The thing is this was a genuine 50/ 50 call. Sutton called try, fair enough.
But you cannot overturn that on any evidence I have seen. Did he bobble it , drop it , lose conntrol of it ?
I watched it 10 times and I have no idea. The technology cannot rule on this.
If we hqve to keep the bunker , it must ask one question only. Was the decision egregiously incorrect.? If Its not a howler, Refs call stands . Bunker forensics is total bs.
Robbed, but not the worst. That was later. Now lets see if Annesley wants to redesign the bunker after this, or does that only happen if the Roosters are dudded??
Bring back Gavin BADGER, at least he can referee, Clien is incompetent on the field or in the Bunker that's just him, no mater what that's what you'll get. We should start a bring back the BADGER campaign.
Since the 6 again rule I have wondered what would happen to the Panthers, Roosters & Storm if they were on the back end of a 6 again count. Now we know. What a great, great, great game of Rugby League. Souths Sydney you ran hard, tackled hard got a 7 to 1 , 6 again count your way. But that was totally deserved. I don't think I've ever enjoyed a NRL game more than last night. Tedesco showed what a great front runner he is, his efforts in defence were embarrassing. Bring on the finals.
Short Memory
Guest
100%.
jimmmy
Roar Rookie
The thing is this was a genuine 50/ 50 call. Sutton called try, fair enough. But you cannot overturn that on any evidence I have seen. Did he bobble it , drop it , lose conntrol of it ? I watched it 10 times and I have no idea. The technology cannot rule on this. If we hqve to keep the bunker , it must ask one question only. Was the decision egregiously incorrect.? If Its not a howler, Refs call stands . Bunker forensics is total bs.
Greg
Roar Pro
I thought this call was correct, the later call against Mark Nicholls however...
DP Schaefer
Roar Rookie
Robbed, but not the worst. That was later. Now lets see if Annesley wants to redesign the bunker after this, or does that only happen if the Roosters are dudded??
Taree Raider
Guest
Bring back Gavin BADGER, at least he can referee, Clien is incompetent on the field or in the Bunker that's just him, no mater what that's what you'll get. We should start a bring back the BADGER campaign. Since the 6 again rule I have wondered what would happen to the Panthers, Roosters & Storm if they were on the back end of a 6 again count. Now we know. What a great, great, great game of Rugby League. Souths Sydney you ran hard, tackled hard got a 7 to 1 , 6 again count your way. But that was totally deserved. I don't think I've ever enjoyed a NRL game more than last night. Tedesco showed what a great front runner he is, his efforts in defence were embarrassing. Bring on the finals.