The A-League has got the grand final it deserves

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

Melbourne Victory never looked troubled in beating Brisbane Roar in their A-League semi-final, setting up a dream grand final showdown against Sydney FC.

Trust Besart Berisha to be the man to fire Victory into the title decider, as he headed home the only goal of the game in a 1-0 win over his former club at AAMI Park yesterday afternoon.

His expertly taken goal came courtesy of a pinpoint cross from Fahid Ben Khalfallah, although Roar fans will be tearing their hair out at how cheaply they gave away possession for the goal.

It summed up a disappointing display from the visitors, and John Aloisi could have some selection headaches to contend with next season with Tommy Oar and Brett Holman as his designated marquee players.

Oar battled hard but had little impact against a well-marshalled Victory defence, while Holman turned in a truly awful display when his team needed him most.

And unless there’s a twist in the tale, they’re unlikely to have the goals of Jamie Maclaren to rely upon next season either.

There are even whispers that Maclaren could be wearing Melbourne Victory colours next season, signing on as a like-for-like replacement for a potentially Chinese Super League-bound Berisha.

Whomever the Roar’s personnel next season – and they’d be wise to do their utmost to re-sign Avraam Papadopoulos – there’s no doubt they saved their worst for last yesterday.

But perhaps that does a disservice to Victory – who were superb in defence, creative in attack and had the always-accurate services of Berisha to fall back on for a goal.

And in Marco Rojas, James Troisi and Ben Khalfallah, Victory possess the sort of attacking trio that could actually cause Sydney FC some problems next weekend.

About the only disappointment from a Victory perspective was the total lack of atmosphere inside AAMI Park, with the on-going boycott from the North Terrace continuing to bite hard.

The Victory fans were completely out-sung by the visiting Roar supporters, many of whom can thank the Roar Supporters Federation for receiving free tickets to the game.

A-League fans in general could do with some similar representation, with Ticketek once again making a dog’s breakfast of getting grand final tickets into the hands of Sydney FC fans.

How many times are Ticketek going to fail at the seemingly simple task of selling tickets – adding insult to injury by charging an absurd service and handling fee – before someone at Football Federation Australia holds the company to account?

That said, given some of the astronomical prices being charged to attend the grand final, it’s clear fans are not at the forefront of FFA’s thinking.

They’re probably too busy fending off enquiries about the Video Assistant Referee system, which was called into play twice in Sydney FC’s 3-0 win over Perth Glory.

If we’re going to split hairs over the VAR, then both decisions looked technically correct on Saturday night – even if Perth Glory fans would prefer to disagree.

But questions have already been asked about how the VAR is to be used going forward, with Sydney FC benefiting twice on Saturday from goals that had already been disallowed.

Their second goal was the most contentious, with defender Jordy Buijs scoring a superb solo strike – but only after Glory defender Dino Djulbic claimed he had been impeded by an offside Bobo in the build-up.

It would have been a harsh decision to disallow the goal given that Buijs started and finished the move himself.

But there’s no doubt Glory were desperately unhappy with the decision – to say nothing of Filip Holosko’s fractionally onside header.

The Sky Blues nevertheless looked much the better side and had already taken a deserved lead through Josh Brillante’s thunderbolt.

They’ll need their midfield to be at their best in a grand final that pits first versus second next Sunday afternoon.

And another A-League season will climax with the biggest game of all, as Sydney FC host arch-rivals Melbourne Victory for the 2016-17 title.

The Crowd Says:

2017-05-02T05:34:09+00:00

matth

Guest


The funniest thing about this thread. Over 200 comments and maybe 3 that actually discuss who is going to win the GF.

2017-05-02T05:28:53+00:00

matth

Guest


The BBL is really set up as a carnival in the school holidays, as opposed to a proper club competition. Cricket has never really had professional club comps as a focus before, so it will be interesting to see if/how they expand. AFLW was a complete first year experiment, and I agree it was a bit cynical by the AFL just to use it to fill a gap in the AFL schedule. Hopefully it will expand. Whatever the A-League does please stick to playing each team home and away. The codes where they play some teams once and others twice just makes for a compromised competition.

2017-05-02T04:10:47+00:00

truther

Guest


Neutral fans are not the ones who the pay the big money... Neutral fans are leeches ;) If all fans were neutral, all clubs and professional players would go broke.

2017-05-01T23:01:58+00:00

Caltex & SBS support Australian Football

Guest


And if I did?

2017-05-01T22:47:40+00:00

Ian

Guest


You don't have 20 friends Jeff/Kevin Dustby /Pat Malone /Casper. Maybe 20 different aliases hahahahaha Even if you did talking about an "internet' relationship you have is very very sad. hahahahaha

2017-05-01T22:44:40+00:00

Ian

Guest


You are running to Stuart asking him to do something about another poster. Are you a baby "Matt Jones"?

2017-05-01T22:42:28+00:00

Ian

Guest


Still scared "Matt Jones"? Seems like the highest participation rate thingy annoys you. "safe"...that old furfy.....you ever play football? I mean real football. Do you not enjoy sports were the most common surname of the players isn't "jones" or 'Smith"?

2017-05-01T22:38:38+00:00

Ian

Guest


Millions of Australians care. or are you the only real "Aussie"? scared much "Matt Jones"?

2017-05-01T22:37:43+00:00

Ian

Guest


And you are here reading and writing about it. Which is worse "Matt Jones"?

2017-05-01T22:35:08+00:00

Ian

Guest


Oh Please.....your buttons are being pressed without anyone having tried to press them. I know you write your comments to be as clever as possible and have thinly veiled insults hurtling from every second sentence......but do you have to be a clown?. Brisbane failed "SPECTACULARLY" at the FFA Cup. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH......wow....what a large, emotive and descriptive adjective for you. You must be very intelligent to have used a word like spectacular in such a placement within your sentence. And Victory only had 20,000 plus at the game. Overawed?.... We had 3000 less last week in a city half your size. Same old excuses out for only having 20,000 people at AAAMI Park...."corporate boxes" take up 8000 seats apparently. Too bad the Roar fans were louder from independent reports. And by the way Victory played better than Roar, but if I was a neutral I'd say the game wasn't that flash to watch. But you didn't care about the game as it was a finals game.

AUTHOR

2017-05-01T22:30:32+00:00

Mike Tuckerman

Expert


I don't think it will have a problem selling out. But I certainly agree that ticket prices are too high.

2017-05-01T17:30:25+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


well said stu, can you get fuss to do the same?

2017-05-01T17:26:08+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


did you type that comment with your feet?

2017-05-01T17:24:14+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


Fuss, how dare he speak like this to you

2017-05-01T17:22:18+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


yeah, its been first for years because its a safe game. fishing and running are huge. i love boxing but would never participate please keep hanging on to your participation numbers and give them a cuddle

2017-05-01T17:21:17+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


who cares? i am sure a league is huge on the streets of Kolkota

2017-05-01T17:20:45+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


he threw out a lure and you caught it

2017-05-01T17:20:14+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


as in accurate?

2017-05-01T17:16:04+00:00

jeff dustby

Guest


i have a group of 20 friends that all want to meet you. but no room for your sycophants Caltex and Punter

2017-05-01T17:15:03+00:00

Matt Jones

Guest


you love a good excuse

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar