Rugby World Cup 2011: Minnows' week one

By The Bush / Roar Guru

Rugby World Cup 2011 has finally gotten underway, and until the tight, pulsating match-up between super-powers South Africa and Wales last night, the talk of the tournament had been the so-called ‘minnows’.

Let’s start proceedings this week with a review of their performances.

Saturday, Scotland versus Romania

If you crashed early enough on Friday night (or maybe you stayed up ‘late’ enough), it is likely you would have caught this engaging opening performance by Romania on Saturday morning, Australian time.

Anyone with serious European rugby knowledge will tell you that Romania have a proud history and have, at various times, defeated France, Wales, Scotland and drawn with Ireland.

However, tragically, the sport has long since declined. Despite this, the team still boasts of a proud World Cup record and the team continued this record on Saturday.

Scotland held a modest lead at half-time (18–6), but a spirited fightback by Romania saw the Eastern Europeans lead 24–21 with approximately ten minutes remaining.

Only a late brace from Scottish winger Simon Danielli, helped the Scots pull ahead and secure maximum points from the encounter.

Man-of-the-Match: Marius Tincu.

Tincu demonstrated why he may be remembered as the last world class player Romania ever produces. Plenty of metres, solid scrummaging and fine defence, it was a sign of how well the minnows played that Tincu would not be the last player from a losing team to be awarded man-of-the-match honours this day.

Saturday, Fiji versus Namibia

The Namibians, again, will serve as the whipping boys of the most difficult pool at the Rugby World Cup (see Pool D from France 2007).

Despite this, and being aware that this game probably presented their best opportunity for a win, the Namibians came out firing and sent through three successful drop-goals and a penalty in the first 15 minutes of the encounter to race out to surprising lead.

However, the lead was not to last as Fiji ran in four tries to nil in the first half, effectively shutting the Africans out of the game.

Whilst definitely the weakest performance so far in the tournament, the game was by no means a bloodbath, however Namibia will have to lift on Wednesday as they face a fresh Samoa, who will be keen to stamp their mark on the tournament.

Minnow Man-of-the-Match: Theuns Kotze.

A personal tally of fifteen (15) points, the most of any Namibian in a World Cup match, deserves a mention.

Additionally, whilst many Australians are adverse to the tactic, Namibia deserved their early lead and Kotze’s calm slotting of two successive drop goals was a joy to watch.

Saturday, France versus Japan

One word – the atmosphere. Admittedly I was several (at least) beers down by this point in the day, but you couldn’t help but feel the atmosphere blaring out through the television.

Much in the mould of the Scotland–Romania game, the eventual score-line flattered the French and deceives the history books.

As late as the 70th minute, the Japanese were still within ten points of the French and the greatest upset in the history of rugby union looked set to take place.

An up-tempo match, John Kirwin’s men did the Japanese nation and their contingent of travelling fans proud, with their greatest Rugby World Cup performance to date.

Ably led by captain Takashi Kikutani, the Japanese forwards moved at pace and attacked the breakdown viciously to provide fly-half James Arlidge with the platform to score a personal tally of 21 points and keep Japan right in the game for over an hour.

While we are yet to see Canada and Tonga’s opening game against New Zealand is a difficult barometer through which to assess them, if Japan is able to reproduce this form, it is quite likely they will finish a national best of third within the group.

Man-of-the-Match: James Arlidge.

The second Man-of-the-Match to come from a losing side, Arlidge demonstrated to the world why teams like Japan need more fixtures against the top sides. No doubt the personal highlight of his career, any player that scores two tries against France deserves high praise.

Sunday, Ireland versus United States

The United States took to the field on an emotional high, due to the ten-year anniversary of September 11. It showed.

Ireland again demonstrated why they have such an abysmal record at World Cups, barely leading the US 3–0 for the first forty minutes.

US captain Todd Clever led admirably from the front, as the US brought the match to the Irish, but played surprisingly tight considering the talent they possess out wide.

While the US worked hard at the breakdown and their fullback, Blaine Scully looked dangerous on the few occasions he touched the ball and the Irish packs’ dominance at scrum-time revealed a true weakness in the US team’s make-up.

A strong performance for the first 40 minutes, considering that the Americans recorded a similar score-line against the English four years ago, it’s difficult to submit that they have progressed substantially since that time.

Suggestion that Italy could be challenged by the US are unlikely after the meagre scrimmaging performance put in by the US against a pack that is usually considered one of the less dominant at scrum time.

Minnow Man-of-the-Match: Mike Petri.

Petri provided excellent service from the back of the ruck, with a few probing runs as well. It was a shame that the US wasn’t able to make the most of his excellent pill and spread it all the way to their talent outside backs.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T06:17:24+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Thanks for the praise Mike, though as a Queenslander (notice the flag!), I'm fully aware of the limited television penetration that Rugby Union has in Australia. I think you'll find that even this limited penetration is larger than what rugby recieves in Japan. Also our rates of pay-TV take up are much higher than theirs, especially in NSW and Qld (our rugby "heartland"). As to your other suggestion, personally I'm not a big fan of bowls and plates - I get it for Sevens, but feel it would take away from the main game too much here. I'd even do away with the Third Place play-off. If people feel like we need more rugby and more teams for longer in the tournament, then I'd rather they restructured the tournament as follows; Phase One (1) Twenty (24) teams in six (6) pools of four (4) teams. The initial pool stage is played over three (3) "long-weekends" (Thursday to Monday). Top two (2) progress. Phase Two (2) Twelve (12) teams in four (4) pools of three (3). Top ranked team plays the bottom ranked team in each pool first. The middle ranked team then plays the bottom ranked team and finally, the middle ranked team plays the top ranked team last. Only the team who finishes top goes through to the semis. Phase Three (3) Semis and then Final. The ONLY draw back to this system is that three (3) teams in each pool results in "byes" - i.e. if you kept the games to weekends then all teams have "byes" which isn't ideal. However it's that or have a round of sixteen (16), but I dislike this in a twenty-four (24) team tournament because it makes it too easy to go to the next round.

2011-09-13T05:45:33+00:00

Mike

Guest


Bush, Your comment "As for Japan, rugby tends to be trapped on cable television over there, which I’m told only has limited penetration." applies to a major extent in Australia also. Most Tests get shown on FTA, but no provincial games. Depending on where you are, there might be a club game televised on the government station on Saturday afternoon. There is no regular Rugby program on TV in Sydney, nothing to compare with the Footy Show, whereas league and AFL have a lot. Its surprising we get anywhere. Anyway, not meaning to whinge, great article on the minnows and yes it was a fantastic first weekend. They have every reason to be proud. Lets have a plate and bowl for the minnows to compete for - something to show off in Tbilisi or Bucharest.

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T02:36:01+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Yep their front and back rows will be their strong points. The issue will be whether they can contain the wide balls that Romania couldn't and if their second row is up to the task at line-out time. I note that Scotland has two (2) beanpoles, both 205cm, in the Second Row.

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T02:34:51+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Georgia is certainly showing my live coverage than Australia. But that is understandable - the sport is probably far more popular in Georgia than it is in most of Australia... As to Romania, I'm not sure. The sport is still significant enough that I'm sure all their team's games are being shown, but I doubt more than that. The FIRA-AER Forum is the best place for all these sorts of facts and figures. As for Japan, rugby tends to be trapped on cable television over there, which I'm told only has limited penetration. Consequently, I can't confirm how much coverage they get. Having said all that and after seeing how little Channel Nine is showing, it wouldn't suprise me to learn that every other country at the tournament is getting more coverage than we are...

2011-09-13T02:20:56+00:00

HardcorePrawn

Guest


TB, I would still call it an upset. I think that of all the Northern Hemisphere teams the French are probably the only ones (on paper, and when in form) capable of gate-crashing the final and upsetting the Tri-Nations hegemony at this World Cup. And, given their history of swaying from the sublime to the ridiculous, it wouldn't surprise me if their performances in the pool games reflect this. They're predictable only in their unpredictability. I agree that exposure for the lesser-known teams is important too. Do you happen to know what sort of coverage this tournament is getting in the other countries? I read a comment from either a Georgian or Romanian elsewhere on The Roar who said that their homeland had more live matches and coverage than in Australia.

2011-09-13T02:14:39+00:00

knockon

Guest


Watch out for the Georgian number 7 Gorgaxx. There is clip of utube of him ripping a ball against Spain and runnind down the field with the ball.. wrapped around the Spainish Jersey he ripped to shreds - monster

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T01:57:14+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


HP, Would you consider Tonga beating France an upset though? Off the top of my head, and I can't be bothered checking, I think that Tonga has beaten them before... Having said that, to deny France a trip to the next stage and have Tonga go through instead, would certainly be the biggest upset in World Cup history. The important thing about all of this is exposure. Due to the timezone, I'm hoping that a lot of Japanese people saw their teams performance on Saturday - that's the sort of performance that draws in new fans and new players.

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T01:54:17+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


gus, My memory is a little scetchy, but I'm rather confident that Tincu is playing injured and therefore will need to be "nursed" (as much as you can nurse a hard playing hooker) through the tournament to get as much out of him as possible. A shame, but then I've often suspected that most of these guys carry niggles through major tournaments. I agree that Georgia will now have their work cut out for them because the Scots will be better prepared. Having said that, everything I've read about Georgia over the last four (4) years suggests that they are significantly better than Romania. One good thing about it will be at least the Scots can't claim they were "ambushed". I was reading this morning that Georgia is fielding a player who was voted "best foreigner" in the Top 14 last year and a prop who is good enough to keep Carl Haymen out of a starting position... At a minimum their scrum should be a fearsome sight.

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T01:44:59+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Yes unfortunately it's the little things that separate these teams from the big boys. As I stated in my article able, the US played well but really didn't show me any more than they did four (4) years ago. Japan for mine have been the biggest improvers - if they can somehow scrape together wins against Canada and Tonga, I think we can safely say that things are looking up for Japan. Whilst it's negative coaching to do it and I never like a team that admits defeat, if I was John Kirwin I'd be resting my key players against New Zealand and keeping them fresh for the more winnable games...

2011-09-13T01:42:20+00:00

HardcorePrawn

Guest


A great piece, the less-lauded teams always bring so much to the World Cup and it's good to see someone devoting an article to their progress. Looking forward to seeing more as this competition progresses, and here's hoping that there'll be an upset or 2, perhaps France-Tonga if both teams' opening matches are anything to go by.

AUTHOR

2011-09-13T01:42:02+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Much appreciated Tristan.

2011-09-13T01:35:57+00:00

gusbrisbane

Guest


What a weird decision to take off Tincu after Romania edged ahead of Scotland late in the second half. Can't wait to see how Georgia go against Scotland mid-week. If anything, Georgia will be disadvantaged by Romania's very good display as the Scots will surely be awake to the possibility of an upset and accordingly be switched on. Go the Lelos!

2011-09-13T01:32:05+00:00

Weatherman

Guest


Nice rundown Bush. Sadly, my memory of the USA performance might be that terrible shot at goal from pretty much in front, but a great rundown. Keep up the good work!

2011-09-13T01:26:50+00:00

Tristan Rayner

Editor


Fixed for you The Bush. Lines of scrimmage aren't welcome ;-) Tristan The Roar

AUTHOR

2011-09-12T22:31:53+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Unfortunately that was not a pun ^ (scrimmaging) ^ but rather American spell-check... Should say "after the meagre scrummaging performance".

Read more at The Roar