Maroons rebuild starts on Thursday

By ScottWoodward.me / Roar Guru

Maroon fans are doing it tough at the moment, in anticipation of a new winning era – the re-engineering commences this Thursday.

The 2018 Origin series is lost, and search parties are out trying to fill the sinkhole left by Johnathan Thurston, Cameron Smith, Cooper Cronk and, next year, Billy Slater.

It is to be seen if Greg Inglis and Matt Scott will put their hands up for Queensland again.

If there were a cap on Origin salaries, then Kevin Walters has just lost $5 million. In NRL terms that is more than half your team in value.

NSW have a population advantage of 2.9 million, and arguably could produce a B-team that would be equal to the team who plays the Maroons on Wednesday night to attempt an undefeated series.

We have seen enough to suggest that all is not lost for the Sunshine State, and they will have a very young and exciting team next year.

They are not lacking in talent, only combinations and experience.

Kalyn Ponga coming in for fullback great Slater is a more than an acceptable start, and if he finishes his season at the Knights as well as he started, then he will make it very difficult to hand the famed Kangaroos No.1 jersey to James Tedesco.

With the retirement of Slater, the national selectors cannot complain about the calibre of alternatives – they cannot lose!

It is much easier for the Maroon selectors and Ponga promises to make the same huge impression that his predecessor did; in fact, his figures are more impressive than Slater at the same age.

Kalyn Ponga (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

David Fifita will be just 19 come next year’s series, and he has only played 97 minutes of NRL, but he will be a ten-year Origin player, and he is that good that he may well start next year on the bench.

Fifita is of Indigenous Australian and Tongan descent and is as good a schoolboy rugby league player as we have seen in modern times.

Selectors are typically hesitant to blood their young players at the highest level, but they showed by selecting Ponga in Game 2 that they will invest early if they show enough at NRL level. Ponga did just that and Fifita could easily follow his path.

Ashley Taylor, 23, is as promising as they come, but co-selector Darryn Lockyer sees “holes in his game” and wants to wait.

One hole Taylor does not have is his short tactical-kicking game, which is as good as Ricky Stuart and Andrew Johns.

He has the amazing skill to seemingly always squeeze the ball between ankles and win another seven tackles or a try, something lacking for the Maroons in Game 2 when the game was there to be won.

He also is a genuine organising halfback, who would complement the running game of Cam Munster. He would also combine well with Daly Cherry-Evans, but one of them moving to pivot won’t happen.

Photo by Jason O’Brien/Getty Images

The DCE ‘experiment’ in Game 3 will be interesting, but long term, his best chance appears to be as a utility off the bench.

Both Munster and DCE are immense talents but logically they are not the long-term answer as they are too similar.

What coach Walters does at halfback will define exactly how quickly the Maroons win back the interstate trophy. Assuming Munster is the long-term 6, the choice is between Michael Morgan, Cherry-Evans and Taylor as his partner.

Getting this correct will not only define Queensland’s future, but also will impact if Walters is re-signed beyond next year, as his former Broncos boss Wayne Bennett is also off contract and he may well be in the market for a job.

Morgan is the likely Queensland captain after Inglis, so it would be unlikely that he is not in the starting 13 somewhere.

Jai Arrow has been their best forward and he finally wins a starting berth in Game 3. The only surprise is that it took so long! He is not the big middle-forward to succeed Scott, but he has a huge motor and is outstanding with and without the ball.

Other promising forwards include Junior Kangaroo Jaydn Su’A and Broncos teammate Joe Ofahengaue.

Certain selections for the 2019 Origin renewal who will not play this Wednesday night are Matt Gillett and Morgan, who may surprise and run out as a centre next year if DCE goes well in Game 3, or it is agreed it’s Taylor time.

Replacing Cam Smith remains the greatest challenge. In Game 3, the Maroons are expected to cover his hooking position by utilising two players– tackling machine Andrew McCullough, who will start, and then Ben Hunt coming on to create dummy-half runs and hopefully points.

This strategy will take up an extra interchange just to stay competitive with the Blues’ Damien Cook, who will be an easy selection decision as the next Kangaroo No.9.

Enjoy Game 3, for Billy Slater walking off at fulltime will be the end of a generational player and an amazing era.

Thanks for the memories, Billy.

The Crowd Says:

2018-07-10T07:00:26+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Let's face it, there are few like Ponga anywhere, anytime.

2018-07-10T06:59:08+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Friend looks busted. Not sure how many seasons he has left in him.

2018-07-10T06:29:40+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Fair call, but I would like Munster's kamikaze style runs from fullback.

2018-07-10T06:27:41+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Morgan at right centre, utilising his evasive skills and flick pass is attractive. He might also put in a decent kick, unlike Chambers. Long term, the spine might yet end up with Munster at the back, Ponga at number 6 and Taylor at 7. We need to discover a new hooker but for now McCullough is the best we have. Hunt can't go 80 minutes at hooker. Short term I think it might be Ponga, Munster, DCE with Morgan at centre, with McCullough at 9 and Hunt on the bench.

2018-07-10T06:23:30+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Well said Paul, after 10 years or so, the series was getting stale. QLD had once in a generation players but we knew what we were going to get, both from them and from Gallen/Pearce/Farah. We now get the chance to see two younger side produce their own legacies over the next 5 years.

2018-07-10T05:41:19+00:00

3 recalcitrant monkeys

Guest


I'll be watching the live stream Scott thank you for you for the honest feed back mate good column good threads .

AUTHOR

2018-07-10T03:02:07+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


3 monkeys Originally I rated the U20s Qld team ahead of the Blues, but since then their best player David Fifita is out and I am not sure if AJ Brimson will play. It is a very average NSW pack, but they do have 2 terrific hookers and Flanagan will lead them around the park well and kick most goals. Sean O'Sullivan at 6 is a late out with ohagan expected to come in. The Qld props Flegler and Carrigan will not be missed and I look forward to seeing big Tino come on.

AUTHOR

2018-07-10T02:55:52+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Larry, With the exception of Cordner, there were no forward stars for NSW in g2.

2018-07-10T00:33:50+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


Peek of, I'm a Qlder & agree with you that those forwards aren't the dominant types but Qld has thrived off a working pack over the years. Remember that Webke played when we got smashed.

2018-07-10T00:33:37+00:00

3 recalcitrant monkeys

Guest


It's an impressive back line Scott all with many ISC games do you think the forwards are good enough to match the nsw big boppers? It's been a tale of woe not getting the lollies in the under 20s.

AUTHOR

2018-07-10T00:14:34+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Larry, You will get an insight into the U20s hookers in the pre U20s origin match on wed. 1. Corey Allan 2. Murray Taulagi 3. Gehamat Shibasaki 4. Kurt Wiltshire 5. Tristan Sailor 6. AJ Brimson 7. Jake Clifford 8. Thomas Flegler 9. Harry Grant 10. Patrick Carrigan (c) 11. Louis Geraghty 12. Beau Fermor 13. Corey Horsburgh 14. Lachlan Lam 15. Tino Fa'asuamaleaui 16. Sam Johnstone 17. Reed Mahoney 18. Logan Bayliss Harry Grant reminds me of Jake Friend; one of the fittest players in the game with a high work rate and skills to match, and Reed Mahoney is a similar type. Both guys are great DH runners and tackle everything that moves. I will be surprised if AJ Brimson starts, and although selected at 6, I see him as a fullback, but he has the skill set to be a class 9.

AUTHOR

2018-07-10T00:06:33+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Larry, Correct mate, he had a season low last week although he had no help from his forwards. Its there, his coaches and his minders just need to bring out his best and keep it there. I think he will make it.

AUTHOR

2018-07-10T00:02:15+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Morgan has already played centre at Origin level; he actually has the perfect build for a centre and is strong with genuine pace.

2018-07-10T00:01:28+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


Hi Scott, given all the retirements I'm optimistic that Qld can get the origin contest back to an equilibrium like those days before 'the era' that is unlikely to ever be seen again. Our biggest issues aren't halfback but unearthing a quality hooker and one or two big bodies in the pack. With due respect to Glasby & Wallace, bringing Christian Welch in as 18th man is a great move, his work for the Storm has been impressive & he's an aggressive big guy. The other spot they need to build is hooker & we'll have to rely on club coaches slotting an ex-fullback/halfback in the role to build that experience, remember Cam Smith was a halfback as a youngster at Logan. Granville & Cook show that's the way to go in today's game. I really liked Matt Parcell as a running hooker when he played Intrust cup & he's now in the English Superleague so might see him back in the NRL one day.

2018-07-09T23:35:41+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


Sorry Scott but Taylor's game against the Broncos showed he's still a fair way off origin level game management. The hype was there pre-game with a bit on the line & he was abysmal. Think he's going to get there eventually but Morgan, when not hampered by a groin injury, has him covered. Big body in defence also helps. I'd go Hunt at 9 until someone else stands up, McCullough has lost any zip he had & there are plenty of tacklers around of similar mood.

AUTHOR

2018-07-09T12:21:03+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Muzz Agree, but I expect he will play the first 30 mins. and try and hold the middle for Hunt to come on fresh.

AUTHOR

2018-07-09T12:18:49+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Snoop Arrow is a lock and I will be shocked and somewhat disappointment in Kevie if he starts him up front. Qld have a heap of half options and no one like Ponga for FB, its an easy call really.

2018-07-09T10:15:30+00:00

Snoop Bloggy blog

Roar Rookie


Only time will tell I guess Scott I’ve been a long time reader new poster and have missed your presence over the years. I guess we will have to agree to disagree. The safe bet is he will stay fb but the game is always evolving as are positions. I doubt the maroons would have Arrow at starting prop back in 2006. The players size has plateaued for years now and I think speed and stamina will be the biggest factors in breaking down defences going forward. It was already happening without the rule crackdown and the changes they are trying to move towards (love them or loath them) seem to also head in that direction. I watched 2 games a couple of months back one in 98 and one in 2006 and there’s definite contrasts between 98-2006 and 2006-present.

2018-07-09T09:56:55+00:00

Muzz

Guest


I think McCullough is one dimension. A work horse in D however offers very little in attack and, zero in game management.

AUTHOR

2018-07-09T08:09:01+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Snoop It is about runs and he will make more runs at FB - between 15 to 20 - while as a half he would do more like 5 - 10

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar