The best of the best: My world XV

By The Neutral View From Sweden / Roar Guru

Alrighty, it is time for Coach Neutral to show his hand.

My selection criteria are pretty simple, I have picked what I consider to be the best XV in the world right now, on recent form, not reputation over the years. Well, almost. Every coach is allowed to have personal favourite or two.

While most players are selected on individual brilliance solely (to be fair, I think all of them are brilliant), some are picked a little bit more to balance the team and give them an edge in every single aspect of the game.

1 Joe Moody
I want my side to completely destroy the other team’s front row at scrum time, so picking Moody is a no-brainer. But I want more than scrum dominance, I want soft hands, heads-up play in the loose and deep knowledge in dark arts also. Moody brings it all.

2 Malcolm Marx
It easy to get carried away and lose perspective after one standout game, but have we ever seen a game like that from a hooker before? And Marx is not a one hit wonder, he has been outstanding in a Lions team that has gone from the bottom to the top (almost) in two years time and since his introduction in the Springboks, the calls for bringing back Bismarck has gone missing.

3 Owen Franks
Almost ten years of excellence in All Blacks duty and still improving. What is not to like about that? His nous to find his opponent’s scrum weakness and make them wish they were somewhere else is off the scale.

Can the man read minds? And just like Moody, outside the scrum, he can be trusted to execute everything from brutal and life-changing tackles to flair moves that would make most backs green of envy.

4 Brodie Retallick
The most complete rugby player in the world and he performs at the same consistently high level that is reserved for the legends of the game. If Colin Meads and Richie McCaw had a love child, the result would be Brodie. Is there anything he can’t do? And I am not only speaking about his abilities on the rugby field, I am speaking off the field also.

5 Maro Itoje
The rise and rise of Itoje has been remarkable to witness. The kid delivers and proves doubters wrong on a weekly basis. A physical wonderchild with athletic abilities – that no-one matches in the rugby world – in sweet harmony with leadership and energy that lifts even tried and tested veterans. On top of that, he is seriously smart – on and off the field – and reads referees and offside lines like an open book.

6 Sam Warburton (c)
In a team that would bring more fire and fury than Donald Trump even can dream of, there is a need for a calm head with horse whispering skills to handle the refs, and Warburton is the best around. That he is an absolute beast at the breakdown with no regards what so ever for his personal safety with very underrated hands and skills help his cause also.

7 Sam Cane
In a team filled with stars, there is a need someone who does some heavy lifting and looks forward to ‘leg-days’ in the gym. I also like the idea of a seven that master the clean-out tackle with the same precision Conor McGregor lands his left hand (and with the same devastating effect).

8 Kieran Read
With Warburton and Cane heavy involved in the nitty-gritty stuff, Read would be able to roam in the wider channels where he is simply the best. And with Read around, any possible weakness Marx have as a lineout thrower is negated.

9 Aaron Smith
One of the first players on my team sheet. Plays on a different level than any other scrum-half in the world. His passes are so crisp that they could cut through diamonds and the speed of thought, legs and hands are frightening. And to come back to this level after all the commotion he had to deal with – and still dealing with – off the pitch tells a story of incredible mental strength.

10 Owen Farrell
Even my team will have an off day at times and for those days I want a kicker I can rely on to slot home pressure kicks. But I am not selecting Farrell solely for his kicking skills. He is a dedicated and well-rounded flyhalf with a mind committed to improving himself and the team. Also handy to have a direct line to Daddy Farrell is we should need some tactical advice.

11 Rieko Ioane
The latest flash flyer from the wing production line down in New Zealand. With ball in hand, he might be the fastest man in rugby these days. Reads the game very well and is totally fearless in contact situations. If a defender wants to take Ioane down, he better bring a couple of friends and a sledgehammer.

12 Ryan Crotty
The aim for my team is not only to score ten tries on average, but we would proud ourself to keep clean sheets also. Crotty is Mr Reliable that cleans up after everyone else and firmly closes any minor gaps that might occur on a bad day.

13 Jonathan Davies
Moulded in the same fabric as Crotty, he gives you 80 mistake-free minutes. Just like Crotty, he keeps things nice and tidy, and the pressure these two would put on the opponents would make it hard for them to even get out of their own 22 with the ball in hand.

