I'd rather watch the A-League than the EPL

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

As the thirteenth running of the A-League draws ever nearer and excitement builds around what promises to be another gripping season, membership numbers continue to build, new international signings arrive and fresh kits are unveiled.

The game has ridden a wave of ups and downs over the years and the current state of play sees the league looking healthy yet suffering from something akin to an irritating and lingering sore throat that pops up each morning.

No matter how much Vitamin C or echinacea you throw at it, it rears its head each day just to remind you that things are not quite right and that more time is required before the lurgee is defeated.

Putting it in football terms, some extremely poor crowd figures in particular cities, the ongoing battle for a more significant presence on free-to-air television and the task of developing our young players to international standard on our own shores, continue to cause discussion and debate.

Seeing Wellington increase its supporter base, creating a comfy home on Channel Ten with the new backing of CBS and better development of youth, particularly attacking players, should be three of the key objectives for the powers at be.

There is no magic formula and time is the greatest ally that football in Australia has. However, sitting back and waiting for the natural evolution of football, as it morphs into the beast which it will undoubtedly become, isn’t the best course to follow.

Aggressive marketing, junior development and attracting fans of the international game to the league, are three key components in increasing the speed of the wave that football currently rides.

There is no doom and gloom, merely some tough decisions and moments ahead, where patience and poise will be key.

Expansion can’t be too far away, surely, and promotion-relegation must happen. Short term pain for long term gain might be a realistic part of the equation.

In identifying some of the future challenges and speed bumps ahead, it is dangerous to spread negativity or fatalism. Football will thrive, there is no doubt about that. There are so many young people playing the game, especially women, that the transfer of numbers will eventually take place.

However, the challenge of connecting the millions of footballing loving people in Australia to the A-League, to the point where they join clubs and attend matches more frequently, is our primary challenge.

Personally, I am surprised it hasn’t occurred already.

When I look at the A-League I see something that many don’t. Certainly the Euro snob crowd don’t, nor do some hard core supporters of other codes, who, unlike me, pitch their tent in one game and fail to see the skill and merit across a broader range of sports.

Sydney FC’s captain Alex Brosque (AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

So what do I see when I look at the A-League? The word ‘see’ is vital in that question. I can see it live and in prime time.

For generations Australians have watched football in the most inconvenient and offensive time zones. Watching EPL teams at three a.m. in the morning with match sticks in my eyes does my productivity at work no favours. Most European leagues fall into this category.

Major League Soccer in the U.S.A is a far more attractive option, as are some of the La Liga games which often hit our screens around eight or nine pm.

While some might suggest it foolish to include time zone and accessibility as a point of attractiveness for the A-League, one only has to think back to the uproar around the change in broadcaster rights for the EPL.

Foxtel customers were furious, sceptical of download speeds and reliability issues. They didn’t want a second box or tablet viewing while huddled under a doona.

The number of people who voted with their feet and are watching far less EPL than in previous years, myself included, is considerable.

Optus’ 2016 figures saw an 11.8 per cent decrease in profits despite a solid pickup in handset growth. Early 2017 figures suggested financial growth and a first step towards a payoff on their $189 million investment. Yet data from late 2016 suggested a drop off (10 per cent, approximately) in the number of Australians engaging with the EPL content.

Unless my allegiance lay with the big six, why would I bother? My league is accessible, supported by excellent midweek programs and viewed live in HD.

This season, as is mostly the case, predicting the winners of the A-League will prove immensely difficult. One would think Sydney FC, Melbourne Victory and Melbourne City will be strong once again. The Wanderers look extremely powerful and should feature once they have introduced themselves to each other and Perth, Brisbane and a rebuilt Adelaide should never be written off.

The Mariners will go in as youthful dark horses and the Jets and Phoenix will tail off most people’s pre-season selections. At this stage, I am only prepared to write of three teams from championship contention.

The A-League honour roll has seen six of the ten current clubs nab the ‘toilet seat’ and two others suffer losses in the grand final. Compare that with the two-clubbed La Liga and the absurd financial domination of the big six in England’s top league, throw in Scotland and other examples and my local league stacks up pretty well for parity.

Watching my A-League club each week makes sense to me. I understand Sydney FC, the city, the people. I get the fact that Sydney is inhabited by elitist snobs who look down upon the rest of the nation. Secretly we are proud of our exorbitant housing prices, we smugly grin, knowing we are just that far ahead of interstate peasants.

Following a local team means much more because of the understanding and appreciation of the identity and fabric of the organisation. Sure I can cheer on West Ham United yet what knowledge and deep connection do I have to the ‘Irons’. Despite my Anglo-Celtic heritage, the bonds are peripheral and circumstantial.

Even more tenuous are connections to other teams I enjoy watching and loosely support. Paris St Germain and AC Milan are merely good looking strips that caught my eye, rather than organisations with whom I share a true relationship.

PSG’s Neymar. (AP Photo/Kamil Zihnioglu)

People still look at me oddly when I tell them the A-League is my favourite league and they openly question my sanity when I tell them that the FFA Cup is my favourite Cup competition.

They cite the value of the players, the quality of play and the lack of attendees and atmosphere that pervades many games. I can see their view yet there is something they are missing.

What they don’t get is the fact that not everyone in the broad footballing landscape of Australia wants to watch overpaid megastars with whom they have little or no affiliation, play in lopsided mismatches at an ungodly hour.

Some of us are happy to watch our domestic league, with all its failings, quirks and idiosyncrasies, knowing full well that in the years to come we will squeeze into packed stadiums to watch our heroes.

All the time remembering that we were there at the beginning, when we bickered, wavered and buckled under the weight of our own expectations.

The Crowd Says:

2017-09-17T06:21:32+00:00

Charlie

Guest


GO Fulham!!!!

2017-09-15T21:15:23+00:00

Michael

Guest


you're making these comments without anything to back them up. I don't have a team in the EPL but watch 3 or 4 games every week because it is competitive. It's definitely not the best league in the world but you never know who's gonna win it. It's not just Real, Barcelona, Bayern, Juventus, PSG. The quality of the top 6 has been way down the past couple of years too which for me makes it more enjoyable. I dunno if you've watched the EPL since the 80's cos that seems to be how you see it, but it is by far the most enjoyable league in the world. Also don't know what your gripe with optus sport is? it's $15 a month as opposed to $55. Chuck a bein sports subscriptions on that for another 20 and you're still $20 under what you'd pay for Foxtel with the EPL instead of the A league. I've been to countless melb victory games because of course I support my local league, but its poor

2017-09-15T11:59:51+00:00

SamDS

Guest


Wonderful read. I love West Ham, but the only reason I support them is because of my dad (he's followed them since they came out to Aus in the 80s). I live in London right now and I've been to a few games at the OS, but regardless of the result I'd be over it by the time I got on the train at Stratford. With Sydney FC it's different, I feel pride when I watch them play well, I feel real anger when we play terribly...I was in tears after our ACL aggregate loss against Shandong. West Ham are still my team, but they'll never do that for me.

2017-09-15T07:35:00+00:00

David McDaniel

Roar Pro


I always think generalisations are a dangerous thing, I don't fit in any group. I starting supporting Chelsea in the 80's as they were my first subbuteo team that I bought due to the colour of the strip. I have supported them for 35+ years and have never been to England. I know all the players and can give you who I think should play from the top of my head. I got rid of Foxtel as it was a waste of money and have no interest in Optus. However, I am not a eurosnob as I was the first president of the Queensland Roar Supporters Club and I have been a season ticket holder for just about every season since inception. I was in the stadium until the end for all 3 grand finals and I rate the first one as the most amazing feeling ever in my sporting life, bigger than Chelsea winning the Champions League with RDM.

2017-09-15T06:28:21+00:00

Sydneysider

Guest


There's lots of positives for football at the moment, even if there are some speed humps along the path. Also, I'm not sure that BeIn show the Championship anymore. There hasn't been any games on BeIn since the Championship season started. These quotes below are from the Foxtel forum: "There has been a bit of interest and queries regarding the EFL Championship (English Championship League) and it's status on our sports channels. Unfortunately, as of right now, beIN SPORTS don’t have the rights to The EFL Championship. Discussions are ongoing & we hope to have the rights soon." So no Championship games on BeIn at the moment.

2017-09-15T06:09:20+00:00

Matt

Guest


Yeah, to your friends that cite quality as a reason not to watch A-League, tell them its getting better every year and part of the fun is watching the quality grow as the competition grows. Its great being a part of a code and competition on the up.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:08:51+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


What a great point. When you look at the state of commercial TV, it appears a few parts of your brain need to be removed in order to find it enjoyable. Football is too cerebral and patient compared to the nonsense they dish out each night of the week. I'll stick to good sports coverage on Foxtel.

2017-09-15T06:07:18+00:00

Matt

Guest


Im hoping bein sports can show more English Championship and League 1 games. I prefer them to the EPL. Im also watching more German league than ever before. I now go for Hertha Berlin (Yes because of leckie) I love the A-League, im a member of the Wanderers and the crowds are great. Ive been to NRL fans and its just yelling and oooh's and ahhhh's. The EPL the fans just sit and clap like its a point in Tennis. A-League attendances as a whole are going UP while NRL's are going down. Hell the Matildas have 17,000 + turning up tomorrow at Penrith, thats more than the Panthers finals NRL crowd.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:06:48+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Always happens Jason and it is a bit of a cross code thing. People love a winner. I was in a friends sports store recently and he was telling me how he has to guess a little in terms of the potential grand finalists because as soon as the teams qualify he sells out his stock in minutes. People love a winner. Human nature I guess.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:04:14+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Yep the ground breaking Raiders!

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:03:41+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Go Lleyton! Geez I cringe when I hear that crap.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:02:49+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


True Ian, and without the Broncos, I think the A-League just about has them covered.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:01:59+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


We are a bunch of tossers....no doubt. But we are good at it.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T06:00:56+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Tara must host.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:59:30+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


who is Alex?

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:58:12+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Limited and Xenophobic? If only you knew.

AUTHOR

2017-09-15T05:55:51+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


mmmmmm.....cred.

2017-09-15T05:05:40+00:00

Football is Life

Guest


Freddy, have you ever attended a World Cup either for Football or Rugby? Ever been to any multi-national sporting event? The adrenaline rush that comes from being in a truly international environment where there is no religion, race, colour etc is amazing. A true football fan understands that apart from having the knowledge to understand the game, its strategies and intricacies, it can unite like nothing else. Your comments are narrow minded, uneducated and completely and utterly self-centred. Since Mr Lowy had the generosity to create the A-League, get us into Asia, which has led to three successive World Cups, look at where football is now. With the NSL what did we have...internal squabbling and prejudice of just about every kind. Go to the Cove there's a united group of people. Go to the RBB, to the North or South end at Victory a united group of people supporting their team.

2017-09-15T05:03:57+00:00

Sam

Guest


What a joke. A-league and epl comparison!!

2017-09-15T04:24:59+00:00

dongdong

Guest


Ugh, give it a rest with the us v them comparison. It goes on and on every year. Don't take on the exact divisive mentality that pervades this country and has seen the A-League's reputation bashed every chance it gets . For some people it isn't about a local team it's simply about entertainment and there is nothing wrong with that. And some people like myself enjoy watching both. Live and let live and quit trying to chop everything down. Tall poppy syndrome rears its ugly head once again.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar