Cowboys can do what history shows '09 Eels should have

By maximus182 / Roar Guru

Eight years after crestfallen Parramatta lost a grand final to the formidable Melbourne Storm, North Queensland have an opportunity to claim the legitimate title that only cap cheating could rob the Eels of.

The parallels between the Eels of 2009 and the Cowboys of 2017 are both near and far.

Both snuck into the finals in eighth position, but only one had a strong run home with a string of victories.

Both, were at one stage in the season listed as $151 to win the title.

Both have a group of players playing without fear or favour of their opposition, but only one was missing their two co-captains for most of the season.

One most definitely had an individual performance that single-handedly propelled them in the grand final, but both have a broad collection of no-nonsense players who have lifted to their potential.

Think Jeff Robson, Joel Reddy and Ben Smith for the Eels, and think Shaun Fensom, Scott Bolton and John Asiata for the Cowboys.

And with destructive capacity, both sides have a forward who can lift and inspire their team with game-changing runs. You’ll know of Jason Taumalolo, but will you have remembered the impact of Fui Fui Moi Moi.

Eight years is a long time though, so how has the constant in this equation – the Storm – changed?

Same coach, same captain, same halfback, same fullback. That’s some consistency in a first-grade football side given the commercial influences of the modern game.

On paper, the Storm side this time around is considerably weaker than in 2009. And it should be, given the ’09 side was close to a million dollars over the salary cap.

But it’s a side still with attacking potency and muscle in defence, albeit with a different crop of men.

The main difference is the age of Melbourne’s big three. Do they possess eight more years of experience? Or do they have they eight more years of slowing down?

Cameron Smith’s second Dally M this week, Billy Slater’s fullback-of-the-year award and incredible comeback from two season-ending injuries this season, along with Cooper Cronk’s ability to guide Queensland to another Origin series’ victory, probably suggest the former.

But it was there in Smith’s performance in game one of Origin, in the match against the Eels in the first week of the NRL Finals, and again in the win over Brisbane last week. The mistakes, slow starts, un-Melbourne like decisions in their play.

The Storm are most certainly beatable and the Cowboys must believe it. That’s how they should view the Storm’s big three; older, slower, weaker.

But of the men who adorn the rest of the positions on the park is perhaps where the game will be won. Grand finals are a different ball-game. Nerves can get the better of the sharpest and calmest player.

Until last weekend, I didn’t even know who Melbourne’s centre Curtis Scott was. Perhaps naïve, but equally, who the hell is North Queensland’s John Asiata?

Melbourne have 11 players backing up from their 2016 grand final loss to Cronulla. Quite a number looking to exact revenge and make up for the lost chance.

(AAP Image/David Moir)

But just as similarly, North Queensland have 12 players in their line-up who played in their 2015 grand final win over Brisbane.

You have to wonder what the betting lines would be like if Johnathan Thurston and Matt Scott were playing on Sunday. Surely, near-on-par.

But that’s the thing, without those two, there is absolutely no pressure on the Cowboys. They’re meant to be on holidays by now. Who cares how far they go? No one expected them to come this far.

The pressure is on the Melbourne Storm, really. They lost in 2016 and have been the best all season as proven by their minor premiership.

Craig Bellamy will look to limit the impact of Jason Taumalolo and Michael Morgan, while Paul Green will hope to shut down the influence of Smith and Cronk.

The key players who can seriously influence this result outside of those listed stars are Melbourne’s wingers, Suliasi Vunivalu and Josh Addo-Carr, and the Cowboys’ forwards Gavin Cooper, Ethan Lowe and off the bench – Cohen Hess.

Can the outside-flyers find the space to put points on the board for the Storm? Likewise, can the cutting runs of the Cowboys hole-runners nab the two or three defining tries usually seen on grand final day?

Parramatta lost on the day in 2009, but history showed they were playing against an un-even spread of talent.

This time, for the Cowboys – and the Storm – the ledges are squared.

They might be missing the world’s best player, but at least North Queensland can know they’re not facing an unconquerable side.

But they don’t fear anyone, anyway, right? They’re meant to be on holidays.

Prediction: Cowboys to have two titles by Monday to go with their new stadium being built next season that Johnathan Thurston called for after winning their first in 2015.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2017-10-02T06:58:25+00:00

maximus182

Roar Guru


Hey Dean, Thanks for the reply champion. Been busy working in the real world since posting. If I'm correct, any story is 'made up' otherwise it would be a copy of someone else's right? My point regarding those two players was to emphasize how both of them have come into their respective sides so quickly, and how they would cope in the pressure of a Grand Final. Both did themselves proud. Thanks for the feedback, Cheers.

AUTHOR

2017-10-02T06:54:28+00:00

maximus182

Roar Guru


It was more to emphasize a point. Full credit to Asiata for doing what he has done. Has just come onto the scene and developed quickly. Good on him

AUTHOR

2017-10-02T06:53:24+00:00

maximus182

Roar Guru


Have a look at the two sides Peeeeko, this one has no Greg Inglis, Ryan Hoffman, Adam Blair or Dallas Johnson? That side was quality right across the park.

AUTHOR

2017-10-02T06:50:20+00:00

maximus182

Roar Guru


I would say the 3 'big' players are able to dominate a game more in 2017, thus their minor premiership this season. In 2009, there was more competitive teams on a week-to-week basis: St. George-Illawarra, Canterbury-Bankstown & Gold Coast. However if you look at Melbourne's line-up across the park in 2009, I reckon it had more players already in the developed stage of their career than in 2017. This year's Storm are quite young except for the experienced veterans. Can't see how the Dragons or Dogs would have made the GF in '09? Eels knocked off Dragons first week, Brisbane sent them packing in week two, and then the Eels took care of the Dogs in the preliminary. How would Storm not being in that comp have meant either of those two making the GF?

2017-09-30T10:50:55+00:00

Peter

Guest


"Doesn't have the guts", etc? Take a chill pill and enjoy the game!

2017-09-30T09:35:46+00:00

Dean

Guest


Storm & Cowboy fans both know who Curtis Scott and John Asiata are. Anyone who follows the game closely knows both of these players and knows that they are quality players. Both of them are playing quality football. The writer of this piece just throws his attempt at journalism out there and doesn't have the guts to respond to the replys given to him. Just a made up story. The only person I don't know in regards to this story is the person who wrote it. I think after this Sunday, one or both of these players is likely to pull of a play that will certainly make you remember them. I think you are a union supporter rather than a League supporter. Go Curtis Scott. Go John Asiata.

2017-09-30T08:32:31+00:00

up in the north

Roar Rookie


Who is John Asiata? He's the bloke who went from the Qcup to be starting half for the Cowbies in the first grade side. Then went on to feature with a significant impact as a starting front rower, he has been playing with a reported broken hand since finals started,with the acquisition of Tia maria old mate at 5/8. So that's some of what John Asiata has done. Special mention for Corey Jensen, a Bowenite who kept a Kangaroo front rower out of the side, legend

2017-09-30T04:47:43+00:00

peeeko

Guest


On paper, the Storm side this time around is considerably weaker than in 2009 really? but you dont really know about Asiata or Scott so that explains a lot

2017-09-30T04:46:59+00:00

not so super

Guest


no you arent, i checked the record books

2017-09-30T01:18:44+00:00

Dean

Guest


Yes, well said Duncan. lol

2017-09-30T00:50:39+00:00

Duncan Smith

Guest


Exactly, Emcie. Funny how Parra fans only look at the grand final, not the other semi finals. Besides, what i don't understand is why Gallop never stripped the 2008 40-0 grand final loss - that should be erased from history too!

2017-09-30T00:12:30+00:00

Emcie

Roar Guru


Never really bought into the arguement that Eels would have won the comp without the storm. The Storm also denied manly and brisbane a shot at the title, both of which had very strong teams

2017-09-29T23:41:04+00:00

Dean

Guest


Keep bringing up what happened all those years ago. Storm fans love it. We don't care, it only makes us stronger. Oh, and by the way, we are all still partying hard celebrating the 10th anniversary of the 2007 grand final win. Man, the winner's rings on The Storm's player's fingers look sensational.

2017-09-29T21:42:02+00:00

Duncan Smith

Guest


I've got to disagree with a couple of your points, Maximus. First Melbourne's 2009 side was not 'considerably stronger' than the current one. That team came fourth in 2009. The 2017 side is much better, in my view. Second, if Melbourne had somehow not been in that comp, due to cap cheating, then the whole season would have panned out differently. St George and Canterbury, who came in equal first on 38 points, may have played out the grand final, rather than the streaky Eels who snuck into 8th spot. It's all hypothetical.

Read more at The Roar