Passing the armband in the Socceroos

By Joe T / Roar Rookie

Whilst watching Australia’s insipid performance against Egypt the other night, I couldn’t help but contemplate the post Lucas Neill era.

Like many of his teammates, Lucas wasn’t at his best against Egypt, hasn’t been for some time, and sadly I can not see his form reversing.

He will be 36 come Brazil 2014 and surely no longer an automatic selection. He did himself no favours pre-game either, with his stunningly out of line comments about his perception of Egypt’s gamesmanship, due to a longer than expected bus ride the Aussies had to endure before their training hit out.

He commented that Australia should in future follow Egypt’s example and that we were being, “Way too honest and way too nice” to visiting teams and was critical that we leave our visitors with a feeling of, “Wow, what a fantastic country.” Isn’t that exactly the perception we want to convey before the December 2nd announcement?

His comments were at best ill thought out, at worst they were damaging to our bid. Not the words we should be hearing from our captain in a country that has a member on the FIFA executive committee, eligible to vote on December 2nd.

Those comments aside, there’s no doubt he’ll lead the Socceroos with pride into January’s Asian Cup and give his heart and soul for the green and gold, as he always does.

But post January 2011, the FFA must look to the future – a future that does not include Lucas Neill, at least not as Australia’s captain.

At the completion of the Asian Cup, I expect there to be some changes to the national set up, as Holger will look to build a younger team with Brazil 2014 in mind. This in my opinion is also the optimal time to hand over the captain’s armband. Which begs the question, who is next in line to lead the Socceroos?

One assumes the FFA and Holger will choose a captain that can see us through to Brazil 2014. Most likely ruling out our current deputy in Mark Schwarzer.

So the obvious name that springs to mind is Tim Cahill. Arguably our best and most high profile player. He also possesses all the off-field qualities required by an Australian captain and is a leading example for all our young hopefuls trying to make a name for themselves in Europe.

He is well regarded and recognised throughout Europe and idolised by so many back home for his exploits in the Premier League.

The only problem is that Timmy will be 34 years old by the time Brazil 2014 is upon us. Will a 34 year old still be in our best 11? I believe he will be. Unlike Neill, Cahill still has some of his best years ahead of him in my opinion, which is evident by his current run of form. His Everton contract is due to expire in 2014, which will take him into his 34th year and up to the World Cup in Brazil.

Cahill, while not officially captain of his club – that responsibility falls to the ‘evergreen’ Phil Neville – did deputise for Everton while Neville was injured earlier in the season and there is no doubt that he is an on-field leader for the Toffees and held in the highest of regard at the club.

There are other elder statesmen that I’m sure would love the job and no doubt fulfil it with aplomb. Jason Culina, Brett Emerton and Luke Wilkshire to name a few.

But they too will be well into their 30’s and if the FFA chooses an established Socceroo, then I would assume they will fall below Cahill in the pecking order.

Unfortunately our younger generation of leaders do not appear ready at present to make the step up to captain the Socceroos, given their current standings in the game.

Players such as Nathan Burns, Matthew Spiranovic and Rhys Williams are all yet to cement their places in their respective club teams either due to injury or lack of opportunity and are not yet guaranteed a place in the Socceroos starting 11 – surely one of the many criteria that needs to be ticked for a prospective Socceroo captain.

So post Asian Cup, I hope to see a new generation of players step up in preparation for Brazil 2014.

And for the FFA and Australian public to thank Lucas for his fantastic years as Aussie captain as he hands the reins over to ‘Super Timmy’, who will hopefully lead the younger brigade to qualification and beyond.

The Crowd Says:

2010-11-26T01:08:34+00:00

Danny_Mac

Roar Guru


I think that Wilkshire would be an excellent choice for captain. Probably our most consistant performer post WC06, very well spoken. I think that the Socceroos captain needs to be filled on a similar line of thought to the Aussie Test captain, the best man for the job, isn't always the best man for the job. (Shane Warne was arguably the best man to captain the side, but unfortunately he wasn't quite right for all the other aspects of the role). I think we would be well warned by the disater of Viduka's "captancy", we need somebody who will give the media all the sound bites they can handle (Possive spin - no warney pun intended - of course). The hard work for the Australian captain is to be somebody that everybody looks up to, is playing at the highest level and can perform all the media and promotional activites. Sadly the list is pretty thin. I can only think of Mark Schwarzer (too old), Tim Cahill (only 18mts younger than Neil) and Wilkshire that fit the criteria.

2010-11-25T22:59:51+00:00

TheMagnificent11

Roar Guru


He doesn't even start for his club. Not doubting is leadership but Socceroos captain is an ambassador for football in this country. It helps if they have a high profile. I wonder if the FFA would weigh in on who they want or whether they'd leave it completely up to the coach.

2010-11-25T22:43:13+00:00

AndyRoo

Roar Guru


Valeri was my pick post workd cup but he doesn't seem to be a certain starter at the moment.

2010-11-25T22:32:29+00:00

TheMagnificent11

Roar Guru


You guys seem very confident about what will happen. I could see this happening if someone like Hiddink was the coach. However, I'm hot sure Holger will be that ruthless. I hope you're correct.

2010-11-25T11:41:47+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Agree Jimbo

2010-11-25T11:00:18+00:00

jimbo

Roar Guru


Kantarovski and Spiranovic have leadership qualities and in 2 or 3 years will be Socceroos regulars. Cahill will lead till Brazil 2014 and one of the younger ones will take over - but who knows who will burst out of the pack before then, Neill will be replaced after the Asian Cup but could still find a place as an anchoring defensive midfielder as he gets too slow for central defence.

2010-11-25T09:25:51+00:00

Huffy

Guest


Cahill is the logical choice, but Valeri must be a close second. I can see him becoming a fixture in the Socceroos midfield after, or during the Asian Cup. If Holman continues on his way and becomes more confident, he might be in the running to be skipper, but he doesn't seem to fit the mould of a captain.

2010-11-25T04:49:08+00:00

Griffo

Roar Guru


Cahill out of your list will probably get it, if he is fit for 2014. I think he wants it, wants it real bad... But if you look at 'youth', and then those that speak well and are not afraid to put their face in the media (like Neil has always done), then I think Dario Vidosic is a potential future captain, if he cements his spot, and plays regularly. Looking at our U17 to U20's, the next 10 years are going to be real interesting to say the least.

2010-11-25T03:54:47+00:00

TheMagnificent11

Roar Guru


I'd have Cullina, Emerton and Kewell (because he's a special case) in there too. Hopefully the fat will be trimmed after the Asian Cup.

2010-11-25T03:50:30+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Mag11 Not sure if Lucas form is good enough ... for me only Cahill, Wilkshere, Holman & Mark S, form is demanding a place ... and Harry is a special case and I am in two minds what to do with H ....

2010-11-25T01:25:26+00:00

TheMagnificent11

Roar Guru


In your opinion, should that "core group of hard heads" include Lucas Neil?

2010-11-25T01:01:07+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Me thinks the better talent is in the U 20 & U 17 players than is in U 25's. Not sure how but we have so many players overseas and now locally putting their hand up ... me thinks we need to develop a group of youth based around a core group of hard heads...

2010-11-24T23:42:09+00:00

Nugby

Guest


Please don't let Culina captain Australia again. He's captained in the past and we won that game, but Jesus he's an embarrassment to the ideals of Australian sportsmanship.

2010-11-24T23:33:13+00:00

TheMagnificent11

Roar Guru


I've always thought Lucas was a douche but was willing to look past it because he was awesome at the 2006 World Cup. Since then, he's never been quite the same. Good at times, but never awesome. Recently he's been very average. Not only is defending not what it used to be, but he try to play those freaking long balls to the wide players that almost never come off. So, I vote that he is dropped. The centre backs should be the Og monster and someone like Spiranovic or Gulum; guys that are hungry to prove themselves, not someone who thinks he's a walk-up starter.

Read more at The Roar