Home-grown football could be Japan's path to World Cup glory

By Matsu / Roar Rookie

Last week, Gamba Osaka made headlines with their decision to fire coach Jose Serrao just three weeks into a new season.

While some commentators have tried to qualify the situation by pointing out that Gamba actually lost five matches in those three weeks (including two ACL contests), it does not change the fact that this sets a new record for sudden coaching departures.

Even Holger Osieck’s departure three weeks into the 2008 season was prefaced by a disappointing run at the end of 2007, which saw Urawa Reds piss away the league title by losing their final four matches, including the final game of the year at home against last-placed Yohokaha FC.

Serrao had no such history, and one has to ask why Gamba hired him in the first place if they were unwilling to keep him around for at least a month or two.

Clearly, it is not going to be easy to rebuild a team that was run by the same coach for a decade. Masanobu Matsunami, who now has to try to pick up the pieces at Gamba, played under Nishino himself, so he will probably be able to reorganise the club around a Nishino-like philosophy. But given the lack of personnel, the age of many veterans, and the fact that Gamba has ACL commitments to deal with, he will be lucky to even manage a midtable finish.

Nonetheless, Matsunami deserves patience from the front office. Though he may lack experience in the coaching ranks, Matsunami is part of a new generation of J.League coaches that is steadily assuming control of Japan’s coaching ranks and its strategic direction.

These individuals all received their early exposure to football philosophy in the J.League itself, and though they surely picked up hints from other coaches and other countries along the way, the approach most of them take is truly Japanese.

Japan is starting to develop a unique style of its own, which may owe a great deal to the Brazilian football (and largely Brazilian coaching) that was consciously imitated in the early years of the J.League, but which has moved off in a direction all its own.

In the past, most J.League coaches were either foreigners or Japanese individuals who played the sport when younger, but whose real focus was always on coaching. Regardless of where they derived their coaching philosophies and influences, none of these individuals had cultivated their tactical ideas and experiences in the new melting pot of Japanese football.

But today, teams are being taken over by former J.League players whose most important experiences and lessons in football tactics, the run of play, the optimal positioning of players and so forth, were cultivated right here in the J.League.

A few of these coaches have already been around for a while – guys like the Hashiratani brothers, Hisashi Kurosaki in Niigata, and Yasutoshi Miura in Kitakyushu. But more are entering the ranks with each passing season.

In fact, the entire Kashima Antlers 1996 back line is now in the coaching ranks: Naoki Soma is head coach of Frontale, Ryosuke Okuno manages Montedio Yamagata, Jorginho is coaching the Antlers this year, and the fourth – Yutaka Akita – was briefly head coach at Sanga (he now is an assistant coach at Verdy).

In addition, Takuya Takagi has done wonders in his first head coaching role, in Kumamoto; Hitoshi Morishita took over this season at Jubilo; Hajime Moriyasu was appointed head coach at Sanfrecce this year; and Motohiro Yamaguchi took over at Yokohama FC two weeks ago, when Yasuyuki Kishino was fired.

These individuals, and many others who are now in assistant coaching roles, will be at the forefront of Japanese football’s evolution over the next few decades, and this is likely to help Japan’s unique style of football develop further.

So keep your eye on the teams mentioned above, as the season progresses. You are witnessing the birth of a new footballing philosophy that will define the country for years to come, and may eventually take Japan to World Cup glory.

The Crowd Says:

2012-04-04T23:55:26+00:00

AndyRoo

Roar Guru


I think it's going to be an interesting few years ahead and it feels like this is the second big shift along a different path than what is happening in Korea. The first was Japans move away from "company" teams to a more community club feel. To be fair Suwon and Seoul are trying but Korea is miles behind Japan in that sense. A lot of K league clubs play counter attacking football and their isn't a large foreign coach influence like in the J league (only 1 manager is not Korean) so I don't see anything changing soon. Japan feels much more dynamic and in this years ACL their sides are looking a lot more pro active.

2012-04-04T11:32:17+00:00

Griffo

Roar Guru


Thankyou Ken, great article. Home grown players, whole professional careers in the J-League becoming home grown coaches would be another milestone that Japan has passed in it's football journey. One that is over the horizon in Australia's own journey but getting closer.

2012-04-04T04:12:58+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


Ouch... Imagine how much better life would be for us all if bureaucrats and administrators could bring themselves to admit their mistakes before they had been carried out to their inevitable, messy conclusions? It is depressing how much of that didn't even raise an eyebrow for me.

AUTHOR

2012-04-04T04:01:50+00:00

Matsu

Roar Rookie


Actually the story behind the Gamba coaching fiasco is a bit more complicated and has less to do with changes in the front office than it does with the front office's lack of real vision, and their continued reliance on the "old boy network". Serrao was never really the head coach. He was a placeholder for a person who had all the necessary "contacts" but didnt have the coaching skills or certification. After Nishino stepped down, Gamba management offered the position to Wagner Lopes, a nationalized Japanese citizen and former NT player (in France WC1998). Lopes knew all the right people, and had a name that was immediately recognized in Japan, so he seemed like a perfect candidate. The problem was that he really had no coaching experience, and lacked the S-class certification. He was coaching lower-level clubs in Brazil and apparently convinced Gamba management that he was a bit more experienced than he really was. When it became clear that Lopes did not have the necessary certification, Gamba should have just looked for another coach, but like so many bureaucrats, especially in Japan, they found themselves unable to admit that they had made a mistake. Instead they asked Lopes if he could find someone to be his "boss" for six months or so, until he earned his S-Class license. When you think about the conditions and requirements, it should be obvious that the only person who would agree to be that sort of a figurehead would have to be someone who owed Lopes a favour, and who didnt have any better offers. Serrao (who reportedly has worked for 30 different clubs in just 25 years) agreed to be the figurehead, but it was clear from the start that neither he nor Lopes really had the experience or talent to step into the shoes of a guy like Nishino. Furthermore, though the front office didnt want to admit their initial mistake, and revoke their offer to hire Lopes, they also seemed to be at least partly aware that they were making another mistake by keeping him and Serrao. It didnt take much in the way of bad results to earn a dismissal. They were probably looking for a good excuse to change their minds even before Gamba played its first match.

2012-04-04T03:52:08+00:00

Ben of Phnom Penh

Guest


It will be interesting to see when Japan starts exporting coaches around Asia in greater numbers. The language barrier isn't as great as some would make out as most of the Vietnamese players only speak Vietnamese, Chinese players speak Chinese etc so even native English speakers require a translator to work.

2012-04-04T02:12:13+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


The Japanese midfield standards are head and shoulders over the Australia midfields, I think, but we have something of an advantage with the defence, keepers and forwards. Not that any of this was on any particularly good display in the ACL yesterday, sorry to say.

2012-04-04T02:10:15+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


"Serrao had no such history, and one has to ask why Gamba hired him in the first place if they were unwilling to keep him around for at least a month or two." Screams front office chaos to me, the sort of reactionary freakout that some administrations and boards can have when they're in over their heads (MVFC's new board comes to mind with this). I certainly don't know for sure and have no idea where I could find out but it would not surprise me if there had been substantial turnover of the board/executive of Gamba Osaka in the off-season.

2012-04-04T01:32:45+00:00

Senoroctober

Guest


Great article Ken. I have been in Japan for 11 years and watched my fair share of football. The game has vastly improved in that time. But the Brazilian style they have employed is a great point. Japan would be a very difficult prospect if they had a world class striker. Slick midfield - check; solid defense - check; forward line - it's all right but could be better. Watch the J- League for some great football. And the future of Asian football. -- Comment left via The Roar's iPhone app. Download The Roar's iPhone App in the App Store here.

Read more at The Roar