It’s time for the big three - not the new three - to stand up

By Dave Richardson / Roar Guru

There will be much hope among Australian cricket supporters that the three new additions to the Test team step up to the plate and ignite the failing Australian team.

While that makes sense, to a degree, placing too much attention on the debutants is wrong. Between Matt Renshaw, Peter Handscomb and Nic Maddison they are only bringing the collective aggregate of 8528 first class runs with a shared average of 39.66.

Reasonable figures, there selections are warranted and they should be given every chance to prove they are up to Test level.

But expectations are high. They enter as a team on a low, facing a team on a high and now possibly angry as a result of ‘Mintgate’.

There is also the added issue of day-night conditions and a pink ball likely to swing for the South Africans.

They should be wished well and any runs of note should be congratulated and celebrated, but where the higher expectation should be placed is on Dave Warner, Usman Khawaja and Steve Smith.

They are the best three in the country and are the ones that really need to step up to the plate.

Without big runs from all or at least two of them over the remaining Tests of the summer, Australia’s problems will only deepen.

And they haven’t been setting the world on fire.

Their collective average over the past five Tests is an uninspiring 34.36, with a return of just one century.

While their class cannot be doubted, it is these three that really need to shape the immediate fortunes of the Test team.

Just imagine a summer where Warner does not fully spark, there is the odd aggressive 50 but he does not go big. He bossed the New Zealand and West Indies attacks last summer but with pressure on this is a different kettle of fish.

Same goes for Khawaja. It was easy pickings when he returned to the Test team. He was a joy to watch but you do wonder if he has a touch of the Carl Hoopers about him. We all hope not, but he will know and all those around him that is now the time to fully fulfil his burning talent.

Then there is Smith, a young captain under pressure. A further loss against South Africa and a poor series against Pakistan will raise the inevitable questions if he is the right man for the job.

Imagine a scenario of another loss against South Africa and let’s say a 1-1 return against Pakistan. This would bring his overall captaincy record to just seven wins over 17 Tests and just one win in the last nine Tests.

Pressure will mount and both his tenure and that of coach Darren Lehmann, whose own win ratio has already dipped under 50 per cent will leave much for Cricket Australia to consider.

It will only be the runs of the big three – not the new three – that will save the day

The Crowd Says:

2016-11-26T10:38:04+00:00

John Erichsen

Roar Guru


It is amazing how quickly Khawaja has gone from a player returning to the test side and attempting to cement his spot to one of our "big three'. I mean three tests ago he was dropped from the side. Tough call to include him with Warner and Smith, in their fortresses of selection solitude. You might have well added Shaun Marsh to the group and called them the fab four. Since Khawaja's return his average is 67, Warner's 52 and Smith's 48. Marsh has averaged 66 but only played one game in each of those four series. History at test and first class levels might suggest that Marsh's inconsistency is best suited to only one game per series and hoping you jag the right game. It will be telling to see if India seals Khawja's test spot for good or proves to be another major stumbling block.

2016-11-24T07:14:17+00:00

James

Guest


It obviously works well for him though. Test average near 50, very good ODI average. But yes, you are correct that he could stand to not throw his wicket away

2016-11-24T00:53:25+00:00

Don Piper

Guest


Warner very overrated at times a glorified slash and hack type

2016-11-24T00:49:41+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Spot on Dave.

2016-11-24T00:02:59+00:00

matth

Guest


Couldn't agree more. It is up to Warner and Khawaja in particular to provide a platform.

2016-11-23T22:24:19+00:00

Happy Hooker

Guest


Geez Dave, you went too easy on Faf. Apart from rubbing the ball on the ground, hard to conceive of a more open and shut case of "altering the condition of the ball"

Read more at The Roar