Super Rugby preview: Reds No.1, with Cooper the key

By Brett McKay / Expert

As I’ve worked my way through these Australian conference previews, it’s been interesting to note the opinions being expressed around the Queensland Reds for season 2017.

What’s become clear, reading the comments, articles, and indeed, previews in other publications, is that there’s no consensus on where they’ll finish.

The opinions backed by some degree of rational thought have them finishing anywhere between first and third, which is hard to argue, while some of the more ludicrous suggestions have them finishing last in the Australian conference. That’s not hard to argue at all – it’s blinkered wishful thinking.

I’ve had them pencilled in to top the Australian conference since the first few days of January, and nothing I’ve seen of the Reds in action since then has changed my mind. If anything, it’s been further underlined.

Forwards
We know the Reds’ lineout will be good in 2017, but if James Slipper and the young props can ensure the scrum set piece is equally as strong, then that’s half their battle won this season.

And the exciting part of that prospect is that it seems highly likely that the Reds will properly unleash Taniela Tupou on Super Rugby this season.

It feels like it’s been a long time coming, but all previews we’ve had to date indicate it’s going to be worth the wait.

Wallabies captain Stephen Moore may well begin the season as the starting hooker, but will he start every game?

My very strong suspicion is that he won’t, and I wouldn’t at all be surprised if he misses the odd away game or tour.

When Andrew Ready has essentially proven himself to be a Super Rugby starter, the Reds can afford to get some more game time in young Alex Mafi.

Lock stocks that still include Rob Simmons, Kane Douglas, and Cadeyrn Neville mean the lineout should remain strong, but a couple of very promising youngsters in Izack Rodda and Lukhan Tui, after strong NRC campaigns, will keep these guys honest.

And that just leaves the backrow. Liam Gill was something of a lone wolf in this department for the Reds last season, but this season, the Reds have more experience than they know what to do with: Leroy Houston, the evergreen George Smith, Scott Higginbotham, and Hendrik Tui have all been there and done that, but it could be that young flankers Michael Gunn and Adam Korczyk are the big winners from the Reds’ off-season recruitment.

Backs
Nick Frisby became a Wallaby in 2016, but playing well alongside Quade Cooper in a winning Reds side could take Frisby from the fringe to the Wallabies game-day squad consistently.

Cooper himself brings elements that Jake McIntyre could only dream of last season, but McIntyre is now in now better place to learn what’s required at Super Rugby level.

The Reds’ midfield looks impressive, with Duncan Paia’aua looking likely at inside centre for Round 1, with Samu Kerevi outside him.

But Campbell Magnay is still only 20 and has shown enough glimpses to know he could become a very good centre before long.

Karmichael Hunt is an option at 12, too, though all signs point to him finding comfort at fullback now.

On the wings, there’s plenty of options, though the pecking remains a bit up in the air. I’d be surprised if former Brisbane Bronco Lachlan Maranta doesn’t start the season on one wing after a high-profile code swap, and you’d think that Eto Nabuli is in front of Chris Kuridrani and the injured-anyway Chris Feauai-Sautia.

Izaia Perese is the X-factor here, however; now a Wallabies tourist, Perese is just the kind of player you need to make room for.

Key player
Probably the easiest ‘key player’ to pick in the history of season previews. So much – if not all – of the Reds’ hopes in 2017 rest on the hands and shoulders and kicking boot of Quade Cooper that it probably won’t matter how many other players happen to find career-best form.

And I say that even knowing that so many other factors – set piece, to name an obvious one – will have a major bearing in how effective Cooper can be with the ball, but it all boils down to the same key point: Cooper is going to be the difference in the Reds converting competitive games into wins.

There were plenty of games last the Reds were competitive in, but they just didn’t have the ability to capitalise. Cooper gives them that ability.

As much as it’s interesting to note the combination developing with Hunt, Cooper’s combination with Frisby will be the most important for the Reds.

The sooner Frisby knows – and doesn’t have to find – where Cooper is, the more dangerous the mercurial No.10 can be, and the more complete the Reds’ attack.

First five rounds
Sharks, Force (away), Crusaders, Lions (away), Jaguares (away)

Though the Reds look strong enough on paper, and even in the trial games, the fly in the ointment is that they’ve got a really tricky start to the season.

You could very easily see them winning as many as three or four of those first five games, or as few as one (or yes, none, for the real pessimists).

But, like I’ve said of a few of the Australian sides in these previews, if they can come through these first five or so games in good shape and posting wins, then they can set up the rest of their season.

After these first five games, it’s probably only away games to the Hurricanes in Round 6, and away to the Highlanders late in the season that loom as big challenges.

Even when on the road within the Australian conference, they’ve got enough talent and experience to know how to win those games.

The Crowd Says:

2017-02-21T23:14:26+00:00

Neil

Guest


I agree with you James, as I don’t necessarily see the Reds forwards are that inspiring other than the Loosies and then is yet to be seen how they comes together. I hope Slipper is in better form than he’s been for the last two years, as I’m still convinced he was carrying a shoulder injury. The locks are so so and as far as I’m concerned Simmons should retire and open a flower shop - simply the worst ball carrying lock anywhere. Fortunately they have some good lock depth that should come to the front sooner rather than later .

2017-02-21T20:48:02+00:00

Rebellion

Guest


It could finish with: - have Pulver and the ARU in your pocket - appoint the Waratahs coach as the Wallabies coach and ignore any conflict of interest - alllowing the Waratahs coach to shamelessly pick favourites instead of more deserving non-Tahs players - enforce a joke salary cap on the Reds to prevent ongoing success after 2011 - forcing players like Higginbotham to other clubs - force Izzy to play for the Waratahs when he requested to play for the Reds (having learnt to play football living in Queensland (attending Marsden State High School) - to have been carried to a championship by a SAF import in a year when standards were low

2017-02-21T11:00:28+00:00

Big Steve

Guest


actually excited to see how the reds do this year. but I just don't understand why they picked up moore. really feel like he is going to slow the team down. and as even worse stop ready from getting experience and making the step up to the wallabies. higgs and Houston are a massive step up from shatz, browning, quirk etc and qld have really struggled there. qld and nsw to finish 1 and 2 with the qld tight 5 too strong taking the number 1 spot. then getting flogged by the kiwis.

AUTHOR

2017-02-21T09:41:14+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


I think so, Nick. Reckon we'll know a fair bit about them after those first five games..

AUTHOR

2017-02-21T09:40:25+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


It's an educated guess Dave - but the Reds were quick to defend the signing of Maranta when he came under fire at the time, and he's been reasonably regular on the media scene. Naturally, they want headlines for their new recruit, but I get the impression they hold him in a very high regard. Kuridrani has found this level tough going often, and Nabuli is finding his feet, so I just think they'll give Maranta every chance to repay the faith, with Perese on the other wing. The curve ball might be that they decide Magnay is too good to come off the bench, even if there no room in the centres yet..

AUTHOR

2017-02-21T09:35:11+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Last Friday Neil: http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/02/16/super-rugby-preview-tahs-second-best-foleys-call/

2017-02-21T09:12:16+00:00

Who Needs Melon

Roar Guru


Of course. I'm sorry. I guess my point is: They've got the personnel - it will be about making sure the whole is at least equal to the sum of the parts rather than good talent being wasted because of poor structure, systems, lack of game time together, attitude, etc.

2017-02-21T08:34:26+00:00

Ruckin' Oaf

Guest


Look at how Brisbane City fell into a heap without Styles in the NRC. He must have made some contribution

2017-02-21T08:33:00+00:00

Ruckin' Oaf

Guest


If they are undefeated after round 15 I reckon they'll have a real shot at the finals..................

2017-02-21T08:31:35+00:00

John

Guest


Reds have 2 obvious weakness's 1 Moores lineout throwing 2 Frisby at halfback, need to get the young McDermott in there. Excelled for the 7s. Otherwise pretty balanced team

2017-02-21T07:43:55+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Thanks Brett - the Reds could easily turn out to be the best overall package in Oz this year...

2017-02-21T07:42:09+00:00

grapeseed

Guest


If Holmes and Gill were both in the team with the current lineup, I would buy a box at Suncorp for the season.

2017-02-21T07:07:06+00:00

Neil

Guest


Hi Brett, Good article. Did you do a preview on the Tahs? if so, which date so I can go back and read it?

2017-02-21T07:02:40+00:00

dru

Guest


Nup. Quade Paia'ua Hunt. That's the axis to watch in the backs. Kerevi, Kuridrani, and Higgers are the trajectiles. But 10-12-15 are the guys cocking the gun.

2017-02-21T07:00:00+00:00

dru

Guest


The last trial Tupou was suspended. He wont start, and suspect thefe's plenty of games he wont be on the pine either. Our front row, without Tupiu is solid 1-3 and 16-18. Slipper didnt quite step up in the scrum, had Simmo on his arse and there may be balance issues. The scrum got better when 1-3 came off. MacIntyre wont be on the pine. Cooper will play 80, injury will be covered by DP. Of course a longer term injury brings Jake back i to contention or some changes involving DP. Kerevi will be the ace weapon, but the damage will come from Quade-Paia'ua-Hunt. The "less than impressive" wings doesnt matter they just fill the holes that 10-12-15 gift them. It will be flat and risky with plenty of fails. This will be balanced by a possession game in the pigs, and THAT is where Frisby is important. Plenty of problems in that lot, but they will not die not having tried.

2017-02-21T06:54:16+00:00

Comrade Bear

Roar Rookie


Agree. Nick Styles performance is key. He has no excuses with this squad...

2017-02-21T06:40:55+00:00

dru

Guest


Sad, but true PK.

2017-02-21T06:40:05+00:00

dru

Guest


I think Frisby's job is to drive the pigs and listen to Quades call. Driving the backs is Quade-Duncan-Hunt. If they pull it off it will be awesome. And fortunately, it's not JUST about Quade the way those guys are going.

2017-02-21T06:36:06+00:00

dru

Guest


Plenty of Reds fans REALLY like Duncan Paia'ua at second fly. Have to admit though, if Hunt continues to be a possible second play maker from 15, there will be a temptation to bring in double big boppers in the centres. Duncan is the better answer for now (in my book).

2017-02-21T05:53:38+00:00

Red Menace

Guest


No mention that Greg Holmes has moved on. I have a feeling they will miss him.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar