2016 AFL Grand Final: The Western Bulldogs win one for all

By Ryan Buckland / Expert

It happened, folks. The Western Bulldogs have broken a 62-year premiership drought – and raised their middle fingers to AFL convention along the way – by beating the Sydney Swans in the 2016 AFL grand final.

All the wash-up from the AFL Grand Final
» Match report: Bulldogs are premiers!
» Seven talking points from the match
» Our top ten tweets from the day
» Another classic Bulldogs banner
» Re-live all the action with our live blog

How about them Dogs hey? Footscray were supposed to be a first up loser to a rampant West Coast – they’ve knocked off the teams ranked sixth, fourth, third and first in four straight finals to win their first premiership since commercial television became a thing.

It was a grand final for the history books, one that will be watched time and time again – an incredible contest where neither team really seemed to hold a winning advantage until the Dogs pulled away in the final quarter.

The Dogs are the first team to finish seventh in the home-and-away season to win a semi-final, win a preliminary final and win a grand final since the current top eight system came into place in 2000.

The Dogs are the first team to win a premiership without a player with premiership experience on their game day roster since 1996.

The Dogs have the lowest home-and-away percentage of a premier since Sydney in 2005.

The Dogs have six players on their long term injury list, and a few others on the short term injury list. Their grand final team was their first unchanged line up since Round 2.

The Dogs are the first team to win four games in a row as betting market under-dogs since records of that sort of information began in 2003; one assumes they are the first team to ever achieve that feat, and they did it in a finals series.

The Dogs are the first team that isn’t Sydney, Geelong or Hawthorn to win the flag since 2010, and only the second team since 2006.

That last point feels like as good a place as any to start. In this year where the competition felt more egalitarian than ever on the field, a victory by the Western Bulldogs, through their adversity, is a symbolic changing of the guard.

The ‘Scrays powered through three of the AFL’s powerhouse clubs, and HQ’s-own juggernaut, to win it all.

Geelong, Sydney and Hawthorn will be back. The Eagles will be too. GWS are the favourites for next year’s flag. But bugger all that for now, because the Western Bulldogs have shown us all what a united club can do if it commits to an identity and pursues it ruthlessly.

The 2014 off season was, at the time, an abject disaster for the Dogs. They lost, in no particular order, Liam Jones (ok that was probably a positive), Shaun Higgins, veterans Adam Cooney and Daniel Giansiracusa, captain Ryan Griffen, head coach Brendon McCartney and chief executive Simon Garlick. That all happened in a single off season.

They also bought in Tom Boyd on a million dollar contract, in a move long foreshadowed in direction if not in magnitude.

That same year, the Brisbane Lions and Western Bulldogs finished on seven wins, and had the same number of games played on their list. The Dogs finished half a win behind Carlton. Footscray’s rise shows how quickly things can turn.

The Dogs aren’t the prettiest football team to watch. Their game is built on being tough and numerous around the contest, exiting with chains of quick handballs, in an attempt to possess the ball and move it forward at all costs. It contrasts strongly with the games of Hawthorn and West Coast, who are built to play the kicking game. It is no less effective.

The Dogs play zone defence like professional partakes in a hot dog eating contest: relentless, efficient and with no desire to let anything escape whence it came. You’ve read all year about how the Dogs are this razzle dazzle football team that play with speed and gay abandon.

That’s the four or five fast break plays the team’s structures manage to create per game talking – the other 115 minutes are like a scene from Saw.

Earlier this week, head coach Luke Beveridge was awarded the AFL Coaches Association Coach of the Year award for the second year running. That’s quite an achievement. It is also his second year as an AFL head coach.

Beveridge’s tactical nous is unquestionable. He becomes the first of the Alastair Clarkson Coaching Academy graduates to have not only beaten his mentor in a finals series, but to have taken his team to Clarkson’s premiership hang out.

Speaking of the Hawks, there is quite a parallel between this victory and Hawthorn’s first post-2000 flag. In 2005 and 2006, the Hawks were a mess. A young mess, but a mess all the same. 2007 saw them leap to fifth on the ladder (from 11th the year prior), with a boost in their percentage from 85.7 to 113.1. They followed that through in 2008 with a second placed finish, a percentage of 131.9 and that premiership.

The Dogs were also a young rabble in 2013 and 2014. They jumped from 14th to sixth, lifting their percentage from 81.9 to 115.1 in 2015. They didn’t follow the same home-and-away season trajectory (their percentage remained at 115.4), but have evidently followed the Hawks to a premiership.

The difference? Those Hawks had 2,362 games of experience in their 22 on game day. The Dogs had 1,807 games today. They’re young, and are set to get younger in the years ahead as their 200 game players transition into retirement.

Strikingly, at the end of next season, Liam Picken could be the most experienced player on the Dogs’ list should Will Minson leave as expected this year, and Robert Murphy, Matthew Boyd and Dale Morris ride off into the sunset. The Dogs are still pups for the most part, and you get the feeling that the spectacular, unprecedented finals run they’ve just completed is the start of something special.

Really, this season has been something special. Sport is the best.

The Crowd Says:

2016-10-04T02:17:34+00:00

Obtuseone

Guest


I agree and that stupid sliding rule was rightly ignored most of the game. How can you not make contact with an opponent's legs at times when trying to win the loose footy. If a serious injury to players is to be avoided at all costs then ban the tackle and penalise players for throwing themselves on top of a player who has the ball underneath him.

2016-10-04T02:08:11+00:00

Obtuseone

Guest


Agree emphatically.

2016-10-02T13:22:38+00:00

Asd

Guest


Victorians vs the rest of Australia. Not a victory for all.

2016-10-02T11:29:21+00:00

Hansie

Guest


You've got to admire the Doggies' style - they kept coming from behind all day.

2016-10-02T09:35:18+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


Haha, correct Col. Cheers

2016-10-02T09:05:57+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


HaHa, congratulations Dougie. I was wondering where you got to but then thought he is probably lacking sleep and nursing a sore head.

2016-10-02T08:27:32+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


Who cares about next year, this year??

2016-10-02T08:26:15+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


LOL. You're soo objective.

2016-10-02T08:24:08+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


I agree. The doggies better players were really evenly spread. Tom Boyd Wood and Picken were our three most influential. But I'd give the medal to Kennedy - he was phenomenal and definitely BOG.

2016-10-02T08:21:45+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


Woof! Woof! We stuck it right up 'em! ?

2016-10-02T07:49:58+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


I know the Swans lost, but Kennedy was the best on ground by a mile -- just had approximately zero support.

2016-10-02T07:49:14+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


Great article Ryan - really enjoyed it. If you look up in the sky at Cloud 9 you might see me floating past. I can't get off it. I'm giving a wave to the Footy Gods. GO DOGGIES!!! YOU BLOODY RIPPER!!! ☁️?☁️

2016-10-02T07:40:03+00:00

DeanM

Guest


Nice delusional rant, never seen in the rule book that the frees for count has to be equal at the conclusion of a game. Bad calls paid and missed both ways ever so slightly perhaps in the Dogs favour. The AFL tried to get the $wans back in the game in the last QTR, Bulldogs to good in the end regardless of umpiring. Both teams played at the MCG an equal number of times this year and it is not the Bulldogs home ground. So Leigh Matthews and yourself think interstate teams needs to be 6 goals better to win at the MCG? Finally after all your ranting you have accepted that the Hawks were clearly better than both the Swans and the Eagles in the 2014,2015 Premierships. The $wans would not even reach the grand final if they didn't have the COLA and Academy rorts. Bulldogs the deserved victor and a fairy tale for the ages. Enjoy sucking on Lemons for another 12 months.

2016-10-02T07:25:33+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Guest


Pretty sad how each week the losing team's supporters come and post dribble about how they were robbed. The umps must have it in for all the losers. But there's plenty of gracious, more realistic losing supporters on here too, which is good.

2016-10-02T05:57:47+00:00

Slane

Guest


'The Swans, who earned home ground advantage for the Grand Final by finishing top of the ladder' You clearly don't understand the rules. The Grand Final is played at the MCG regardless of which teams are featured or where those teams finish on the ladder.

2016-10-02T05:49:00+00:00

anon

Guest


The Swans, who earned home ground advantage for the Grand Final by finishing top of the ladder, had to give up that home ground advantage for the Grand Final and travel to Melbourne to play a Melbourne team that finished 7th. Leigh Matthews talks about an interstate team having to be a 6 goal better team than the opposition to win a Grand Final in Melbourne against a Melbourne team. And then you throw in a 17-4 free kick count early in the 4th quarter when the game was up for grabs, a 4-1 50m penalty count against the Swans, and the truth is the Swans were never a chance. In fact, none of the Bulldogs opposition were a chance. In the prelim the Bulldogs enjoyed a 23-13 free kick advantage over GWS, with a howler not being paid in the final 90 seconds that would have likely put GWS in the lead has it been paid. Then 20-8 in the Grand Final. The Bulldogs enjoyed a free kick advantage of 43-21 in the two biggest matches of the season. The fix was in.

2016-10-02T05:06:11+00:00

marron

Guest


A statistical anomaly, not enough of you to be relevant and break the stereotype of the once or twice a year "swannies! Love my Swannies! What was that for?" fan. ;)

2016-10-02T04:41:58+00:00

Reed

Guest


Mate don't be the "correct terminology" guy. I thought the Bulldogs were the better team on the day and the swans just couldn't keep up. However, if the "FREE KICK" count had been reversed I think the result could have possibly been different. Or who knows maybe not, it was still a great game of footy, and you can't help but feel good for the Bulldogs fans who got to experience a GF win. I remember the feeling of the 05 swans win and it is definitely something special. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2016-10-02T03:53:49+00:00

DeanM

Guest


Remarkable win by the Bulldogs, to be able to overcome the 6 goal advantage the Swans have with residual COLA benefits and the Academy rort is a true fairy tale win for the people. The impoverished Bulldogs taking on the $wan$ and the AFL and winning comfortably. A true David and Goliath battle where David was not simply content with slaying the giant he felt it necessary to take a dump on his corpse.

2016-10-02T02:25:31+00:00

duecer

Guest


Think you'll find that the ratings for Sydney with over half a million disagree with you

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar