Right and proper end to 2011 Rugby World Cup

By Brett McKay / Expert

And that, as they say, is that. New Zealand has won a thoroughly deserved second Rugby World Cup in Auckland, beating a spirited and gallant France, 8-7.

I’m not expecting many comments from my New Zealand readers today. Indeed, they are well excused for still partying like it’s 1987. In what’s been a tough year for their country, it’s time to allow the Kiwis their time in the sun.

And since they’re not reading, I might first indulge a few pars about the Wallabies breaking their Eden Park drought; a hard-fought 21-18 win in the Bronze playoff over Wales.

All in all, this was a bit of a letdown as a game. Even though I had forecast late last week that it might be a tight and torrid affair, and that the Wallabies might be facing their toughest match yet, it just never reached any great heights as a contest.

The first twenty minutes were decent enough, and the Wallabies opened with a well-worked try for Berrick Barnes. But the twenty minutes either side of halftime were très ordinaire at best. This period also unfortunately claimed Quade Cooper, whose serious knee injury capped off what must have been a tough campaign in his homeland.

Thankfully, the final twenty minutes made up for the previous sixty. Wales’ try after the bell might well have been the team try of the tournament, a 32-phase movement that started near their own 22m line. Happily, by that stage, Barnes had already sewn up both the result and the Man of the Match hamper (or whatever it is MotMs win).

Yes, Shane Williams’ foot probably was in row C in the lead-up to the last try of the game, but honestly, it doesn’t really matter. If we were happy for the players to be a bit lax in this game, then it’s only fair that we can’t go hard on the officials as well.

Cooper’s injury was a horrible sight – knees buckling in ways they’re not designed to rarely make for comfortable viewing – but his absence from the Spring tour in a few weeks gives Robbie Deans the chance to try yet more combinations.

Barnes has to be a death-and-taxes certainty now for the no.10 jumper. That much we can probably all agree on. But I reckon James O’Connor showed enough in the midfield to suggest that he perhaps should be given a run in London and Cardiff at inside centre. He’s played well over thirty Tests now, and it must be getting near time to throw some more responsibility on his vitamin-boosted shoulders. Let’s see if he doesn’t get tired or stressed in a high-pressure position.

Interestingly, this could be the beginning of a budding rivalry between two teams on the up, too. Both teams have young exciting players in the backline and some imposing young punks in the forwards too. The thought of Pocock v Warburton over the next few years is mouth-watering alone.

Friday night’s game was the first of five within eight months, and by the time RWC2015 rolls on in England, these two teams could well be toward the top of the rugby tree. Stay tuned, I suspect.

Of course, the main event of the weekend, in fact the main event of the last four years of international rugby, was what played out on Sunday night.

From the outset, this was always going to be a night to remember. Both sides belted out their respective anthems, but the early highlight of the night would come just moments later.

When France lined up in their arrow formation to face off against the All Blacks’ Kapo O Panga, you certainly hoped something more was to come of it. And boy, didn’t it!

Advancing not just beyond their sterile IRB-legislated don’t-dare-offend-anyone 10m line no-go zone, the French moved as one arm-in-arm just into New Zealand territory, and stared down the haka in a manner not seen since Wales’ brilliant standoff in Cardiff years ago.

This was an important statement from France: we’re here on your turf to take what you think is yours.

And how close they nearly came to doing it. Though the All Blacks’ defence would stand up and repel the constant barrage of French attacking waves, Les Bleus can be proud of their part in one of the games of the tournament.

From the opening whistle, it was obvious France wanted to play the same way they faced the haka: in the All Blacks’ faces. Maintaining both possession and their break-neck speed, it really looked as though the French really wanted to run New Zealand around.

Unfortunately, though, the opening salvo only lasted around fifteen minutes, where after a bungled French lineout and penalty saw the All Blacks make their first visit deep into attacking territory. The front and back of the lineout split in opposite directions, and suddenly Tony Woodcock found himself with the ball as the waters parted in front of him to the try line.

You felt that Woodcock’s try would be the start, but the French held on like they hadn’t before in the tournament. Players, stadium crowd, commentators, and the entire occupancy of my sports den seemed surprised that the score was still 5-0 at halftime.

Both teams were forced to go their bench early. The evident curse on No.10s over the last seven weeks had one last double dose to hand out, with both Morgan Parra and Aaron Cruden cruelly struck down before the break. Surprisingly, Graham Henry replaced Piri Weepu and Keven Mealamu not long into the second half, too.

Goal kicking was perhaps unsurprisingly off on such a high-pressure night, and so it really was a special kind of irony that Stephen Donald – of all people – would kick what would be the winning penalty goal. I can’t imagine he was thinking of that scenario when fishing on the Waikato a fortnight ago. But good luck to him, either way.

France produced a game against New Zealand that perhaps only France could; a spectacular kind of flawed brilliance only the most erratic of teams are capable of.

The stats will support a decent argument that perhaps the best team lost on the night, too, but then there isn’t a stat for Les Bleus’ abundant enterprise and flair. Nor is there one for the All Blacks’ resilience and ability to withstand what plenty of other teams at the tournament would succumb to.

No matter how wide France threw it, and often it was sideline to sideline and back, the All Blacks were there to cover it. New Zealand’s fortified consistency over the last however many years got them home.

This was a triumph for the hours upon months upon years spent honing their defensive patterns, where everyone knows their role within the garrison, and how to execute it to perfection. Steve Hanson very deservedly got the bulk of praise within the New Zealand coaches’ box as Craig Joubert blew time on the 2011 Rugby World Cup.

On fulltime, Richie McCaw was an exhausted, yet obviously proud captain. Likewise, Coach Henry’s upside down smile has possibly never been bigger. It both cases, it was highly justified.

The All Blacks will undergo something of a generational change in the coming years, with both coaches and some key players moving on. Other players may not make it to England in four years time for varying reasons. But one thing you can be assured of is that whoever comes into those places vacated will be just as good, and the All Blacks juggernaut will roll on.

As much as I willed France on to spring an upset on the night, I was happily satisfied that New Zealand lifted the quadrennial symbol to confirm what the rugby world has known for years.

It was just the right and proper end to what has truly been a memorable Rugby World Cup.

The Crowd Says:

2011-12-08T02:05:52+00:00

kovana

Guest


Dont know why us Kiwis are proud of this match when it was Joubert who handed us the RWC. Disappointing really.

2011-10-26T08:44:40+00:00

Flamant

Guest


when it comes to rugby or any passion (art, music, wine or whatever), fronteers don't really matter...

2011-10-26T08:24:53+00:00

jumpers

Guest


Reported on Radio NZ Sport a kaumatua from Coopers whanau and tribe stated QC had said degregortory remarks about his own whanau and tribe! That is a No no no! in Maoridom! you do not run yr own whanau and tribe down cause it will come back and bite you and so it did when he went off injured. His ancestors would have been disgusted with his comments!!!

2011-10-25T22:22:06+00:00

sheek

Guest


Yes it is, Brett.

2011-10-25T22:12:23+00:00

Brett McKay

Guest


Sheek, is this the Barnes article in question?? http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-union/rugby-world-cup/feeble-french-show-the-need-for-major-rethink-20111021-1mc9k.html

2011-10-25T22:03:23+00:00

sheek

Guest


KPM, I wasn't enthused with Barnes' article either. But it did provoke in me the thoughts as to whether we can improve the world cup & how. Plus all the associated stuff about effectively developing lower ranked nations.

2011-10-25T22:01:19+00:00

sheek

Guest


And Brett, you're the man for this because me, well, I'm too confrontational. And this topic needs a delicate hand to guide it..........!

2011-10-25T21:52:54+00:00

Brett McKay

Guest


thanks for your comments Flamant, very gracious of you, as indeed it was of Les Bleus to allow the ABs to wear their black strip, you're quite right.. (As an aside, I'm loving that I'm suddenly big in France...)

2011-10-25T21:50:07+00:00

Brett McKay

Guest


Hi Thelma, that's outstanding!! And I do understand completely - my own nearly 9mth old daughter has taken to raising her arms above her head and slapping them down on her little thighs lately. Now maybe this is a sign that I've overdosed on rugby recently, but I had to ask her she was bringing out her inner Maori (of which there is none, for the record) - it looks just like she's about to launch into Ka Mate..

2011-10-25T18:12:18+00:00

flying hori

Guest


STOP CRYING KING, WE DID'NT BOO HIM OFF, HE WAS CLAPPED OFF!

2011-10-25T17:30:28+00:00

Flamant

Guest


Brett, and all ABs fans, I am French and totally supporting the French team of course, but the ABs -all in all- deserved to win the RWC. French game last Sunday was just outstanding (and such a gallant display!) but the semis was so poor against wales (+defeat against Tonga) that there is no doubt in the end that ABs were globally better. Congrats to you and kiwis! Still, one point to those NZ fans who would not be aware: before the final, though France won the toss, they agreed to be in White and not wear our traditional Blue (les Bleus) so that the ABs can play in Black. Here is fairplay.

2011-10-25T15:48:47+00:00

kingplaymaker

Roar Guru


Sheek I think that's awful nonsense from Barnes which would destroy the growth of rugby that participation in the RWC gives to these minor nations. What's more he doesn't seem to care, all he worries about is what happens to the big teams. Besides he is misguided in thinking the minnows are causes in any weakness of the World Cup. The problem is in fact that no rules have been devised yet that guarantee running rugby can be played successfully in such pressureful matches where the defences go up several notches in quality. In fact I would increase the RWC to 24 teams, to capitalise on the increased interest in rugby that should be shown in peripheral nations with the coming of the Olympics, and so that there could be 6 pools thereby eliminating the need for midweek matches from anyone. This would be the ideal way to bring on teams with a strong rugby participation such as Uruguay and Sri Lanka, and countries with growing interest because of the RWC in countries such as Brazil.

2011-10-25T13:46:02+00:00

frenchy

Guest


We must learn to play like we can all the time ,the way we play not even all blacks can live with us if we get it right ,more money in french rugby will help

2011-10-25T13:40:36+00:00

frenchy

Guest


What couldve we done with good coach ,and no drama in the team ,im sad to say we are sleeping giant though will we wake i dont know ,we have the magic everyone knows though we need to bottle it ,watch out if we work it out

2011-10-25T12:16:54+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


Winning a World Cup isn't easy, even when you're the All Blacks playing at home on a ground you haven't lost at for 17 years. That was the biggest lesson I took away from this World Cup. It's no wonder there hasn't been a repeat champion yet when you consider what it takes out of you and how much has to fall your way. I hope France win a World Cup someday and join the big 5; there's certainly a gap there waiting to be filled.

2011-10-25T11:57:55+00:00

Paul_From_Melbourne

Roar Rookie


I'm glad it turned the way it did. It wasn't one of AB's best games, but it was good enough. No team has ever won the cup and lost a match. It might happen some day, but fortunately it didn't happen this time. I know people say France deserved to win the match, but I say All Blacks played well through out, deserved to win the tournament. At the end of the day, we won not because we deserved to, but because we were good enough to, we were desperate enough and we wanted it more. I predict this one point victory will become a blessing in oncoming years. Winning by just one point, AB are crowned the Champions of world rugby, we got that monkey off our backs. New Zealanders can look on brighter side of things. More importantly, the wafer thin margin would keep us planted firmly on the ground, keep us humble in our success. Because we know being ranked number one in intervening years means nothing in the world cup. We will not take anything for granted. Being humble and working hard, we might be blessed with this little gold cup in NZRU's trophy cabinet more often than we expect.

2011-10-25T10:10:19+00:00

ThelmaWrites

Guest


Hi Brett! On a domestic note, my 2 and 1/2 year-old grandson was helping his dad put together a Lego pirate ship while replaying the Australia v Wales game. Out of the blue, he says "PAUSE...ENGAGE" complete with referee inflection! My favourite moment during the World Cup. I hope you'll understand. :-) Happy Post-RWC!!

2011-10-25T10:10:14+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Except the refs have been ruling that differently all tournament, and even more so in the knockout rounds.

2011-10-25T10:04:22+00:00

Zorro

Guest


How could AB deserve to win that title after having struggled against a team that didn't deserve to be in final? Should I recall that France was beaten by Tonga, had a lot of difficulties to beat Japan, and was very lucky while playing at 16 against 14 Welshs... Don't undertand! I hope that IRB will change rules a,d will do it's best to improve refereing, that is a shame that team are spoiled because a team has to be favoured because hewas spoiled 4 or 8 years ago... Or maybe we already know that France will win next WC because they deserve after their 2 losts against hosts.

2011-10-25T10:02:57+00:00

Charles Plowdog

Guest


the lineout came from a penalty awarded to the ABs for holding onto the ball when the French player was clearly not released by McCaw. In most instances the penalty would have been awarded to the French.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar