It's time for Essendon to pull their heads out of the clouds

By Christian Montegan / Roar Pro

For a club as significant as the Bombers with their prestige, history, and massive following, it’s incredible how far they have fallen.

A 22-year premiership drought along with failing to win a finals game in 6559 days have made Essendon a laughing stock to the rest of the competition, and rightly so.

On Friday morning it was announced that three-time premiership-winning coach Alastair Clarkson had joined North Melbourne on a lucrative five-year deal, rejecting Essendon’s last-minute offer.

Unfortunately, the shambolic way in which the Bombers have been run as an organisation has overshadowed the great news for the Kangaroos and the AFL as a whole.

Firstly, good on North Melbourne for getting their man and showing the courage to be ambitious.

Club president Sonja Hood and the people working behind the scenes should be applauded for the planning and effort put in to pull off such a coup.

Credit to them, they fully deserve this.

As for Essendon, they can learn a thing or two from the Kangas about how to produce a long-term plan and how to conduct the process properly.

Before continuing, everyone understands the turmoil and heartache that the red and black faithful went through back in 2011 during the dark times of the drugs saga that tore the club apart.

That being said, it’s not a valid excuse for the way the board has handled the Bombers in recent times and over the past two decades quite frankly.

Despite having the stature as a big club as mentioned earlier, what gave Essendon the impression that swooping in for Clarkson would be a good idea? What gave them the right to think that they are above everyone else and can just get what they want with a click of the fingers without going through a review process?

Sorry if it sounds harsh, but Essendon has done absolutely nothing in the past 20-odd years to put in a quick five-minute pitch to anyone to argue why they should be coaching their football club.

It all starts from the top, though, and changes need to be put in place and remove the people responsible for the recruitment and direction of the club.

Newly appointed president David Barham was involved in a bizarre media conference and made comments that raised eyebrows.

“When you’re 2 and 10, can’t make the finals after 12 rounds, no one’s happy,” he said.

Thankfully the Essendon hierarchy wasn’t living under a rock and could see with their own eyes that they were not in a good state.

However, if that was the case, then why didn’t the board organise a review earlier and pinpoint coaching options to look into?

Clarkson has been publicly open to taking up a new coaching role for a few months now. The door was left ajar for the Bombers to take advantage of.

(Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

Instead, they foolishly hit the panic button and opened themselves up to a potential scenario that could see them fall flat on their face and cause them to blush. Of course, that’s exactly what happened.

The consequence of their actions? Ruining current coach Ben Rutten’s reputation and making a mockery of his credentials. An absolute disgrace, over which the club should hang their heads in shame.

Barham tried to clean up the mess he made by attempting to take some sort of accountability for the poor handling of the situation. “Had I had my time again, I would’ve rung him Monday, but I didn’t get to that, so I apologise for that.”

Do you believe him, Bomber fans?

This epitomises the cultural problems that Essendon is experiencing behind the scenes. They lack respect and ethics which is part of the reason why this once great club finds itself in such a dark place.

It is stating the obvious that the board needs a clean-up and must start from scratch, with the best example being the conflicting views of the people up top.

Under-fire CEO Xavier Campbell has fully backed Rutten and former president Paul Brasher throughout, whereas other members have different opinions and are not on the same page.

How can any team function efficiently when there are so many voices upstairs that have a say and possess their own powers?

Another issue that desperately needs to be addressed is the position of list and recruiting manager Adrian Dodoro, who seems to do well at avoiding the spotlight.

Despite being able to negotiate for star players such as Dylan Shiel and Jake Stringer, Dodoro has been at the club since 1998 in various roles and it is clear that this department needs fresh new ideas.

Jake Stringer of Essendon looks dejected after losing to Carlton. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

This needs to happen now. Not soon, not in a couple of years, not when the club falls further behind the rest of the competition.

If Essendon wants to create real change, then they need to sit down and plan for what squad list they want whether that be youth, experience, or a mixture of both.

Latest reports suggest that former Essendon coach and club legend James Hird is a serious contender to reclaim the reigns as the head coach.

If the Bombers are serious about this crucial rebuilding phase, they need to look to alternatives and not the past for answers.

The drugs scandal was an incredibly unfortunate situation that Hird found himself in at the helm, but whether he knew about what was going on or not, that ship has sailed and the club should know better and move on.

As much as Hird and Sheedy are heroes of the 16-time premiers, it is time for some new blood.

They need people who know what it means to play for the red and black guernsey. They need people that show passion and heart and care greatly for this Bomber outfit.

Club figures such as Matthew Lloyd and Mark McVeigh are the first that come to mind.

One area of the club that should be commended is the management of the finances to make them a more financially stable unit.

Ever since the infamous scandal caused a hit to their pockets, the management has steadily increased their profits, as just last year it was announced that they had strengthened their profitability by $8.2 million. 



With all that said, it will mean nothing if the same board is kept and the same incompetent decisions are made. 
It will mean nothing if that money is not pumped into the football club to improve the squad.

There is a window of opportunity for the Dons to capitalise on the extra cap space that they have to begin building their future, but they cannot afford to make mistakes anymore.

Dylan Shiel. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

The Western Bulldogs achieved the unthinkable. Richmond achieved the unthinkable.

Essendon want to achieve the unthinkable, when earlier this year their five-year plan was announced to win a flag.

The difference between them is that the Dogs and the Tigers were all action and no talk, coming up with achievable plans and persisting with them.

If the Bombers are to repeat the same feat, consistency needs to be key as this has been lacking both on and off the field.

Whichever people are hired and whatever path they decide to go down, it cannot be ditched after one year.

To say that Essendon supporters have endured endless torture and agony is an absolute understatement.

They have done so well to stick by their side during challenging times where it seemed as though there was no light at the end of the tunnel, but they love their club too much to turn their back on them.

The time has now come for Essendon to turn their back on the past and get back to being back where they belong, which is at the pinnacle of the sport, winning premierships again.

This week was undoubtedly one of the worst in the club’s history, but it could just be the wake-up call that finally resuscitates this sleeping giant.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-04T08:42:13+00:00

Chris

Guest


So Ruttens reputation ruined by Essendon ? Mate RUTTEN ruined any reputation he had based on his coaching performance Is he the only coach to ever get the sack Would you have him as your coach at your club I think not

AUTHOR

2022-08-23T02:36:16+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Agreed. When you have people at the top with different opinions it’s very difficult to actually analyse which direction to go in. That’s why this clean out is crucial because everyone at the club needs to be on the same page and stay consistent, which will then translate on the field.

2022-08-22T15:29:36+00:00

Ball Burster

Roar Rookie


I have been pondering the ins and outs of whether Essendon stuffed up the Rutten/Clarkson business. The answer is yes because they hesitated: (i) the team was 2/11 after 13 rounds and the alarm bells were ringing. The club would and should have been thinking "We are going backwards - Rutten is not working". (ii) the team then have a mini revival; 4 wins out of 6, including a loss against Collingwood that was widely criticised as being the result of incompetent game management on and off the field; (iii) Clarkson comes back onto the coaching market; (iv) there is then a very decent win against the Roos - moves against Rutten are quelled (v) then come three pretty feeble losses. It's pretty clear that the club should have started to engage Clarkson after Round 13.

AUTHOR

2022-08-22T10:36:44+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Agree Simoc. There have always been glimpses of hope but the management of the club is so far backwards that the club has no hope on the field to consistently compete.

2022-08-22T08:50:26+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


To my mind the Board is a group of fat balding old men in suits who are blindingly incompetent fools. Essonden bombed again but (while I only watched them briefly) they can play as well as any team in the competition and unfortunately seem to lose the plot completely as often. That is a fixable problem. Starting over again with a new coach is plain dumb. Especially with the so called experienced coach. Bring back Rod Eade. They're complete tossers. Hang the board at dawn.

AUTHOR

2022-08-22T04:53:01+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


The long-term plan was mainly talking about the appointment of Clarkson and the months leading up to offering him the job. This helps their future but I acknowledge that there’s still a lot that North needs to do to be successful

2022-08-22T04:17:00+00:00

Stephen B

Guest


Agree with the article but I’m struggling with the bit about learning from the Kangaroos about producing a long-term plan. I have to say that one of those most remarkable results of Essendon’s hamfisted actions this week was the media’s sudden portrayal of North Melbourne as a well-run organisation with a bright future.

2022-08-22T03:30:00+00:00

Pistol

Roar Rookie


I have sneaky suspicion that Sheeds new Clarko was going to North and tried to have a pot shot at him and North.

AUTHOR

2022-08-22T00:51:25+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


I think a lot of people feel the same way…perfect example being his comments on radio about Clarkson to North

2022-08-22T00:24:48+00:00

Spanner

Guest


Is it just me, or is Sheedy doing way too much damage " in the background" ?

AUTHOR

2022-08-21T10:21:50+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Can’t disagree with you on any of those points. The Heppell argument could be compelling however…for a couple of years now I’ve said that he has not been able to influence games and play as well as he used to…but his leadership skills are obviously first-class and if Essendon want to rebuild then it’s important to keep players like that in the dressing room

2022-08-21T09:53:14+00:00

Ball Burster

Roar Rookie


Good article. I don't pretend to know what the real problems are, so these are random thoughts: 1. The Worsfold/Worsfold-Rutten/Rutten coaching regime has not worked: there has not been a noticeable improvement. This points to poor decision making at the top. 2. Hird was the AFL's scapegoat for the supplements program and not organisationally responsible for it. Still, it would be a poor decision if he was appointed as coach because there are many media and fans that just won't acknowledge the facts of Hird's role. It would be a significant and needless distraction. 3. All the best Essendon teams had players that were intimidating. I'm not talking about blokes belting the oppo behind the play, but blokes that imposed themselves physically in the contest. Dodoro seems to have favoured recruiting skill (he's done well) over mettle (he done poorly). 4. There looks to be a problem in the conditioning department. Players arrive looking powerful (Shiel, say) and start to look weedy. Players leave looking weedy (Daniher, say) and wind up looking powerful at their new club. 5. Key players that have left the club tend to have jumped rather have been pushed. 6. Dyson Heppell is a decent player, but not an inspirational on-field presence. The great Essendon sides fielded any number of people that would have been accepted as captain. I struggle to think of a successor for Heppell.

2022-08-21T09:25:20+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Yeah their treatment of Rutten leaves a lot to be desired

AUTHOR

2022-08-21T08:40:04+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Well Nathan Buckley has just ruled himself out! I’m sure they’ll be quite a few more that are the same who don’t have faith in this Essendon project (whatever that project end up being)

2022-08-21T08:33:53+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


As long as it’s not Pike, Lyon or Hird I will be happy

AUTHOR

2022-08-21T08:27:43+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Big decision ahead that’s for sure

2022-08-21T07:49:49+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Anyone who has been a senior coach so that means Ross Lyon, Don Pike, James Hird, Leon Cameron, even if they’re not the best candidate which sucks.

2022-08-21T07:47:37+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


I regally really hope not but I’ve been disappointed by my club today

AUTHOR

2022-08-21T07:42:36+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Hopefully not James Hird…although I have a feeling that they’ll go down that road…

2022-08-21T07:28:26+00:00

Opps74

Roar Rookie


Who will be on the bombers coaching hit list?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar