Hail to the Kings: Pavlich deserved the same respect as the other milestone men

By Giovanni Torre / Expert

As you’d all be aware, Mark Robinson covered himself in glory on AFL 360 a few days back by opening a short interview with Matthew Pavlich with a gem.

“Do you take that as incredibly insulting when someone like me says it’s sad seeing Pav playing the way he’s playing?”

First of all, what is up with the phrasing? Did he not have the chutzpah to say it directly?

Robinson then rehashed some criticism made of Pavlich by a former Dock… no, wait, it was by a former St Kilda coach – Grant Thomas – made several years ago.

What’s that? Pavlich never played for St Kilda? No kidding.

Apparently the coach of a rival club had some insight so amazing that it is still relevant years later, on the occasion of the player’s 350th game.

Secondly, journalists shouldn’t shy away from asking tough or awkward questions – it is what we do for a living – but when you ask someone on for a short interview about their 350th game, do you open with “So, are you insulted that I think you’re a s**t player now?” and then rehash some criticism from Grant Thomas?

Thirdly – yes, Pavlich’s leg speed isn’t what it used to be. But in 2015 his leg speed wasn’t what it used to be either. Maybe it’s because he turned 33 at the end of 2014 and since he stopped playing as a midfielder years ago, it’s not that big a deal.

Maybe he’s not kicking as many goals because his team is playing really awful football and only go into their forward 50 46 times a match, and it’s usually delivered appallingly.

Yes, it’s Pavlich’s last season. Yes, he’s not as quick as he used to be. But the truth is, he’s still one of the best two tall forwards at Fremantle this season, if not the best. Maybe that’s a bit damning of Fremantle at this stage, but the man deserves his place in the side and to be accorded a bit of respect.

Channel Seven, in cutting away from the Sydney match early and failing to broadcast Pavlich being carried from the field aloft the shoulders of his teammates, applauded by the crowd and the Swans, showed a total lack of appreciation of the occasion.

The other grand veterans got the treatment they deserved this round.

To paraphrase Ze’ev Jabotinsky, I look upon Corey Enright with the same instinctive love and true fervour that any Aztec looked upon his Mexico or any Sioux looked upon his prairie.

The man is an icon of his club and of the game.

The Geelong record he broke on Friday night with his 326th game had stood since 1983. He and Matthew Scarlett were the most important two stones of the Great Wall on which the Cats built a dynasty. He has a preposterous tally of playing honours.

Jimmy Bartel is a living saint. His 300th was rightfully lauded and celebrated.

And what more can be said about Brent Harvey? As Ivan Drago said of Rocky Balboa “he’s not human – he is a piece of iron”. There’s nothing to indicate Harvey can’t play on next season and be just as good as he is now. It’s just bloody extraordinary.

Enright, Bartel and Harvey all have premierships to their name. Pavlich doesn’t – but neither did Bob Skilton. Pavlich never won a Brownlow, but neither did Leigh Matthews or Gary Ablett Snr.

Pavlich’s 350 games includes playing slightly less than half his regular season matches, and almost every final he’s played, bookended by four-hour flights. As a former FIFO worker, I can tell you that it wears you down.

Saying he is a six-times All Australian player doesn’t really cut it. In 2002 he was the All-Aus fullback. In 2003? Half forward flank. Two years later – centre half forward. In 2007 he was named at full forward.

What other players have been All Australians multiple times, in defence, the guts and in the forward line?

Despite spending plenty of time in defence and the midfield, and despite the Dockers having many disappointing seasons during his career, Pavlich is now approaching 700 career goals.

His 350 games means as much as Bartel’s 300 or Enright’s 326. And, under the circumstances, it’s not far off the stature of the elite 400 club.

There was a certain parochial myopia applied to Pavlich’s milestone by some in the game’s capital, and that’s a pity. From wherever you stand, it’s clear to see he’s a giant of the game.

The Crowd Says:

2016-08-02T11:05:44+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Hilarious...........??

2016-08-02T09:29:58+00:00

Craig

Guest


Boomer purely making it because he could lace up the boots more often isn't a solid enough reason. Pav is well and truly above Boomer, as are guys like Bartel, Black, Ablett.

2016-08-02T05:03:43+00:00

Minz

Guest


Well, I'm blaming Hodge. He should've known better :D Worst guernsey I've ever seen....

2016-08-02T03:50:40+00:00

johno

Guest


Freo has appealed and asked for 10 weeks

2016-08-02T03:49:54+00:00

johno

Guest


Unfortunately I think that hybrid may have been Jeff Daicos, Bruce Ablett Snr, Clem Fyfe, Rodney Dangerfield, Gino Matera, Mrs Brereton, Williams, Gavin, Hunter Kim, Hocking Stuart, Keplar Bradley and Cloke Timmy

2016-08-01T22:29:17+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Dawson was going for a legitimate bump. Lloyd was the one that ran past the ball and turned into Zac. Zac was committed to a football act. More than any could say about Mitchell and Hodge when they hit players.

2016-08-01T22:24:00+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


He did say "downhill skiers...of our age". That age is 3 years old.

2016-08-01T20:42:27+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


The ball was never supposed to be where it ended up - Dawson was committed at Lloyd (who would anticipate him dropping that handball??). I just get sick of the MRP looking at incidents in slow motion from the camera angle rather than real time from the players angle but it's all geared around the 'look of the game' which is why even if it's an accident - if someone gets hurt then the penalty is greater - whereas Travis Varcoe got off entirely for a cowardly punch to the face of MacKenzie last week We punish an accident and condone punching to the face. #mixedsignals

2016-08-01T15:55:36+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


John...none of those boys ever got AA as a key back, key forward and midfielder. Why? Because they couldn't do what Pav did.

2016-08-01T15:52:37+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Definitely better than Whitten. Vics are silly about Whitten.

2016-08-01T13:26:56+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


He didn't have the best day yesterday, but he did still manage to kick two goals :) .

2016-08-01T13:22:02+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


My guess is they don't really pay attention, but feel they need to have an opinion, even if it's just something they've taken from the back of the public toilet stall door.

2016-08-01T13:19:17+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Does Dawson do anything deliberately on the field? i'm not sure he's that coordinated.

2016-08-01T13:12:16+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Pav is still heading Freo's goal kicking list this year, so he's not really out of his depth. Sure he's not the player he was, but not many are at his age.

2016-08-01T13:00:05+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Minz Is that strip the camp pink one ? I don't care who is responsible for that they should be hung and quartered - shocking guernsey - worst ever !

2016-08-01T12:15:37+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Johno You obviously never saw me in my prime - a hybrid of Daicos, Ablett snr, Fyfe, Dangerfield, Matera, Brereton , Williams G , Hunter K, , Hocking, Bradley and lastly Cloke T. Yes , I couldn't kick to save myself !

2016-08-01T11:57:27+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Marshal WA has a big ex pat rugby community of Poms and South Africans . You have conveniently forgot about the utterly woeful Western Force - Super Rugby team . Pav is a big girls blouse - the rugby boys would squash him like a fly - you have plenty of them in that wasteland .

2016-08-01T11:53:15+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Captains play an integral role in liaising with the coach about players roles, skills, abilities and shortcomings. A great captain empowers the coach to listen to him and act upon his thoughts in an objective way. Pavlova was unable to inspire his coaches to make better choices.

2016-08-01T09:43:16+00:00

Minz

Guest


I can only assume our posters from warm climates are getting downhill and cross-country skiing confused - Pav's spent his whole career working hard, shouldering the load for Freo (usually against the flow) and playing wherever the club wanted him to. Not an easy thing to do at a high level over a long period in a club which has had very poor culture for much of that time.

2016-08-01T09:35:49+00:00

Minz

Guest


So, as a Queenslander, you should think of Pav as the long-time captain of a second Brisbane NRL side, an underachieving side compared to its neighbours, but with a rabid, passionate supporter base (as one would expect if the NRL managed to get it right). Would you consider that a small pond situation? Or would it, perhaps, be a high pressure and potentially unpleasant situation for the unfortunate captain? Holding the guy responsible for Freo's recruiting being rubbish is like holding Luke Hodge responsible for Hawthorn's horrible 2015 away strip...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar