League versus union: Letting go of the code war bitterness

By Robert Burgin / Expert

Admittedly I’m a person with an elaborate imagination, but lately I’ve become transfixed by a rather absurd hypothetical scenario.

Do you think that, while knocking the froth off a few cold ones and sending down lopsided lumps of black plastic at their local lawn bowls club, Reg and Bruce regularly slag off practitioners of other forms of bowls?

“What about that hoity-toity lot down at bocce? And don’t get me started on those petanque imposters,” Reg would say.

“Bunch of pansies. I reckon even the skittles crowd would have their measure, even though there’s bugger-all of them left,” Bruce would fire back indignantly.

Then they’d both vent their anger about the ‘sell-outs’ of tenpin bowling, protecting their delicate skin by congregating indoors, jiving away to garish music, wearing fancy shoes and rolling off for the big money.

Quite possibly this daydream comes to me because I’m approaching the second half of life in which the prospect of walking back-and-forth on a 35-metre patch of grass is gradually starting to sound like an acceptable way to spend a weekend.

But, more strongly, I suspect this fantasy has entered my consciousness because of the increasingly ludicrous juxtaposition of rugby league and rugby union supporters.

Me, I’m firmly a rugby league kid. To me it reflects the way I grew up, it reflects where my family is from, it reflects my values and I genuinely believe it is the more dynamic and entertaining game.

In my younger years, when I thought it might actually be something that mattered to anyone else, it was a fierce affiliation I wore like a badge.

(Image: Grant Trouville / nrlphotos.com)

It’s as if rugby league versus rugby union reflects a simmering class war that has never physically erupted for our rather blessed and privileged generation in Australia.

You can say, “I’m a league man” and it allows you to believe you are a man of the people, fighting the good fight, standing up to the nepotism and corporate greed of our failed capitalist system – or, erm, something like that.

To imagine yourself as a ‘league man’ is akin to imagining Che Guevara staring wistfully into the distance as he fights for the plight of the common man – save aside the fact Guevera was actually a rugby union inside centre in his youth.

My allegiance to rugby league will surely never abate, but the happenings of the past few months and weeks have made me question how stupid the whole league versus union things is and how foolishly we tie our identity to it.

As I’ve alluded to in past columns, I assist with helping to spread and develop rugby league across Latin American communities. I do so on a committee of nine people who treat what we do as a humanitarian and cultural project as much as we treat it as a sporting project.

I’d say that at least once per week I receive an antagonistic message from somebody involved in rugby union about the supposed pointlessness and failure of our efforts.

Sometimes I know we must be doing particularly well. Those are the weeks where I receive four or five aggressive, insecure emails. Nobody much bothers writing when they don’t feel threatened.

But as much as my own rough hide has become impervious to insults from working in a daily environment surrounded by journalists, not everyone is the same.

Just this week another of our committee members received a grenade from the blue – some internet warrior who had tracked him down and unloaded a string of abusive messages about the “stupidity of Mungos” before then blocking his account so there was no right of reply.

To give context, this particular committee member lives in quite a remote area, and our project is not only a way for him to interact with the wider world, it’s also a way for him to honour his wife’s family, who came from a poor, war-torn background.

His involvement with rugby league allows him to have a connection to her relatives and culture, and do some good for the community. He sacrifices countless hours, like everybody involved, for free.

And this is where I think the whole rugby union versus rugby league thing has worn thin on me – or any sport versus any other sport for that matter.

(Image: AAP Image/Dan Peled)

Essentially what we have is a person with a social conscience, giving up their time and money to promote an activity for young men and women, copping a gobful from some trumped up idiot that believes he is a warrior for his clan.

A younger me would notch this down as another grudge against union – you know, stretching back to the breakaway in 1895, the Vichy period, the many roadblocks, bans and even imprisonments that have been imposed over time – except I know that s**t flows both ways, excuse the English.

I’m sure there are dyed-in-the-wool leaguies out there lobbing similar gutless barbs at proponents of the 15-man game, similarly hitting those who sacrifice time, money and effort because they want to do something tangible for the community.

I’m over waging war against the supposedly elite classes, ‘tweed patch brigade’ or whatever else we choose to denigrate union lovers with.

The war I choose to take up now is against the apathetic and unhelpful in our community.

It’s cool these days to be disengaged, critical and free of responsibility. You can blame everyone for your’s and society’s ills without ever getting off your fat arse to do something about it.

Most don’t.

Governments, councils and neighbourhood action groups rarely help either, legislating anything physical to within an inch of its life, finding reasons to deter groups from using public parks.

I’m of the view that anyone who is making the effort to enrich lives of others, promote health, meaningful interaction and teach life values is to be applauded no matter what sport they proffer.

It’s why when our organisation takes league into a new country we specifically outline that we are simply another avenue for people to represent their heritage, improve their life, learn important lessons, not to oppose rugby union.

And the honest truth is that outside of Australia and a select band of administrators with a position to protect, not many people the world over care at all about the whole league versus union thing.

I’ve taught clinics in Brazil where the same athletes played union first, had a break to learn how to make an effective league tackle, practised their union line-outs, played touch football, then progressed to full rugby league rules.

These people, millions of them around the globe, don’t see a delineation or a reason not to play and enjoy both sports or choose whichever one they prefer.

To them, closing their minds to possibilities and new experiences is as stupid as old men in a park fighting over what’s better: lawn bowls, bocce, petanque, skittles or tenpin bowling.

Sometimes you have to let go of the bitterness that’s holding you back.

The Crowd Says:

2017-07-10T11:23:06+00:00

Peter

Guest


Silly bugger. Do you actually have any idea how many countries play union and how many play league? That is not to support one over the other. It is to suggest that if you make foolish incorrect claims it pretty much destroys any value in your argument.

2017-07-10T08:42:50+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


PFJ - Dedicated to the continuing struggle to liberate the parent land from the hands of the Roman Imperialist aggressors, excluding those concerned with drainage, medicine, roads, housing, education, viniculture, and any other Romans contributing to the welfare of Jews of both sexes and hermaphrodites.

2017-07-10T08:25:35+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


Whatever happened to the Judean Popular Peoples Front?

2017-07-10T06:38:28+00:00

PJ

Guest


They don't work together because the reality of the situation is globally league is a nothing sport and doesn't rate a mention anywhere other than Sydney & Brisbane

2017-07-10T06:34:32+00:00

PJ

Guest


Albo do your self a favour, if you are in Sydney get down to a Shute Shield game and you will fall in love with the game again. It's rugby how rugby should be played!

2017-07-10T06:33:24+00:00

PJ

Guest


+2 both games have their brilliant moments and both games have some terrible moments.

2017-07-10T06:18:27+00:00

matth

Guest


Maybe when your Mum is Australian and your Dad is Samoan?

2017-07-10T06:15:31+00:00

matth

Guest


When I think about League vs. Union, it reminds me of: Brian: Excuse me. Are you the Judean People's Front? Reg: $%^& off! 'Judean People's Front'. We're the People's Front of Judea! 'Judean People's Front'.

2017-07-08T16:22:06+00:00

RM

Guest


Sadly, I have to agree with this. People all over the world a desperate to feel superior to others about something, anything at all really. For some, they latch onto the sporting code of their choice and use that. It is fine to prefer one sport over another, it is fine if someone watches a certain sport and it's not their thing - but to denigrate others for liking a different sport...well, it says more about the person than the sport. My list of preferences would be cricket, league, union, AFL in that order. I've tried getting into soccer many times, but after several years, I had to come to the conclusion that it just wasn't for me. And that was that - I didn't then spend my time attacking the game or its fans online because that would be ridiculous.

2017-07-08T15:33:40+00:00

Jeff dustby

Guest


We all know the real enemy is soccer and their "we are the world game" supporters like Nemesis etc

2017-07-08T15:24:28+00:00

Jeff dustby

Guest


Moved here as a child

2017-07-08T14:45:43+00:00

William Dalton Davis

Roar Rookie


As a man who listened to a Canadian argue with three Australians about whether the NFL was tougher than the AFL for 5 hours on Thursday night (not an exaggeration) I can honestly say there's nothing more boring than hearing a my sport is better than your sport arguement. Could've set your watch to the number of times the words "300 pounds of muscle", "pads", "soft", "Hayne", and "who tf is Hayne?" were said.

2017-07-08T13:21:01+00:00

3_Hats SSTID 2014

Roar Rookie


BORING, that is 10 minutes I will never get back.

2017-07-08T12:24:15+00:00

Chris

Guest


Yeah be great if Rugby League was under World Rugby Union roof and to promote 15/13/7 as side along side Touch and Tag.

2017-07-08T11:55:18+00:00

The Doc

Roar Guru


Fantastic read Robert and great work in promoting sport in other areas of the globe. Not much to add. I am too short and weak to play either forms of the game and so have enjoyed it from my armchair over the last 25 years of my life. As a lover of all sports, code wars infuriate more me than anything and so it is great to read an article that seeks to break this barrier down or at least give a refreshing perspective on it.

2017-07-08T10:11:54+00:00

Katipo

Guest


Yes. And rugby's stupid decision to call their Super teams Blues, Reds, Sharks, Sunwolves, instead of Auckland, Queensland, Durban and Tokyo further down played the international nature of rugby.

2017-07-08T10:04:29+00:00

Birdy

Guest


Pre tell big al Where did afl come from. Ireland, funny how they beat you all the time. A game for cricketers to keep fit during the off season? Or the latest that popped up when reconciliation became popular . It came from our indigenous brothers. So many beginnings depending on whats popular at the time. And while your explaining your origins could you also explain why when the NRL celebrated our 100th anniversary presto the afl jumps out from nowhere celebrating their 150th? Oh and one more thing, how about a hybrid game against one of the rugby codes? No nah nope , can't have that , fancy another code giving you a floggin.

2017-07-08T07:31:28+00:00

Dave_S

Roar Rookie


sheek, surely you remember when league scrums were either legalised dockyard brawls, dubious "straight" feeds ... anything but an absorbing contest :) Rugby scrums are far more "interesting", but for the dubious penalties, 3 resets ... Give us something in the middle of the modern quick league and contested rugby scrums, please. Unfortunately I don't think that's possible.

2017-07-08T06:49:14+00:00

Nate

Guest


Ugh, fish...

2017-07-08T06:45:02+00:00

Justin Kearney

Guest


I understand the history of australian rules football all to well al. You must have a different interpretation to it but thats okay. I don't follow the game though. I don't find it very interesting but each to their own my friend.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar