Melbourne City vs Sydney FC: A-League live scores, blog

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Melbourne City and Sydney FC face off at AAMI Park in a top-of-the-table clash. Join The Roar for live scores and commentary from 7:50pm (AEDT).

City have been stoic in defence, yet have also found ways to put the ball in the net in every match, parlaying that into four wins to sit atop the ladder.

Sydney have also started well, with only their draw against the Wanderers tarnishing their season to this point.

They premiers haven’t quite hit the heights of their stellar 2016-17, however there have been enough early signs to suggest that they will be somewhere around the mark when the finals roll around.

Therefore, this becomes an acid test for City and a night where they could stake a claim for early A-League favouritism. All eyes will be on Ross McCormack once again, after his impressive start to the campaign, yet his supporting cast of Tim Cahill and Bruce Kamau could be just as vital in finding ways past a usually reliable Sydney defence.

Sydney will no doubt look to their talisman Milos Ninkovic, while Bobo is in goal-scoring form and looking sharper and fitter than last season.

After coming off the bench recently, it will be interesting to see how Graham Arnold uses Adrian Mierzejewski and the attacking options of both teams could make for a classic encounter.

Prediction
In a tense and potentially brutal encounter, it is hard to see an avalanche of goals. In a game sure to be decided by key moments and opportunistic chances, a draw seems likely.

Melbourne City 1-1 Sydney FC

Catch all the action on The Roar live coverage from 7:50pm (AEDT).

The Crowd Says:

2017-11-03T22:58:20+00:00

Redondo

Guest


JB - I totally agree. It's so frustrating seeing otherwise excellent footballers regularly choose the wrong pass or play the right pass poorly. For Sydney, O'Neill and Zullo are also guilty too often. Hopefully Ninkovic will teach them how to do it right before he leaves. Equally frustrating is watching poor crossing from fullbacks and wingers, when that is their primary attacking role. They mustn't do enough focussed skills training in the off-season. I'd have them repeat practicing 'sprint 30, cross while at full speed, hit target'. I''d also stick a 2mtr dummy between them and the target - it's amazing the number of crosses that hit the first defender. At night, they'd be watching Beckham highlights - first the early years to see how it's done, then the late years to see what happens when opponents work out you can only bend the ball from right to left.

2017-11-03T22:54:14+00:00

LuckyEddie

Guest


Wrong language.

2017-11-03T22:22:57+00:00

punter

Guest


No worries Eddie, we just see things in different ways, because even in the dark days of Frank Farina I never thought of ever joining a AFL club. You see MV (2nd best team last year) played a very aggressive, cynical way in the GF, they did again this year, MC (top of the table before last night), did the same yesterday, trying to nullify our superior play & played a very cynical game & outside of Fitzgerald had nothing in attack. SFC combats this to win the game.

2017-11-03T22:17:32+00:00

punter

Guest


JB, this is the same question I have been asking about Australian football for the last 50 years. Even in the so called 'golden generation' we had very few players with this basic skill, yet many of them were playing in the PL.

2017-11-03T22:10:55+00:00

j,binnie

Guest


Redondo - You get very near to pointing to a "flaw" in our locally bred players. Brillante is not alone in having a problem in "poor passing in tight situations". If you measure the "unforced errors" in any team's "passing game" you will find it is a problem endemic to most of our young local players. That takes us back to grassroots football in our country and the coaching at that level, It also poses the question why is it that imported players appear to be better at that basic skill than our Aussie youngsters battling to make their mark in the HAL. Cheers jb.

2017-11-03T21:09:21+00:00

LuckyEddie

Guest


Yes and probably you and Arnold are the only ones excited. A game of predicatable bring football with a second half of Sydney cynical tackles and time wasting. Boring and FFA does FA. If Arnold ever got Socceroos I think I would join an AFL club and just give up.

2017-11-03T13:40:32+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Good point but also to the south and inner city suburbs... Around St George and the whole area around it ... its Football first .... Two teams have shown how and the second team copied the first... Nick Tanna at Perth Glory way back in the bad times of the NSL had huge crowds as he connected with the local associations.... The Northern Spirit copied his methods and even through The Northern Spirit had four other Sydney clubs to compete against drew crowds similar to SFC in their first couple of years ... and they did it via the associations... In case you think Nick Tanna was crazy I listed to a speech he made once when he said if you have limited dollars to spent in promotion then spent it where the players are as they at least have an interest in the game...

2017-11-03T13:28:20+00:00

Redondo

Guest


The eastern suburbs is an obvious problem. Over time I've walked away from Allianz in 3 directions; towards Bondi Junction, towards Kings Cross and towards Central. I'd swear that at least 95% of the foot traffic after games heads to Central. I can't believe everyone from the east drives to games, because getting out at the end of a game is a grind. It'd be quicker to walk 3k than drive. There's no point going to Central to catch a train to the eastern suburbs - you might as well walk to Bondi Junction. I don't know how much effort Sydney has put into connecting with the eastern suburbs but whatever they've done hasn't had much effect. It would be interesting to see the postcodes for memberships.

2017-11-03T13:13:03+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Stuart You have Eastern & Southern Sydney plus the inner city ... IMO the league needs to solve the SFC problem in lack of crowds given IMO what it has to draw upon... SFC have connections most clubs would die for yet its inability to get more mainstream media and capture the vast Football culture around it is a huge worry moving forward.... to me has always shown a management team capable of running BHP or a major bank ... but would struggle to run the local canteen for a park team... I have always been of the opinion that A-League clubs need to connect to their local district associations and SFC have failed badly at this. To me professional Football in Australia whether Hal, NSL or Pre NSL has not build the sport .... SBS go on about Sydney United etc ... but never about Southern Districts ie the association they play in. AS I see it again our reporting history has given the professional side of the game credit it does not deserve in the building of the player base.... the player base was build by the regional associations their local park teams and community volunteers. There is no connect between the professional game and the player base ... why we only have somewhere between 18 & 20 % of the player base connected to the A-League whereas the others codes this percentage is around 86%. Its not location for SFC its an inability to connect to its local player base... BTW this same thing applies to most clubs... but if we can solve SFC we can solve it for all...

2017-11-03T12:47:14+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


Fair enough. If you SydFc fans are content with how the club is engaging, that's all that matters. From the outside, it looks like there are major problems. Remember, SydFc is currently the Double Champions & in FFA Cup Final. They've lost 1 in past 35. Imagine if they started losing? What happens then?

2017-11-03T12:41:00+00:00

Redondo

Guest


Stuart - maybe the lack of appeal in the vicinity of Allianz is a marketing failure on Sydney's part. A good part of the booming crowds at Football in the US are students/youth/hipsters attracted to football because it's European/cosmopolitan and not ethnocentric, like gridiron/baseball. Just the kind of crowd living close to Allianz. I walk past them all in Elizabeth Bay, Potts Point, Kings Cross, Darlinghurst, Paddington on the way to games and feel like I should be handing out Sydney FC brochures as I go past. I understand the travel issues but that's why Sydney should be pushing harder in its current area - lots of scope to sell an international sport to young people as NRL and Rugby decline.

2017-11-03T12:15:19+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Mental floss is very useful sometimes

AUTHOR

2017-11-03T12:15:02+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Wanted to say this in French, however I can't speak the language. What many fail to understand about Sydney is that the crowds will never grow whilst Sydney fc play at Allianz. It is physically impossible, impractical or unreasonable for most fans to get to the games In the east. The eastern suburbs continues to become more tourist orientated and flooded with units and townhouses where students and temporary residents dominate the landscape, hardly a basis for bigger crowds at Allianz. The future for Sydney is at ANZ. I am biased as I am a member of the ground yet there are more Sydney fc members out west than ever and it is just a shame they cannot make it to the games in the city. For people passing judgement on Sydney Crowds, they need to come and live in the city for a period to truly understand the limitations to travel and the disencentives that exist to attend games. A powerful Sydney FC at ANZ would pull 20,000 each week if committed to the venue.

2017-11-03T11:59:17+00:00

Redondo

Guest


Nemesis - plug the A-League and Sydney's average attendances since 2011 into excel and you'll see Sydney's are trending up better than the rest of the A-League's. Over the life of the A-League Sydney is going up and the A-League has flatlined.Perhaps some focus should be on other clubs to lift their game.

2017-11-03T11:55:00+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


MV people who live in glass houses ... hhhmmm... To me and Punter will back me up here I in the first say six years of Hal SFC drove me mad ... how could a team with so much going for it ... in the heart of a Football area get such poor crowds... I have mellowed in my criticism but SFC as the club has improved its management ... but while we bang on about the appeal of our game I look at SFC and ask myself why don't you draw much bigger crowds .... Moore Park is a traffic nightmare as and Central station to Moore Park is a very decent walk starting up a reasonable hill... but it can't be that simple... I sometimes thing many posters want things to be different ... and think simplistic solutions will drive change... I hope I am wrong, I pray I am wrong, but dramatic changes to structures and competitions, based on I want it this way and think it will happen, without due diligence, will lead to more sorrow and heartache and we will blame the newly appointed management team. I think its important we find out why SFC don't draw 23 to 35 K regularly....

2017-11-03T11:40:17+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


If a win is all that matters, Sydney FC fans should be flocking to games. The team has lost 1 match out of the past 35. Perhaps, there's more to attracting fans to watch a team than simply winning. Having said that, this match far exceeded my expectations. I'd expected a 0-0 score. So, to have one goal was hugely exciting.

2017-11-03T11:37:24+00:00

Redondo

Guest


Peut-être elle essaie de vous faire venir au lit. Trop de football ce soir.

AUTHOR

2017-11-03T11:28:37+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


We are Punter but geez that was a painful game. Friday nights should be more exciting than that.

AUTHOR

2017-11-03T11:26:58+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Thanks for tuning in to the blog tonight and I apologise for some of the dirty French language that appeared. I didn't understand most of it, but my wife translated and it was astonishingly dirty. Midfielder has always been one of my favourite contributors on theroar, tonight I have never been so impressed. Love you Mid!

AUTHOR

2017-11-03T11:22:03+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


In a match that never reached the heights expected of a clash between the top two teams in the competition, Sydney FC have defeated Melbourne Victory 1-0 at AAMI Park. The first half was a lacklustre affair where both teams seemed content to sit and restrict their opponents and chances were few and far between. The 0-0 score line at the break was reflective of the contest and the second forty five promised more than the first period. It took sixty one minutes for the deadlock to be broken and the unlikeliest of sources in Luke Wilkshire was the provider. Sydney stuck to their defensive structures through the remainder of the contest and despite a few half-chances, City never seemed likely. Sadly, many were more interested in the plight of the injured Tim Cahill who limped off with an ankle injury in the first half and with the upcoming play-off against Honduras looming, their angst was a natural reaction. For Sydney, they have re-affirmed their quality and City will seek to rebuild and take on the sky blues next time round in Sydney. Whilst not being a game of immense entertainment value, it does set up an interesting return encounter. Final Score City 0 Sydney 1

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar