Can Molik solve the Stosur problem?

By Isaac Buatava / Roar Pro

Australia are through to the Fed Cup final where France await on home soil on November 9 and 10.

This is a fantastic achievement for Australian tennis and especially the women’s game.

Not since 1974 has Australia won the Fed Cup, when Evonne Goolagong led us to victory 2-1 over the United States. Ties then were decided by two singles and a doubles match.

In the halcyon days of the 1970s – with names like Gooloagong, Margaret Court and John Newcombe – tennis must have consistently frequented the sporting pages of our newspapers.

Their exploits captured the adoration of the wider sporting public throughout the year.

However, tennis now finds it hard to get anywhere near the back page outside of the Australian Open.

Of course, there are exceptions. But during football season, an ankle injury to a star player is likely to produce more headlines than an Australian tennis player winning an ATP or WTA tournament.

Tennis Australia will be eager for that to change as the Fed Cup final looms.

An Australian victory on home soil will be a boon for the local game.

But equally, TA will be keen to cash in. The tie falls well outside the football season and will be on the first weekend after the Melbourne Cup is run and won.

The Fed Cup final is well placed to feed an incessantly hungry sporting public.

As the tie approaches, one question may grab the headlines from the Melbourne Spring Racing Carnival: who will be chosen to play the other singles rubbers alongside Ashleigh Barty?

(AAP Image/Craig Golding)

This question didn’t grab much attention in the lead-up to Australia’s 3-2 semi-final victory over Belarus, for the reasons mentioned above.

But as the final looms – much like our cricket selectors face more scrutiny before an Ashes series – captain Alicia Molik will receive much the same attention around who she selects to take the court in the singles matches.

This time Molik won’t have the luxury of a usually distracted media.

And if the semi-final is anything to go by, Molik made a few questionable choices.

The correct decisions appear more obvious in hindsight, but the selection of Samantha Stosur to play in the fourth singles rubber was very poor indeed.

The first rubber of the tie saw Stosur – ranked 77 in the world – selected ahead of the 58th-ranked Daria Gavrilova, who would seem the obvious choice.

The surprise selection was justified by Molik.

“It’s a player Sam’s really familiar with and that’s really important in a tie like this, one where no doubt experience has to count as well,” Molik said.

Stosur pushed the much higher ranked Aryna Sabalenka, losing in three sets. The gallant defeat went some way to justifying the decision for Stosur to play in one of the first two singles rubbers.

Barty then showed why she is a top ten player by levelling the tie, ending Victoria Azarenka’s run of 13 straight Fed Cup singles triumphs with a 7-6, 6-3 win.

Though Stosur played some good tennis, the defeat should not have come as a surprise given her history on home turf.

Unable to get past the first round in the last four Australian Opens – and never having made it past the fourth round across her career – Molik’s decision to place familiarity over ranking was a puzzling one.

This became even more apparent when Molik then doubled down and stuck with Stosur for the fourth rubber against Azarenka. At this stage, Australia were up 2-1 thanks to a second Barty victory.

(AP Photo/Kamran Jebreili)

But Stosur not only suffered another defeat, but she capitulated 6-1, 6-1 in a paltry 59 minutes to Azarenka, giving the Belarusians momentum going into the deciding doubles match.

Though Molik would have been prepared for the tie to go to a decider, Stosur being nothing more than a hit-up for the Grand Slam-winning Azarenka would have been concerning to the team captain.

To Stosur’s credit, she pulled herself together and partnered Barty to win the doubles and the tie.

But serious questions should be asked not of Stosur herself, but Molik’s choice of Stosur to contest two singles rubbers.

Fresh and ready to give Azarenka a much bigger test, the higher-ranked Gavrilova would have taken more than two games off the Belarusian.

Fortunately, the tie was won nonetheless.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

In November, we will welcome the French – a proud tennis nation that last won the Fed Cup in 2003 and contested the final as recently as 2016.

Media interest will peak. This will please Tennis Australia, putting tennis near or on the back pages, leading to an increase in revenue – an important KPI for a sporting body.

Yet this will be a double-edged sword. There will be a groundswell of support for the women to succeed, but the negative effects that come with extra punditry will have to be managed by Molik.

One subject that will inevitably rear its head is Stosur’s poor form on home soil and her failure to deal with pressure.

The attention will be more parochial given there is a team dynamic here. Think ‘lay down Sally’.

Molik’s job may become easier. November is a long time away. Players’ form and fitness may force Molik’s hand.

But everything being equal, the Stosur-Gavrilova question will attract a tidal wave of scrutiny.

All that aside, let’s pray that Ash Barty stays healthy!

The Crowd Says:

2019-04-26T11:46:07+00:00

Max Mayer

Roar Guru


Tomljanovic played for Croatia in 2010 when she was 15 and is still cap-tied to them under ITF rules, otherwise she would be straight in this team, no question. Stosur and Gavrilova are terribly out of form. https://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/tennis/ajla-tomljanovic-to-fight-to-represent-australia-in-fed-cup/news-story/be3f2e005a1741571980ef81f47c2264

AUTHOR

2019-04-26T07:32:58+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


Hi Wendy, as per above comment to DIon and posted below

AUTHOR

2019-04-26T07:32:23+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


Hi Dion, I copied a pasted my reply to Wendy as I thought it was relevant to yours as well.

AUTHOR

2019-04-26T07:30:39+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


I take everyones point about Stosur over Gavrilova though I invite to read the comment below as I hadn't factored in Tomljanivic. Food for thought. But what do people have to say about the final and the differing dynamics around media attention, moliks player management etc. I think it will be a different beast come September and the media wont be so occupied by other sports. Some of those tough questions of Stosur will get asked.

AUTHOR

2019-04-26T07:28:59+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


I take everyones point about Stosur over Gavrilova though I invite to read the comment below as I hadn't factored in Tomljanivic. Food for thought. But what do people have to say about the final and the differing dynamics around media attention, moliks player management etc. I think it will be a different beast come September and the media wont be so occupied by other sports. Some of those tough questions of Stosur will get asked.

AUTHOR

2019-04-26T07:28:19+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


2019-04-25T03:51:47+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Where is Tomljanivic in all of this? I thought she was having a good season? She is ranked 39, her highest ever. She beat Sabalenka in Miami, reached the quarters in Brisbane and the final in Thailand.

2019-04-24T13:20:37+00:00

Wendy

Guest


What a misguided and uninformed article. Have you seen Gavrilova play lately? She's in MUCH worse form than Stosur. She has only 2 wins and 8 losses for the year, many coming against lower ranked opponents. She has lost her last THREE consecutive Fed Cup singles rubbers (and her last doubles one too). In fact even with the home advantage she lost her singles match last year against doubles specialist Nadia Kichenok (singles ranking #606), and 15 year old junior Ukranian Marta Kostyuk. There's also the fact that she just played Azarenka at the US Open a few months ago and was clobbered 6-1 6-2. Priscilla Hon has been losing in ITF 25k level tournaments. For some reason Astra Sharma (a decent singles AND doubles player) was not on the team. With all this considered, Stosur was definitely a better choice than Dasha (despite the lower ranking and bad H2H vs Azarenka). She proved her mettle against Sabalenka and was very instrumental in the deciding doubles. Like a lot of countries, we are basically a one-woman team. We aren't guaranteed a point from anyone else on the team. The only logic for not playing Sam after her performance on the first day, would be to keep her fresher for singles (knowing full well Dasha would have lost just as badly).

2019-04-24T06:35:52+00:00

Dion

Guest


I don’t think Daria would have got the job done against Azarenka regardless and she certainly has not played many matches this year. Plus Sam has got the experience and had the match play this year that’s why she was picked

2019-04-24T06:15:55+00:00

Simoc

Guest


Pretty stupid article. Isaac has zero understanding of the woman's game compared to coach Molik. Azarenka is ranked 61 so Isaac would have Gavrilova favoured over her. Silly boy. Since the tie is in November and he is using hindsight to justify his arguments, why bother to write this rubbish. Stosur played a huge third set with Barty to take out the Belarus girls in doubles. But the clueless Isaac wouldn't have played her.

2019-04-24T02:15:21+00:00

Susan Barnes

Guest


Great article. I'm afraid I agree Sam Stosur was not a good choice. Let's hope she thinks long and hard beige the final and that Australia gets behind the team

AUTHOR

2019-04-24T00:18:53+00:00

Isaac Buatava

Roar Pro


Have to agree Carl, though Gavrilova has a better ranking it has taken a slide from 35-58 since January, so she may not have done better. Besides personal gain the girls will have something to play for throughout the year leading up to the final, that is to impress Molik. Will be interesting to see develop and play out come November.

2019-04-23T23:25:15+00:00

Carl

Guest


It's easy to live to live in hindsight, difficult to live in foresight. It's all speculation that Daria would have put in a better performance. She ain't exactly the player she was a couple of years ago. Sam has been on the professional circuit for around 20 years. That is a fantastic achievement. The issue has always been (besides a few technical flaws) between the ears. A shy individual that has trouble dealing with pressure and expectation. Very few try, fewer succeed. I'm sure she has had psychologists dealing with her to to help with her game. It is easier said than done though. Australia doesn't have great depth so it up to the players, especially Ashleigh, to be fit and firing in November. Otherwise even the home crowd, with plenty of French cheering for their team, will not see Australia win. But I have a feeling they might. Lets enjoy the contest.

Read more at The Roar