Contenders' failures helped Marsh: Taylor

By News / Wire

Shaun Marsh can credit his Test experience for his surprise Ashes berth, according to former Australia captain Mark Taylor, as other No.6 contenders failed to bang down the selection door.

The 34-year-old Marsh has earned his eighth Test recall during a career plagued by injuries and form troughs, and will face England in the series opener that starts in Brisbane on Thursday.

The left-hander was overlooked for the recent Test tour of Bangladesh, bouncing back to top the run-scoring in the domestic one-day competition and scoring 91 for Western Australia against an all-Test NSW attack during a recent Sheffield Shield game in Sydney.

But his selection has raised eyebrows given five players not in the Test team – Jake Weatherald, Callum Ferguson, Alex Doolan, Marcus Harris and Jake Lehmann – had scored more runs over the first three Shield games.

Taylor said Marsh had benefited from his familiarity with selectors.

“Glenn Maxwell made one hundred but hasn’t nailed the spot down. Other people they’ve tried – Mitchell Marsh, Hilton Cartwright haven’t made enough runs,” Taylor told AAP.

“So they wanted a guy at (No.) 6 who they know can make runs for them. That’s why they’ve gone back to Shaun Marsh.

“They’ve tried (Marcus) Stoinis in the one-dayers, Cartwright they’ve given a couple of Tests to and Mitchell Marsh in the past – these guys have all been tried there.

“Once again selectors are looking for them to do what Bancroft has done – belt the door down, demand selection. That hasn’t happened. That’s why they’ve gone with Shaun Marsh.”

Head selector Trevor Hohns backed Marsh, who has scored four Test tons and helped salvage a draw in Ranchi earlier this year, to deliver ahead of less-experienced contenders.

“The younger players we have chosen over the past 12 months or so, at this stage haven’t given us enough performance to be chosen in the initial squad for the Ashes,” Hohns said.

“The Ashes is very important, we don’t feel it’s the ideal venue to inject them again.”

Given his age, it’s likely this will be Marsh’s last chance at Test level, with retired Test skipper Michael Clarke confident he will repay selectors’ faith.

“The advantage of having someone like Shaun is he can bat anywhere in the order,” Clarke said.

“I’ve always rated him and it’s great he’s earned his position.”

The Crowd Says:

2017-11-19T11:42:48+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


By the end of 2017, he'll probably have another year in the 50s.

2017-11-19T11:41:32+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


2014,15,16 and 11. Check out the link Captain Cranky sent above. Impressive, hey?

2017-11-19T09:23:35+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


What years did he average over 40?

2017-11-19T04:49:21+00:00

Captain Cranky

Guest


It's all in the semantics. I consider these stats as "reasonable" or "not bad", but "very strong batting" and "outstanding" is quite a creative description of Marsh's batting record.

2017-11-19T04:28:37+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


George,you can complain on as many seperate articles as you like but two simple facts remain...Shaun Marsh will deservedly be yet again pulling on the baggy green to represent his country and 90% of what's been said by the armchair experts over the past month has been proven incorrect,in actual fact most of the armchair predictions havnt even been close.

2017-11-19T04:14:13+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Which particular cherry are you rejecting, George? Or are you speaking in cliches?

2017-11-19T04:12:56+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


4 years averaging over 40 and one of them over 50. What more do you need? That is outstanding. Good stats Captain Cranky.

2017-11-19T03:13:54+00:00

George

Guest


Absolute cherry-picked garbage as per usual.

2017-11-18T23:06:25+00:00

Captain Cranky

Guest


Okay, here's Marsh's Test stats by calendar year: http://www.howstat.com/cricket/Statistics/Players/PlayerYears.asp?PlayerID=3561 His overall average is 36.00, but after a poor 2012 he's still averaged only 39.16 in the last four calendar years. That doesn't suggest "very strong batting since".

2017-11-18T22:40:28+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


When Taylor and Clarke can look at Marsh and point to his success, it should make Marsh's knockers realise that truth. They won't. They will keep quoting an average affected by a run of failures from almost 6 years ago and suggesting that ducks scored then have something to do with now. A test average just shy of 40 despite that run 6 years ago over only 23 Tests indicates some very strong batting since.

Read more at The Roar