Sacrifices and opportunities: Life not too grim for former Force players

By Will Knight / Expert

I wonder what Taniela Tupou thinks of the latest grumble from a former Western Force player.

Two days after Tupou’s family home in Tonga was swept away by Cyclone Gita’s 200 km/hr winds, new Melbourne Rebels captain Adam Coleman was on Wednesday reiterating how his ex-Force teammates had sacrificed so much in moving from Perth to the Victorian capital to continue their rugby careers.

“Just got off the phone with my brother from Tonga. Our house is gone already and the cyclone is not even there yet,” Tupou posted on his Instagram account.

“Not exactly what I wanted to hear but much love to all my Fams back home.

“Stay safe errbody.”

Thankfully, Tongan Thor’s family – it seems his mother Loisi and four sisters live in a tiny village outside the Tongan capital of Nuku’alofa – were unharmed.

But it brought into perspective what Tupou has given up to be in his position – which in a global context is extremely privileged in itself (do you know that a person on the average Australian salary of about $80,000 puts them in the top 0.19 per cent of incomes globally).

As a 16-year-old, he left Tonga to take up a rugby scholarship at Auckland’s Sacred Heart College. He was being chased by a few New Zealand Super Rugby sides, but after school moved to Australia as his brother was living in Brisbane.

He rose through club rugby in Brisbane to land a contract with the Queensland Reds and the hulking prop’s rapid rise was rewarded with a Wallabies debut against Scotland at Murrayfield at the end of last year.

[latest_videos_strip category=“rugby” name=“Rugby”]

He’s only 21. He’s got a massive future. His YouTube montage clips are frightening. And he can be grateful that rugby has opened up plenty of doors already.

But as sacrifices go, to leave your family as a teenager and move to another country is daunting to say the least. Perhaps he had relatives already in New Zealand and a close school and local community that made it easier for him to settle in and thrive as a rugby player and young man.

Regardless, he deserves respect for taking the leap. Quite a few Pacific Island youngsters tread a similar path to New Zealand and Australia trying to set up their professional sporting careers.

(Credit: Sportography/QRU)

Why do they do it?

Well it can be a brilliant adventure for a start. And they’ve got great passion for the game.

But a large part of their decision is based on the potential to not only chase some good coin for themselves, but often provide for their families who remain at home.

The Nathan Hughes case is stark, and involves the reprehensible context of financial inequality between rugby nations that World Rugby should address.

In late 2016, the No.8 spoke candidly before making his debut for England at Twickenham against the country of his birth, Fiji.

It was because he could earn a match fee of around £22,000 per game – that’s A$38,000 per Test – for England as opposed to his beloved Fiji, where players get about A$800 per Test.

Hughes could set up his family – and extended family – for life.

“That’s the decision I made – I play my rugby to support my family and put shelter over their heads,” he said.

Hughes, like Tupou, has made big sacrifices. Leaving your family at a young age with a lot of talent and plenty of hope takes a lot of guts.

So why do the Force players still seem stuck on the sacrifices, and not on the opportunities ahead?

Coleman spoke to the Daily Telegraph about the sacrifice of some players taking kids out of school in Perth, and with their wives moving to Melbourne.

That’s – according to a recent survey – moving from the seventh most liveable city in the world to the most liveable city in the world.

And I don’t want to seem cold-hearted and undersell sacrifices made by these Force players. Of course a lot of them would still want to be in Perth where they were established. But it happened almost six months ago.

I can’t recall any Australian professional rugby player in the past signing a deal with another Super Rugby team, which means moving cities, and being as downcast as the Force players.

Their industry is fast-moving and flexible. Things can change quickly for better or worse. Isn’t every new contract an opportunity to continue your career?

Yeah, I know, they will argue that the Force were axed because of Rugby Australia mismanagement.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

But the Force couldn’t cut it. Results were poor. Crowds were down.

I’d imagine Coleman, Pek Cowan and Matt Hodgson – a few of the ex-Force players who have spoken about the difficult times following the club’s Super Rugby chop – would rationally concede with a nod in agreement if you told them the local tomato cannery closed down because not enough people were buying tinned tomatoes.

Or the local car dealership shut its doors because they didn’t sell enough cars. The Force didn’t sell enough. It’s as simple as that. Businesses thrive. Businesses fail.

What happens to the bloke who has worked assembling cars at Ford or Holden for the last 20 years? There are no more jobs in Australia. The whole industry has disappeared. They have families and mortgages.

The former Force players have probably all got good intentions. But maybe they’ve been emboldened by RUPA, Twiggy Forrest and a contingent of angry Force fans. There are plenty that aren’t Force fans too that believe the Rebels should’ve got the chop.

Sure a lot of hard work went into keeping the Force alive. The players are tough men who put their bodies and minds through plenty. And there are sacrifices no doubt.

They have resilience in bucketloads on the field. And the tragic death of Dan Vickerman, a father of two boys, was evidence professional sportsmen struggle with the transition away from their chosen field.

But is it not legitimate to ask for a bit of perspective? Isn’t sacrifice the single mum working two jobs to provide for her kids?

Isn’t sacrifice the soldier leaving his wife and kids for a six-month tour of duty? Isn’t sacrifice the parent who quits their job to be by their child’s hospital bedside as they go through chemotherapy?

It’s been almost six months since the Force were cut. Only some have remained in Perth, Cowan and Heath Tessman among them.

There’s sacrifice and there’s opportunity too. Can’t the Force players that have moved to the Rebels, Waratahs, Brumbies, Reds, Japan, France – wherever – just be grateful they’ve got another chance?

The Crowd Says:

2018-02-21T06:54:51+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


You should ask where will the ARU's funding come from as they already spend money to run the Rebels between 2018-2020 with revenue they would only earn post 2020. Compliments of Pulver and Clyne... to whoever will manage the ARU by that team. This is the same organisation that tell the IPRC that they cannot go ahead as they planned to expand the NRC to Asia Pacific post 2020!

2018-02-21T06:48:20+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


One guess...the same place it came from in the past 6 years

2018-02-21T04:36:22+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Good on you mate, well said

2018-02-21T04:16:55+00:00

GusTee

Roar Pro


I wonder where the Victorian team's funding will come from circa 2019 and beyond.

2018-02-20T01:05:51+00:00

George of Perth

Guest


Rebels were not competitive and that is re-inforced by having 12 players & coach from the Force now in the Rebels side. It was just Eastern States looking after fellow Eastern Staters - shocking decision, the Rebels should have been axed. Anyway I now support NZ Rugby. Cheers,

2018-02-18T23:51:40+00:00

ScottD

Guest


Spot on Rhys

2018-02-18T15:37:09+00:00

GusTee

Roar Pro


No "not so Super" Rugby for me either.

2018-02-18T12:31:54+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


Well said!

2018-02-18T12:08:22+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


You're dreaming... I will not support a team that is 4,000 km from where I live. We have nothing in common with the Rebels side that is the cause of the ARU'S financial problems. The Force was sacrificed to bail out the Rebels in the dumbest decision of 2017.

2018-02-18T04:29:12+00:00

AJ

Guest


OK. I'll stop seeking some balance and perspective for the ever decreasing conditions of my terrible life in this broken country that's heading for third world status. I'll trumpet my sense of what I'm entitled to and rage against any government that tells me otherwise. That should stop the destruction of modern Australia.

2018-02-18T03:05:29+00:00

double agent

Guest


Every team has players that have moved from somewhere else to get the opportunity to play Super Rugby.

2018-02-18T02:58:31+00:00

double agent

Guest


The destruction of Sydney? When did that happen?

2018-02-17T20:11:19+00:00

soapit

Guest


those building sites dont have performance linked so closely to current physical condition.

2018-02-17T13:30:30+00:00

Realist

Guest


Has Pek Cowan been signed yet ? He was the one voicing opinions over suicidal players. It was this comment where it was obvious that some players lost perspective on what they are entitled too and what the governing body needs to do to ensure the survival of the code. Australian Rugby is still in a dark place but I genuinely believe the ARU made the right call in scrapping the Force. Terrible for the supporters, but those same supporters have to get their arms around the consistency of sub par performance over a long 12 year life span The quicker they get behind a new team the better and find the backbone and perspective to be grateful for the extended shot they had where they simply couldn’t achieve the bare minimum required to justify a proplonged stay at the top level

2018-02-17T12:42:05+00:00

Metalisticpain

Guest


Hello! I am a Perth kid living in Melbourne. Go back several times a year. neither housing not public transport have any relevance on why the force players should be either happy or unhappy about being forced to move. All that depends on is what they and their families had planned and suits them. This article for me is basically a trash argument. Force players and fans should continue to voice their disappointment. Even though they don't have the hardship of a Pacific island born person doesn't mean they need to 'get over it'. By that logic everyone needs to shut it because of all the staving people in the world. I like that they keep reminding everyone. Everyone needs reminding. What the Aru did was not ok as the national Sports body in charge of growing the game. If union was better managed in this country, we could be succeeding like new Zealand is throughout their grassroots to professionals. But we are not. We struggle at all levels and have done so for a while due to poor management. I don't have a team anymore. It sucks, it killed my drive to play club this year for the first time in 18 years. I'm not going to get over it. I'm not just swapping to the rebels because I live in Melbourne now. It doesn't work like that. I'm a Perth kid, my team was the force. Good times and bad. I took my supporter membership out despite rarely being able to get to any game because they were my team. So yes I'm sorry if it annoys you Will Knight. But too bad. Because it happened, it's a part of history. It affected people. There's many billions of people not as fortunate as myself in this world. But since we are on the context of Australian rugby, I'm not going to let their situations dictate whether I should express my displeasure about Australian rugby.

2018-02-17T12:03:06+00:00

In Brief

Guest


My comment demonstrates the exact opposite. The idea that you should be content with what you have as it is worse overseas encourages people to stop caring, stop fighting, stop believing. Australian democracy itself is under threat as we speak and yet you are foolish enough to make glib comparisons to mobile phone usage. Only in Australia.

2018-02-17T11:52:51+00:00

elvis

Guest


New York subways are heaps better than anything Australia has to offer, because when you are in New York you are on holidays and everything is through rose coloured glasses...

2018-02-17T11:50:47+00:00

elvis

Guest


FWIW I too thought 5 new stations would be on existing lines. On long lines to outlying areas you infill stations as population grows. And a new line with only 5 stations probably isn't all that common...

2018-02-17T09:29:20+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


Tim, small correction, the Rebels does not have their own team, they have our team and coaching team as well. The Force would have targeted finals for 2018, if the Rebels does not make the finals with all the talent they have then 2018 is a failure! I will not be watching any of this Superugby farce this year...

2018-02-17T09:27:16+00:00

Bazza

Guest


Saying that just because they earn 80k plus a year puts u in the highest percent of workers in the world means nothing if u don't know what the costs are that are associated with it. I do agree your work is potential always moving and never know when a career ending injury can happen. Its a tough life. The ones who make it are doing well many don't and struggle.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar