’s problems are all on-field, then think again. The Blues selectors are a concern. A major concern.

For starters, Dylan Walker and Robbie Farah are way down on form and confidence – handy prerequisites if you’re expecting to thrill 80,000 diehards.

Trent Barrett hasn’t done Walker any favours, expecting the ex-Rabbitoh to instantly ignite Manly’s backline from the unfamiliar playmaker role. The sizzle is simmering and doubts persist over his one-on-one defence.

You have to wonder then, given Walker’s awkward Brookvale initiation, what Daley and Bob Fulton expect from the first time bench utility. If strike-power and reliable defence across several positions tick all the boxes then someone rang the wrong Jack Bird.

Likewise, with one win from seven Tigers outings Farah is hardly going to be strutting around camp-Daley grinning from ear to ear. Throw in ongoing speculation about his longevity at Wests Tigers and frosty relationship with Jason Taylor and you’d be forgiven for thinking Danny Buderus was the only other hooker on Laurie’s list.

Farah’s inclusion is a bright light beaming in the selectors’ faces. How the questionable Tigers run-on jumped Michael Ennis sounds like a question only the straight faced Tony Archer could answer. In career-best form, Ennis’ slick work with current Blues James Maloney and Andrew Fifita have orchestrated Cronulla’s surge to top spot.

In my opinion, the NSW selectors are confused. Stranded between loyalty and generation-next they’ve strangled themselves with their own twisted logic.

Not many doubted Paul Gallen would lead the team despite nudging 35 years but the blatant omissions of Beau Scott and Luke Lewis exclusively based on age remain a mystery.

Beau Scott took his axing on the chin telling The Saturday Telegraph he understood Daley’s reasoning,

“It was always going to go to the younger kids who have a long-term future in the game. NSW are trying to create that now”, he said.

With one series win from the last ten, one can only imagine what future the Blues selectors have in mind. How about picking the best and most deserving for the task instead of harvesting excuses for another loss.

I’d be interested to hear young Matt Moylan’s thoughts on the shafted brigade. Having been smeared across Shark Park in the tackle of the season I suspect the try-bound Panther would welcome Lewis’ intensity throughout the series.

In fact, the Lewis axing is one of the more perplexing and most under-the-radar snubs in Origin history. The busy all-rounder felt the wrath after playing from the bench in all three games in the Blues rare 2014 series win.

Injury free for several seasons now, the 17-time Blue is in better form than two years ago. Capable of covering 80 minutes, Lewis averages 64 per match after 11 rounds mixing punishing defence with the creative skill and unsettling power that would worry Cameron Smith’s line-up – as a minimum, a spot on the bench a must.

It’s only speculation now but come Game 2, who should make way for Lewis?

For me it’s a no brainer, three props in the dug-out plus a fish-out-of-water utility wreak of negativity and an unsustainable approach for multiple victories against a points-happy opponent. Aaron Woods might be a decent bloke but he’s bugged by inconsistency and best omitted with James Tamou to start.

Sadly for Blues fans they’re stuck with a questionable list and unlikely dream missing several who’ve earned the right.

Premiership heavyweights Brisbane and North Queensland contribute six and five players respectively for the opening clash yet the table topping Sharks only support three. The addition of the in-form Bird, Ennis and Lewis might sound shark alarms at Blues pool sessions but without them Queensland have much less to fear.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2016-06-01T08:34:44+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Welcome aboard Tah-Man. You've given me Valley flashbacks, heavy nights. Much rather Burkey and Poido memories - Poido the best leaguey that never was....

2016-06-01T05:40:46+00:00

Tah man

Guest


Field the tahs instead - their form would knock over an ancient team that has spent to much time on the bundy in the valley..

AUTHOR

2016-06-01T05:02:35+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


T'was early in the series, it was a special night We made our way to Homebush to give the locals some bite Queensland were excited they sensed an early blue You should have seen their faces when we turned the other screw Blues by plenty+

2016-06-01T02:50:34+00:00

Bring back the Biff

Guest


I think your articles are getting old like the team roster you are suggesting, but like an old port, your points excellent - NSW selectors are clearly on the take. We are screwed.

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T23:14:40+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Good point Chuck. Reynolds and Maloney will be expected to step up and demand possession when Gal tries to overplay his hand. I'd rather a victory than a Gal man of the match after smashing the Qld wall for +200m in a narrow loss.

2016-05-30T22:46:25+00:00

Chuck

Guest


100% agree Jason. The Tigers win/loss record with/without Farah this year surely proves his 'value'. Ennis' biggest asset is his ability to NOT give the ball to Gallen every time he calls for it (especially on 4th tackle).

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T08:28:42+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Are Bozo and Loz the only selectors, I've not heard McCarthy/Gerard mentioned. I guess there'll be no complaints from the coach but has he been rail-roaded by the veteran...

2016-05-30T07:55:55+00:00

Stu

Guest


This was a big opportunity for NSW - but the selection of players out of form or no game conditioning seems like a big risk. Responsibility lies with the selectors for political picks rather than form.

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T05:56:41+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Mate, you must be laughing come kick off. It is frustrating on the receiving end, even more so if Qld win the opener and all the suggested names get selected for game-2. Great to see Coote slaying it again after a few injury ruined years. Always keeps getting up no matter how hard he's hit. Townsend has been a big surprise this year. I thought Bird would be the Sharks 5/8 leaving Townsend to play mostly at Henson Park. Although I don't think I could pick him ahead of A Reynolds - primarily due to superior kicking, pressure is on...

2016-05-30T05:00:47+00:00

MrJSquishy

Roar Pro


I definitely think there are serious politics in the NSW selection process. But, the thing that amazes me the most about NSW team selection is the constant "random" selection. There is almost always at least one every series. And if that one random costs you one game (out of a best of three series), it's just suicide. Look at Buhrer in 2012. Look at Tupou last year. To me, Walker is that pick this year. Where is the form? Admittedly he was in good form last year (when he was at Souths), but now, a change of club, a prescription drug overdose later and all of a sudden he is better than he was last year? How? It's just unfathomable how they came up with his name. And to load up 3/4 of your spine with players from teams that have a losing record (Panthers 5 from 11, Rabbitohs 5 from 11 & Tigers [were] 4 from 11 [and Farah was only there for 1 win]), it's just extraordinary. I would have been more worried (as a Queensland supporter) to see Ennis, Townsend, Maloney and Coote (3 from a team with a 9 and 2 record, 1 from a team with an 8 and 3 record [at the time of selection]). And then throw in Lewis, Bird etc. That team could be a serious rival...

2016-05-30T04:41:02+00:00

P. Marlowe

Guest


Munster probably would have gone close to Justin O'Neill's spot

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T02:43:37+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Just as odd is the lack of media attention. They guy has all the skills and runs great lines. Just as comfortable in the pack or plugging a hole in the backline. For me, he's the best all-rounder in the NRL.

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T01:20:38+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Cheers for the feedback Mr J. We keep hearing there's no politics involved but it sure doesn't present that way. I understand the article sounds like it's written by a Sharks diehard (go Manly) but there's no doubt Cronulla have the bulk of NSWs in-form players, that's why they top the table. What else apart from politics is preventing their selection. And that's even without mentioning Wade Graham. It's almost like there's a quota system to keep clubs happy.

2016-05-30T00:58:03+00:00

MrJSquishy

Roar Pro


Good article Jason. Couldn't agree more that NSW selectors are the major issue. If not, the only issue. I mean, how can not-the-best team win a series against a powerhouse that has been QLD in the last decade? There has always been a belief across all sports that winning is a habit. Picking players from teams that don't have a winning habit is just suicide. Farah (as you mention) has played in one winning game from 7 starts this year. And he will handle the ball more than most players on the field for NSW. How can he be relied upon to make the right decision at the crucial times when he hasn't been involved in making those decisions at all this year? I think Ennis was dropped purely based on the 52-6 loss, but , I wouldn't have ruled out any of those three players from the Sharks that you mentioned. They are winning games. They have the habit. They should be in the team...

2016-05-30T00:57:45+00:00

Squidward

Roar Rookie


It was a gee up when Lewis had a decent kangaroo test and then dumped for origin

AUTHOR

2016-05-30T00:06:07+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


Manly's my team. So you like the Blues line-up or just in it for a bit of Origin niggle?

2016-05-29T23:51:31+00:00

Curaeus

Guest


Spoken like a true Sharks fan. Obviously objectivity isn't something you "do"!

AUTHOR

2016-05-29T22:35:26+00:00

Jason Hosken

Roar Guru


How many rebels would have Kevvie picked. Milf, maybe Napa. Apart from Val who else is on the list?

2016-05-29T21:58:19+00:00

Gaz

Roar Rookie


Main reason for QLD not using any alternative players is those alternative players gave Walters the bird and got on the grog.

Read more at The Roar