14 Israel Folau
With so much talent around him – and coach who believes in him, plays him in the right position, and design tactics to get the pill out wide a lot – he would be able to showcase his strengths non-stop.

15 Ben Smith
Every coach has a few favourite players that they will put their trust in even at the darkest night. To me, Ben Smith is that player. On average he makes about three four mistakes a season. There are no flaws or weaknesses in his game and if there was a Nobel Prize in Rugby Smarts, Ben Smith would have won it every single year.

Impact players
16 Tendai Mtawarira

Has found a new spring in his step this year and carries the ball into contact like a … beast. He has seen it all, and found a scrum solution.

17 Dane Coles
Would have been a shoe-in this team a year ago, but concussions and Marx have forced him out of the starting XV; in the last stanza, he is a handful to contain, and won’t miss his jumpers, to close out a game.

18 Tadgh Furlong
When your lungs are burning after 60 minutes of hurt from Franks, the low-slung Furlong is a menacing nightmare for any opponent in open play or in the set piece.

19 Eben Etzebeth
Almost a coin toss between him and Itoje and Retallick; choosing between them is probably a ‘horses for courses’ decision on the day. Breaks the first tackle more often than not, and is a constant threat at the front of opponents’ lineout.

20 CJ Stander
Covers all three positions in the back row and that is very handy. A hard man to put down in the tackle, especially in the red zone.

21 Will Genia
Sports the same haircut and playing style as Aaron Smith, so there will be no confusion when Aaron gets a rest around the 60-minute mark. Still has the gas to snipe into the gap, and hates to lose.

22 Beauden Barrett
Not the best player in the world in my book, but he is the best impact player in the world, capable of turning the match around in one surprising play.

23 Kurtley Beale
Like Stander, he covers a lot of positions and only knows one speed: full.

The Crowd Says:

2017-10-17T10:57:22+00:00

cuw

Guest


Tuisova, Nagusa, Goneva Nandolo Patrick Osborne :)

2017-10-17T10:39:44+00:00

Schlongy McWollah

Guest


Ben Tameifuna Malcolm Marx Tadgh Furlong Eben Etzebeth Adam Coleman CJ Stander Jaco Kriel Billy Vunipola Will Genia Beauden Barrett Nemani Nadolo Samu Kerevi Tevita Kurindrani Waisake Naholo Israel Folau BOOMFA

2017-10-16T19:03:38+00:00

Riccardo

Guest


No logic here Jerry. And your point is also well made as usual.

2017-10-16T17:32:44+00:00

MIB2

Roar Rookie


Warburton is the only glaring anomaly in my book. Itoje to 6 whitelock to lock. Job done.

2017-10-16T02:14:39+00:00

Terry

Guest


Maybe cos Genia didn't Pway super Wugby in 2017 Ya thunk ?? Dum didee dum dIdde dum dum dum dum..... Derrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr ...

2017-10-15T08:45:52+00:00

Cuw

Guest


@ Taylorman there are enuf 3rd rowers in the world who play great. the problem is either they are in clubs ( and playing very little test rugger ) or they play in rubbish teams so dont get the recognition. just 2 names for u F Lowe - is the best 7 atm , as far as i am concerned. he is just great for Bath P Matera - is the best 6 atm , its just that he plays for Argies. there are others like Samu Manoa playing at 8 for Toulon ; Courtney Lawes playing at 6 for Saints ( who was voted player of September in Aviva) ; Sione Kalamafoni at 8 for Leicester ( who has made the most carries in Aviva so far) ......

AUTHOR

2017-10-15T06:16:11+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


19 Leone Nakarawa Not noticed by many becoz he plays little test rugger, but his skills are stuff for legends. Just watch Racing 92 match this weekend vz Leicester. RonanO’Gara has said the R92 team is suffering becoz everyone wants to play like Nakarawa and try to offload causing mistakes. I watched the game and he was the king of the park. Just wow!

2017-10-15T05:16:24+00:00

Cuw

Guest


dude the best 6 in AVIVA for September was COURTNEY LAWES. the most penalized player in Aviva was Maro Itoje :)

2017-10-15T05:09:04+00:00

Cuw

Guest


simple fact is - Eddie Jones trusts Ford to be his 10 . that shud tell u something :)

2017-10-15T05:06:16+00:00

Cuw

Guest


1 Joe Moody 2 Malcolm Marx 3 Tadgh Furlong 4 Brodie Retallick 5 Eben Etzebeth - Sir Clive Woodward thinks he will walk into the England team. Need I say more?? 6 Pablo Matera Ok, Argies play right and left flankers , but Matera can do everything an openside or blindside can do. Its just that he plays in a rubbish team. 7 Francois Louw The best 7 in the world atm. Watch Bath , watch Bokke , his work rate is just great this year be it 6, 7 or 8!! 8 Kieran Read (C) 9 Aaron Smith 10 Johnny Sexton Dude: Sexton was played despite being injured. That says it all. He is a better 10 than most give him credit for. 11 Rieko Ioane 12 Ryan Crotty 13 Jonathan Davies 14 Juan Imoff Pity he is not being selected by Argies , becoz he is one of the best in the world , be it 7S or XVs rugger. 15 Ben Smith Impact players 16 Tendai Mtawarira 17 Dane Coles 18 Uni Antoni He is big and strong and gets around fine. :) 19 Leone Nakarawa Not noticed by many becoz he plays little test rugger, but his skills are stuff for legends. Just watch Racing 92 match this weekend vz Leicester. RonanO'Gara has said the R92 team is suffering becoz everyone wants to play like Nakarawa and try to offload causing mistakes. 20 Sean O'Brian Onlything he does not have that A Savea has is speed. 21 Will Genia 22 Beauden Barrett 23 Liam Williams He has created more trouble for all blacks than anyone else in the last 3 years. In the form of his life atm.

2017-10-14T01:29:31+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


Yes seems Barretts the obvious one, 11 posters alone here opting for Barrett. Stands out really.

2017-10-14T01:12:44+00:00

Kirky

Roar Rookie


Jeezuz Fionn where'd you dredge that lot from? Genia over Smith!!!!, Vermuelen over Read - If you have any inkling of getting to be an International Coach, get your sums right!!! - Cruden?????

2017-10-13T23:55:41+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


Yeah that is true Taylorman, Farrell is a superb goal kicker but he nowhere near the playmaker the Barrett is...Barrett is the best play maker in the world right now and by some distance when he brings his A game. And you are right , he has had some ordinary performances against the AB's in the past that's for sure when he has started at 10.. Who do want ? A player who might win you the game scoring 3 pointers or one who get your more five-seven pointers and Barrett is still kicking pretty okay at international level overall - he has his days off but has kicked at 100% in games as well and that is from everywhere with lots of tries so I know who I would have at 10.- its a no brainer And Farrell does not have Barretts X-factor either with that blinding pace and acceleration Barrett has - there is gap between then in class around the field that is for sure. Farrell plays at 12 for England and there are several reason for this obviously, but one is that he is not as good a playmaker as George Ford but is good 12 and second play maker now his defence has got much better over the years. The other thing Barrett offers is he can play fullback and wing really well if there are injuries during the game. Farrell is really a 10 or 12 at test level.

2017-10-13T23:40:59+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


Yeah I agree Fionn Goodhue had a stand out season and offers real pace as well and he defends his channel well -I can't understand why he hasn't been given a decent run in one of the games. Maybe the Tour to Europe he will get his chance. But he is a serious prospect that's for sure.

2017-10-13T23:40:59+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


Yeah I agree Fionn Goodhue had a stand out season and offers real pace as well and he defends his channel well -I can't understand why he hasn't been given a decent run in one of the games. Maybe the Tour to Europe he will get his chance. But he is a serious prospect that's for sure.

2017-10-13T18:22:30+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


Odd comment, but anyway, as I said, good side, spoiled by Farrell. In thinking about it, in a year where no one individual stood out Farrell could actually be up for POTY as well. Like Itoje, steady all year and played right through.

AUTHOR

2017-10-13T16:35:17+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


What are you up to? Seriously. Are you lonely and bored?

AUTHOR

2017-10-13T16:27:50+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


On their day, your boys would still be able to create some thunder, no doubt. But it is unfair that I had the first 23 picks. Maybe we should produce a "card game" like the ones we had as kids with cars and airplanes with four five key values, (remember them?) but with rugby players? Could be a fun thing to do play while drinking.

AUTHOR

2017-10-13T16:22:10+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Four-hour dinners with bread and butter only?

2017-10-13T16:03:49+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Pollard is only 23, also.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar