Australia's Ashes squad announced: Analysing every player picked

By Scott Pryde / Expert

The Ashes are just under a week away and, after months of speculation and three rounds of Sheffield Shield results, Australia have finally named their team for the first Test. Here’s our reaction to the players announced in Brisbane this morning.

»The Ashes Squads

More cricket
» Golden Ashes: Australia’s best partnerships
» Paine, Marsh, Bancroft in Ashes squad
» Womens Ashes Test proves a success
» COMMENT: Paine’s selection is a farce
» COMMENT: Australia’s pace to rattle England

Steve Smith (New South Wales, captain)
The Aussie captain started the summer in a bit of a form rut, but has quickly worked his way out of it under intense media scrutiny for his team selections both with New South Wales and Australia.

Some solid scores last round at Hurstville, backed up by another 44 in the first innings against Queensland, should alleviate any major concerns about the skipper’s form.

Smith is key to Australia’s chances in the Ashes. His technique is one of a kind and he scored a stack of runs last summer. If he can do the same this time around, Australia are a step closer to taking out the biggest series on the international calendar.

David Warner (New South Wales, vice-captain)
There was never a question about the vice-captain being selected after scoring plenty of runs in Bangladesh and a mountain of them last summer.

Despite that, Warner needs to make a statement in the first Test. Being honest, most batsmen in the Australian top seven are struggling for form with plenty of the wickets during the first three rounds of the Sheffield Shield.

Warner made a streaky 83 in his first innings of the summer during the pink ball round, but has dropped off since then. A run of single-figure scores, including back-to-back innings of five against Western Australia at Hurstville, means he won’t be feeling all that confident getting ready to face the bowling of James Anderson and Stuart Broad.

He at least cracked double figures in the first innings against Queensland, making 26. We all know Warner’s talent, but there will be more than a few Aussie fans feeling nervous when he strides out at the Gabba.

Cameron Bancroft (Western Australia)
Bancroft’s resume has stacked up over the past fortnight to the point where he can no longer be ignored. He made a shock T20 international debut two summers ago against India, but after carrying his bat once against New South Wales – who had the Australian attack in that match – and scoring 86 in the other innings, he came into contention.

He then went out and smacked 228 not out against South Australia in the third round, before going straight back out and keeping.

The selectors have gone the route of opening the batting, which makes sense given it’s where he scored his runs for the Warriors.

He won’t be donning the gloves though, and that’s probably for the best given the demands of being on the field for most of the Test, keeping and batting at the top of the order.

Jackson Bird (Tasmania)
The Tasmanian spearhead is very much Australia’s perennial 12th man these days. He gets selected in most squads, plays if there’s an injury and more often than not does a solid job.

He isn’t on the same level as Australia’s three first-choice quicks, but he is reliable. That much has been proven in the Shield and there was never really a question about him being included in the squad.

Bird has been in some decent Shield form as well. Expect him to be released from the squad after the match starts so he can keep bowling overs for the Tigers and remain fit in case of injury ahead of the rest of the series.

Pat Cummins (New South Wales)
Of all the first-choice bowlers, Cummins probably had the biggest questions at the selection table. Injuries have hampered his career, so the chance of him getting through five Tests seems slim, even if he did get through two in Bangladesh in what were trying conditions.

His form hasn’t been sensational in the Shield either. He has taken wickets, but isn’t bowling at the standard which might be expected.

His pace and bounce, alongside Mitchell Starc, gives Australia two genuinely scary options to lead the attack.

Peter Handscomb (Victoria)
After bursting onto the Test scene last year, the Victorian has flown under the radar in the last few weeks. With all the attention – rightly so – on the opening, No.6 and wicketkeeper positions, Handscomb’s scores have gotten little coverage.

They are far from disastrous, but they are a small cause for concern. Nine, 34, 43, 58, 0 and 13 is the run for the Victorian.

There’s a half-century and a couple of starts there, but under extreme pressure in the biggest series on the international calendar, you’d like him to be in better form, especially given the issues across the rest of the Aussie order.

He could find himself in a sticky situation more than once this summer.

Josh Hazlewood (New South Wales)
Hazlewood has an important role to play against England. With Cummins and Starc both possessing genuine pace and the ability to strike fear into the English, Hazlewood will be playing the Glenn McGrath-type role.

He reminds me (and everyone else) of McGrath, from his action to consistent line and length. He may well be Australia’s best since McGrath and will need to play the steadying hand during the Ashes, bowling along the two firebrand quicks.

Usman Khawaja (Queensland)
The man who made No.3 his own last summer is back in the side after missing the second Test in Bangladesh, and it’s hardly a surprise.

Khawaja was really only dumped because, let’s face it, playing spin in Asia isn’t his strongest point. He struggles big time, but back on Australian decks, there is no better option at the top of the order for the Aussies.

Khawaja comes into the match having scored a century against the pink ball and another two half-centuries against New South Wales in the most recently completed round. It’s an impressive form line and, if he can produce a summer of runs like the last couple, he will be a key man for Australia.

Nathan Lyon (New South Wales)
Lyon is Australia’s greatest ever off-spinner. He has 269 Test wickets at 31.83 and, while he has his knockers, there’s no better spinning option.

The questions surrounding his place in the side ended with the injury to James Pattinson. With no chance of playing four quicks, Lyon is now in a position where he can provide the Aussies an X-Factor in the Ashes.

With Moeen Ali being England’s first choice spinner, Lyon could be a difference maker.

Not only that, but bowling spin in Australia is a difficult art. Flat pitches and little assistance make it a difficult exercise at best. We have seen opposition spinners come here and get their pants pulled down for years, so Lyon’s role is crucial.

Shaun Marsh (Western Australia)
Another chance. Yep, Shaun Marsh has been granted another chance in the national set-up. It’s almost unbelievable, but with no other candidates throwing their hand in the air, I guess Marsh was left as the only option.

He has been in and out of the Australian team like a yo-yo over the years. He has plenty of potential, but struggles for consistency at the best of times, failing to go on with starts. He averages just 36 in Test cricket and this surely will be his last chance – for Australian fans, hopefully it’s not a short-lived, frustrating one.

Tim Paine (Tasmania)
The Tasmanian keeper has played four Test matches, the last of which came in 2010. On top of that, he has a first class batting average of 29.

While he scored a half-century against England playing for the CA XI last week and another for Tasmania in his first Shield game of the season this week, it’s a left-field decision from the selectors. One most hadn’t even thought about before reports caught everyone by surprise on Thursday evening.

Let’s be honest – we didn’t see this one coming, and who really knows if it’s the right call. I’m reserving judgement based on the lack of runs from all the other key candidates. The selectors were backed into a corner, and this was their answer.

Chadd Sayers (South Australia)
Coming off a 62-wicket season in 2016-17, Sayers has well and truly earned his call-up to the Test squad. While he’s unlikely to play, and will probably be released from the squad in the days leading up to the first Test, the experience he gains from this will be invaluable.

Sayers is a different sort of bowler to the three first-choice quicks – he’s slightly slower, but is accurate and can move the ball both ways, something that aided him greatly last season.

His figures haven’t been on the same level to start 2017-18, but he still has 14 wickets and toiled hard during the most recent round at the WACA on a lifeless deck.

A well-deserved selection which acknowledges form with the red ball in Shield cricket.

Mitchell Starc (New South Wales)
The bowling attack has been locked in since the end of the Bangladesh tour. The only question was fitness, but Starc has come back with plenty of intensity, taking two hat-tricks in Round 2 against Western Australia.

He will strike fear into the hearts of England, and could well have a summer similar to that of Mitchell Johnson during the last English Ashes tour.

The spearhead might have trouble matching the 38 wickets Johnson took, but you get the feeling he won’t be far away against a potentially brittle English batting order.

Roarers, what do you make of Australia’s team for the first Test on November 23 in Brisbane? Drop a comment below and let us know.

The Crowd Says:

2017-11-20T07:44:04+00:00

Aidan

Guest


And who would you drop any of those players for? Warner and Smith are safe until they retire, Warner gets lambasted for being too aggressive, for not valuing his wicket.He currently averages 47.94 with the bat,has 5705 runs, has passed 100 twenty times, and 50 twenty-four times. For someone who has no value of his wicket, he sure seems to score a lot of runs, also, if I am not mistaken with my maths, he faces 62 balls an innings (I agree, this could be higher, however he's facing over 10 overs himself per innings) as well as passing 50 every 2.8 innings. (Again, I agree for the caliber of player he is, this could be slightly higher, however it is still higher than anyone putting their hand up for his position). None of Starc, Hazelwood or Lyon have their positions under any sort of pressure from anyone else in sheffield shield cricket, and would make most of all the XI's around the world. Cummins is the only one you could question, and even thats only due to his past injuries. Stop complaining about NSW bias, start complaining that your states batsmen/bowlers are performing to a sub standard rate if they truly are up to international test cricket, cause there is truly only a small handful of players showing that they are.

2017-11-18T09:07:57+00:00

John Erichsen

Roar Guru


Careful DavSA, the "greatest ever" tag doesn't mean what you think it means. Well, not in Australia.

2017-11-18T09:05:19+00:00

John Erichsen

Roar Guru


I am keen to see what pitches are served up this summer. Do CA back Warner, Khawaja and Smith to perform better than Cook, Root, and the Ali, Bairstow combo on bowler friendly pitches or will that bring Anderson and Broad more into the series? I anticipate Starc, Hazlewood and Cummins will be more threatening than the English bowlers on less lively pitches so perhaps that protects our batting lineup from having Jimmy and Stuart run through them ala Edgbaston and Trent Bridge 2015. It wouldn't be a confident or positive move by CA, but neither was selecting Marsh yet again,

2017-11-17T21:48:19+00:00

ColinP

Guest


Yeah he bowled beautifully in England, looks a real find. Moeen also bowled well it has to be said and has improved substantially

2017-11-17T15:18:31+00:00

Ben Brown

Guest


Qwetzen so a keeper has to bat like a top 5 batsman then? Get of your high horse you mug

2017-11-17T10:04:27+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


I didn't leave it out but you're right, you clearly weren't saying that and I should've been more careful not to misrepresent you.

2017-11-17T09:02:47+00:00

Johnny Dalmas

Guest


Come on, Renshaw wasn't selected based on his recent form not because of a cherry-picked comment from someone who isn't even a selector. For the record I would have selected Renshaw, Banfield and Cartwright in the squad. Renshaw and Cartwright are both the incumbents in their position and Banfield is obviously the form player outside of the last Test team.

2017-11-17T08:05:14+00:00

DavSA

Guest


John, Maharaj may be an unknown in Aus but here in SA is already been touted as our " greatest spinner ever".Mind you not much competition though.

2017-11-17T08:01:32+00:00

DavSA

Guest


Was Khawaja unexpected ? I personally rate him highly but he has been a bit of a Yo-Yo man for the selectors .

2017-11-17T07:45:42+00:00

plxmn

Guest


The Australian cricket team selection should be by postal vote by the public. $100m+: worth it. No more 34 year olds making comebacks when there is no obvious clear form to do so.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:45:04+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Interesting points John, but I can't see spin having much of an impact on this summer. Moeen Ali isn't a first choice spinner, and will get shelled very similar to Mark Craig when NZ last toured. Lyon will do an okay job, but again, probably not one that's going to turn any heads. Thanks for that as well! Can't wait for things to get underway.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:42:38+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Ha, yeah - sums it up well. No keeper (apart from Bancroft) demanded selection

2017-11-17T07:41:55+00:00

qwetzen

Guest


So logically he'll soon have a trifle named after him.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:41:09+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Weatherald was superb in his last hit. Could come into calculations at the end of the summer if he keeps scoring runs.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:40:28+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Hurts your head if you're an Aussie supporter. Of course, Stokes won't be here till the third Test at the earliest according to most reports.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:39:22+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Yeah agree with Rellum here. Langer wasn't the only one going after Renshaw.

AUTHOR

2017-11-17T07:38:21+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


"I guess" is an important phrase you happened to leave out Burgy Green. That's the way the selectors might see it, but I sure don't. I'd much prefer having a fifth bowling option and one of the all rounders for a multitude of reasons.

2017-11-17T07:36:15+00:00

qwetzen

Guest


"Section 44 of the CA Constitution forbids players with dual citizenship or the entitlement to dual citizenship". Well that's Qld thoroughly gutted then...

2017-11-17T07:33:34+00:00

qwetzen

Guest


Ashley, the Vics have won it three years in a row (and 5 of the last 9). This insignificant detail hasn't stopped CNSW from blithely stating; "Six NSW players have been named in a 13-man squad for the first two Magellan Ashes Series Tests in Brisbane and Adelaide, *** highlighting the state’s continuing domination of Australian cricket***.". https://goo.gl/rADP2G And they can't understand why nobody likes them...

2017-11-17T07:24:36+00:00

dave

Guest


Marsh has now had more comebacks than dame nellie melba.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar