The real shame in Mayweather versus McGregor

By Jamie Mills / Roar Rookie

One of the greatest super-fights in the modern era of boxing is set to take place at the T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, Nevada, in the coming weeks, with a match-up that has been demanded by boxing fans for years.

This bout no doubt promises to deliver on what a true blockbuster sporting event should be – two athletes at the top of their profession squaring off against one another to find out who the greater competitor really is. On this occasion, which is a much-needed shot in the arm for boxing as a whole, we could witness one pugilist earn their 50th professional career victory.

Three weeks prior to that mouth-watering contest, ‘The Notorious’ Conor McGregor (0-0-0, 0 KOs) will step into the ring to make his professional boxing debut against one of the greatest boxers of all time, Floyd ‘Money’ Mayweather Jr (49-0-0, 26 KOs).

Following on from this media-hyped event, the super-fight I’m referring to is of course none other than Saul ‘Canelo’ Alvarez (49-1-1, 34 KOs) taking on Gennady ‘GGG’ Golovkin (37-0-0, 33 KOs) on 16 September.

Let me set the record straight: I’m not against the Mayweather versus McGregor event taking place. Will I be watching the fight? Yes. Do I think it’s going to be a competitive match-up? No.

Mayweather Jr and McGregor, along with their teams, are highly intelligent businessmen who know how to sell both a fight and themselves and, above all, how to make money. They are also immensely skilled elite athletes who will surely put on an intriguing contest when 26 August rolls around; however, with no world title on the line, Mayweather Jr on the decline and McGregor undertaking his maiden foray into the sport, it’s not the fight that should be getting all of the limelight.

Three weeks later at the same venue the Canelo versus GGG rivalry will finally come to a head, and although Anthony Joshua’s crushing 11th round knockout victory over Wladimir Klitschko back in April was a tremendous display of what boxing has to offer, I’m backing this fight to live up to the hype and become the standout fight of the year, if not the greatest night for boxing in recent history.

It will see two incredible fighters, both currently in their prime, pit themselves against each other in a sport that they have dedicated their lives to since they were children to establish who will be crowned the true unified and undisputed king of the middleweight division.

(Image: AP Photo/John Locher)

They are also both especially entertaining fighters inside the ring, with Golovkin having produced 33 stoppage wins through his 37 professional bouts and Alvarez recording 34 victories inside the distance of his 51 encounters. With both fighters having won multiple world championship belts, GGG remains undefeated, while Canelo’s only defeat came, ironically, at the hands of Mayweather Jr in September 2013 via majority decision.

On the other hand, McGregor sports a record of zero fights, zero wins and zero knockouts in the boxing ring. In mixed martial arts (MMA), he does tally an impressive 21 victories, with 19 of those coming inside the distance, along with three defeats, which also came before time. However, MMA is a completely different sport to boxing.

Mayweather Jr proudly wears his 49-0 record, of which 26 of those victories came by way of knockout, and he is also a five-division world champion who has collected 15 major world title belts. During an amateur career in which he is believed to have amassed 84 victories inside the square circle before turning professional later that year, Money also earnt a bronze medal for the USA at the 1996 Olympic Games in Atlanta.

That McGregor can be expected to give his American opponent a tough night’s work on 26 August is just not plausible to me. The UFC star lacks the experience and the skill set to trouble someone of Mayweather’s calibre – in boxing, that is. If the fight were to take place under MMA rules, McGregor would surely dominate, but it’s Queensberry rules.

Looking at the names on Money’s record, he’s beaten everyone who has been put in front of him. The list includes numerous world champion and hall of fame boxers, such as Manny Pacquiao, Ricky Hatton and Oscar De La Hoya, who lived and breathed the sport of boxing from a young age. If those men were unable to hurt him, surely McGregor cannot.

In my eyes, the Irishman relies solely on the awkwardness of his own unpredictable style along with the hope that at 40 years of age his rival’s skills have diminished considerably.

Somehow, though, this fight is the one that continues to hold the media and public’s attention, with people from all walks of life gathering for it. The reason for this is because both fighters are far superior when it comes to self-promoting, whereas Mexican Alvarez doesn’t speak English and Kazakhstan native Golovkin prefers to let his actions in the ring do the talking.

For me the most disappointing aspect is the fact that what promises to be a landmark occasion for boxing on 16 September has been overshadowed and is in danger of sailing by unnoticed by casual and would-be fans due to the money train and media circus that is Mayweather versus McGregor.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-08-18T04:26:40+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Yeah absolutely Grafter, 'Mericless' Ray Mercer is a good example that I'd completely forgotten about. That one didn't last long, hey! I hadn't forgotten the James Toney versus Randy Couture fight, I just didn't want to bring it up, haha. Nice point too, I agree and think that it does show weakness in the MMA for their star to have to come across to boxing for a big payday. Like you said though, sadly, he didn't come across to challenge a current champion or top fighter in their prime, such as Crawford or Spence as you mentioned, which I guess shows a weakness in boxing also. Yeah, I must say I was happy to read that the Canelo versus GGG bout sold out early, and before this fight which supposedly still has quite a few tickets available. Astronomical prices may have something to do with it too though rather than general interest in the event.

2017-08-18T04:13:57+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Hey Grafter, as i said before Mayweather's streak is the most prized thing in boxing, being a world title holder is nothing on beating his streak. There are about 8 world titles outhere per division; WBC, WBA, WBO, IBF, IBO, LINEAL, THE RING AND THE WBF. but Mayweather streak is a once in a lifetime opportunity. Once its broken he can never get it back. Plus McGregor is being paid about ten times what he makes in the Ufc

AUTHOR

2017-08-18T04:13:16+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Haha. Thanks J.C. I appreciate it.

2017-08-18T04:03:19+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Quiet you or ill come round there and give you a good pistol whipping!!!!

2017-08-18T03:52:47+00:00

The Grafter

Guest


There has been boxers (past their use by date) transfer across to MMA. Old Man Ray Mercer had a KO victory against some former MMA 'Champ' whilst james Toney (a natural middleweight) got hammered by Randy Coulture. Personally I think this spar on the 26th is an embarassment to MMA. Why does their No 1 'star' have to cross codes to make the big money whilst in his prime? If so, why not of challenged one of the current title holders like Crawford or Spence, or better still, go to light middle (154 pounds) and try Alverez or a couple of the other 'bangers' going around? I see the ticket sales havent been great whereas the big fight next month has been sold out for awhile.

2017-08-18T03:46:39+00:00

J.C.

Roar Pro


There it is big fella the smartest thing you will ever say and no people in your life to read it. Such a waste of talent. Jamie great article mate, nicely done mate. Cant wait til August 27th.

AUTHOR

2017-08-18T00:03:08+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thanks mate, I appreciate it. I love seeing different views, so I think The Roar will be a great thing to be a part of. I'm definitely from the boxing side of the ledger as well as being heavily into motorsport. I do enjoy watching MMA, there's still a lot for me to learn about it though. I agree that it's so difficult to come in to another sport and face someone who's been mastering that particular sport for a long period of time. Likewise, if this fight was taking place under MMA rules, McGregor would obviously dominate Mayweather. As you say, boxing is highly specialised though, and there's only so much McGregor will be able to pick up in this training camp. You're right in saying the scenario of a boxing versus MMA card would definitely make MMA look bad, just the same as it would make boxing look bad if it were done under MMA rules in the cage.

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T23:36:15+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Yeah the news of 8oz gloves is certainly interesting. I too think that McGregor's best chance is definitely an early onslaught, but agree Mayweather is too wise and experienced to fall for that. Great fight certainly looms three weeks later! I'm picking GGG, I think his power will overcome Canelo.

2017-08-17T10:38:15+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


No problem, good to have you here Jaime, great first column. Combat sports articles have gone in and out of vogue on the site so any new voices are welcome. I must admit I come from the MMA side of the ledger so part of me does hope McGregor knocks Maywether right out but highly doubt there is any real chance of that happening, Maywether even at 40 should prove too technically sound. While I don't know the ins and outs of boxing that well I've seen how fighters get completely schooled when they step in the MMA ring without experience in the sport so why should I realistically expect anything else in the boxing ring? Even guys like Joe Schilling who is one of the best kick boxers in the world have had massive problems in MMA, even in stand up where you would expect him to thrive. I am also very glad that they didn't do it as MMA v boxing card, would have made a joke of MMA boxing skills. While every one of them would probably completely starch their opponent in a real fight boxing is just so highly specalised that the MMA guys just wouldn't have a chance, would look very bad for the sport generally.

2017-08-17T10:36:26+00:00

The Grafter

Guest


Neither of them are Joe Parkers of Jeff Horns Jerry. Evens the Yanks dont like Mayweather, and McGregor isnt exactly endowed with modesty. In fact, the pair of them make 'The Man' come across like a gentleman.

2017-08-17T10:34:23+00:00

The Grafter

Guest


Cheers Jamie. The 8 oz gloves will work in Moneys favour. Realy the only hope McGregor has is come out like a train and try and bully the old man. Floyd has been around to long for that. Ringcraft, ducking, weaving, jabbing and absorbng the intial onslaught should see him win inside 6. GGG to big for Canelo although his last fight against a bigger fighter wasnt so good. Alverez is tough, resilient, more skilled than the usual wlak up Mexican. A great fight looms.

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T10:11:49+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thanks for your comment Jerry. Your best bet is a draw, so that at least neither would win! I respect your stance and if you're not watching, I don't think you'll miss anything spectacular. Canelo versus GGG is much more deserving of our hard earned in my opinion.

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T10:06:38+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thank you for your kind words Grafter. Good observation there, I agree it was definitely a strategy from Mayweather Promotions and the UFC to schedule their bout before the Canelo versus GGG fight. The Irishman's left hand is definitely his best weapon in offence, but like you said, doesn't seem to be doing it's job on the defensive side of things, inviting the right hand, although we've only been able to view a small amount of footage. Indeed you're spot on that the jab is the bread and butter of boxing. For what it's worth, I too share the prediction that this will be Mayweather's first win inside the distance for a long period of time. Best of luck at the TAB. Roll on Canelo versus GGG indeed!

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T09:58:37+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thanks for your comment Sam. I totally get your point. Unfortunately, like you said, that's not the world we live in. I also agree that this fight isn't doing much for the sport of boxing. On a positive note, there is a few quality fighters featuring on the undercard. I'm glad they didn't go with the boxing versus mixed martial arts theme for the whole card.

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T09:30:49+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Haha, nicely put BigJ!

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T09:28:59+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the comment Council. I'm on team Money for this one as well, purely because I want boxing to shine. It wouldn't be great for the sport if someone came in and defeated one of the greatest on their debut!

AUTHOR

2017-08-17T09:25:54+00:00

Jamie Mills

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the welcome BigJ! I appreciate the comment. As I said, I'll be watching, so they've done enough to sell me on it too! I do agree that the potential of taking away Money's undefeated status is something to be fighting for, and wouldn't for a second doubt the fact that McGregor will give absolutely everything and then some to this fight. Interesting observation too mate with your point of the casual fan only caring about the result rather than the method.

2017-08-17T04:23:43+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


I glad you liked that one JD

2017-08-17T03:02:22+00:00

JD

Guest


LOL. Funny. Well done!

2017-08-16T22:24:07+00:00

Jerry

Guest


The real shame is that they can't both lose, to be honest. Though Mayweather is obviously a much worse person, I can't really support either of them based on their public personas and that extends to paying to watch them.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar