AFL boss says yes to longer bans, no to red cards

By Roger Vaughan / Wire

The AFL will consider ramping up the ban for one-punch offences in the wake of the ugly Tomas Bugg and Ali Fahour controversies.

While league chief executive Gillon McLachlan is wary of introducing a red card at AFL level, he is happy to discuss tougher tribunal penalties for serious incidents.

On Tuesday, Melbourne’s Bugg was banned for six matches after he concussed Sydney opponent Callum Mills with a punch to the head.

The following night, Ali Fahour resigned from his role as AFL diversity manager after he received a life ban at local level.

Fahour was caught on video punching out an opponent in a scuffle during a match.

“If there’s a view that, say, six weeks is not enough deterrent, we’ll look to escalate it,” he said.

McLachlan was speaking at a Thursday morning media conference where he confirmed Fahour had left the AFL.

There are campaigns in the wider community to stamp out so-called coward punches.

“We’re certainly a leader in this area,” McLachlan said.

The former amateur-level ruckman said the game at all levels no longer tolerated such ugly incidents.

“I have no doubt there are less on-field issues at the community level and elite level than it was five years ago, certainly 10 years ago,” he said.

“I certainly feel the strong statements over the last couple of weeks will help us have less issues.”

But McLachlan is yet to be sold on a red card in the AFL, an issue debated in the wake of the Bugg case.

Bugg punched Mills in the first quarter and the Sydney player did not return, meaning the Swans were a man down on the bench for nearly the whole match.

“I feel that the red card potentially raises as many issues as it solves,” he said.

“I feel comfortable with the system – so that leaves you with if it’s not a significant deterrent where the penalties are now, I feel the thing to pursue … (is) raise the stakes.

“That’s a discussion I will have.”

The Crowd Says:

2017-07-08T01:18:42+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


I agree Slane. The offences occurred against Carlton and Sydney yet they get no benefit from the suspensions to either Houli and Bugg. What they got was having to play the remainder of the game one player down while both Richmond and Melbourne enjoyed the benefit of one extra player through reportable actions of one of their players. Imagine in the 2004 GF if Alastair Lynch had of been a better fighter than he showed. He could easily have put a couple of Port Adelaide players out of the game while he stayed on the ground. We could be talking about a Brisbane 4peat and Port could still be looking for their first flag.

2017-07-06T07:01:46+00:00

Slane

Guest


I don't see an issue with bringing in a red card for offenses that leave the opposition team a player down. If you get reported and your actions leave an opponent unable to take the field you should have to sit on the bench as well. I don't think playing with 17 men on the field is the correct solution, but certainly we can look at evening up rotations and such by sending the offender off the field.

2017-07-06T06:59:48+00:00

Republican

Guest


......good call in my opinion Gillon........

Read more at The Roar