Collingwood Magpies vs GWS Giants: Giants win 36-27

By Lachlan Ballingall / Roar Guru

Match result:

The GWS Giants have finally gotten their first win on the board in season 2019, knocking off the now 0-4 GWS Giants by nine points on Sunday.

Final score
Collingwood Magpies 4.3.27
GWS Giants 5.6.36

Match preview:

The Collingwood Magpies welcome the GWS Giants to Morwell Recreation Reserve this Sunday, with both sides looking for their first win for the 2019 AFLW season. Join The Roar for live scores and a blog of the match, starting from 2:05pm (AEDT).

Collingwood have not had the start to the new season they would have wanted. They currently are yet to win a game, which sees them at the bottom of the Conference B table.

The Magpies were awful away from home last week against the Fremantle Dockers. They were defeated by 33 points in the west, which no doubt would have rocked the confidence of the side as a whole.

The Magpies really did struggle to get their hands on the ball, with Sarah D’Arcy being the leading possession-getter for the black and white with 15 disposals.

Collingwood also were only able to find two majors, which came through Jaimee Lambert and D’Arcy, as they kicked one goal each.

The Giants are also having a season to forget, as they are yet to notch up a win in 2019, which sees them just above Collingwood on percentage in Conference B.

GWS did have a fantastic opportunity last week, however, to bring up their first win in 2019 as they faced the Carlton Blues at home.

Carlton have struggled in recent times in the AFLW competition, but they left the Giants stunned, claiming a 29-point victory on the road.

On a positive note for the Giants, Rebecca Beeson continued her solid form, reeling in 17 disposals. She has had no problem with finding the ball in the first three games of the 2019 season.

Christina Bernardi also had a good game down in the forward line kicking two majors.

Both sides this week will be desperate to get some points on the board, but one side is going to leave very disappointed and dejected.

Prediction
Both sides have been very poor in the opening first three games, and the fact neither side have a victory at this point of the season backs that statement up.

However, one side is going to leave Morwell with a victory, and I personally believe it will be the Giants.

They do appear to be a more rounded side than the Magpies, which will prove the difference come the end of the game.

The Giants to prevail by 11 points.

Join The Roar for live scores and a blog of the match, starting from 2:05pm (AEDT).

When: 2:05pm (AEDT)
Where: Morwell Recreation Reserve
TV: Fox Footy
Betting: Magpies $2.35, Giants $1.60

Collingwood Magpies
B: J.Allen 6, S.Casey 22, I.Ross 21
HB: G.Parker 19, S.Livingstone 12, N.Hildebrand 3
C: B.Bonnici 8
HF: M.Kuys 9, S.D’Arcy 4, M.Shevlin 35
F: S.Rowe 7, S.Alexander 24, C.McIntosh 20
Foll: E.Hynes 11, S.Chiocci (c) 17, J.Lambert 13
I/C: S.Layton 1, K.Lynch 16, S.Dargan 46, K.Stratton 41, E.Grant 5

GWS Giants
B: E.Brush 10, P.Randall 21, N.Barr 8
HB: A.Farrugia (c), L.Stephenson 12, T.Hetherington 9
C: A.Eva 2
HF: E.Bennetts 22, Y.Bonner 27, J.Dal Pos 7
F: C.Bernardi 4, C.Staunton 13, T.Davies 16
Foll: E.McKinnon 23, R.Beeson 6, C.Gum 26
I/C: M.Collier 14, J.Barclay 34, T.Mackrill 32, H.Zreika 24, A.Parker 3

Comments:

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:48:22+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


Thanks for joining me everyone. I'll now be covering Melbourne vs North Melbourne.

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:47:52+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


Collingwood: 4.3 = 27 GWS: 5.6 = 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:47:16+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


GAME OVER! The Giants hold on for their first victory of the season! Collingwood: 27 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:45:32+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


BEHIND! 01:02' - Another minor for the Pies. Collingwood: 27 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:44:11+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


BEHIND! 02:30' - Dargan misses. The Pies score a minor. Collingwood: 26 GWS: 36

2019-02-24T04:43:35+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


She’s played in the wind before, hasn’t she? That was a designed fade…

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:43:13+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


GOAL! 03:02' - Shevlin with superb composure converts for the Pies. They are not done yet! Collingwood: 25 GWS: 36

2019-02-24T04:41:03+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


I don't know the geographic layout at Morwell - is there a funnel of wind moving across the center of the field there, or is it simply that midfield's as far as any defensive players can get the ball to travel before it flies wildly off to their left?

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:40:43+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


06:02' - The Pies are starting to run out of time. Collingwood: 19 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:35:17+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


GOAL! 09:45' - Membrey wins a free directly in front of goal, and she converts from the set shot. A big goal for the Pies. Collingwood: 19 GWS: 36

2019-02-24T04:34:46+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


But the Giants are doing something Collingwood refused to do consistently when they had to face the wind - they're making more torpedo like kicks, keeping them lower so they don't get knocked down so quickly. So they're not putting themselves at quite the disadvantage the Pies were last quarter.

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:33:51+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


11:32' - Collingwood are getting inside 50 quite comfortably, but they are just not using the ball well enough. Collingwood: 13 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:32:22+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


12:37' - The Pies starting brightly in the final term. Collingwood: 13 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:30:10+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


Fair point. Still a decent lead, however.

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:29:46+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


The final quarter is underway!

2019-02-24T04:28:44+00:00

Gordon P Smith

Roar Guru


GWS let the Pies stay in the match that period - one goal with the wind won't guarantee anything. Pies play like the Giants played in Q1, and they'll be desperate, then they win.

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:25:18+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


GWS just need to be defensively sound in the final quarter and they will gain their first points of the season.

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:23:10+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


THREE-QUARTER TIME! The Pies have a mountain to climb. Collingwood: 13 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:19:15+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


BEHIND! 03:00' - A minor for the Giants. Collingwood: 13 GWS: 36

AUTHOR

2019-02-24T04:18:32+00:00

Lachlan Ballingall

Roar Guru


03:19' - Nine inside 50's to zero for the Giants this quarter. Collingwood: 13 GWS: 35

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar